Chapter 4

NATALIE STOOD wistfully looking after Brenda’s car as it drove away from the school. It was okay. They were all sharing together, right? She wasn’t sure why she felt like her stomach was in a knot.

“Come on, sister. No sad puppy-dog looks,” Roberta chided. “We’ve got company tonight.”

“I know,” Natalie sighed. “I just want to run after them. That does make me a puppy dog, doesn’t it?”

“It’s okay to have puppy dog moments. Just don’t become a bitch about them. Now get in the car and tell us all about what’s on your mind. We’re having Leanne over for dinner tonight,” Roberta said.

“That makes it sound like you’re planning to eat her,” Natalie laughed as they got in the car.

“Well, now that you mention it, she does look like a tasty morsel. Now tell big sisters what’s eating you, because it’s not me,” Daniella said.

“I don’t know. I know what they’re going to do. I talked to Brenda about it. And I know we all agreed to share. I just feel left out and ... a little scared,” Natalie said.

“What are you scared of, sweetie?”

“Amy loves him so much, I’m afraid he’ll love her more than me. She’s so cute and absolutely fuckable!” Natalie said, letting her frustration get the best of her.

“Hmm. Do you think I could ever steal Dennis from you?” Daniella asked.

“No. Don’t be silly.”

“What? Why? Do you think I don’t love him? Or do you think I’m not fuckable?” she pressed.

“No. I just know that neither you nor he would ever do that to me.”

“Do you think Brenda and Amy would do that to you?” Roberta asked.

“Nooo. Not exactly. I trust them to do what they said they would. It just makes my pussy itchy. I guess I wanted to be his first at everything, but Brenda and Amy have done everything with him except fuck.”

“Which is the one thing you’ve done that none of the rest of us have,” Daniella said. “I want him to be my first. Guy, I mean. Do you know how that makes my pussy feel?”

“Yes. I’ll bet it feels all slippery and yummy,” Roberta said to her sister. “Come in the house and let me check to find out how you feel.”

The three girls all laughed and Natalie’s mood lightened some. And once they got in the house, they did check and discovered how the conversation had made all three feel.

“Where are your parents?” Dennis whispered as they went through the house toward Brenda’s room.

“They went to Las Vegas for the weekend. There’s some new show they want to see. They said they’d be back Sunday night late. We’ve got the place to ourselves,” Brenda said lightly. She pulled Dennis and Amy into her room. “Not that we’ll need any more of the house than that,” she said, pointing at her bed.

“Um ... Brenda, I’m not ... I don’t think...”

“Don’t worry, baby. We won’t go all the way. But we don’t want to not have the same fun we did have. Natalie understands that. There’s something new for all of us to enjoy.”

“I need a shower,” Amy said. “I’ve gone from stinking to stale. Dennis, help me get undressed. I ran a race today.”

“And you did great!” Dennis said, unzipping her jacket. He tilted his head back to kiss her, and felt Brenda’s hands unzipping his own jacket. “I didn’t get all sweaty today,” he said as she pulled it off his shoulders.

“Yes, but who will wash our backs?” Brenda asked. Dennis paused with Amy’s jersey at her arm pits, ready to come off.

“You want me...?” he asked.

“Oh, yeah. Come and wash all of me,” Amy said, encouraging him to finish taking off her shirt. Before long, the teens were all naked and Brenda was testing the water to be sure it was warm enough and not too hot. Dennis set his glasses on the sink. Amy took his hand and guided him into the shower where Brenda was waiting. It was a little crowded with three in the shower, but they didn’t mind touching.

“I can’t see anything with water and no glasses,” Dennis chuckled.

“Look with your fingers,” Brenda said. “Feel this?” She pulled his hand to her breast and ran his fingers around her nipples. “That’s Braille and says ‘touch me and kiss me.’ You’ll find messages like that all over my body.”

“And mine,” Amy said, pulling a hand to her own breast. Her breasts were smaller than Brenda’s but the nipples were just as hard. “It’s a slightly different accent, but it says the same thing.”

Brenda soaped Dennis’s hands, letting him begin rubbing the soap under Amy’s arms and down her front, as she soaped his cock until it was full and upright. Once he got started, Dennis wasn’t shy about making a thorough inspection of each girl with his soapy hands, indulging in frequent deep kisses as one or the other stroked his cock. He was locked in a deep kiss with Amy when his fingers strayed across her butt hole. Amy started gyrating against him and whining.

“Me, too,” Brenda said, but she moved her butt against his soapy cock as she rubbed up and down on it.

“I want that,” Amy said.

“You sure, baby?” Brenda asked. “I’ll be happy to have it if you don’t want it.”

“Let’s move to the bed,” Amy answered. They all rinsed off and then carefully stepped out of the shower to dry themselves on the big fluffy towels Brenda had in her bathroom. Dennis grabbed his glasses and followed the two naked beauties to Brenda’s bed. She threw back the duvet and top sheet. Amy bounced on the bed, pulling Dennis along with her.

“Are you still hard, Dennis?” Brenda asked. She explored downward and found his almost full erection. In a flash, she had her mouth over it and Dennis stiffened to full rigidity. Amy pulled his hand to her pussy.

“Am I wet, Dennis?” she husked. “I know we can’t go all the way, but you can make me come in so many ways.”

“Lick her, lover,” Brenda whispered. Amy wiggled herself into a position where Dennis could get to her, as he pulled his glasses off and Brenda put them on the table.

“I love to look at you from this close,” he whispered. “You’re so beautiful.”

“Look. Taste. Love,” Amy sighed. “Do it.”

Dennis dipped his head to feast on her pussy, licking around her hole and noting the hymen membrane was still mostly intact. He ran his tongue up to circle her clit a few times and then glide back down her slit all the way to her butt.

“Yesss,” she hissed. “I like it when you play with that. I must be really weird.”

“Not at all,” Brenda said. “I love it. Wait until you feel his cock there.”

“Yes! Do that to me, Dennis.” She lifted a foot to bring over his head while she rolled to her side.

“Don’t go all the way over on your stomach,” Brenda directed. “Get behind her, Dennis, and we’ll attack front and back with our tongues all at once.” With Brenda’s tongue on Amy’s clit and Dennis’s tongue on her butt hole, Amy rose quickly to the point of no return and gasped out her orgasm.

“I didn’t get to feel his cock there,” she complained.

“We wouldn’t leave you wanting,” Brenda laughed. “That was just a warmup.” She tugged on Dennis’s cock to get him up behind Amy. Before she let go, she sucked him into her mouth to make sure he was very wet and slippery. Dennis knew what he thought was expected and began sliding his cock through Amy’s slippery crack. The feeling was intense for both teens and they moaned in unison. Brenda held Amy’s leg up as she dipped her fingers in her girlfriend’s plentiful fluids and smeared them around her anus. Amy gasped as Dennis slid down and bumped his cock into the tight ring before sliding on up.

“Yeah! Oh, yeah. Yeah,” Amy said.

“I’m getting really close,” Dennis panted. Brenda reached through and gripped his cock, but not in the way that would delay his orgasm. She guided the tip to Amy’s butt hole and began rubbing it around to smear Dennis’s precome on it. Amy continued pressing back against him.

“Like that, little angel?” Brenda whispered as she kissed Amy.

“Oh God, yes. Keep doing that,” Amy choked out.

Brenda held the tip of Dennis’s cock right against Amy’s sphincter, expecting Dennis to blast right against her. She wasn’t expecting Amy’s hole to suddenly flare open and surround the tip of Dennis’s cock. Dennis moaned and his hips automatically thrust forward, sending the head of his cock into Amy’s rectum. Amy gasped and pushed back hard, burying an inch of cock in her backside. Brenda kept hold of his cock to keep it from going any farther.

“No more,” she whispered. “Don’t try to stretch her too much.”

“Oh, do it! Fuck my bottom!” Amy cried. Dennis pulled back until he was almost out of her and then pushed forward until Brenda’s hand stopped him. He clutched Amy’s breast in one hand as he bit her shoulder. Amy screamed an orgasm that sent her hole into flutters around Dennis’s spurting cock as he came.

Dennis saw stars and faded away slightly. Amy went limp. Brenda just held the two, connected together, as they gradually recovered. Dennis’s cock shrank and came out of Amy’s butt.

“That’s a weird feeling,” Amy sighed. “I think I need to go to the bathroom.” She climbed over Brenda and ran to the toilet where a huge glop of come dropped from her bottom into the basin.

“You’ll do that for me, too, won’t you, lover?” Brenda asked as she kissed Dennis passionately.

“Anything you want, Bren. You know that.”

“Come on, we need to wash this off so I can suck you back up hard.” They went into the bathroom, where Amy was still sitting.