Chapter 2

“Okay, what’s this about, guys? Ronnie, Betty?” Archie Andrews reacted to the presence of two of his favorite ladies in all of Riverdale ... one of them his girlfriend, the other his lifelong best friend.

“Well, Arch ... how do I put this? Ronnie and I have been talking, and you know how we swore never to let a man come between us again? Well, I also talked to Jughead, after he and I broke up. Yes, we did. Again. And... , “ Betty Cooper clearly struggled with what she meant to say.

“We both want to date you, Archiekins. That’s just how it is. There’s only one way that happens with both of us knowing and it not ruining our friendship. We want to share you. We want you to be OUR boyfriend. Do you get it? How about it? Don’t worry. This won’t be a wanton free-for-all. You’re not boning half the girls in town, right? This is you having a committed relationship with us, babe. With both of us. Just as we toyed with in the past. With the double prom date, for instance. So, what do you say?” Veronica Lodge encouraged her boyfriend to include Betty in their relationship.

“Well, it would be great to get to hold you both without having to reassure each of you that nothing’s changed ... when the truth is that something has changed. I guess that we can all feel it, but I’m ... in love with you ... both. Both you and Betty, Ronnie. So long as it’s about love, I guess that’s good, right? We’re just all so loving that our love spills over and touches each other ... all three of us. I guess that I’m just trying to say is... , “ Archie stammered a little in shock.

“Just shut up and kiss us both, you big jock stud!” Betty told him as she locked lips with her lifelong crush again in her best friend’s house of all places.

“Oh, Archiekins ... this was always meant to be! You, me, and Bettykins! This is just how it should be! Don’t even try to deny it! Finally, we’re together ... the three of us, just as we belong!” Veronica added her own kisses to the picture to make it evident that she was in earnest about sharing her boyfriend with her girlfriend.

“Hey, not fair!” Valerie Brown of the Pussycats now intruded upon their little meeting, having followed the trio for some time now.

“What do you mean? You dumped Archie, remember?” Betty waxed a bit defensive now.

“Yes, but ... I like him, too. That was when I felt neglected, that’s all. I still ... really like Archie. Hell, who am I kidding? I love the goofball, okay? And I want to encourage his singing, too. If you two can share him with each other, why not with me? I’ll share, too. I’d never want you guys unhappy, after all. What do you guys say?” Valerie insisted.

“I think that’s fair. We’ve always been friends, right? How about it, Archiekins, Betty? Open things up just enough to welcome Valerie with open arms? You lucky bastard, Archiekins! You get three girlfriends now! But don’t count on a fourth. We’re not that wicked, I think. This isn’t a porn palace! Stick with the three of us and be faithful to us, okay?” Veronica backed Valerie up entirely.

“Especially since I’d ... want to ... what’s the phrase... ‘fluid-bond’ with each of you. I want to keep you three around, if we’re going to date, permanently ... knock all three of you up, and raise a family together with you gals. Basically like having three wives, but loyal to each other. What do you think?” Archie tried to will his boner down as he realized that he had just agreed to take three lovers instead of one.

“Hey, if it works for Moose, Midge, and Kevin, or Jughead, Cheryl, and Toni, why not, right? It’s helped make Cheryl less of a bitch, too, from what I can tell in the past few hours, looking at her social media at least,” Betty snorted, “I’m proud to share our Arch man with two girls who have been so good to him.”

“For the record, I do think that you deserve a hall pass for Jughead, though. Since I’m getting three girlfriends, it’s a sensible gesture on my part, given your feelings for him,” Archie abruptly stated.

“Well, that saves me the trouble of suggesting it. Thank you, Archie. You’re the best!” Betty told him with a fierce kiss.

“Yep, that’s our Archiekins! Valerie, do you want to do the honors? I stole some Viagra from my Dad’s medicine cabinet, planning to repay him later ... but now that he’s been arrested, that won’t be necessary. God, I can’t even defend the bastard, since he up and murdered FP Jones and Penny Peabody, only to get caught! How stupid was that? Killing someone who’s known to have a beef with you, getting the Serpents all over your ass, and getting caught into the bargain.

“After how things have gone down between him and Sheriff Keller and Mayor McCoy, no one’s gonna do Daddy any favors. Hell, for all I know, Mom could well be accused of involvement in the hit! Using Andre to do it was a bonehead move for sure! Trying to pressure Pop Tate to cover up for him ... that was sheer stupidity! How could Daddy lose his mind that way? Is he preparing an insanity defense, because he could well have a case for that,” Ronnie fumed about her father’s idiocy there.

“Hey, let’s relax and get your father off your mind, okay?” Archie encouraged Veronica, kissing her neck, just as Valerie unzipped his pants and Betty put on her black wig/costume.

While Betty and Veronica held hands and playfully made out again, this time for Archie’s benefit, Valerie Brown climbed aboard the “Archie Express,” as she liked to call it. She began kissing his face and chest, too, even as she took him deeper, bareback, inside her gushy twat. This time, she knew what she wanted: she wanted a little Archie Junior swelling up inside her womb, giving her a baby bump. She made a special point of pulling his hands onto her ass so that he could feel her smooth mocha buns for himself. She might not have the exact same history with Archie as those two other girls, but she had the tush and she had encouraged his songwriting.

“Three girlfriends, honey ... I’m glad that you have us. You deserve three girlfriends for sure, especially granting Betty a hall pass for Jugs. Especially now, in case he needs the comfort, though I imagine that Toni and Cheryl mostly have him covered,” Veronica whispered in a husky voice before switching to Spanish for a few choice words.

“So, Archie, you have a white girl, a black girl, and a Latina. Clearly, you like diversity,” Valerie teased Archie while humping him with abandon now.

“He’s just the best, most loving guy ever! Too many guys would take three girlfriends, but never even hint at a hall pass for one of them. Think that Moose would give Midge one, even though he’s dating Kevin, too? Not likely! Of course, I hate to be an ungrateful pest, but shouldn’t we girls be allowed to do each other, since we’re all sharing him, anyway?” Betty proposed, motivating Archie by kissing Veronica’s cleavage.

“Oh ... fuck, yeah ... anything that you girls want to do with each other is ... fine ... by me. Oh, God, yes!” Archie groaned as Valerie kept riding him for the hell of it.

“In that case, Archiekins, watch and learn!” Ronnie told him as she parted Betty’s thighs and started licking that blonde bush between her legs.