Am I a Nymphomaniac
by SuburbanStories
Copyright© 2025 by SuburbanStories
Erotica Sex Story: Seventeen-year-old Lilly, after several sexual adventures, worries that she might be a nymphomaniac. She consults with her best friend, Braylin who tells her she is normal, but she is still unsure. So she turns to a dirty old man and then her pastor to help her determine whether she is a nymphomaniac
Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/ft ft/ft Mult Teenagers Consensual Drunk/Drugged Reluctant Teen Siren Fiction Anal Sex Cream Pie Oral Sex Clergy .
Ever since Lilly turned seventeen last fall, she had been wondering. Am I just a normal teenager who likes sex? Or am I a nymphomaniac- a pervert girl who wants to have sex all the time and can’t think of anything else? And if I am a nympho, what should I do about it?
Lilly’s best friend Braylin told her she was just normal; that all sixteen and seventeen-year-old girls loved sex. Braylin said she loved having sex with boys in school and older guys, and even with men old enough to be her father- and all teen girls did too. Braylin told Lilly that once she even had let her momma’s boyfriend fuck her, after he went down on her, and licked her pussy until Braylin was cumming all over his mouth and chin. Lilly thought that sounded pretty dirty. She even told Braylin that it sounded kind of wrong to be doing her ma’s boyfriend. But when Braylin showed Lilly a picture of the guy- named Jake- she had to admit he was pretty hot, and Lilly admitted she might do him if he went down on her, too. He had scruffy blond hair and a little beard that looked like it might tickle a little bit if he rubbed it around her kitty.
Lilly didn’t have any other close girlfriends she could talk to about this personal issue, and she sure couldn’t talk to her mom about it. Her mom, Grace, was one of the few moms in the neighborhood who had a night shift job; she worked at the diner. Grace was now part-owner of the diner and told Lilly she could start working there once school was out for the summer. But Lilly was worried that she might just get carried away and end up fucking more customers like she had at Christmas break when her mom let her fill in as a waitress.
That little incident was part of what made Lilly think she might be a nympho. She had been working at the diner all afternoon, and she was due to get off work at 8 when this guy came in around 7:15 and sat by himself in a booth. He had smiled at Lilly, so even though her shift was almost over she walked over to his table, since she thought he was sort of cute. And she unbuttoned the top two buttons on her blouse as she walked.
Now at this point, it makes sense to give you a little description of Lilly, because her sexy body was part of the reason she got hit on by the customer that night, and on other occasions as well. Lilly was tall, with long muscular legs, and a tight ass. She also had bigger boobs than your average seventeen-year-old, a firm set of solid b-cup tits. Of course, her little white waitress button-up blouse showed them off with its deep v-neckline, and she sometimes left the top button or two open, to show a little more of her tits. Lilly had dark- almost black hair that was a little unruly and cut short around her cute face. She looked a little wild and a little innocent, all at the same time.
So the guy at the table had smiled, and when she bent over to ask what he wanted, Lilly- intentionally- gave him a good look at the firm mounds of her tits, straining against her cotton blouse.
“I’m Lilly, and I’ll be your server. What would you like, sir,” Lilly asked politely, her green eyes sparkling.
The guy, looked first at her luscious tits, and then looked right into her big green eyes, and said, “I think I know just what I want, but it ain’t on the menu ... When does your shift end, Lilly?”
Lilly was a little shocked by the guy’s aggressive response, and she smiled and blushed a little, and looked away from his piercing gaze. She also brought a hand up to sort of block the view of her deep cleavage. But she felt a tingle in her crotch, and she shivered just a bit at the guy’s confident attitude.
“Well ... errr ... I ... I do get off pretty soon, but I can’t go out...” Lilly stuttered out.
“My name is Luke, and I’m just in town for a business meeting, but I’d love to have you accompany me to the nightclub down the street for a drink, Lilly,” Luke said, ignoring her protest that she couldn’t go out. Then he added, “You are just about the most beautiful thing I’ve seen in this whole town.”
Lilly knew he was complimenting her, and trying to get her to say yes, but that tingle she felt was getting warmer and was spreading.
“Well, I guess I could have one drink with you,” she said finally, not mentioning she was not quite old enough to order alcohol. “But you need to order something here, before the kitchen closes.”
“Great,” Luke said with a big smile that made Lilly get all hot,” I’ll have a grilled cheese and fries, and a Diet Coke.”
“I’ll put it in right away,” Lilly said, smiling back, and turning quickly to turn the order in at the kitchen counter. Luke admired her long legs in the short, black skirt as she walked away, noticing the the black and white striped knee high socks, and red Converse sneakers with fat wedge heels that she wore. The socks and heeled shoes added even more height to her tall, sexy frame.
She then told her mom a little lie, that she wouldn’t be coming home after work, that she was going over to her friend Braylin’s house. Her mom shrugged and said “fine- I’ll see you in the morning.”
After her shift ended she met Luke outside, and they went to the little bar up the road, and Lilly had a rum and coke, and let Luke sweet talk her, and listen to her talk about school and working in the diner. She felt the rum and Coke, and enjoyed Luke’s gentle touching, and when he suggested they go back to his motel, she just smiled and took his hand.
Once in the room, Luke embraced her with a big hug, and kissed her with a deep, wet, tongue-filled kiss, and began fondling her tits. He quickly removed her blouse, and her bra, and they began making out on the bed. Lilly didn’t resist when he pulled off her panties and started licking her already wet pussy, and she was hot and ready when he turned her over on all fours, and flipped up the little waitress skirt, and began rubbing his cock along the crack of her ass, and the slit of her pussy. She moaned and yelped as he forced his cock into her tight pussy, but she soon was vigorously fucking right back into him, as he gripped her hips, and pounded into her from behind. After a hot and sweaty session of hard doggy-style fucking, Luke shot his load, and Lilly came hard, bucking and gasping as her pussy gripped at the big cock erupting inside of her. They fucked again twice before falling asleep and fell asleep tangled in a sweaty embrace.
When they woke in the morning, even though she felt a little slutty about fucking this guy within an hour of meeting him the night before, Lilly wanted to fuck again and gave Luke a sloppy blow job to get him hard, so he was again ready to fuck. He enthusiastically fucked the nubile teen, taking her side saddle, and riding him cowgirl.
“You are one hot little fuck machine,” Luke said. “Almost a nymphomaniac!”
“No, I’m just a normal girl,” Lilly protested. But Luke smiled, and said, “Whatever you say, babe.”
After that incident, she had talked to Braylin, who had reassured her that she was just a normal girl, but Lilly wasn’t so sure. She needed to talk to somebody with a little more life experience than Braylin.
And so she decided to ask Ray, the old retired Marine at the thrift store, who was friends with all the girls who came in, and had helped Lilly find some outfits a few times when she was at the store. She knew he had a reputation among her friends as a dirty old man, but she figured he would also know what qualified a girl to be a nympho.
She found Ray helping some younger teens, and giving them his opinion of the bikinis they were trying on in the dressing room area. Lilly was wearing her tight hip-hugger jeans and a pale-yellow thin cotton camisole when she came in, which really showed off her tits and her puffy nipples. When she approached him and asked if she could talk with him about a personal matter, and maybe give her some advice, he looked her over with an appreciative smile and told her to meet him in the back furniture section and he’d be there in five minutes. Lilly watched as Ray groped the teens in their bikinis, turning them, and adjusting the suits, managing to get his hands all over their nubile bodies as he chatted and they giggled with his attention. He is a dirty old fucker, Lilly thought, but he’s kind of hunky, and he’s damn sure of himself. She felt herself getting a little excited at the idea of being alone with dirty old Ray. She walked back to the furniture area and took a seat on a big queen-sized bed and almost inadvertently began stroking her pussy through her tight jeans.
Ray sauntered back moments later, and sat down next to her, right up against her body. He put an arm around her, and she felt his fingers grip her side, just touching her bra-less boob, under the flimsy camisole.
“What can I do for you, beautiful?” Ray asked, giving her a gentle squeeze, and pulling her against his body.
“Well, it’s about sex, Mr. Ray,” Lilly said tentatively, not meeting his eyes.
“You can ask me anything you want, sweetheart,” Ray said. “I consider myself somewhat of an expert in that department.”
“Well ... errr ... I guess what I want to know,” Lilly began, a little shyly. “Well ... I mean ... How do I know if I’m normal ... or if I’m some kind of ... You know ... a nympho. A Nymphomaniac.”
“Hmmm,” Ray began, looking at the well-endowed girl, with the long legs in the tight sexy jeans. “I guess I’d have to see how you react in a sexual situation, to really give an opinion on that. Do you have some time to spend, so I can evaluate how you react to various stimuli? I wouldn’t want to just give you some off-the-cuff answer, because I can tell you are looking for a serious answer, aren’t you Lilly?”
“Yeah!” Lilly exclaimed, with a big smile, giving Ray a big hug and pressing herself against him. “You get me, don’t you, Ray?”
“Well, I think so,” Ray said smiling, “so let’s peel off those jeans and that sexy little top, and see how you react to certain sexual stimulations. I’m going to start with licking your pussy, because that tells me a lot!”
“OK, thanks Mr. Ray,” Lilly said, kicking off her sneakers, as she unsnapped her jeans and began peeling them off. Once she was down to her little white cotton panties, and her camisole, Ray helped her lift the flimsy camisole over her head. He smiled as he admired her firm forward-thrust tits, and the puffy little nipples that topped them. He kissed each tit a little roughly and sucked the nipples into his hot mouth, making Lilly moan softly. That warm, tingly sensation in her pussy began to heat up.
“You’ve got very sexy tits, Lilly,” Ray told her, “they likely are sensitive and help you really enjoy a man’s attention, don’t they?”
“Mmmmm ... hmmm, yeah, you do seem to understand me,” Lilly mumbled, as he pushed her down on the bed, and slid down to begin sucking on her nearly smooth, lightly furry pussy.
Lilly moaned deeply as the old man vigorously tongued her teen slit, forcing her tight labia lips apart with his strong tongue.
“Omigod,” Lilly moaned, “your tongue feels so good, Mr. Ray. You’re gonna make me cum.”
“Well, I hope so,” Ray mumbled witha little laugh, as he came up for air.
Ray focused his efforts and tongued her gently, then more aggressively. After a few minutes, he used his finger to reach inside her and massage her little clit nubbin, as his tongue swirled around her hot little hole. Lilly was now writhing on the bed, moaning and sighing alternatively, as the old man steadily brought her to a strong orgasm, and watched as she creamed over his mouth, and dripped her slick cream on the plain mattress. As the orgasm subsided, Ray grabbed her hips and turned her on her side.
“Now, let me get behind you here, and I’m going to spoon you, and fuck you while I can hold your body, and massage those beautiful tits, Lilly” Ray ordered, as he got behind her, and stroked himself to full hardness. He lifted her leg a little and pressed his cock against her slippery little pussy.
“Ungghhh ... mmmm,” Lilly moaned as he entered her, and began stroking into her tight teen cunt. He fucked deeply into her, and enjoyed the tight grip of her pussy on his rock-hard old cock.
“Oh, yeah, baby,” Ray grunted, as he fucked the compliant teen, “that’s a nice tight little pussy and you know how to use it.”
“Ohhhh ... mmmmm ... unnggh,” Lilly mumbled as she enjoyed his hard fuck strokes.
“So far,” said Ray, “I find you you to be a perfectly normal girl, and there ain’t nothing wrong with your sexual functions. Should we keep goin?”
“MMmmm ... oh yeah,” Lilly sighed, as the old man slammed in and out of her teenage pussy.
And Ray proceeded to get her on her hands and knees, and after sliding a big finger into her pussy to coat his finger with her cream, he lubed up her tight asshole and then fucked her in the ass.
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.