Chapter 4

I’m disappointed when I wake up alone. Emma is no longer by my side, and I assume that she returned to her own bed during the night. I hope my sister isn’t having second thoughts. This has been a week of many firsts, and I’m looking forward to the trip on Saturday. A possible mind blowing experience with two sexy cheerleaders. I just have to play it smart, and avoid the pitfalls that are placed in my path.

It’s probably best if I don’t leave my bedroom. I can’t afford to make any more mistakes, and I don’t need another encounter with Amber. Or another face to face with Mom. I might say the wrong thing, and end any hope of losing my virginity. Amber is already curious about my sister’s boyfriend, and I’m not going to be her source for information. I certainly can’t tell her the truth.

I want my sister to be my lover. The flowery smell of her long blonde hair, and the touch of her soft skin. I fell in love with the sweet taste of my sister’s pussy, and I can still feel her wet lips around the shaft of my cock. A ring of red lipstick remains as a reminder. Emma and I have become closer than a brother and sister ever should, and I hope that she doesn’t regret our actions. Is it so wrong to want my sister to be my girlfriend?

The sound of running water gives me hope. Someone is in my shower, and I assume it’s my beautiful sister. Her panties remain where they were dropped on the floor, and her cheerleader uniform acts as a trophy on my dresser. The bedroom door is wide open. Elsa has to know that Emma slept with me last night, and she probably thinks that we had sex. I’m just glad that she didn’t stab me to death in my sleep.

Mom wants me to put a leash on the Dark Princess. I have yet to come up with a plan, and the smart choice may be to cut down the tree that allows my sister her freedom. If only to take back some of my privacy, and before someone gets into trouble. Though it may already be too late. A shadow moves across the bedroom wall, and I’m surprised to see a familiar face in my window. It’s amazing what the girls in my family will do to gain entrance to my private sanctum.

“Hey, Josh. Did you miss me?”

“Why are you in my bedroom, Amber, and how did you climb that tree in your white shoes? You do know that we have a front door?”

“I knocked three times and nobody answered. Is your mom home?”

“She’s probably at work. Don’t you have cheerleader practice or something?”

“It was changed to this afternoon. Your sister sent a text to all the girls, and she said that she was going to spend the morning in bed with her boy toy. That’s why I’m here. I thought this was your sister’s bedroom, and I wanted to meet Jeff. Are they here?”

“Emma’s bedroom is downstairs. But I haven’t heard anything in over an hour, and I don’t think she’s home.”

“Are you sure? Your sister sent new pictures of her boyfriend’s cock just a few minutes ago.”

“Really?”

“It’s huge, and do you want to see? I don’t blame you for being curious, and I won’t say anything to anyone. Your sister had her boyfriend’s cock in her mouth, and she left a giant ring of red lipstick around the shaft. Your sister is such a slut.”

“I really wish you wouldn’t call her a slut, Amber.”

“At least I admit that I’m a slut. I’ll bet your sisters do nothing but tease you, and have either of them once offered to suck your cock? And how is your cock this morning, Josh? Are you ready to fuck me, and is talking about your sister making you hard. I was hoping that we could finish what we started.”

It seems I can’t get a break. Amber steps down from the window ledge, and she takes a good look around my bedroom. The sound of running water from my washroom is very obvious. My sister’s panties remain balled up on the floor, and her cheerleader uniform is neatly folded on my dresser. An exact match to the green skirt and blouse combination that my cousin is currently wearing, and the same school uniform that is worn by all the cheerleaders. Luckily there’s nothing to say that it specifically belongs to my sister.

“I see that we’re not alone. Who owns the uniform, and who is in your shower? It can’t be Chloe, and I know it isn’t Zoey. I know for a fact that Zoey is at Coach Wilbur’s house right now, and she’s probably getting hammered into his mattress. Is it Hannah? I know she’s a big slut.”

“It’s Payton. She was waiting for my sister to finish riding her boyfriend, and so they could go to practice. Payton grew tired of just standing around, and we sort of hooked up this morning.”

“Are you being serious right now? I find that difficult to swallow, dear cousin, and there’s not much that I won’t swallow.”

“Emma opened my bedroom door, and she saw us together. She didn’t look very happy.”

“I’m not surprised. Did your sister see the size of your cock, and was she impressed? Did she faint?”

“I didn’t see her reaction. Payton was on top of me, and she was moving up and down pretty fast. Emma must have seen me cum inside Payton, and I’m pretty sure that’s when she left the house.”

I don’t know if my cousin believes my story. The lies are becoming more elaborate, and they are starting to involve other people. Amber touches the discarded panties with her left shoe, and she inspects the sports bra on my dresser. I’m pretty sure that Payton wears a full cup size smaller when compared to my sister. There’s no lock on the washroom door, and nothing to stop Amber from discovering the truth. This may not end well for anyone.

“I didn’t think Payton was interested in guys. She’s always with your sister, and I’ve seen them kissing several times. Not that it matters. I’ve kissed my fair share of girls, and I still prefer cock. I just find it interesting that Payton was in a sexual relationship with your sister, and now she is sleeping with you. Don’t you think that’s a little weird?”

“Not really. You and I are cousins, and we kissed a couple of times. I know you want to do a lot more. I’m sorry about what happened the other day, and it seems like we can’t catch a break.”

“I’m not sorry. You obviously think that I’m hot, and I want you to make love to me. You said that you came inside Payton, and that’s exactly what I want from you.”

“Do you still want me to make you pregnant?”

Amber offers me a sneaky little smile. The girls of my family are crazy for cock, and they only have eyes for me. Not that I mind the attention, and I have to wonder when I began to come out of my shell. My cousin can see the shape of my erection beneath the bed sheets, and she appears pleased. My number one goal is to lose my virginity, and I don’t care who is first to spread her legs. A cousin or a sister will do just fine.

We clearly share the same thoughts. Amber climbs onto the bed, and she straddles me at the waist. I can see her panties beneath her cheerleader skirt, and I really enjoy the weight of her fifteen year old body. Amber slides her pussy over the bulge that is my cock, and she lowers her lips to mine. My cousin’s tongue feels hot in my mouth, and I wonder if we have time. I’m certainly willing to find out.

Amber obviously doesn’t care if Payton is in the other room. She certainly doesn’t need to know the truth, and that the girl in the shower is really my sister. My cousin continues our kiss, and my hands move over the swell of her tits. My cock feels like it’s on fire, and I hope not to cum so soon. This could be our last opportunity to be together.

“Did Payton beg you to make her pregnant? I’m just curious, and I don’t care if she has your baby. Why should I be the only one?”

“I don’t know if we have time, Amber. Payton will be out of the shower in a minute.”

“She’s certainly taking long enough. You must have really filled her pussy with cum, and I hope you saved some for me. I wonder what your sister would say if she caught us having sex? Do you think she might become jealous, and join our fun?”

The sound of running water disappears. Amber looks to the washroom door, and I don’t have the ability to warn my sister. Pictures of my ten inch cock have been sent out on social media, and Amber is sure to recognize me if I leave the safety of the bed. My cousin looks into my eyes, and then her focus returns to the washroom door. She makes a move before I can toss the sheets from my naked body.

I didn’t expect Elsa to save the day. The Dark Princess enters my bedroom at warp nine, and she steps in front of our cousin. Elsa looks ready for war in a cut off shirt and boy briefs. Amber is startled, and she takes a nervous step back. If only for a second. The two girls remain toe to toe, and I’m probably going to have to step between them. It won’t take long for Elsa and Amber to notice my lack of clothes.

“Why are you in my brother’s bedroom, Amber? You’re such a slut, and can’t you give Josh and Payton a little privacy? Or are you looking for sloppy seconds?”

“Get out of my way you ink covered freak. I was looking for your sister, and I need to speak with Payton. This is official cheerleader business.”

“I’ll tell Payton to message you after she’s done cleaning my brother’s jizz from her pussy. Or is it true, and all the cheerleaders are trying to become pregnant? Why don’t you use the front door, and save yourself the climb down the tree in that ridiculously short skirt. The last thing you want is to bruise those perfect white thighs, and for Emma to see you leaving Josh’s bedroom. She might think that you were having sex with our brother, and can you imagine what might happen if everyone found out at school?”

Elsa can be devilishly evil at times. Amber weighs her position, and she look to me. I believe I can scratch my cousin from my potential date list for next years prom. Amber doesn’t say another thing, and she takes her leave. Elsa chases our cousin into the hall, and she watches her bolt down the stairs. The front door can be heard to slam a few seconds later, and I can assume that Amber is in full retreat. Elsa never looked more satisfied.

“Seriously, bro? You have one girl in the shower, and another in your bed? It’s great that you’ve become so popular, and confidant. But you can do a lot better than our cousin. I’m sorry if I just ended your big chance to lose your virginity.”

“Forget about it, sis. It’s not your fault that I can’t get laid, and I’m use to it by now.”

“It’s really a good thing that I was here to stop Amber. You and Emma need to be more careful if you’re going to play around, and take nude photos together. Not everyone is as understanding as me.”

“I thought that we were finished. But Emma keeps changing her mind, and asking for more.”

“I saw the pictures that she took a few minutes ago with her phone. I could have taken much better pics with my camera, and I could have edited them professionally. You should ask for my help next time.”

“Emma suggested the same thing. But I didn’t want to bother you, and I said no. I was asleep when she took those pictures, and I’m as surprised as you.”

“Did Emma take your cock in her mouth last night, and did she swallow your cum? She told me that she was finally ready.”

“I don’t know if I should answer. But I guess you already know.”

“Did you go down on her last night, too?”

“Yes, and thank you for teaching me. Do you want me to eat your pussy right now, sis?”

“I’m actually here to see Emma. I really need to cum, and I was hoping for some girl time. No offense.”

“That’s okay. I’m willing to share, and I don’t exactly know what our sister wants from me.”

“Amber has been riding Emma pretty hard. No pun intended. Our sister is stressed to the limit, and I can help take some of that away. You’re pretty good, Josh, but you’ll never be as good as me. You could show Emma a little compassion, and focus on something besides trying to get your cock into her tight pussy.”

I feel like Elsa and I are in open competition for our sister’s affection. Emma is done with her shower, and she opens the washroom door. She clearly didn’t expect an audience. Our cheerleader sister begins to cover her oversized tits with one of my big fluffy towels, and then changes her mind. It’s just family, and nothing Elsa and I haven’t seen before.

“I thought I could hear voices. Why is everyone up so early, and are you two waiting for me?”

Elsa describes her altercation with Amber. Emma doesn’t appear happy, and she quickly dresses into one of her long nightshirts. Emma steps over the panties that remain on the floor, and she retrieves a clean pair from inside my dresser. I had no idea that some of my sister’s clothes had been transferred to my bedroom. My personal space is becoming smaller and smaller, and my sisters appear in no hurry to leave. I have to wonder if they see me at all.

The kiss comes as a surprise. Two pairs of juicy red lips that open upon contact, and I’m left to watch in silence. I already know that my sisters have been intimate with each other, and I have no good reason to be jealous. It’s just something new to process. Elsa is the clear aggressor, and Emma appears quite timid. Possibly because of my presence. The two girls close their eyes, and their lips remain together for a seriously long time. Long enough to make me feel like an outsider.

“I love you, sis.”

“I love you too, Emma. But our brother’s cock is going to explode if we keep this up in front of him. Maybe we should give him some privacy, and go back to my room?”

I’m clearly not wanted. Elsa asked to be alone with Emma, and she leads our sister toward the door. Emma looks back at me, and my sisters begin a whispered conversation that lasts for well over a minute. I can only hope that Emma wants me to be involved. Elsa says something under her breath, and she storms from my bedroom. It appears that my first chance for a threesome has just been reduced to zero.

“Does Elsa hate me that much?”

“She doesn’t hate you at all. She’s not sure if she wants to be touched by a guy this morning, and it has nothing to do with you being our brother. I really think she’s warming up to you. Right now she prefers a more feminine approach, and she wants to be alone with me. Lucky for you I was able to change our sister’s mind.”

“Is she coming back to my bedroom?”

“Elsa agreed to a neutral territory. The three of us are going to meet in my bedroom, and we’ll see what happens. Just don’t expect too much. Elsa isn’t ready to ride your cock, and neither am I. Not yet anyway.”

“I’m not certain if I understand, sis. I’m growing tired of this game, and we’re going to get caught if we take any more pics. Look at what happened with Amber.”

“I really am sorry. But I have an idea that should get Amber off my back, and our sister offered to help. Of course I need your assistance, too. But after your part is done you have to promise to leave my bedroom, and you have to leave Elsa and I alone for awhile. Okay?”

I agree with a slight nod of my head. But I’m not happy, and I almost change my mind. Emma leads the way from my bedroom, and I follow at arms length. I stare at my sister’s panty covered ass as we walk down the stairs. I want Emma to be my first love, and I can’t wait to sink my cock into her tight pussy.

Elsa can be second in line. If she can break herself away from Emma, and if she allows herself to be touched by a guy. The fact that both girls are my sisters doesn’t matter to me, and my cock appears to agree. Though it might not happen today.

“Who are you texting, sis?”

“Payton needs to know our plan. She’s a part of this now, and I have to tell her that she’s officially dating my brother. Before Amber asks her any questions, and you know she will. That was quick thinking to say it was Payton in the shower.”

“Will Payton be mad?”

“Payton will want to be involved in anything that makes Amber look like a fool. But we have to be careful, and you and Payton have to get your story straight. Did you use a condom with Payton?”

“I’ve never used a condom in my life. Obviously that much is true, and Amber would have see the torn wrapper on the floor.”

“Good point. Did you pull out?”

“Of course not. Payton was on top of me, and she made me finish inside her pussy. You already said that your girlfriend wants a baby. So does Amber, and she already asked me to make her pregnant. I should have told you everything, and I’m sorry that I didn’t tell you before now. I truly am sorry.”

Emma comes to a sudden stop. My sister spins around in the hall, and she looks me straight in the eye. She doesn’t seem angry, and I’m lucky to have such an understanding family. Emma knows how I feel in my heart, and she loves me in return. Though I still expect a punishment, and I’m not disappointed. My sister pushes her panties down her legs, and she retrieves them from the floor. The balled up material is pushed into my open mouth, and I offer no resistance. Sometimes it’s best not to struggle.

“That’s for not telling me the truth when you had the chance. But nothing you said surprises me. Amber is a big whore, and she can’t wait to be pregnant. I feel like every girl in our school has baby fever. Payton loves babies, and she can’t wait to become pregnant. But Payton has never even touched a guy, and we are probably the only virgins left in our school. Just don’t tell anyone.”

I’m surprised to hear that Payton is a virgin. She’s beautiful, and she has a very sexy body. Another girl from my wet dreams, and one of the few who aren’t family. A possible candidate for a real life girlfriend, and another opportunity to lose my virginity. Unless my sister has objections. Emma looks to her phone, and she reads another text. I’m relieved when she pulls her panties from my mouth.

“Payton is completely on board with our plan. She says that you were wonderful this morning, and you made her cum more than any other man. I think I’m going to be sick. Payton sends her love, and she loves the idea of being your girlfriend. I’m becoming quite the matchmaker.”

“Does this mean that Payton and I are dating for real?”

“I don’t know yet. I’m not sure how I feel about you sleeping with my best friend, and I’ll have to think about that for a minute. I’m still thinking about what I’m going to do with Amber when I see her at practice this afternoon, and I really need to cool down. I told Payton that twins run in our family, and now she can’t wait to have sex with you. I think she’s serious.”

“I have no problem with knocking up Payton. Or any other girl that you want me to breed, and you already know that includes you. I’m sorry that I didn’t tell you the complete truth about Amber. I was embarrassed over what happened in the pool, and I don’t like you girls fighting over me. Not that there’s any real contest, and you know you win every time.”

“Just tell me the truth, bro. Did Amber suck your cock, and did you cum inside her pussy?”

“Not for one second. I’m still a virgin, and I want you to be my first. I love you, sis, and nobody is going to stand between us. That’s the truth.”

My sister appears to accept my word. She offers me her balled up panties, and she kisses me on one cheek. I’m quick to turn my head, and our lips join together. A kiss that is clearly reserved for lovers. My sister is slow to pull away, and she leads me toward her bedroom. Where I expect we will formulate a plan to keep Amber out of our business.

“I can’t believe that Amber was in your bedroom while I was in the shower. Did she think that I was home?”

“Amber doesn’t care if someone sees us together, and maybe that’s my fault. I told Amber that you walked in on Payton and I this morning. That you saw your girlfriend riding my cock, and that you nearly lost your mind.”

“That sounds like me. I’m already feeling jealous, and you and my best friend haven’t even hooked up yet. Payton has a message for you, and she says that she can’t wait to see you at the motel. Do you have any message for her?”

“Tell Payton that I can’t wait to see her on Saturday, and send her my love. Does this mean that I’m officially dating you, and Payton?”

I have to remember this is just a game. I’m not really dating anyone, and Payton isn’t seriously interested in me. Or so I assume. My sister continues to walk toward her bedroom, and she sends my message. My sister never liked the way that I looked at any of her friends in the past, and she always seemed jealous of the attention that I gave to other girls. A romance with Payton could drive a wedge between the two life long friends.

“I don’t know how I feel about this, Josh. Payton is very high strung, and you know how demanding I can be at times. Are you sure that you can handle both of us at the same time?”

“I’m willing to try. Can you handle me being with your best friend, and what if she really asks me for a baby? Or are we just pretending?”

“I’ll be okay as long as you knock me up first. Pretend or not, and I’m not sure what I’m doing yet. But as captain of the cheerleaders I’ve always been the flyer, and I won’t play second position to any one of my girls. Including Payton.”

“Being a cheerleader means everything to you. Doesn’t it, sis? Are you sure you want to go through with this plan of yours? It could permanently end your career.”

“I don’t see any other option. I need you to play my boyfriend, and I need you at the motel. Amber obviously isn’t going to let this go. In fact, Payton says Amber just sent her a new text, and she asked if you guys are going steady. Our cousin is clearly jealous, and she wants you for herself. I’ve had more than enough of that boyfriend stealing whore, and I’m going to kill her. I don’t care if she’s family.”

“Should I tell Amber that I’m not interested?”

“There’s not much sense in lying, bro. I know how she feels about you, and I know you can’t wait to cum deep in her pussy. Maybe I can use a sexual relationship between you and Amber to my advantage.”

“This is starting to become confusing, sis. Am I dating you, Payton, and Amber?”

“Is that a problem? I know your cock is rock hard most of the time, and you should be able to handle three girls. I’m liking this idea more and more. You can turn Amber into a teen mom, and maybe she will finally leave me alone. At the very least you can keep tabs on our horny cousin, and report back to me. What do you say?”

“Do you really want to see me with Amber, sis? What about Payton, and shouldn’t your girlfriend and I be seen in public if people are going to believe that we’re together?”

“Word travels fast on social media. The cheerleaders love the pictures that I sent this morning, and they believe that I was with my boyfriend. Payton answered Amber with a gigantic yes, and she gave all the details of your morning in bed. Apparently she came three times, and you blew your load deep inside her pussy. It’s a done deal, and everyone thinks that you and Payton are an item. Payton asked me to tell you about a beauty mark on the inside of her right thigh. It’s shaped like a butterfly, and it might prove useful if Amber asks for greater detail.”

“Should I give Payton a ring if we’re dating?”

“Only if you’re planning to give me one. My ring size is five, and maybe I should pick out the rings myself. I don’t know if I trust you to pick out something in my style.”

“What happened to a one time thing, sis? I thought we were finished, and I didn’t realize you and I are still faking pictures. Amber described the pictures from this morning, and why didn’t you wake me? Was my cock even hard?”

“Of course your cock was hard. Your cock is always hard, and it’s one of the reasons why I love you. The truth is you came in my mouth. I wanted to practice some more, and I didn’t expect to give you an orgasm while you slept. Not that I’m complaining, and I didn’t think that my brother would have a problem if I swallowed his nut sauce this morning. I think my technique is improving.”

I can’t stay mad at my sister. Emma took my cock in her mouth, and she made me cum. That certainly explains why my body was tingling when I woke up. My sister doesn’t mind how I ogle her sexy body, and oral sex has become just another thing that we do together. Our brother and sister relationship continues to evolve, and we feel very comfortable with one other. I don’t want things to return to the way they were before this week.

“I should be wearing a ring, and maybe Amber will finally believe I have a boyfriend. I wonder if mom has an old ring I can borrow.”

“I could buy you one for our next birthday. It will probably take that long to save up the money.”

“That’s six months away, and too long to wait. I need something to show off to the girls right now.”

“I wasn’t sure what to get you for your sweet sixteen, sis. I was thinking something lacy, and maybe a matching bra and panties. Or is that too weird a gift for a brother to give his sister?”

“I don’t think so. Do you even know my bra size?”

“Thirty-four double D. Am I right?”

“I imagine you were snooping through my underwear drawer. Or maybe you pulled one of my bras out of the laundry, and you could have just asked my size. What else do you know about your sister’s body?”

“I know you weigh a hundred and fourteen pounds.”

“That’s not true. I lost six pounds, and I’m down to a hundred and eight. That’s due to all my recent training on the field, and I’m trying to get down to a hundred and two. Thanks for noticing.”

“Believe me I noticed. You look great, and you know how much you turn me on. You have a fantastic body, and I know how hard you work to keep it that way. We can go running together if you want to slim down even more, and I can help you with a few toning exercises.”

“I thought that Amber was your running partner?”

“Amber has her own schedule. We don’t plan to go running together, and we’ve only met on the street the one time. Do you really want me to hang out with our cousin?”

“I guess it’s not the best idea. Amber lives on the other side of town, and I’ll probably never see you again. I don’t have time to go running every morning. But I might take you up on the toning exercises, and maybe you can come to practice with me. You can help the cheerleaders lose a few pounds, and I can help you lose your reputation as a loner. I might even help you get laid.”

An interesting proposal. Though probably meant to be a joke, and I’ll assume that my sister is playing one of her games. I feel like a puppet on a string, and I’ve had enough of her ever changing plans. My sister knows what I want, and she doesn’t seem to mind how I look at her sexy body. It might be time for me to take control, and show her exactly who’s boss. Before my attention turns to someone else.

Emma seems to know what I’m thinking. My sister spins around in the hall, and she kisses me full on the lips. One of my hands is directed beneath her nightdress, and I welcome the soft skin of her massive tits. My sister doesn’t like to be second to anybody, and she wants to remain the focus of my desires. I don’t know if she sees me as her brother, and that’s fine with me. I just wish that she would make up her mind.

Emma leads me into her bedroom. Elsa is waiting for us, and she has made a dramatic change from her typical dark clothes. A new look that sees the Dark Princess wearing one of Emma’s waist length nightshirts. Long enough to cover all of my sister’s ink, and to help act as a disguise. It appears that each of us has a role to play, and I have yet to hear mine. Though I expect my lines to be limited in the coming scene.

“I brought my camera like you asked. Where do you want me to set up, and does Josh know the whole plan?”

“Not yet. I’m still working on the details, and we can always make it up as we go. Obviously nobody can see our brother’s face, and he can’t say anything. I guess we could find ourselves a mannequin or a dummy, and probably achieve the same results. But where’s the fun in that?”

The humor is lost on me. Emma joins Elsa on the bed, and my sisters enjoy another healthy kiss. Elsa drives her tongue deep into Emma’s mouth, and their cheeks turn red. The same color as my cock. I have yet to hear a plan, and I’m not sure what the three of us are going to be doing together. Though it clearly has something to do with irritating our cousin.

“Where do you want me, sis?”

“I want you to lay in the middle of my bed. I’ll sit on your cock, and Elsa will sit on your face. She can run the camera, and all anyone will see are her bare legs. This way I will be the star, and nobody will recognize you as my brother and sister. Are you on board with this, Elsa?”

“Do I have to remove my panties?”

“That’s entirely your decision. I know you’re back with Cassie, and I understand if you want to remain faithful. I know you showed Josh how to eat your pussy, and I’m not jealous if that’s what has you worried. I’m not wearing panties, and I expect Josh to cum all over my pussy. It won’t be the first time that I had our brother’s cum all over my bed.”

“I have a better idea. What if you and I hold Amber down, and Josh can rape a baby into her womb? She won’t be able to tell anyone about us if she’s pregnant with our brother’s baby.”

“We can call that Plan B. Amber wants proof of my imaginary boyfriend, and the other cheerleaders are begging for more than just pictures. They want to see us perform in a video. I want it to look like I had a threesome, and I want Amber to be mad that I didn’t invite her to join us. But we’re not really having sex, and you’re not going to stick that baseball bat into me or Elsa. Understand so far, Josh?”