Amy and Jordan
by BigJW
Copyright© 2025 by BigJW
Incest Sex Story: A story about a love that wouldn't be denied. Jordan and his twin sister Amy fight an attraction for each other that they both know is wrong. Will they continue to resist or will they give in?
Caution: This Incest Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including mt/ft Teenagers Consensual Reluctant Romantic Fiction Incest Brother Sister Cream Pie First Oral Sex AI Generated .
The late afternoon sun, a weak, diluted gold, spilled through the window of their shared living room, painting long, distorted shadows across the worn rug. Seventeen years, and not a single one had passed without Jordan and Amy breathing the same air, sharing the same space. State College, Pennsylvania, was a quiet town, its rhythm dictated by the university, but their small, two-story house on Elm Street felt like a world unto itself, a bubble where the ordinary hum of life outside often faded into background noise.
Jordan sat on the floor, legs splayed, a textbook balanced precariously on his knees. His dark hair, usually messy from practice, fell across his brow, catching the light. He traced a finger along a diagram, but his gaze kept drifting, snagging on his twin sister Amy. She sat across from him, perched on the edge of the sofa, a sketchpad in her lap. Her own dark hair, a mirror of his, cascaded over her shoulders, shimmering. She had a way of biting her lower lip when she concentrated, a habit he’d known since before memory. Today, though, her concentration seemed fractured. Her eyes, the same color as his, a deep, unsettling hazel, flickered toward him, then away, then back again. He shifted, the textbook sliding. “Still trying to nail that perspective?” His voice was a low rumble, a familiar sound.
Amy’s hand froze, charcoal poised above the page. “Something like that.” Her voice, a softer echo of his, held a tremor he hadn’t heard before. She didn’t look at him directly, instead focusing on a smudge on her thumb. The silence that followed stretched, thick and humid, like the air before a summer storm. It wasn’t the comfortable silence they usually shared, the unspoken understanding that had always existed between them, a bond forged in the womb. This was something new, something charged.
It had been building for weeks, maybe months, a subtle shift in the gravitational pull between them. A brush of hands lingered too long. A shared glance held an unfamiliar intensity. A sudden, inexplicable flush when one caught the other in a moment of undress. He cleared his throat, the sound rough. “You’ve been ... quiet lately.” He watched her, waiting.
She finally met his gaze, and the electric current that arced between them was almost visible. Her cheeks flushed a delicate rose. “So have you.” Her eyes, wide and searching, held a question he couldn’t quite decipher, but felt deep in his bones.
The air thrummed. He felt a strange heat bloom in his chest, then spread, a blush climbing his own neck. He looked away, focusing on a dust mote dancing in a sunbeam. “Just ... school, I guess. Practice.”
“Right.” Her voice was barely a whisper. She closed her sketchpad with a soft thud, the sound amplified in the quiet room. She stood, moving toward the window, her back to him. The light silhouetted her form, long and slender. He found his eyes tracing the curve of her hip, the line of her spine, a possessive ache he instantly recoiled from. He squeezed his eyes shut for a moment, a desperate attempt to push the thoughts away. This was Amy. His twin. His sister. The very idea was a betrayal, a perversion that clawed at his gut. Yet, the thoughts persisted, insidious and unwelcome, blossoming into images he couldn’t control. He stood up, the textbook forgotten on the floor.
He walked to the kitchen, needing distance, needing a cold glass of water to quench the sudden thirst in his throat. He filled a glass, the ice clinking loudly. When he turned, Amy stood in the doorway, her presence filling the frame. “Jordan.” Her voice was soft, hesitant.
He gripped the glass, knuckles white. “Yeah?” He kept his gaze fixed on the condensation beading on the glass.
“Are we ... okay?” She stepped further into the kitchen, her scent, a light floral mixed with something uniquely her, drifting toward him. It was a scent he’d always associated with home, with comfort. Now, it was intoxicating.
He forced himself to look at her, to meet her eyes. Her brow was furrowed, a delicate crease between her dark eyebrows. “Of course, Amy. Why wouldn’t we be?” The lie felt like sandpaper on his tongue.
A small, sad smile touched her lips. “I don’t know. It feels ... different.” She took a step closer, then another.
He felt the warmth radiating from her, a magnetic pull he fought against with every fiber of his being. “Different how?” His voice was hoarse.
She reached out, her fingers hovering, then gently touched his arm. Her touch was light, feather-soft, but it sent a jolt through him, a searing current that travelled straight to his core. He flinched, pulling back slightly, and her hand dropped. “Like we’re strangers. Or like ... like something’s wrong with me.” Her voice cracked on the last word.
The sight of her pain twisted his insides. He hated that he was the cause. He hated himself for the thoughts that plagued him, the desires that simmered beneath his skin. He wanted to tell her everything, to confess the terrifying, exhilarating truth that had taken root in his heart, but the words felt too monstrous, too forbidden. “Nothing’s wrong with you, Amy.” His voice was rough, a desperate plea. He took a step toward her, then stopped himself. The proximity was dangerous.
She shook her head, “Then what is it? You avoid my eyes. You flinch when I touch you. We don’t talk lately, not like we used to.” Her gaze was intense, piercing, demanding an answer.
He swallowed hard, his throat dry. “It’s ... it’s complicated.”
“Complicated how?” Her voice rose, a hint of frustration lacing her words. “We’re twins, Jordan. We’ve always told each other everything. And now ... now you’re shutting me out.”
He felt a sudden, overwhelming urge to bridge the distance between them, to pull her into his arms and confess, to drown in the impossible truth. But the moral compass, drilled into him since childhood, spun wildly and cried out. ‘No. This is wrong. This is family. This is forbidden,’ it said. “I can’t.” His voice was barely a whisper. He turned away, walking back towards the living room, needing to escape the suffocating intensity of her gaze.
She followed him, her footsteps soft on the wooden floor. “Can’t what? Can’t talk to me? Can’t tell me what’s happening?” She stood directly behind him. He could feel her breath on the back of his neck, sending shivers down his spine.
He closed his eyes, clenching his jaw. “I just ... I can’t.”
“Is it me?” Her voice was small, vulnerable. “Did I do something?”
He spun around, the desperation evident in his eyes. “No! God, no, Amy. It’s not you. It’s me.” He ran a hand through his hair, tugging at the strands. “It’s ... it’s everything.”
Her eyes searched his, a silent plea. “Tell me, Jordan. Please.” He looked at her, truly looked at her, and the dam he had built around his emotions began to crack. Her beauty, a familiar landscape he’d always taken for granted, now struck him with the force of a revelation. Her tall, graceful frame, the way her lips curved, the flecks of gold in her hazel eyes. It wasn’t just a sister he saw any more. It was a woman, captivating and alluring. And the forbidden desire, long suppressed, surged forward, demanding recognition. “Amy...” His voice was rough, laced with a plea of his own.
She took another step, closing the last remaining space between them. She reached up, her hand cupping his jaw, her thumb stroking his cheek. Her touch was fire, igniting every nerve ending. He leaned into it, an involuntary surrender. “What is it?” she whispered, her voice barely audible. Her eyes, wide and luminous, were fixed on his, searching for the answer he was terrified to give.
He couldn’t hold back any more. The truth, ugly and beautiful all at once, clawed its way out. “I ... I think I’m falling in love with you.” The words, once unspoken, now hung in the air, a fragile, explosive confession.
Her eyes widened further, a gasp catching in her throat. Her hand dropped from his face, her arm falling limp at her side. A range of emotions flickered across her features: shock, fear, then, unmistakably, a mirroring of the same forbidden longing he felt.
The silence returned, heavier than before, suffocating them both. He watched her, his heart hammering against his ribs, waiting for the inevitable rejection, the disgust, the shattering of their world. But she didn’t recoil. She didn’t scream. She simply stood there, trembling, her gaze locked with his. Her eyes held a different emotion now, a desperate, yearning recognition. “Oh, Jordan,” she whispered, her voice raw, broken. “I ... I think I’m falling in love with you too.”
The words were a lifeline and a death sentence all at once. Relief washed over him, dizzying and profound, followed immediately by a fresh wave of panic. They had crossed a line, a sacred, inviolable boundary. There was no going back. He reached for her, his hands trembling as he cupped her face. Her skin was soft, warm beneath his palms. He leaned in, his gaze dropping to her lips, full and slightly parted. He saw the same hunger in her eyes, the same terrified desire. “We shouldn’t,” he breathed, the words a futile protest against the overwhelming current pulling them closer.
“I know,” she whispered back, her voice barely a breath, but she made no move to pull away. Instead, she leaned into his touch, her eyes fluttering closed.
His thumb traced the curve of her jaw, then brushed over her lower lip. The scent of her, now magnified, filled his senses, a heady mix of fear and arousal. He hesitated, one last desperate plea from his conscience, then plunged forward. His lips met hers, tentative at first, a soft brush, a question. Her lips were soft, yielding, tasting faintly of the mint gum she chewed. He deepened the kiss, a slow, agonizing exploration.
Her hands, which had been limp at her sides, rose, her fingers tangling in his hair, pulling him closer. A soft moan, a delicate sound, escaped her throat, and he felt it deep in his chest. His tongue, hesitant, traced the seam of her lips. She parted them, an invitation he eagerly accepted. His tongue slipped inside, a slow, searching probe. Her tongue met his, a shy dance at first, then a passionate tangle, swirling and stroking. The kiss deepened, becoming hungry, desperate, a silent conversation of long-suppressed desire.
He tasted her, the unique flavor of her mouth, and it was intoxicating, more potent than any alcohol. He felt her body press against his, soft curves molding against his hard planes, and a guttural groan escaped him. His hands slid from her face, down her neck, over her shoulders, then settled on her waist, pulling her flush against him. He felt the soft swell of her breasts against his chest, the warmth of her belly. Her fingers tightened in his hair, pulling his head back slightly, deepening the angle of the kiss, her mouth opening wider, allowing him full access. He sucked gently at her lower lip, then her upper, a soft shlicking sound echoing in the quiet room. Her body trembled against his.
The kiss was a revelation, a breaking of all taboos, a plunge into the forbidden. It was messy, urgent, and exhilarating. His erection, a hard, demanding presence, pressed against her lower belly, a stark reminder of the impossibility and inevitability of their actions. He felt her shift, a slight movement, and then felt the softness of her mound against his hardness, a jolt that sent fire through his veins.
He broke the kiss, gasping for air, their foreheads resting against each other. Her eyes were still closed, her lips swollen and red. Her chest rose and fell rapidly. “Amy,” he breathed, his voice raw, thick with emotion.
Her eyes fluttered open, dark and dilated, filled with a mixture of fear and insatiable longing. “Jordan.” Her voice was barely a whisper, a plea. He held her gaze, a silent question passing between them. The world outside, the rules, the judgments, seemed to recede, leaving only them, two souls irrevocably drawn together.
He lowered his head, trailing kisses down her jaw, along her neck, tasting the salt of her skin. She arched her neck, a soft moan escaping her. His lips found the hollow of her throat, then moved lower, pulling aside the collar of her worn t-shirt. He pressed his mouth to her skin, his tongue tracing patterns, a slow, deliberate exploration.
Her hands, still tangled in his hair, slid down to his shoulders, then his chest, her fingers fumbling with the hem of his shirt. He understood. He pulled his t-shirt over his head, tossing it aside. She gasped, her eyes devouring his bare chest, his shoulders, the ripple of muscle. He felt a surge of masculine pride, a primal urge to be seen, desired by her. She reached out, her fingers timidly tracing the line of his collarbone, then lower, over his pectorals. Her touch was electric, sending shivers through him. He shivered, a deep, resonant sound. “You’re beautiful,” she whispered, her voice hoarse.
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.