Chapter 5

I arrived at Sarah's Friday night Halloween party dressed in a pirate costume. I had a black hat and coat, a fake parrot to sit on my shoulder, and an eye patch on my forehead because it annoyed me when it was over my eye.

Tiffany was dressed as a princess in a fancy dress and a tiara. I guessed it was an actual dress she once wore somewhere. Elizabeth had a clown wig with baggy pants. Samantha looked like a farm girl. Angela said she was dressed like a singer but everyone mistakenly thought she was a prostitute because she wore this low cut top that would show a lot of cleavage if she actually had tits. Her top was still very revealing because the pink material was thin and semi-transparent. I could see her small mounds and her nipples and she gave me a hard-on every time I was around her. Angela's skirt was very short and the way it clung and moved made me think she was without panties. I thought Melissa looked like a farm girl like Samantha but she explained that the stuffed dog she carried around was Toto and she was Dorothy from The Wizard of Oz. Erica who was the last to arrive came dressed in her gymnastic tights and we all accused her of wimping-out which obviously she did. Speaking of wimp-outs, Sarah was dressed in blue jeans and a t-shirt. She said she would get dressed after everyone arrived.

I danced with all the girls including Erica but not Melissa. It was a fun time and we played some games and the usual suspects flirted with me - Tiffany and Elizabeth. As the evening wore down, we sat on the floor in the den and snacked and talked.

"Time to get into my costume," announced Sarah.

By now, I forgot she was not in her costume and I assumed she never was going to get changed.

Five minutes later, Elizabeth exclaimed, "Sarah!"

All eyes went to her. My eyes certainly did. Sarah was naked.

"I'm pirate treasure," Sarah said. She lay on her back on the floor with raised knees and opened legs. "Pirate Jack, take your treasure."

Tiffany immediately started to remove her clothes and said, "Would the naughty pirate like to put his sword away in the princess?"

Elizabeth said as she became naked, "Pirates make a clown so happy."

Singer Angela said as she removed her scant clothes, "I need some helping hitting my high notes."

Samantha said as she undressed, "You'd make a great farmer. You have a great big pitchfork."

I definitely had a great big pitchfork now.

Erica sat goggled eyed at what was going on.

Melissa stood, "You sluts! You all want to fuck him?"

"Don't knock a good thing," said Sarah.

I looked at Melissa and then at Sarah and her open legs that were an invitation for me to enter her pussy. I looked at the increasing nudity of the other girls. Angela wore practically nothing anyway and now I feasted on the sight of her completely naked body for the first time. I once more enjoyed looking at Tiffany and at Elizabeth with her large tits that caused her to be such a bad gymnast. Sophomore Samantha looked very much like naked Tiffany when she was naked. They both were small brunettes.

Melissa looked at me and said with distaste, "Enjoy!"

"Melissa!" called out Tiffany.

Melissa stopped and turned.

"You don't know unless you try it," Tiffany said. "It's that good with him and Jack's a nice guy."

Melissa shook her head and left.

"Why does she think she needs to date a football player?" Tiffany asked to no one in particular.

"She's so stuck up since high school," said Elizabeth.

Sarah thrust her hips up which grabbed my attention. She lilted, "Oh, Pirate Jack. Get your treasure."

"Or your princess," said Tiffany. She rubbed her clit.

"I'm first!" said Sarah.

"Why?"

"It's my house," Sarah said authoritatively. "Now get that hot sword over here and fuck me."

I barely started to undress when Tiffany, Angela, Elizabeth, and Samantha began to do it for me. Erica remained wide-eyed and frozen as a statue.

My cock sliced right into Sarah's pussy and I thrust right away.

"Oh, fuck, yes!" moaned Sarah.

After sex with Tiffany in front of Elizabeth, I had no misgivings about the audience. I focused on the wonderful sensations.

"Oh, yes!" Sarah gasped. "Yessss!"

The sex was almost as hurried as when we did it in the bathroom but it was much more satisfactory because there was no concern about getting caught. Everyone watched us screw.

"Jack! Jack! Jack!" she moaned my name.

I grunted as my thrusts became hard rapid fires.

Sarah cried out. She arched underneath and then collapsed down.

I groaned and pressed down hard and deep. I exhaled loudly as I shot my cum into Sarah.

As soon as I lifted off Sarah, hands pulled me until I was on my back. Angela climbed on me with her cunt near my face and she gently massaged my cock with her hands. I stared at her pussy.

"Hey!" protested Tiffany.

"It's my turn!" insisted Angela. "I haven't done it with him yet and then he does Samantha next, right?"

"Right!" said Samantha then spoke to Tiffany. "You let him take your virginity. I want him to take mine."

"You're a virgin?" said Angela.

"I know - surprise but I haven't done it."

"But you two will wear him out," whined Elizabeth.

"Deal with it," said Angela. "Me then Samantha next."

Tiffany looked at me as if I should say something. I knew the best thing to do was keep my mouth shut. I'd do my best to satisfy them all. I didn't have the concept in my head that their might be a limitation to how many times I could get hard again.

Hard again was my cock. Angela spun around and put her sex-slimy hands on my chest. She lifted her hips and easily found my cock with her pussy.

"She's good," said Elizabeth when Angela's cunt easily slid down my pole.

"She's experienced," said Tiffany.

"She's a slut," came Sarah's satisfied voice.

"Even sluts want satisfaction," said Angela.

"I'm not objecting," said Sarah. "He definitely satisfies."

Sarah looked at Samantha, "Ready to say good-bye to your cherry?"

"I can't wait," Samantha replied. "I'm so wet already."

It's not that I didn't notice Angela. I can't not notice a warm pussy moving up and down on my cock, but after cumming so recently in Sarah's sweet cunt I now could just enjoy the good sensations and focus on the conversations by the non-participant girls. However that all changed when Angela slid slightly forward which altered the angle and then she started these wonderful cunt squeezes.

I groaned loudly which got everyone's attention. It was so loud that I felt like five houses in all directions heard me.

Angela was good. Angela was very good.

Every time I wanted to hold her hips and rub her nipples, a new powerful sensation surged in my cock and my arms collapsed back down to my side. I had the energy to thrust up and meet her cunt but I couldn't grip her tightly in my hands like I wanted to do.

"You're so deep!" moaned Angela. "So fucking deep in me!"

"Now that's fucking," said Tiffany to Elizabeth.

"There's definitely a good side to sleeping with a lot of guys," replied Elizabeth.

"Experience," said Tiffany.

"Experience," agreed Elizabeth.

"Oh, fuck!" said the bouncing Angela. "This is the best fuck ever!"

"That's saying a lot," said Sarah.

"Oh, shut up!" said Angela between moans.

"Just kidding."

"Ohhhh!" moaned Angela. She stopped at the apex of my cock. She trembled and slowly slid down my cock orgasming all the way.

Unexpectedly I spurted my cum up into Angela. I felt close but I didn't feel ready yet something about her last downward movement rubbed me the right way and my cock shot off.

Angela collapsed off to the side toward Tiffany and Elizabeth. I sunk into the carpet and felt very relaxed.

"Play with him," Sarah said. "Be gentle. He'll be sensitive."

I wasn't sure who she said that to until Samantha said, "Okay."

"Once he's recovered, he can fuck you and take away that embarrassing virginity problem."

Samantha giggled and moved over. She took my soft cock in her hands and said, "Hi."

"Hi," I replied and smiled back at her.

This was the best costume Halloween party I ever went to.

This was the best Halloween party I ever went to.

This was the best party I ever went to.

This was the best.

"I think I wanted to do this with you ever since the first day you started gymnastics. I thought you were so cute," said Samantha.

"You did?" I said surprised.