Chapter 24

“UM ... BRENDA? You said you didn’t like go all the way,” Natalie said as the four of them settled on the blankets.

“We didn’t.”

“Why is there a box of condoms on the coffee table?”

“Three rules,” Brenda said. “First, never force, coerce, or pressure anyone sexually. No means no. Second, never without protection. Third, never in front of Peg. We probably have some additional ones of our own but those are the ones Mrs. Enders made us agree to. To be sure we abided by the second one, she put a box of condoms out here. You know, Amy isn’t even on the pill or anything. I don’t know about any of the rest of you. You’ll notice, though, that the box is still sealed. It’ll be fun to watch the reactions when the other girls come tomorrow night and see it. Think anyone will want to go back home?”

“It’s so embarrassing,” Dennis said. “I think she’s trying to keep us from doing anything by making it too embarrassing to do. What if she comes into the living room and finds the box has been opened or decides to count the condoms? She would know the exact moment I lost my virginity.”

“Dennis? When it’s time for that, I’d like to be the one you’re with. It’ll be my first time, too,” Natalie said.

“Nat? Are you sure you want somebody like me? I know you girls all like me and like to tease me. And Brenda and Amy, well ... they like to be with me, I think, but they really like each other. I’m just what people always call me: a dweeb.”

“Dennis, that’s not fair,” Brenda said. “Yes, Amy and I like each other. We might be in love. But we love you just as much. Believe me, we’d never stick your dick in our mouths if we didn’t have real feelings for you. We aren’t running a charity.”

“I’m sorry, Bren. I’m sorry, Amy. I know you both like me. It’s just so hard for me to believe it.”

“Believe it, boyfriend,” Amy said. She closed on Dennis and kissed him with real intent, pulling his hand up under her T-shirt so he could caress her breasts. “I won’t be your first, but you’ll be mine,” she whispered. As Amy backed up, Natalie stalked forward on all fours, looking like a big cat coming for her prey. She crawled up to him, pushing him over backwards and crawling right over him. The T-shirt might not have been as long on her as the other two, but it was still big and baggy. He could see down the neck to her boobs and past to the gap between her legs. She lowered herself and began kissing him as she rubbed her crotch against his dick.

“I’m not as advanced yet as either Brenda or Amy,” Natalie said. “But I’m as much in love with you. I’m not ready for you to take my virginity tonight, but maybe you could start teaching me the things you’ve learned from Brenda and Amy.” She kissed him again and he put his arms around her, pulling her against his chest.

“I dreamed of holding you and kissing, since even before we held hands at your party,” Dennis breathed.

“I hope your dreams were as wet and sloppy as mine have been,” she answered, kissing him some more. They rolled to their sides, holding each other and looked over at Brenda and Amy. They were in an intense embrace and as they watched, Amy lifted Brenda’s shirt and took it off, leaving the former cheerleader as the first one naked. That only lasted a moment, though, as Brenda helped Amy divest herself of her shirt as well. They began kissing again, letting their hands roam over each other’s body. “Dennis?” Natalie whispered. “Will you help me ... um ... take off my shirt? I want you to see me and touch me while we kiss.” Dennis shook as he lifted Natalie’s shirt and pulled it over her head, exposing the ripe full breasts of the girl of his dreams.

“Oh, Natalie,” he breathed as she lifted his hand to caress her breast. She worked the buttons of his pajama shirt unfastened and slipped it back off his shoulders.

“Has anyone told you how really well-built you are?” she asked as she stroked his chest and stomach. “You work out as hard as the rest of us and it really shows. I bet no one realizes how ripped you are because you never dress to show it off.” She pulled him closer to her and felt her breasts pressing into his muscular chest. They glanced over at Brenda and Amy. Amy was holding and sucking on Brenda’s nipples. Natalie looked back at Dennis and urged him down to her chest as if she were following guidance from Brenda and Amy. When Dennis reached her nipple and began to tongue and suck it, she moaned loudly. Amy jumped to kiss Natalie deeply.

“If you are going to be noisy about it, we’ll need to help,” Brenda said. “We don’t want to wake Peg or Mrs. Enders.”

“It’s just so nice, isn’t it?” Amy asked. Natalie pulled her back for another kiss as she ran her fingers over Amy’s nipples. With the dual stimulation, she moaned again. That was nothing yet. Dennis moved to the other breast and Brenda latched onto her abandoned nipple so both were being stimulated. Natalie’s hips began to buck and Brenda pulled on Dennis’s hand to drag it down to Nat’s pussy. They both stroked through her wetness as Natalie moaned into Amy’s mouth and began to thrash around. She opened her legs wider and Dennis knew what to do from then on. He circled her clit and ran his fingers down to her opening. She’d said she was a virgin, so he didn’t try to poke in but he was making love to Natalie while Amy kept her quiet with a kiss. Or—Dennis looked up from the breast he was happily worshiping with his tongue—Amy kept Nat quiet by pushing her own nipple into their girlfriend’s mouth. Amy was obviously enjoying that.

Nat froze up in what Dennis had just learned to recognize as a sign of a girl’s orgasm. She clamped her thighs together on his hand so he could do nothing more than twitch his finger against her button. Natalie kissed Amy again then pulled Brenda to her for a kiss. Then Dennis took his turn, gently sliding his fingers out of her pussy as they kissed deeply.

“I love you guys,” Nat whispered.

“We’re not done with you yet,” Brenda said. “But poor Dennis is straining at his pants. We need to take care of our boyfriend. Have you ever held a boy’s cock? Kissed it? Sucked it? Felt it spurt into your mouth?”

“Oh, God!” Natalie moaned. “Dennis, can I suck you?” Dennis’s mouth was suddenly too dry to answer and he just nodded his head. The girls pulled his pajamas down around his cock and off his legs. His flagpole stood proud and tall. “I knew it was big but wow!” Natalie breathed. She reached out and touched it tentatively, causing his dick to jump. She giggled.

“This fluid that’s coming out of the tip is a lubricant to help with penetration,” Brenda said. “But it’s just as tasty as a girl’s lube. Go ahead and lick it. You’ll like the taste.” Nat stuck out her tongue and licked the tip, sampling the fluid. Then she wrapped her lips around the tip of his cock and licked all over the head. Dennis was so keyed up after touching Natalie that he almost came, but Brenda read him correctly and pinched the base of his cock until the urge passed for the time being. He moaned and Amy started kissing him to keep him quiet. Natalie slid her hands up and down his cock, licking it to get it wet and slippery as Brenda continued to instruct her and joined her mouth running up and down the shaft. Then the magic moment came and Natalie engulfed the head of his cock in her mouth and began bobbing up and down. Dennis was desperate to help or do anything to participate. At the moment, that anything amounted to kissing Amy and running his hands from her tits to her pussy.

Amy suddenly lifted up and pulled Dennis’s glasses off to place them on the coffee table.

“I can’t see without my glasses,” he said.

“I’ll make sure you get a good close view,” Amy whispered to him while Brenda and Natalie continued to work on his cock. Brenda had moved to start playing with his balls. Then, to Dennis’s amazement, Amy straddled his face and planted her pussy on his mouth. Dennis was surprised to see the open curtains of her pussy as she settled and decided the best view of a girl’s pussy would be without his glasses. It didn’t take long to get the message that he should be licking. He followed the instructions he’d been given on pleasing her with his fingers and simply translated them to his tongue. He slid his hands up Amy’s torso and began playing with her little nipples as he licked her happy place. Amy started to moan and Brenda immediately got up to start kissing her girlfriend. Feeling her presence, Dennis turned one hand to cup Brenda’s breast while he continued to play with Amy.

Amy was mounting fast and producing almost more lubricant than Dennis could lick up as he licked all the way down her slit to her butthole and back again. But Brenda was no longer squeezing his cock and he quickly approached the point of no return. He poked at Amy’s clit as his cock started spewing into Natalie’s mouth. Amy pressed down hard against his mouth, muffling his loud groan and her pussy released another torrent of liquid as she quaked in her own orgasm.

Natalie was the first to look up after she released Dennis’s cock with a pop. “Oh, my god! Did he just lick you to an orgasm?” she asked. “I want that.”

“You get yours after I get mine,” Brenda said, flopping on her back and pulling Natalie toward her crotch. Natalie obviously knew what to do with this and was soon busily eating Brenda out as Dennis and Amy attacked her nipples and mouth. Brenda was generally quieter than the other two girls and was kissing Dennis as she moaned out her orgasm. All four friends lay back in blissful repose.

Brenda tapped Dennis on the shoulder and motioned him toward Natalie’s pussy. Dennis nodded and crawled down between Natalie’s legs.

“What?” Natalie said raising her head. She saw Dennis peering at her pussy from just a few inches away. “Dennis? Are you going to eat me?” He looked up at her, though she was out of range to see her face clearly.

“May I eat you, Natalie?” he asked softly.

“Oh, God yes!” she whispered back.

Dennis had already had one taste of pussy but his view of the mystical place had been cut short as Amy had been intent on getting his mouth in action. This time his near-sightedness made the view of Natalie from three inches away a detailed lesson in female anatomy. He separated the petals of her sex with his fingers and stared right at the opening. He licked at it tentatively at first, having scarcely had any opportunity to taste Amy before he was too caught up in orgasm for it to register. He liked Natalie’s flavor and licked softy at the opening to collect more of her fluid on his tongue. He treated her sex in much the same way that Brenda had taught Amy and Natalie how to worship his cock. He set about worshiping Nat’s pussy.