Chapter 46: A Little Too Far

Our "birthday" was rapidly approaching. We were over at Kim and Stacy's, every day now. I was sort of baffled. Stacy was a bright girl. I just did not understand how she did not at least suspect, something was going on with Kim and us. She had never caught us in the act, but had walked into a room that smelled like sex, and Kim and I were the only two in there. Jane was not sure either. But she did say Stacy was acting much more familiar with her, and she was downright flirty with me. Stacy even would sit on my lap some now, making sure to rub her prominent ass on my cock. She had a pretty big ass. Not fat; but just full, and round, and muscular. I love asses as long as they are round, and I prefer soft and small. But Stacy's was definitely her best feature, although she had nice round breasts too. But they were rather large, and tended to droop, as large ones do.

I was sitting in the recliner, and Stacy looked at me sort of strangely, and walked over and sat in my lap. She then reclined the chair, so she was laying on me, as we watched TV. She felt good, not as good as Jane, or even Kim. But a teenaged girl feels good, laying on you. I put my arms around her, and gave her a hug. She sort of sighed, and snuggled closer. We watched TV for a bit, and I felt her head turn. I looked down as she looked up at me. I recognized that look, she wanted to be kissed.

Quickly I ran over my options in my head, and thought: 'screw it'. I kissed her. She tasted of the coke she had drunk, and she was an accomplished kisser. It lacked real passion on my part, and on hers too, like she was just testing the waters.

When I kissed Jane; the world stopped, and nothing else existed, except for her. Kim was almost there. I suspected that my feelings for her, were why it was not quite the same, yet. My feelings for Kim were still confused, Jane was the one I wanted. I sometimes felt guilty about that. When Kim kissed me, her world stopped, I could tell. But I still felt the need to hold back, some. Whether a person could be in love with two people, I was still not sure.

We kissed for a while, and Stacy encouraged my hands to explore. I took the hint, and softly ran them up and down her sides, making sure to caress the side of her tits and hips. Stacy responded to my touch, and her kiss became more demanding. Her tits were large, over a handful, and pillowly soft. I teased her nipple, and felt it harden. We moved. I laid her down on her back. I was on my side now, in the chair, as we kissed and I gently explored her curves.

I had just started to touch her pussy, when Kim and Jane came back in. Neither one of us moved much, to my surprise. Jane and Kim just looked at us, then each other. I watched Jane closely and was a bit worried.

"Trying to steal my boyfriend?"

"No, just borrowing him, like Kim does," Stacy replied, with a touch of challenge in her voice.

"Kim asked, though," my sister fired right back.

"Well, can I then?"

"Yeah, but don't get too attached."

"Oh, I won't. I am not after a boyfriend, or anything. It's just like when you guys fool around, or Kim fools around with him. It kind of gets to me."

"Yeah, watching him and Kim does the same to me. But that's a little different than him and you, though."

"Why's that? I'm not trying to steal your boyfriend, while Kim probably would, if she could."

"No, she wouldn't."

"Oh, yes! She would! Wouldn't you, Kim?"

"Nu huh," replied Kim.

Stacy looked skeptical, but didn't argue anymore. I leaned over and gave her a little kiss, and got up and went over to Kim. She leaped into my arms. I gave her a sexy kiss, and squeezed her soft little buns, before setting her down. I turned towards Jane, with a rueful grin on my face.

"Hey, lover?" I said.

She just flowed into my arms, and I knew she was upset. My heart was then heavy, too.

I picked her up, and she clung to me, as when she was little. I walked out of the room, and into the kitchen for some privacy. We sat in a chair, and I held her, and whispered soothing things in her ear. I was telling her over and over, that I loved her, and she was mine, and I was hers.

When she calmed down she said in a sad little voice, "Oh, Brett! What are we gonna do?"

"Whatever you want to do, sweetheart. You are the one I want. Stacy came on to me, and it made me a little uncomfortable. But I went with it some. You're the one I wanted in my arms, not her."

"I didn't think it bothered me, but I guess it does."

"I know. It has always made me uncomfortable, too. I just want it to be me and you, and nobody else. But then Kim comes along, and I like the three of us. If you were to kiss another guy, it would break my heart. This is a dangerous thing we are doing, an maybe we should stop."

"I think so, too. But I love Kim. Somehow it doesn't bother me when you two are together."