Chapter 3

The next day in school Kimberly was talking with Melissa and Heather while she got her books out of her locker for her next class.

“I went over to Theodore’s house last night. I told him it was to work on the project, but I didn’t tell him WHICH project! He just assumed it was the biology project for Grody Brody’s class!” The girls all giggled, knowing what she meant. “Yeah I got all dolled up and I wore my slinky red minidress and my black CFM’s.”

“You didn’t!” Heather gasped. They giggled again.

“So what happened?” Melissa inquired.

“Well, that’s where it gets really weird. I was doing the whole seduction thing – you know telling him how sorry I was that I had mistreated him all these years and how I wanted Todd and the guys to stop picking on him. I asked him to forgive me for acting like a bitch to him. He said he forgave me so to put the seal on it, I gave him a little kiss.”

“Eww gross! You kissed that?” Heather commented.

“Yeah, I did. At first, I thought the same thing. But then as I was kissing him, I realized that guy is a hell of a kisser!”

“EEEWWW!” Heather and Melissa squealed together.

“No, I’m serious. He can really kiss. In fact, as I was kissing him, I ... well I kinda got turned on!”

“NO WAY!” Melissa said her eyes wide as dinner plates over her girlfriend’s revelation.

“Yeah. Anyway, I had already decided to go through with Todd’s challenge so we made out for a bit then went into his room...”

The girls were standing there practically salivating at this juicy gossip.

“Girls, that nerd has got a cock on him that would make a horse jealous! Oh my God, can he use it too!” Kim said.

Heather and Melissa were too stunned to make any kind of comment at that point. They stood there like a couple of zombies, just listening to Kim go on about Theo’s performance.

“Yeah, he fucked me last night and made me cum two or three times. But what’s more, he actually cared about my having a good time over his own enjoyment! He made me cum once and then as we cuddled – yes he actually wanted to cuddle and hold me afterward – I noticed he hadn’t cum. He had told me going in that he was a virgin, and after that performance ... well I felt kinda obligated I guess, to help him get past that. So we did it again and he made me cum a second time – this time with him as well.”

“H-how was it?” Melissa asked, still trying to wrap her head around this news.

“Oh my GOD girls, he is fantastic! I’m not just saying this as part of the whole challenge thing – I mean it. Feeling that cock inside me, spreading me open further than anyone ever has, it was incredible! Okay, so he’s not the most handsome or most popular guy around. And I’m not saying I have any feelings for him or anything.

But one thing is for damn sure – he can outfuck anyone I have ever been with and that includes Mr. Todd Peterson! And what’s more, he cares about my feelings and my pleasure ... something Todd has never done, even when we first started going together. Todd is all about Todd and what makes him happy. But Theo ... he cares about me, even over himself. It’s ... nice. Nice to be appreciated, and nice to be taken care of for a change.”

Melissa and Heather were dumbstruck that their girl would be talking like this. After all, she was the head cheerleader and the most popular girl in school. She could have her pick of any guy in WHK. And she was going on about a nerd! It was not only not heard of ... it was unnatural! Like the whole order of the universe had been flipped on its ear!

Then the class bell rang, shaking the girls from their dazed bewilderment. With a “We’ll talk later!” the girls broke up to go to their respective classes.

It didn’t take long for Todd to get wind of what had happened with Theo and Kim. Gossip like that travels through the “grapevine” like lightning through the night sky. And the very next day Todd and his two cronies came walking down the hall towards Theo while he was at his locker.

“Hey, nerd. I heard what happened between you and Kim. Looks like I owe her $200.00!”

The look on Theo’s face was exactly what he wanted to see and he grinned maliciously.

“Oh, that’s right – you didn’t know about the little challenge I gave her! Well, a few days ago she told me to lay off picking on you. She said she was bored with it and that you never did anything to me. I accused her of being sweet on you and told her I would give her $200.00 if she would have sex with you. So I guess she earned her money!”

Theo was crushed. He slammed his locker shut and ran off before he burst into tears, but not before he heard the cruel and heartless laughter from Todd and the others as he ran down the hallway.

Very proud of himself, Todd went to tell Kim all about how he humiliated the nerd. “You should have seen the look on his face! It was priceless! Even Scott and Randy were impressed!”

“YOU DID WHAT? I could KILL you, Todd Peterson! I can’t believe you could be so fucking heartless! I never ever want to hear from you again and if I do I will tell everyone all your little secrets – and believe me, I know enough about you to make for some very juicy gossip!”

Kim stormed off, too pissed off to even look at her now ex-boyfriend. She went to find Theo and try to explain what happened but she was unable to find him anyplace. Frantically she walked up and down the hallways, checked in rooms she thought he might be in and everywhere but there was no sign of him. As she walked around she asked everyone she passed if they had seen him but no one knew where he might be.

Kim was desperate and enlisted the help of Melissa and Heather. After explaining what Todd had done, they readily agreed to help look for him. The three girls scoured the school top to bottom to try to find him. They began to think he might have left the school altogether and was getting ready to call his mother when Melissa spotted a shadow under the staircase at one end of the main hallway. She went around the corner and called Kim on her cellphone.

“Kim, it’s Melissa! I found Theo. He’s sitting under the stairs at the end of the hallway in front of the cafeteria!”

“Oh thank god! Okay, I’ll be right there. Keep your eyes on him!”

Kim showed up less than a minute later and Melissa pointed to the shadow still under the stairs.

Kim approached the stairs And Theo saw her coming. He crawled out and started to run off again. “Theo wait! Please wait, Theo!” He ran into the cafeteria and she caught up to him just as he got inside.

“Theo, please, let me explain! Please!”

Theo whirled around at that point. “Yes, why don’t you explain. Why don’t you explain how you tricked me, how you lied to me, and how you embarrassed me in front of everyone. Kim, I have never been so humiliated in all my life. You do realize that by now I am probably the laughing stock of the whole school. So explain to me just what I did that was so wrong you felt you had to do this to me!”

“I am so sorry, Theo, I never meant for this to happen. All this started out because I was tired of the way Todd was picking on you. It had gotten old and I wanted him to stop. But he accused me of being sweet on you and when I denied it, he told me he’d give me $200 if I would give you a blowjob or have sex with you.

So I took him up on his bet to teach him a lesson. I figured that if I did it and then played you up to be some big stud, he would realize that he could lose me and maybe he should treat me better. But my plan backfired when you kissed me. Theo, I meant what I said about never being kissed like that before and when you and I had sex – wow!

“I never wanted to hurt you, Theo. In fact, I was tired of Todd hurting you. But I guess I did anyway and for that, I am truly sorry.”

“Kim, this all sounds like a very good movie plot and maybe someday someone will make the ‘Poor Geek Wins The Girl’ movie you describe. But I don’t want any part in it. So why don’t you go back to your vapid, plastic, perfect life and leave me and the rest of us nobodies the hell alone!”

He stomped out of the cafeteria leaving Kim crying at the table. Melissa and Heather had been at the doorway of the cafeteria and when they saw Theo leave they came to the aid of their heartbroken friend.

“Kim let him have a couple of days to cool off and then maybe you can talk to him and work things out”

“Yeah, Todd was a jerk and you are better off without him. But Theo seems like a good guy. He’ll see things more clearly when he cools off.”

“I hope you are right, Heather, I really like him. I hope we can get past this.”

For the next two weeks, Kim tried over and over to call him. But Theo was either not home or the answering machine picked up and he didn’t return her calls. She tried to catch him at school, but he ignored her or walked the other direction when he saw her. He didn’t want to talk to her or anyone else.

Kim also became something of a recluse. She missed the biology class that they had together. She skipped cheerleading practice and even a big football game because she didn’t have the heart to be cheerful and she certainly didn’t want to see Todd. When the head of the cheerleading squad started talking about replacing Kim as head cheerleader, the girls knew they needed to take action.

One day, the two girls came over to Theo’s house to talk to him. His mom had gone to work a couple of hours prior, and Theo was just holed up at home watching TV. It was raining that day, so when there was a knock on the door, Theo saw who was at the door and wasn’t going to answer it at first.

“Go away! I don’t want to talk to anyone!”