Too Old for Halloween - Cover

Too Old for Halloween

by Tristan Tharp

Copyright© 2026 by Tristan Tharp

Horror Sex Story: Robin took a job that seemed too good to be true. All that was required was his presence for one hour on Halloween night. No experience required. And the pay was excellent. He should've listened to his instincts. The job offer was a trick, and he was NOT in for a treat.

Caution: This Horror Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including mt/Fa   Coercion   Mind Control   NonConsensual   Rape   Reluctant   Gay   BiSexual   Heterosexual   Horror   Paranormal   Magic   Humiliation   Anal Sex   First   Masturbation   Oral Sex   Voyeurism   Halloween   .

The online ad had been strangely specific, but also annoyingly vague.

Wanted: Male human. Not a child. Not a man. Halloween night only. No experience required. No experience desired.

The ad claimed only one hour of work was required. And the pay it offered was ... enticing. Robin was saving for his first car. Just acquiring enough money for a decent downpayment was taking a frustratingly long time. Flipping burgers part time didn’t pay much. Mom and Dad were helping, but there was only so much they could afford. That one hour of work ... a mere sixty minutes ... would bring him so much closer. Robin was tired of his friends having to taxi him around everywhere. They’d all been driving for at least a year. He was still just a lowly passenger. Even worse was when one of his parents had take him anywhere. It made him feel like he was still a little kid.

A week before Halloween, he’d answered the ad. An hour later he received a survey in his email that could only be described as creepy. Besides some innocuous inquiries into his interests ... comic books and the school baseball team ... there was a long series of questions that were odd, almost invasive. It never blatantly demanded his sexual history, but it crept around the edges of that particularly sore subject, poking and prodding. The truth was, he had no sexual history ... unless long hours masterbating in his darkened bedroom counted. Which it didn’t.

All of his friends either had girlfriends or told lurid tales of sweaty one-night encounters. They weren’t virgins. Or so they said. Robin sometimes wondered. Actually, he hoped at least some of them were exaggerating, or lying outright. He hated the thought of being the only inexperienced one in the group. He’d tried telling his own lies to compensate, but he didn’t fool anyone. He was a terrible liar. When they demanded names and particulars, his stories always fell apart. His virginity and his attempts to lie about it were the source of a lot of teasing.

Robin had the uneasy feeling the questionnaire had rooted out this embarrassing virginity with its oblique yet incisive inquiries. It was embarrassing. Someone, somewhere ... a total stranger on the other side of the computer screen ... knew Robin’s most shameful secret.

Was that faceless person some kind of pervert, trying to lure innocent young men into a lair of danger and debauchery? The name on the email was Wisteria Vale. Wisteria sounded like a woman’s name. Surely a woman wouldn’t be some kind of sexual predator. Or maybe he was being naive. On the other hand, Robin wasn’t so naive he believed that name was necessarily the sender’s real name. In fact, it sounded fake. Wisteria Vale? Really?

He agonized over his decision for days. Was he really willing to accept the risk of being molested by some big, hairy pervert just to get a few hundred dollars closer to his dream car?

In the end, his answer was what he’d known it would be all along.


He’d bicycled by the vacant lot a million times over the course of his life. It was perpetually choked with weeds and covered in gnarly, misshapen oak trees. Even on a bright afternoon, those trees shrouded the lot in gloom. It was a mysterious anomaly in an otherwise well-ordered suburban neighborhood. No one knew who owned it. The local kids avoided it.

At exactly nine o’clock on Halloween night, as stipulated, Robin stared at the lot from the street with a growing anxiety. What was he doing here? Was he crazy? The sounds of rambunctious trick-or-treaters were far away on other streets. The only other person he’d seen in the vicinity was someone walking unsteadily about a block down the street. The guy had probably overindulged at an early Halloween party. Now even the drunk was gone. Robin was alone.

The scariest feature of the dark abandoned lot was that it was no longer abandoned. A dilapidated old house stood far back from the street, nestled in the tress. Robin would’ve sworn it had never been there before. But there it was, with warm, yellow light flickering through the windows. Maybe he’d never been by at nighttime, so there was no light to give away its presence. He couldn’t remember. His mind seemed strangely foggy.

The trick-or-treaters sounded even further away than before. Their voices were muted. The neighborhood around him seemed to retreat into the distance. Robin could’ve been inside a bubble, isolated him from the rest of the world. He wanted to run, but he couldn’t remember how. There was only one move available to him, and that was forward through the thick weeds towards the front door of an old decrepit house that shouldn’t even exist.

Robin stepped onto a gravel path he only just then noticed. He ventured forward, following it as it weaved through the dark, menacing trees. There seemed to be more of these than before. It was a forest. The pointy ends of branches, looking like skeletal fingers, snagged the sleeves of his hoodie as though trying to remove his clothes. Robin felt a chill of premonition.

When he reached the house, it was larger than it had originally seemed, though still in a ramshackle state. The stairs to the porch creaked beneath his feet. The porch itself was littered with clay pots spilling over with all manner of plants. Three rickety looking rocking chairs sat off to the side, moving eerily in the slight breeze. The boards of the wooden siding warped outwards.

Two jack o’lanterns sat on either side of the front door. Orange flames burned behind their eyes. Their sly, grinning faces told Robin they knew things he didn’t.

The front door opened with the high, squawking sound of rusty hinges. A heavyset old woman stood in the doorway. She wore a long, shapeless black dress that draped all the way to the floor and a pointed black hat with a wide brim.

In a rasping voice, she asked, “Are you trick-or-treating, young man?”

The spell that had pulled Robin from the street to the house was broken. His mind immediately cleared. The renewed clarity brought a sense of outrage at being mistaken for someone young enough to engage in such childish frivolities.

He proclaimed haughtily, “I’m way too old for Halloween.”

The old woman’s laugh became a coughing rattle. When she recovered, she said, “I’m over a hundred years old, and I’m not too old for Halloween.”

Robin thought to himself, Obviously not. You’re dressed like a cartoon witch.

She said, “Then I suppose you must be Robin, the young man who answered our online advertisement. You’re our nine o’clock.”

“Yes, ma’am,” he replied. He noticed how she’d mentioned the time. Her wording made it sound as if there’d be other respondents at other times. Was he even the first?

He was also amazed this old woman knew how to use a computer. Weren’t old people completely lost when it came to modern technology?

Then he recalled how she’d used the word our. She wasn’t alone. His suspicions flared up again. Something had always seemed off about this short-term, high-paying employment. It was even more shady now that he’d arrived. He should never have agreed to come.

“Ma’am,” he said nervously. “I think I’ve changed my mind. I’m just not sure about this at all.”

The old woman’s expression hardened. “Young man, your acceptance of our offer constitutes a contract. And contracts with witches are binding. I believe you noticed that on your trip to our front door. I could detect your feeble, unconscious attempts at resistance. If you were of stronger will, you could’ve broken the bond. But that would’ve been a very unwise act, one that would have lasting consequences ... at least for as long as you lasted.” Her face brightened in a smile. “Luckily for you, you’re a typical, feeble-minded young man of your generation. So, here you are, in compliance. You should be fine.”

Robin didn’t know how to respond. The old woman was both reassuring and insulting at the same time. But some inner voice of warning told him she was quite serious about the perils of defaulting on their agreement. After all, he had been compelled by some mysterious force all the way to this front door.

The old woman stepped aside. “Come in, young Robin. Your hour has already begun.”

Robin reluctantly entered a large, rustic room. It was lit with dozens and dozens of candles and lanterns scattered about haphazardly on old tables and shelves. Another jack o’lantern sat at the end of a wooden table in the center of the room. It’s features were alight with an internal flame. Green vines coiled around the table legs and spread out on the floor. Potted plants were everywhere. The air was thick with the smells of the scented candles, incense, the earth in the potted plants, and other nameless odors. Robin felt light-headed.

Two other women, their features and garb indistinguishable from the first one, awaited him.

Wisteria said, “Robin, these are my sisters. Ivy is on the left and Briar on the right. In case you hadn’t guessed, we’re triplets. The power of three holds even more power when the three are all born of the same woman at the same time. This means we’re not witches to be trifled with, young man. Just a friendly warning.”

Robin said, “Oh ... ok.”

Wisteria continued with the introductions. “My sisters, this is Robin, a young man who has graciously offered the entirety of himself to us for an hour of our evening.”

Ivy spoke. “In the interests of transparency, we should mention that an hour within these walls can be however long we wish it to last.”

Briar added, “You could spend a hundred years with us here tonight, and still emerge only an hour later into the outside world.”

Wisteria said, “But don’t worry your very pretty little self about that. You’ll only age the promised hour. Once we’ve done all we wish to do to you, you’ll still be the same youthful, puerile young man you were sixty minutes before ... if a bit more experienced ... and a bit more aware of the shadows that can surround you even in the light.”

Ivy said, “And perhaps with a haunted look in your eyes for the rest of your life.”

Briar said, “And you may cry yourself to sleep some nights.”

“Or wake up screaming.”

They’d been moving around in front of him, looking him over in a disturbing intensive way. Robin had lost track of which witch was which. The only one he continued to sure of, for some reason, was Wisteria.

Another one spoke. “You’ll never be able to take yourself in hand again for your lonely pleasures without thinking of this hour on this singular Halloween night.”

“When you finally coax a partner into bed ... probably years from now, if ever ... you’ll see our wizened features over her own as you move inside her.”

“And Jack, of course. You’ll see Jack.”

“You’ll feel Jack.”

Robin was growing increasingly alarmed. He whispered, “Jack?”

Wisteria said, “You’ll meet Jack soon enough. You’ll wish you hadn’t, of course. But we’re paying you well for your troubles. You have nothing to complain about.”

“In the old days, when we’d finish with one of you young virgins ... usually your age or younger ... we’d just leave him naked and quivering on the side of the road ... sometimes with a few foreign objects up his butt just for fun. Being found in that state by his fellow townsfolk always made his life more interesting from then on.”

“The townsfolk were terrified of any lingering effects of being used by witches. The boys had to undergo some very embarrassing cleansing rituals in the middle of the town square, including being bathed aggressively with lye soap and stiff brushes by all the women in the town.”

“In those days, the word women included all females from ten years and up.”

“Don’t forget the repeated public purging of the bladder and bowels to eliminate anything evil that might’ve been left within. The forced consumption of some harsh laxatives ... provided by a secret member of our coven ... insured this stage could last for days.”

“And the boys then had to purge themselves in another way.”

“They had to do what young men your age are so adept at ... manually spilling their seed. At least twenty times just to be sure. That took place over the course of days, too.”

“That was to insure there’d be enough volume in every release.”

“All of this had to be witnessed by everyone in town, no exceptions, or ... according to their beliefs ... the procedures wouldn’t work.”

Robin had grown increasingly horrified at this tale. “Why ... who ... I mean, where did all these rules come from? Who thought of this stuff?”

“Our coven wasn’t above a few practical jokes. Ages before, we had secretly provided the sacred texts that outlined the cleansing procedures. The ignorant fools took it all as gospel. They were trying to do their best for those unfortunate boys, but were only degrading them even further. And believe me, those rituals were designed for maximum humiliation. Those boys suffered.”

“Ahhh, yes. Those were the days. Once we’d used a young man for our rather esoteric purposes, we knew he’d continue to be humiliated long afterwards. We’d be secretly in the crowd to watch his continued degradations firsthand.”

Robin said, “You said that witches would do this in the old days. But you make it sound like you were there personally. I mean ... you couldn’t have been. This sounds like something from medieval times or something.”

Wisteria said, “You’d be surprised what life was still like in some isolated areas even into the early twentieth century. Besides, I told you we were over a hundred years old. I didn’t say how many hundreds of years over a hundred we were.”

Robin was getting close to crying. “Are you going to do that to me? The public purging and all that?”

“That’s all in the past. We’ve gotten more mellow as we’ve aged. We’ve become kindly.”

“The most we do now is leave a few time-delayed spells to cause things like spontaneous erections at inconvenient times.”

“Like in the locker room after your baseball practice. In the hot, steamy showers with all those other boys.

“I’m sorry to say you’ll become notorious for your ... lack of control.”

“Then there are the spells that do the opposite by denying an erection when it’s most needed.”

“Girls love that.”

“She’s being sarcastic, by the way. Having no experience, you might not have realized that.”

Offended, Robin snapped, “I’m not stupid. I know girls don’t like guys who can’t get it up.”

Wisteria asked mildly, “Do you want to be notorious for that, too?”

Robin almost whimpered, “No. No, ma’am, I don’t.”

“Then watch that tone when you speak to us. You’re definitely getting the unwanted erection spell. More than the usual, I’d say. And in more locations and situations. Your parents may end up taking you in for some counseling. Not that it’ll work. You’re about to learn that disrespecting your elders has its consequences.”

“We can manipulate events with situational spells, too. I think I’ll cast one that undermines your privacy. You’ll never know when someone will walk in on you during your more personal moments.”

“Yes, that sounds fun. Changing clothes, showering, peeing, pooping, and ... of course ... masterbating.”

“No one will intentionally try to catch you in those various acts. It’ll just happen. Often.”

Robin said, “Please don’t.”

Wisteria told him, “It’s a done deal. Just watch your mouth from now on or it gets worse.”

Robin meekly said, “Yes, ma’am.”

“There, that’s a good boy. Is respect so hard?”

“You should tell him about the connection. He should know we’ll always be with him from now on.”

“Yes. We’ll be able to tune in on what’s going on with you. You’ll be like a television station we can turn on when we need a diversion. We’ll see through your eyes. We’ll feel what you feel.”

“And when one of our time-release spells kicks in ... like the unwanted erection in the locker room ... we’ll be alerted. We’ll feel your anxiety and panic as you begin to harden. We’ll know your sense of shame as the other boys see you in your aroused state. We’ll see their jeering faces. We’ll feel what you feel at their laughter and ridicule.”

“We’ll know if they take their responses further and do what mobs of hormonal young men are capable of.”

One of the witches unconsciously rubbed between her legs. “Oh, my. I’m getting excited. Enough talk. Let’s get this show started.”

Robin had backed up to the door. He said plaintively, “I don’t deserve this. I’ve never done anything to anyone.”

Wisteria said, “Oh, we know that. It’s one of the reasons we chose you. We could tell by how you answered our questions that you were an innocent. That quality makes your degradation so much sweeter.”

“But don’t worry. All you’re going to do is provide some entertainment for three poor, feeble old ladies who don’t have the vigor they used to. Our bodies can’t take the rigors of the coercive sexual conquests that used to bring us such enjoyment. But we can watch Jack do all the strenuous activities for us. And we can feel the effects on you as you endure his attentions.”

And we can sit back and ... well ... partake in our own way.”

“Jack provides all the visual, emotional and internal stimuli.”

Robin was trying to stealthily turn the doorknob behind him. “What does that mean?”

Wisteria said, “You’ll see. And the door is locked, Robin. And not simply locked. It’s spell-locked. As are the windows. You could throw a chair at one ... or try to jump through it ... and it wouldn’t so much as crack the glass. We know. It’s been tried many times before. You’re here with us till we decide to let you go. And we won’t do that till you’ve satisfied Jack ... and us in the process.”

Robin’s voice quavered. “What are you ... what is Jack... going to do to me?”

The three witches looked at each other as if in silent conference. Wisteria answered, “Everything.”

“Pretty much.”

“Yes, everything.”

Wisteria said, “You probably don’t know what everything includes. You only have experience with masterbation. And a lot of experience at that. Am I correct?”

Robin cried, “You keep talking about me jerking off. That’s ... that’s like ... really personal.”

“It appears to be a touchy subject. Get it ... touchy. As in touching himself.”

“Ivy, bad jokes don’t get any better by over-explaining them.”

“The boy probably isn’t completely inexperienced. There’s second-hand experience from watching internet porn. That’s how virgins satisfy their urges nowadays.”

“That won’t prepare him for Jack, unless he’s been on some really strange websites.”

Robin told them, “If you wanted to humiliate me ... you’ve accomplished it. Your work is done. You can keep the money. Just let me go, ok? I won’t tell anyone about this.”

Wisteria said, “That’s true. You won’t. And I think I’d like an answer to my question.”

Robin was genuinely confused. “What question?”

“About how experienced you are with masterbation.”

Robin cried, “What? What does it matter?”

Wisteria explained patiently, “It matters because the subject embarrasses you. Much of how my sisters and I attain our gratification is by reaping vengeance on the male race for the injustices they’ve inflicted on womankind throughout the ages. We do whatever our scapegoat of the moment doesn’t like to be done. We bring up whatever makes him uncomfortable. In your case, as Ivy said, masterbation is a touchy subject. You’re ashamed of it.”

She was correct. Robin’s friends had other outlets for their needs besides their own hands ... or humping a pile of pillows as he sometimes did. He felt like a barely pubescent child next to them. Rather than address that embarrassingly astute part of her statement, he said as carefully as he could, “Don’t get mad at me, please. But you said the male race. I don’t think males are actually a separate race.”

“Of course they are, young man. I’ve seen much more of the world than you. Males and females may fit together for purposes of pleasure and procreation, but that’s as far as the commonalities go. Men are a breed apart ... perverted, savage, violent, domineering. Most of them are rapists. The younger ones are rapists-in-training. Name any negative attribute, and it will be men who embody it.”

Robin protested, “I’m not like that. Really. I’m not a ... a rapist-in-training. Why are you taking it out on me?”

Wisteria shrugged. “I explained that. Innocent women suffer under men. So, you will suffer under us.”

“And Jack.”

“Yes. And Jack. You have to bear the burden of the male race’s sins. Now ... answer my question or I’ll show you savagery to rival anything a man can do.”

She made a small gesture with one hand. Robin flinched as he felt something twist inside him. It wasn’t terribly painful, but it was enough to demonstrate she was capable of what she threatened.

“Ok, ok. I ... yes ... I jerk off. I said it. Ok?”

One of the other witches asked, “How often?”

Robin felt sick. This was humiliating. “A lot, I guess. Once or twice a day. Sometimes more. I’m ... I’m horny a lot and I don’t have a girlfriend. As you know.”

Wisteria narrowed her eyes at him. “A girlfriend isn’t just something to dump the sticky fluids of your lusts into. She’s a human being, a partner, someone you supposedly love.”

Robin quickly said, “Yes, yes. I know all that. I didn’t mean that’s the only reason for a girlfriend. You’ve just got me all agitated. I can’t think.”

The next witch in line asked, “How do you do it? Show us.”

“How do I do what?”

“What do you think we’re talking about? Masterbation, boy. Show us how you masterbate.”

Robin cried, “Really?”

Wisteria answered, “Really.”

He hesitated, hoping they were joking. The looks they gave him as they waited said they were quite serious. He hesitantly put his right hand down to the level of his crotch and mimed a jerking off motion. After five strokes of the invisible penis, he dropped his hand and let out a whimper. That had been awful.

Wisteria said, “I think there’s been a miscommunication. That can happen with such a generational gap. My sister asked you to demonstrate how you masterbate, not play a game of charades. So, show her. Show all of us.”

Robin still wasn’t sure what they were asking. “You don’t mean ... like ... really doing it? In front of you.”

Wisteria said, “Yes, like really doing it. And take off your clothes first. I suspect you’re often naked when you self-pleasure.”

Robin stood for a long, long moment, agonizing over what he should do. These witches were the real thing. They’d proven that. But what they were ordering him to do was too much. He’d suspected this job might involve something sleazy ... the questionnaire had been so peculiar, and the pay was just too good, especially for a single hour. But he’d always figured he could refuse and leave, running and screaming if he had to. There had always been the chance that his employer would turn out to be that big, hairy pervert. But Robin had decided to risk it. He played baseball ... not very well, but he did play ... so he was ... kind of ... athletic. He might be able to fight off an attacker.

 
There is more of this story...
The source of this story is Storiesonline

To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account (Why register?)

Get No-Registration Temporary Access*

* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In