Chapter 4: Betting on Haley – Part II

Can you stay?

As I sat there, Haley’s hand began to touch and feel and explore my cock. She could barely wrap her tiny little hand around it. She clearly didn’t know what she was doing, so I gently wrapped my own hand around hers and began to slowly stroke. I started telling her what to do and giving her directions. She followed them eagerly, and she learned fast.

Haley began to stroke the shaft and the head. With some direction, she started to work on my balls as well. In no time at all, she learned what worked well and what didn’t. I lifted my head, put my arm back around her, and held her close again. I turned to her.

“Now put your mouth on it.”

She stroked it a couple more times and said. “Really?”

I looked at her and said, “You did say you knew what to do, right?”

She said, “I do! It’s just...”

I knew, of course, that she had no idea what to do.

“Haley, do you plan on having a boyfriend at all?”

I also knew she already had plenty of guys asking her out. She answered, “Of course I do.”

“If you plan to have a boyfriend, I guarantee he’s going to want you to give him a blow job.”

She just looked at me and bit her lip as she tried to decide what to do.

“Go ahead. Just try it. Just a little bit. I promise you’ll be fine.”

Haley thought about it for a moment, then decided to just go for it. She leaned down hesitantly and gently touched the tip of my cock with her tongue. I swear I could have blown her head off right then and there. Slowly, she started to lick and taste and once again began to explore, but with her mouth this time.

At that moment, almost exactly on cue, my phone chirped. Haley jumped up off my cock as if it had exploded. I told her to relax; it was just the phone and tried to direct her back to what she was doing. She asked who it was, and I told her it was Carly. Haley panicked just a bit and suddenly stopped what she was doing, frantically looking at all the doors and windows again. I told her to relax. Carly obviously wasn’t here if she was calling. Then I read the text to her.

“At Ashley’s house. She’s having a meltdown. Can you wait there for a while longer??”

That was our prearranged code for “Are you fucking my sister yet?”

I looked at Haley and asked her, “What do you think? Do you want me to stay a while?”

That naughty smile I loved returned to her face. I gently pushed her head back to my cock. I spoke aloud what I was texting back to Carly. What Haley heard was...

“Yes. Haley is keeping me entertained. Take your time.”

What Haley didn’t hear was what that meant. That was our code for, “Yes, I am getting your sister naked, and yes, I am going to fuck her before the day is over.”

Haley actually laughed at that and began licking my shaft up and down again. What Haley didn’t know was that what I had actually texted to Carly was, “Watch this,” and then turned on the camera. I had the phone up at chest level and pointed right down at Haley going to town on my dick; she thought I was just texting. Just as the camera turned on, Haley, for the first time, wrapped her little mouth around the head of my cock.

I almost dropped the phone on her head as she took it in her mouth and started to suck. The phone pinged immediately with Carly saying ‘OMG OMG OMG!!!!!!!”.

I texted back, “Innocent little sister???” I let the camera continue for a moment. Haley was sucking, Carly was watching, I was in heaven. I recorded a little bit and then said to hell with the phone and got back to more important issues.

As Haley continued to suck, I again began to give her more directions. Slowly, she was able to take more and more of me into her mouth. Not a lot. She gagged a lot, but she was really making the effort. I didn’t care. It was incredible having this beautiful, sexy, eager young girl going to town on my dick. Soon she was sucking on my head and working her hand on my balls. I was ready to explode.

Wanna do it?

After a while, I made her stop for a moment. I didn’t want to, but I also didn’t want to bust all over the living room sofa. Plus, it was important to make some moves. I wanted her clothes off.

I sat her up, then reached down and started to pull her shirt up.

She said, “What are you doing?”

I said, “If you keep going, I’m going to explode, and if it doesn’t all go in your mouth...”

“EWWWWW,” she interrupted.

I smiled but continued, “If it doesn’t all go in your mouth, then it’s going to go all over you. Do you want to explain cum stains on your shirt when your mom does the laundry? Or all over the sofa?”

While she thought about that, I stood up, grabbed my pants, then took her hand and started to pull her up. I wanted her on a bed.

“C’mon, let’s go upstairs,” and started pulling her up to the bedrooms.”

She didn’t even hesitate to follow right along. She jumped right up and almost beat me up the stairs. When we got to the top of the stairs and were passing Carly’s room, I stopped.

I looked at her with my favorite evil grin and said: “You wanna do it on Carly’s bed?”

Haley clearly misunderstood. She panicked for the slightest moment, obviously thinking of what Carly and I had done on Carly’s bed. Then said, “Do it????”

I kind of snickered a little and answered: “Well, I meant continue what we were already doing, but if you want to do it...”

It was good to know that was what she was thinking.

She thought about it briefly, looked down at my still-hard member poking between us, then lit up that smile again and pulled me down the hall to her room.

“My room!” she said.

When we got into her room, I pulled my shirt off. I was now completely naked. Haley looked at me and swooned just a little bit. I pulled her close, my cock poking at her belly, and kissed her again. Kissing she was really good at. Then I reached down and grabbed her shirt again. This time, she just raised her hands up over her head as I pulled the shirt up and off. I slid my hands up her body and stopped at those little tits. They were so perfect. She just cooed and smiled and never once tried to stop me as I felt her up.

I turned her around and walked us across the room to her bed. I reached up and undid the bra she was wearing and slowly pulled it off her. Again, she never tried to stop me. When I turned her back around, she had her hands across her chest, covering herself up. I gently took her hands and pulled them away. She was incredible. Her tits were bigger than I had expected, firm and soft, with perfect dark little nipples standing right up for attention. I needed my camera again.

We kissed for a few moments, and then I stopped and pushed her down on the edge of the bed. Time to get back to what we were doing. I stepped closer and pulled her head back to where we left off. This time she attacked my cock. Her mouth enveloped what she could. Her hands stroked what she couldn’t get in her mouth while alternately kneading my balls.

After a few short minutes, I was ready to blow. As she was sucking, I told her, “Close your eyes.”

She asked, “Why?”

“When I pull it out, it’s gonna go everywhere; you don’t want to get it in your eyes, do you?”

She had seen me do the same thing to her sister two weeks earlier.

She said, “Can’t you just shoot it somewhere else?”

What a perfect question.

I answered, “You want it on your sheets? On your floor? It’s much easier to clean up off of you.”

I had no intention of pulling out of her mouth or shooting anywhere other than all over her face. She was going to get her first taste whether she wanted to or not. The first cum this girl was going to swallow was going to be mine. I reached over and grabbed my phone. As she sucked and fondled with her eyes closed, I turned the camera on and started recording.

Within moments, I could no longer take it. I grabbed the back of her head and held her tight as I thrust forward and shot my first load right down her throat. She gagged and tried to pull back, but I held her there for a moment, so she had to swallow that first load. Then I let her go and shot the next blast all over her face. It was beautiful. She was covered with it. She scrunched her face up and pulled away, taking the final shots all over her chest and tits. All of it was recorded.

As Haley was wiping cum from her eyes and face, I turned the camera off and tossed it to the floor with my clothes. My knees just about gave out, and I collapsed on the bed next to her. She was wiping her face clean with her fingers. Then she laid back next to me.

“I told you it might get in your eyes.”

“You didn’t say you were going to do it in my mouth! That was gross!”