The Blackstar Legacy - Cover

The Blackstar Legacy

Copyright© 2026 by Lumpy

Chapter 9

The night was an uneasy one. Even with someone on guard, no one slept well. The crazy old man wasn’t the problem; he curled up and slept the sleep of someone completely unbothered by his surroundings. The rest of them couldn’t help but listen to the noises outside the cave.

It was like the night before when they entered the Claws, but worse, because any noise could be a sign that the creatures out there followed them into the cave. That their safe haven for the night wasn’t safe after all.

And yet, none came. They passed the night completely unbothered by whatever lived out there.

The old man barely roused as they packed the next morning and prepared to leave. It was only when they were fully ready, having eaten a small breakfast, that he finally woke, looking confused and a little wild, mumbling to himself and the rocks around him.

Osric still felt a little bad for the wild old man.

“You could come with us,” he said as they started to leave. “We can help you get back to the world beyond these mountains.”

“No, no, no,” he muttered, rocking back and forth. “Can’t leave. Never leave.”

Grace rolled her eyes, slinging her pack over her shoulder. “This is going to be hard enough without bringing crazy with us.”

“Have some compassion,” Jasper chided her. “We don’t know what horrors this man has endured.”

She shrugged and moved to head out of the cave. Osric was prepared to ignore what she had said. Grace might have been crass, but she wasn’t wrong. The man’s mind was pretty far gone. The old man, though, for some reason, had locked on to Jasper, staring at him with intensity.

As they turned to leave, the old man said to Jasper, “The girl, the blonde girl, she screamed for you, holy man. She screamed your name. She asked why you didn’t come. Why you didn’t protect her like you promised.”

Jasper froze, his face draining of color. Osric looked to the others, all of whom looked as perplexed as he was, with the exception of Grace, who glared at the cleric for a moment before turning and storming out of the cave.

Rowan hurried to follow, knowing how dangerous it was for any of them to be out there alone.

“Jasper,” Osric said gently as the cleric stared back at the old man. “We don’t want to get left behind.”

Jasper seemed to shake himself enough to follow the others, who’d paused to wait outside the cave for them.

For a little while, they trudged up the hill in silence, but Osric couldn’t stop thinking about what the old man had said. Yes, he’d said a lot of crazy things since they found him, but this last comment had hit home. He’d mentioned a blond girl, and, given Grace’s reaction, he couldn’t help but wonder if maybe the girl was Grace.

Osric had always felt there was more between the two of them than either let on, although he had no idea it was this serious. After thirty minutes of walking, it seemed that Grace couldn’t take it anymore.

“You lied to me,” she shouted, seething and pointing a finger at Jasper’s chest. “You said none of it was true.”

Rowan and Osric both looked around, worried her shouting might draw creatures they’d been lucky enough to avoid so far.

“What are you talking about?” Talia asked. “What isn’t true?”

“I first heard of Jasper from others near Farhaven. They said he wasn’t to be trusted, that he’d done something. Some people thought he’d killed someone. Not just someone, an innocent. When he ... found me borrowing things from him, I asked him about it. He denied it, and I believed him. But that old man, he might be crazy, but he knew stuff. So tell me again that it’s a lie. Say it to my face!”

“You, of all people, have no right to lecture me about lying,” Jasper said, a lot more harshly than Osric had ever heard him speak to anyone.

But she might have a point.

“Grace isn’t wrong, though,” he said softly. “He said it was nothing to me, too.”

The thief’s head snapped toward Osric. “You know about this too? And you kept it from us?”

The hurt in her voice was palpable. Osric was surprised by that. He and Grace got along well enough, but they’d only known each other for a few months, and she was usually fairly snarky with him.

He hadn’t imagined that his withholding information would bother her so much. She clearly held back what she knew about Jasper, too, after all.

But he’d only stayed silent because he’d trusted Jasper. Because he saw him as a man of integrity. If Grace was right ... then Osric had made a mistake staying silent.

“When I went into the pool, the gods actually showed me two visions. They showed me not just the tower, but a vision of Jasper with a young girl. A young blonde girl. Something felt off about it, but the vision didn’t give me any more information. I spoke to him about it afterward, before we left Avendell. He said he didn’t want to discuss it, that it was nothing. I ... I believed him and respected his privacy.”

“Well, I want to know,” Grace demanded, crossing her arms.

Rowan nodded in agreement. “If the gods themselves are showing visions of this, it’s something we should all be aware of.”

Talia nodded, agreeing with both of them. Jasper was outnumbered.

Jasper’s shoulders sagged, the fight draining out of him. He looked older suddenly, weary beyond his years.

“It’s why I left the Brethren. There was a girl, her name was Nora. She was no more than twelve or thirteen. I was told she posed a danger to magic itself. They told me it was my job to stop her. I asked them to explain, explain why she had to die, but they refused. I begged them, but they kept insisting it wasn’t something that someone of my status needed to understand. That it was my duty to accept their judgment on faith alone.”

He paused but refused to look up at any of them. Osric could hear the pain in his voice. It was raw. Visceral.

“When I met her, I found only an innocent child. She was so excited when she found out I was a cleric and that I’d come to visit her. She said she heard voices that told her someone was coming to help her. She said it was the gods, and they were preparing her for some great mission to help the world. She said a lot of other things, most of which made little sense, like our friend in there. I thought perhaps she was ... touched. I felt sorry for her. I couldn’t understand how this sweet, confused girl could be a threat to magic itself. I also thought, maybe these voices were something else, something corrupting her.”

He finally looked up, his eyes almost imploring them to believe him. “The thought of harming her was repugnant. I thought, if someone was manipulating her, I could help her. Get her to resist whatever it was. That way, she wouldn’t have to die. But ... I had to get her away from the Brethren first. I tried to help her escape. I was woefully unprepared. The others found us easily enough. They put me in chains while another member, a man I thought was my friend, carried out the execution I had refused to perform. I begged him to stop, but he didn’t even acknowledge me.”

“If they had you in chains, how did you live to say anything? Why would they let you live after disobeying them?” Talia asked.

“They claimed that, while it needed to be done, it had been given to me as a test. A test of loyalty, of my willingness to do what needed to be done to protect magic and the world from the evils trying to end it. They said most recruits failed the first time, that it was hard to become the type of person who could do what was needed. They welcomed me back with open arms. They said I could try again. But I couldn’t. I started questioning everything about them, about their methods and their goals.”

“But you told us you were a minor member of the Brethren,” Osric said. “Why would they give a minor member a job like that, or tell you that you were being tested?”

“I was. One of the lowliest of the low. That’s likely why they gave me that task. For the early ranks of the Brethren, I think it’s not about protecting anything. I think it’s about breaking you down. Telling you you’re special and capable of helping save the world. They make you feel like you are part of something, all so that when they ask you to do something unforgivable, you’ll do it. That’s what it’s about, to get you far enough in so that you’ll make that one choice you can’t unmake. Once someone does something like that ... the guilt, the shame, it binds you to them forever. You become malleable because fighting back means accepting that you’re a monster. So you have to believe it was the right thing to do, and that they’re right. It wasn’t a test. It was a trap.”

The cleric reached out and grabbed Osric’s hand between both of his, squeezing it hard. “It’s why I was so willing to believe in you, Osric. To follow you. I know now that she was actually talking to the gods, gifted with visions, and so were you. You were both chosen. I saw in you a second chance, an opportunity to truly do their will. To be forgiven for failing.”

“Then you weren’t the first they did that to. How did you stay with them for so long? What made you believe in them?” Talia asked.

“I was lost, looking for answers, and they are masterful at indoctrination. It wasn’t just blind faith or fear that kept me there. They showed us concrete evidence of magical disasters they’d prevented. Extensive historical records of catastrophes they’d stopped. They wrapped their lies in truths, making it very convincing. And very hard to ignore.”

“But surely you must have questioned some of their methods?” Rowan asked. “They’re obviously ready to murder people at the drop of a hat, so they’ve done it before.”

Jasper nodded slowly. “I did question them, at times. But they mixed genuine threats with their more questionable actions. It made it ... difficult to separate truth from manipulation. But it was more than that. They made us feel chosen. Special. Every mission was framed as part of a noble legacy of protecting the world. Doubt was weakness. Questioning orders was seen as dangerous not just to us, but to everything.”

“But you’re not some simpleton. How could you not see through their lies?” Grace said.

“They isolated us from outside perspectives. Gradually conditioning us. It became nearly impossible to maintain independent judgment. I couldn’t see it, or what they truly were, until I was away from them.”

“If it was so powerful, how did you manage to stop being indoctrinated?” Talia asked.

Jasper’s gaze fell to the ground. “I didn’t, not really. Not until Nora. Yes, I questioned them a lot, and though it got me in trouble, they always smoothed things over. The incident with her ... it forced me to confront the reality of what they were asking me to do. It shattered their web of control.”

 
There is more of this chapter...
The source of this story is Storiesonline

To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account (Why register?)

Get No-Registration Temporary Access*

* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In