Chapter 123

While generally shy, Liz also wasn’t afraid to rise up to the challenge. That was fitting of a delver, Natalie supposed. And it came to Natalie’s great benefit.

Liz lined up one end of the double-sided dildo to Natalie’s entrance. She rubbed the toy into Natalie, her eyes wide, her breathing hard, as if it was Liz herself the toy was about to penetrate. Natalie shivered at the sensation, her cock twitching in excitement. Precum beaded at the tip.

“You said ... I can touch?” Liz asked.

Natalie might have teased Liz about changing her mind so quickly about ‘keeping it to just testing the wand’, but doing so might change her mind—so she just nodded. Liz reached out, then, still rubbing the toy at Natalie’s pussy, gripped her cock.

Natalie had done some brief experimentation with being pleasured from both ends at once, but she’d never had someone else play with her in that way—and masturbation obviously didn’t hold up to the real deal. A moan escaped her at the contact of Liz’s hand, and to her amusement—which bubbled up even past her arousal—Liz nearly jumped in surprise.

“Oh. You, uh. Like that?”

“Yeah. You can. Um. Go in.”

Liz wiggled the head of the toy into Natalie’s lower lips, getting purchase rather than just teasing. Slowly, Natalie was spread apart, her pussy stretching to accommodate the girthy toy. For all she’d been teasing Liz, it really was thick enough to give any girl pause. Another moan escaped her, her hands clutching the bedsheets as she felt herself spread open. Liz held a firm grip on Natalie’s cock, stroking up and down even as she pushed the toy inside Natalie.

Bit by bit, she worked it in, and Natalie squirmed at the pressure. It was definitely the largest thing she’d ever had inside her, and she quickly found a newfound respect for Jordan, who took something even thicker with apparent delight. Honestly, Natalie struggled—though with hot waves of pleasure swirling around inside her at the incredible sensation of being so full.

When Liz had properly filled Natalie up, her half of the dildo inserted, Liz said tentatively, “Um. Okay, I guess it’s my turn, now.”

Natalie elbowed up to get a better sight. She had collapsed back in pleasure as Liz had gone at it, but obviously she wouldn’t miss the sight of Liz sharing the toy with her.

It unfortunately meant Liz had to stop stroking her cock, but Natalie was fine with that, considering what was to come. Besides, the two-pronged attack was difficult to resist, especially without much practice. It would be rather embarrassing if Natalie came first—or at least not with Liz—after so much teasing of the other girl.

Liz settled down, spreading her legs and draping them over Natalie’s. She lined up the dildo to her own pussy, then, letting out a little gasp, penetrated herself. Natalie gripped her side of the dildo while Liz worked her way down, helping stabilize the flexible shaft. Her cock throbbed painfully at seeing Liz impale herself.

“W-What’s the best way to go about this?” Liz asked. “How do we, uh, use it right?”

“Let’s see if we can—mm—get all the way, first,” Natalie said, the sentence interrupted by a moan. It had been some time since Natalie had been penetrated by anything other than fingers and tongues, since toys actually hadn’t been something she used much of. It was having an unexpectedly intoxicating effect, her cock throbbing in little twitches and leaking precum as it begged for its own relief.

“Okay,” Liz said, looking down with some apprehension. “But, all the way? It’s just, a lot.”

“We can do it.”

Natalie really wanted to see her pussy pressing into Liz’s, the two of them kissing with their lower halves, so she had good motivation to work her way down onto their thick shared toy. Liz draped her legs over Natalie’s to get into better position, and the two of them wiggled their way further down, moaning as they were filled up.

Liz apparently wanted it as badly as Natalie, because she worked just as hard. With a few whines, she scooted her lower half forward one last thrust, pulling Natalie’s thighs toward her, and the gap closed; their pussies kissed, all sixteen thick inches shared between the two of them.

“That ... wasn’t so bad,” Liz panted, gazing with wide, transfixed eyes down at their kissing pussies.

With Liz’s arrival, Natalie’s urges overtook her. She turned sideways, her cock sliding against Liz’s warm, soft thigh. A shaky breathe escaped her at the contact. Her hips bucked, a reaction she couldn’t stop, and a loud moan escaped her as her sensitive shaft slid across Liz’s skin. The motion also had the dildo stirring around inside both of them, adding to the cocktail of pleasure. She hugged Liz’s leg with both arms, who had also turned sideways to give them a better angle to share the toy with—and for Natalie to rub her cock into her leg.

“That’s nice,” Natalie groaned. “Fuck, that’s good. You don’t—you don’t mind?”

Not that Natalie was even certain she could stop if Liz asked her to; her hips kept jerking back and forth, rubbing herself against Liz’s soft thigh even as she stirred around their shared dildo.