The Caretaker - Cover

The Caretaker

by yfnsp

Copyright© 2026 by yfnsp

BDSM Sex Story: He inherited a cabin, but it seems someone is already living there. The results are life-changing.

Caution: This BDSM Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Ma   Consensual   Gay   Fiction   DomSub   MaleDom   Anal Sex   First   Oral Sex   .

Nathan approached the picture window as stealthily as he could. The deep snow silenced his footsteps. He was glad of that, but the drifts were almost waist high at the point where he could finally peer into the cabin without being seen.

The snow was no longer falling, but his Subaru rental had nevertheless been trapped in a drift of a height rarely seen on roads this heavily wooded. Nathan put on his boots, prepared to walk the final mile or so. He remembered this stretch of dirt road and how it curved around the end of the lake to where the cabin perched above the short beach.

He knew that the road ran close to the water’s edge here and before he’d trudged more than a couple hundred yards, he found hat he was looking for. The flat expanse of snow looked like an open field, but Nathan knew the frozen lake offered an easy shortcut.

Walking was easy on the ice, blanketed as it was by enough snow to provide traction for his warm boots. He scanned the opposite shore to get his bearings in the waning afternoon light and immediately sighted his destination.

The cabin was there, pretty much where his mental map had predicted, but nothing had predicted that it would be inhabited! The lake-facing window was brightly lit and he could see smoke from not one, but two chimneys.

Curiosity quickened his step as he pondered the situation. Maybe one of the cousins? The place had originally been his grandfather’s and he recalled the family reunions he’d attended there as a kid. Who knew what uses the place had been put to in the last thirty years?

That’s how much time had passed since his parents’ divorce had put an end to contact with his father. So the letter from the executor had come as a total surprise. The cabin was his now. Nothing else, though; but then nothing had been expected. Dad had three kids by his second wife, after all. Maybe it was a nod to primogeniture? Dad had been a first born too.

It wasn’t until he reached the beach that it occurred to Nathan that maybe squatters were living there. He could tell the place had been vastly improved, though. There was a new dock, for one thing. There was a new structure with a chimney where the outhouse used to be. And the bright light he had seen from across the lake sure wasn’t a kerosene lamp.

A cautious reconnoiter was warranted. He scrabbled clumsily up the slope toward the front window, skirting the stairs that led to the door. With his shoulder pressed against the log wall, Nathan peered into the spacious great-room from the edge of the window.

Daylight had almost completely faded, so the bright interior was easy to see. He recognized the hearth with its imposing iron stove. He also saw that the room was larger and better furnished than he remembered. It now had all the hallmarks of a comfortable home in addition to the touches of rusticity that had always predominated.

Lots of evidence of inhabitation, but no inhabitants were in view. He scanned the room for clues, noting the modern kitchen, one that his wife would appreciate, and the new hallway where the side door used to be. It looked like there were two or three new rooms there.

Suddenly, a man emerged from one of those rooms. Nathan, taking a deep breath, watched him as he entered the main room.

The man was naked. He was an old man, but nevertheless he struck Nathan with a kind of magnificence. He moved about confidently, gracefully, unaware of being watched, giving Nathan the opportunity to take in every detail.

His face, weathered and scarred with years, looked calm and thoughtful, his eyes lit with intelligence. He was of medium build and height, trim and athletic, and tanned without tan lines. His chest, though not chiseled, was firm - his pecs didn’t droop or sag - and wore a light coat of soft grey fur. His shoulders were broad and shapely, wielding strong arms with only a little sag to the skin. Nathan was impressed by his flat stomach. He was relatively hairless there, but the hair picked up again around his navel, a darker and narrower trail that pointed down below his waist.

Ignoring a nagging sense of shame, Nathan allowed the trail to lead his eyes downward, out of bounds, down to where the man’s pubic region was surprisingly neatly trimmed! Nathan was moved by the sight of the substantial cock that was so prominently displayed, languidly relaxed against loose, low-hanging testicles. He felt his pulse jump.

When the man turned back toward the hallway, Nathan turned away to reach the front door, but not before getting a glimpse of the round, firm globes flexing beneath the surface of the sagging skin of the old man’s ass.

He knocked loudly, quickly, as if the man might get away. The door opened. The man looked surprised, but unfazed by either the unexpected visitor or his own state of undress.

“Can I help you?” was the greeting, the voice deep and self-possessed.

“Who are you...” the younger man began, before quickly self-correcting to a more polite introduction, “I’m Nath...”

“Nathan Johannsen!” he interrupted, extending his hand in greeting, “Come in, come in!” He stepped back, pulling Nathan inside while shaking his hand warmly. “I was expecting you sooner or later.”

Closing the door, he continued, “I’m Jan Heikkinen.” Noting Nathan’s confusion, he added, “The caretaker.”

Jan paused a moment and smiled kindly. “I’m sorry about your father,” he said, resting his hand on Nathan’s shoulder.

Nathan felt Jan’s sincerity. It was comforting.

“Come to take possession, eh?” Jan grinned. “Mike told me he was going to...”

Nathan had started removing his parka and Jan reached to take it from him.

“I was just going to the sauna. Why don’t you join me?” He led him to a door in the hallway. “This is your room. Get undressed and join me. We’ll talk.” He pointed down the hall. “The sauna’s right out there.”

The bedroom was surprisingly well furnished. His father’s, he presumed. There were personal items; the framed photo on the dresser was undoubtedly of his family, an attractive woman with three kids.

He didn’t spend any time looking around, though. He stripped quickly, excited about trying the sauna. Normally uncomfortable being naked around men, he was looking forward to hanging with Jan. He reasoned that having already seen Jan in the nude assuaged his modesty. But that didn’t account for his erection.

The truth was, he wanted to look at Jan’s body some more. And the prospect of displaying himself to the older man excited him despite his usual shyness. As he shed his last piece of clothing, he shivered. Not from cold; but from defenselessness. He felt a sudden desire to stand naked and vulnerable before the man.

Nathan was about an inch taller than Jan and a few pounds heavier. Longer of limb, a bit softer in the belly. At forty-five, he had held on to much of his youthful build. The most striking difference was how pale he looked compared to the tan and weathered woodsman.

He shuffled quickly across the wooden walkway to the outbuilding, thankful that the cold air had immediately shriveled his cock to limpness. Less embarrassing. Or was it now too small?

He pulled the thick wooden door open and felt the welcoming heat. Jan had just poured water on the hot stones and was emerging from the steamy mist like a mythical pagan god. Nathan’s cock rose again.

Jan didn’t seem to notice. He motioned to the bench beside him as he seated himself and Nathan perched himself there beside him as nonchalantly as he could while trying not be obvious about hiding his boner.

“The place looks great,” Nathan said. “Do you live here full time?”

“Yup, for the last ... almost nine years,” Jan replied. “Started working on it a few years before that, though. Your dad hired me to put in the indoor plumbing when they got electricity. And then there were more and more projects, literally every year. I had my own business in Rhinelander as a plumber and general contractor. Retired now.”

He was looking Nathan over. He liked what he saw.

“You look a lot like your dad,” he stated. “We got along really well. He did a lot of the work himself, you know. Learned real fast.”

Nathan was impressed. “It’s amazing! I haven’t seen it for like thirty years. I told my wife I’d take a look. I was at a conference in Chicago but nothing on Friday’s schedule was worth staying for, so I canceled my flight and drove back instead. It’s only a couple of hours out of the way...”

“You live in the Cities?”

“St. Paul,” Nathan nodded. “Place looks great, though. I might want to keep It after all.” That would be a definite change of plans.

“Not sure how often we could get out here, though,” he added, unconsciously staring at Jan’s cock, draped over his thigh, ridiculously long and thick.

“It’s only three hours,” Jan said.

“It’s not me, it’s my wife. She does a lot of work at church. Every weekend, pretty much year round.”

Nathan sighed, calculating. Both kids would be in college by fall; there was no reason he couldn’t spend every weekend here if he wanted. It could work, but could he afford it?

“What does my dad pay you?” he asked, lifting his gaze to Jan’s face. It glistened with sweat.

“It’s not like that,” Jan smiled dismissively.

“Seems like a full-time job, though,” Nathan wondered.

Jan studied the younger man speculatively. “Mike paid me in other ways,” he said cryptically.

Something in his tone caught Nathan’s ear, something edgy. “What ways were those?” he asked, feeling a little off balance.

“Let me ask you something,” Jan said in lieu of an answer. “You’ve been looking at my dick a lot.” He picked it up off his thigh as if to show off its full dimensions. “Do you like what you see?”

Nathan stared at it. He couldn’t help admiring the shape and size of it. He had never really considered cock before. Not as such; not as a thing to look at. Certainly not as a thing of beauty.

“I’m sorry,” said Nathan. “I don’t usually ... I mean I’ve never ... I don’t know, I...” he tapered off, suddenly conscious that his own cock was growing stiffer.

Jan shook his big snake, sort of waving it at Nathan as it too became larger and more rigid. With a voice of authority, a tone new to Nathan’s ear, he said, “You haven’t answered my question.”

That drew Nathan’s attention from the cock. What question? he asked himself. “Oh!” he realized, turning his eyes back to the object in question.

“Yes. Yes, I do like it.” He said, surprising himself at his candor. He wanted to say more, but he didn’t have the words.

“You can touch it,” Jan said softly. “Go ahead.”

Nathan reached out and ran his index finger over the top of the big, flared head. It felt soft and warm. The touch made his own cock twitch excitedly. He reached again, farther, and repeated the stroke from further down the shaft. It was alive! It picked itself up off Jan’s palm where it had been resting and pulsed to a straighter, higher posture.

“I think it likes you too,” Jan said decidedly. “Here, why don’t you sit down here, a little closer.” He pointed to his feet. “You can play with it.”

Nathan did what Jan suggested without a thought. Maybe it was the heat, the steam, or just the novelty of the situation, but Nathan felt an implicit trust in Jan, as if he had something to offer that Nathan needed.

He sat cross-legged on the floor, his erection aimed straight up, and reached forward to grasp the larger, semi-erect cock before him. It felt so alive! He could feel Jan’s heartbeat in it. He squeezed it and felt its inner core, firmly resistant, and the weight of it, substantive and hefty. It was mesmerizing.

He stroked it gently, feeling its pliability waning. He squeezed it again and watched a drop of perfectly clear fluid form at its tip.

“Taste it, boy.” Nathan’s voice was soft and low and compelling.

Nathan leaned forward and licked the tip of the cock with the tip of his tongue, The drop disappeared and his tongue returned, bringing a bright, clean flavor and a wonderful texture into his mouth. His mind shifted, a threshold crossed. He liked it; he had licked another man’s cock and he liked it. It seemed at once both harmless and foreboding. What am I doing, he asked himself, how is this normal?

“Good boy,” Jan said, instantly dispelling Nathan’s qualms.

He looked up at the older man’s face while still holding on to the cock. Jan was looking back at him, appraising him, Nathan thought. He returned his focus to the cock in his hand. It was so big! His fingers didn’t reach all the way around the thick shaft. It was beautiful, too, so tall and imposing, its wide, flared head so shiny. Its little piss-slit seemed to smile at him.

I licked a man’s cock! he said to himself in disbelief. Why did it excite him so? His own cock was fiercely raging.

Am I gay now, he worried. Am I turning into a cocksucker? His mouth watered, despite his dismay, at this idea, so taboo.

He looked up at Jan again, in search of approval. He needed to know he hadn’t disgraced himself. Thankfully, he saw no disapproval there, but Jan still seemed to be sizing Nathan up.

Nathan felt the need to earn this man’s approbation for some reason, in some manner. By pleasuring his cock, perhaps?

He began to stroke it. He pumped it with two hands, enjoying the feel of it as his sweaty hands slid up and down the long pole, enjoying the knowledge of how good it must feel to Jan. Up and down. He wanted Jan to feel it, the pleasure of it. Up and down. He had decided. He wanted to give this pleasure to him. Up and down. He wanted Jan to come. He needed to make Jan come, to give him all the pleasure he could. To please him.

“That’s very good, Nathan,” Jan said. But he stood up, and took the cock away from him. “You’re doing a fine job, boy, but I’m going to finish it myself.”

Nathan was elated by the encouraging words even as he already missed the feel of the other’s sex.

Jan stroked himself vigorously.

“Look at me, boy,” he commanded.

Nathan tilted his head. Jan’s face looked as intense as his stroking had become.

“Open your mouth.”

Nathan complied.

“Stick out your tongue.” Jan’s breath was getting ragged. “No, straight out,” he corrected.

Nathan waited anxiously, helplessly, with his tongue out. Saliva was pooling in his mouth. He began to drool, feeling like a dumb animal, as he watched the swelling cock and the hand that flew up and down its shaft. He watched, excited, like a pet awaiting his master’s treat. Did he deserve a treat? Had he been a good boy?

Then Jan came! He grunted. He aimed the shot right into the open mouth. Nathan felt it hit the back of his throat as another spurt landed on his tongue. Cum was pouring down onto his tongue now as Jan spoke.

“Don’t swallow. Wait until I tell you.”

Nathan was overwhelmed with sensation and emotion. The heat of the sauna. His throbbing cock. His heart was pounding. Sweat had fallen from Jan’s face; it was mingled with his, stinging his eyes. And Jan’s cum - he held it in his mouth - its fumes were permeating his nasal membranes - it felt thick and heavy on his tongue, salty and acrid.

Why was he so excited, so sexually aroused? he wondered as he waited ... Why did he feel compelled to obey?

“You may swallow now,” came the signal Nathan had so expectantly waited for.

Nathan swallowed. It went down easily, easier than he expected. But it left an aftertaste, oddly bitter and caustic. It tasted like surrender.

Jan squeezed a final dollop of slimy cum out of his softening cock onto his index finger. He extended his hand to Nathan’s lips. Nathan opened his mouth and accepted the slime-coated digit and dutifully sucked it clean.

He found both the flavor and the texture more to his liking this time. “Thank you, sir,” he said after he had swallowed. He truly did feel grateful, beholden even.

Jan put the head of his cock to Nathan’s lips. “There’s a little more. Clean it up.”

Nathan opened his mouth to engulf the bulbous glans, closing his lips around the shaft behind the flange and polished the knob with his swirling tongue that delighted in the soft, smooth texture of its skin.

He sucked gently as he swallowed, compressing the object that so perfectly fit his oral cavity. His sexual arousal had now reached even greater heights and he was close to orgasm.

He reached for his own cock, wanting to masturbate, needing to answer cum for cum.

Jan moved his foot to block Nathan’s hand, nudging it away. “No,” he said, “Not yet.”

But it was too late. Nathan’s cock erupted, spewing his seed onto his belly and down his shaft, pooling and clotting in his pubic hair.

Nathan’s orgasmic rush was tinged with fear. Had he angered his partner, his accomplice in this ... whatever this was? Jan was more than a confederate, though. More like a leader, the mastermind, the author of this thing.

“I’m sorry!” Nathan cried out, his voice shaking with orgastic wobbles, “I couldn’t help it!”

Jan loved the sound of panic in Nathan’s voice. So submissive! He laughed out loud and stood up. “Come on,” he said, and offered the flustered Nathan a hand. “You need a shower.”

The cold air of the outdoor passage was exhilarating, as was the quick ice-cold shower they took together in the mudroom just inside the cabin.

“I’m going to fix supper,” said Jan, “while you call your wife. Tell her you’re staying over till Sunday.”

He smacked Nathan on the ass and added, “Don’t get dressed. Meet me in the kitchen when you’re done.”

Jan was wearing jeans and a sweat shirt when the two sat down at the table to eat. As he dug into the steaming bowl of venison chili and chewed a hunk of sourdough, Nathan began to lose some of the self-consciousness he felt, being the only one naked. But he was still grappling with his uncharacteristic behavior in the sauna and he worried about the impression it must have given Jan.

Deliberately suppressing the shame he felt, he found it easy to praise the meal. He was hungry and tired and the food was both satisfying and mood-lifting. Jan replied that he enjoyed cooking, especially when ingredients, like the venison for example, had been harvested by his own efforts.

They talked about hunting and fishing for a minute or two. Then a silence fell as they continued to eat.

“About what happened before...” Nathan began abruptly, “I don’t know...” he faltered. “I mean, I’ve never done anything like that. I mean...”

“Nothing happened that I didn’t want to happen,” Jan stated flatly. He stared Nathan down.

Nathan shut up and turned red.

“Let’s talk about the cabin,” Jan said. “What are your plans?”

Nathan relaxed a little. “I was going to sell it, but now I don’t know. I told my wife I was thinking of keeping it. I told her what it’s like now - nothing like I remember - how it’s got everything all fixed up and up to date...

“The thing is, I don’t know how much time I can spend here and you can’t just leave a place like this unattended. Even with a good alarm system, I don’t think.”

He looked at Jan, studying the lines on his face, like etched wisdom.

“If you stayed on as caretaker ... What exactly was the arrangement you had with Dad?” he asked the older man.

 
There is more of this story...
The source of this story is Storiesonline

To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account (Why register?)

Get No-Registration Temporary Access*

* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In