The View From the Cello Section
Copyright© 2026 by Marc Nobbs
Chapter 8a: I Won! – Twitter Reaction
10:17 p.m.
The Westmouth Union @WestmouthUnion: RESULT - THBT the gender pay gap is evidence of structural discrimination. PROPOSITION WINS. Congratulations to first-time speaker @CelloLana on an outstanding debut.
Replies
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @WestmouthUnion Thank you! I appear to still contain far too much adrenaline for punctuation.
The Westmouth Union @WestmouthUnion: @CelloLana We noticed.
Student Politics UK @StudentPoliticsUK: @WestmouthUnion Wait. FIRST debate?
The Westmouth Union @WestmouthUnion: @StudentPoliticsUK First competitive Union debate. Yes.
Student Politics UK @StudentPoliticsUK: @WestmouthUnion Who was opposition?
The Westmouth Union @WestmouthUnion: @StudentPoliticsUK Our President, @HJCavendish.
Politics Student @PoliticsStudent: @WestmouthUnion HAHAHAHAHAHA FRESHER BEATS PRESIDENT ON DEBUT
Meg @redmeg92: @CelloLana OH MY GOD CELLO LANA DID IT
10:26 p.m.
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: I WON MY FIRST DEBATE. Beat the President of the Westmouth Union. I WON.
Replies
Free Market Dan @FreeMarketDan: @CelloLana Surely not. HOW badly did you beat him?
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @FreeMarketDan Badminton terminology?
Free Market Dan @FreeMarketDan: @CelloLana Obviously.
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @FreeMarketDan Two games to love. Fewer than ten points conceded overall.
Free Market Dan @FreeMarketDan: @CelloLana JESUS CHRIST!!!
Badminton Dan @BadmintonDan: @CelloLana I HAVE NEVER BEEN MORE PROUD!
RacketGirl @RacketGirl91: @CelloLana STRAIGHT SETS
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @BadmintonDan Debates are not scored like badminton. I would like that formally acknowledged.
Badminton Dan @BadmintonDan: @CelloLana TOO LATE
RacketGirl @RacketGirl91: @CelloLana Did you shake hands at the net?
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @RacketGirl91 Yes. No racquets were involved. It was disappointing.
Tom Fraser @TomF_Physics: @CelloLana When’s the final?
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @TomF_Physics Apparently debating societies expect people to keep debating indefinitely. There may be no final. Terrible system.
10.38 p.m.
Amy @amyplaysviola: SHE POSTED “I WON!” THIS IS NOT A DRILL http://tmblr.co/cl721Iw
Replies
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @amyplaysviola Amy!
Amy @amyplaysviola: @CelloLana YOU WROTE THE TITLE
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @amyplaysviola Yes. I am temporarily abandoning restraint.
Jess @JessFromLeeds: @CelloLana YOU ARE ALLOWED TO BE PLEASED WITH YOURSELF FOR FIVE MINUTES
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @JessFromLeeds I intend considerably longer than five minutes.
10.41 p.m.
Econ & Feminism @EconAndFeminism: CelloLana has returned from her first university debate with a calm and scholarly analysis of the result: “I WON!” http://tmblr.co/cl721Iw
Replies
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @EconAndFeminism This was calm compared with the noises I made in our kitchen.
Econ & Feminism @EconAndFeminism: @CelloLana Congratulations! Did you genuinely beat the society president?
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @EconAndFeminism Yes. First debate. Beat the president. It was not close. I may mention this several more times.
10.44 p.m.
Student Politics UK @StudentPoliticsUK: Current state of @CelloLana after beating the Westmouth Union President on her first debate: “40% adrenaline and 60% smugness.” Honestly fair.
Replies
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @StudentPoliticsUK The percentages remain approximately accurate.
Politics Student @PoliticsStudent: @CelloLana You were worried SIX WEEKS AGO that you weren’t clever enough for university.
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @PoliticsStudent I was.
Politics Student @PoliticsStudent: @CelloLana And now?
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @PoliticsStudent Currently reconsidering the hypothesis.
10.46 p.m.
Henry Cavendish @HJCavendish: For the record @CelloLana is understating it. The rebuttal was vicious.
Replies
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @HJCavendish “Vicious” seems unfair.
Henry Cavendish @HJCavendish: @CelloLana You smiled politely while dismantling three minutes of my speech in about forty seconds.
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @HJCavendish That sounds efficient.
Henry Cavendish @HJCavendish: @CelloLana This is exactly what I mean.
Student Politics UK @StudentPoliticsUK: @HJCavendish PRESIDENT CONFIRMS DESTRUCTION
Henry Cavendish @HJCavendish: @StudentPoliticsUK I wouldn’t say destruction.
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @HJCavendish I would.
Amy @amyplaysviola: @CelloLana WHO IS SHE
Badminton Dan @BadmintonDan: @CelloLana 60% SMUGNESS HAS BECOME 72%
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @BadmintonDan Possibly.
10.48 p.m.
The Westmouth Union @WestmouthUnion: FULL FIGURES: Motion carried, 67–18, with 6 abstentions. Speaker of the evening: Alannah Carrington, proposing in her maiden debate.
Replies
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @WestmouthUnion I prefer my scoring system.
The Westmouth Union @WestmouthUnion: @CelloLana The committee has declined your proposal to replace votes with badminton points.
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @WestmouthUnion Cowards.
Motions & Motions @MotionsAndMotions: @WestmouthUnion A first-year beat the president 67–18 in her maiden debate?
The Westmouth Union @WestmouthUnion: @MotionsAndMotions The vote was on the motion, not the speakers. But yes, she also won best speaker comfortably.
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @WestmouthUnion I am saving this tweet forever.
10.52 p.m.
Henry Cavendish @HJCavendish: Congratulations to @CelloLana. Precise definitions, honest concessions and excellent answers. I kept forcing concessions. She kept giving them to me. None defeated the motion. Very good debating.
Replies
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @HJCavendish Thank you. That is extremely gracious.
Henry Cavendish @HJCavendish: @CelloLana Your Tumblr report contains one error. My private education began at four, not conception.
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @HJCavendish I apologise for those four years of educational inflation.
Henry Cavendish @HJCavendish: @CelloLana Otherwise, two games to love is a fair summary.
Badminton Dan @BadmintonDan: @HJCavendish Was that because you had a poor evening or because she dismantled you?
Henry Cavendish @HJCavendish: @BadmintonDan The latter.
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @HJCavendish You are not required to help them.
Henry Cavendish @HJCavendish: @CelloLana I lost the debate. I retain an interest in factual accuracy.
Market Liberal Girl @marketliberalgirl: @HJCavendish THIS was what worried me reading her Tumblr. She can concede half your case and still somehow keep hers standing.
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @marketliberalgirl You helped with that.
Market Liberal Girl @marketliberalgirl: @CelloLana I KNOW AND I FEEL USED
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @marketliberalgirl You volunteered.
Market Liberal Girl @marketliberalgirl: @CelloLana WORSE+
10.55 p.m.
Westy Econ Tom @WestyEconTom: Was there. Henry tried “women freely choose different careers”. Lana basically went: agency ≠ absence of constraint. Room went VERY quiet.
Replies
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @WestyEconTom It was not “basically”. That was almost exactly what I said.
Motions & Motions @MotionsAndMotions: @CelloLana THE LINE. THE LINE WORKED
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @MotionsAndMotions It worked extremely well. Thank you again.
Motions & Motions @MotionsAndMotions: @CelloLana I WANT ROYALTIES
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @MotionsAndMotions Cake was offered. Do not become greedy.
Laura @WestyLaura: Best moment was Henry saying women choose part-time work. Lana: “Yes. Now tell me why the part-time version of so many senior jobs doesn’t exist.”
Replies
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @WestyLaura That is an abbreviated version.
Laura @WestyLaura: @CelloLana IT WAS STILL GOOD
Shop Steward Sue @shopstewardsue: @CelloLana OH SHE USED THE PART-TIME STRUCTURE POINT
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @shopstewardsue Yes. And the class criticism from Tumblr substantially improved it.
10.56 p.m.
Economics Girl @EconNerdGirl: WAIT. Was @DrLexiBennett actually at the debate tonight???
Replies
Westy Econ Tom @WestyEconTom: @EconNerdGirl Yep. Back row.
Economics Girl @EconNerdGirl: @CelloLana YOU KNEW SHE WAS THERE???
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @EconNerdGirl Not until shortly before we started.
Economics Girl @EconNerdGirl: @CelloLana HOW DID YOU NOT DIE??
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @EconNerdGirl I was occupied.
Amy @amyplaysviola: @CelloLana SHE HAD TO MURDER HENRY FIRST
Henry Cavendish @HJCavendish: @amyplaysviola I’m still here.
Amy @amyplaysviola: @HJCavendish SORRY HENRY. FIGURATIVELY
10.57 p.m.
Dr Alexandra Bennett @DrLexiBennett: Congratulations, @CelloLana. You were formidable tonight.
Replies
Economics Girl @EconNerdGirl: @DrLexiBennett AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA
Policy Student @PolicyStudent: @DrLexiBennett SHE SAID FORMIDABLE
Amy @amyplaysviola: @CelloLana CHECK ON THE CELLOIST
Politics Student @PoliticsStudent: @DrLexiBennett Have we lost her?
Henry Cavendish @HJCavendish: @DrLexiBennett Dr Bennett, I think you’ve broken my opponent.
Dr Alexandra Bennett @DrLexiBennett: @HJCavendish She seemed considerably harder to break an hour ago.
Henry Cavendish @HJCavendish: @DrLexiBennett Believe me.
Young Economics @YoungEconUK: A first-year student defeated her Union president tonight. @DrLexiBennett was watching and called her “formidable”. Quite an evening.
Keynes Is My Copilot @KeynesCopilot: Imagine discovering your academic hero is in the audience 12 seconds before your first debate and then winning 67–18.
Feminist With A Fiddle @FemWithAFiddle: “Formidable” is not “promising”. Formidable” means LEXI BENNETT THINKS YOU ARE DANGEROUS.
11.01 p.m.
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @DrLexiBennett Thank you. That means an embarrassing amount to me. I saw you at the back about 12 seconds before I stood up. This did not assist my nerves.
Replies
Economics Girl @EconNerdGirl: @CelloLana SHE ADMITTED IT AGAIN
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @EconNerdGirl I am choosing honesty. Temporarily.
Dr Alexandra Bennett @DrLexiBennett: @CelloLana Good. It did not show. And you should be proud of yourself. The argument was carefully constructed and very well defended.
Replies
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @DrLexiBennett I am. Very. Thank you.
Ordinary Girl @ordinarygirl1989: @CelloLana 😭😭😭
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @ordinarygirl1989 No crying.
Ordinary Girl @ordinarygirl1989: @CelloLana YOU SAID YOU’RE PROUD OF YOURSELF
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @ordinarygirl1989 Yes. This appears to have happened.
Economics Girl @EconNerdGirl: @DrLexiBennett @CelloLana I CANNOT COPE WITH EITHER OF YOU.
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @EconNerdGirl Please try. It is nearly eleven and I cannot accept responsibility for a stranger’s economic-emotional stability.
Economics Girl @EconNerdGirl: @CelloLana FOLLOWED.
11.03 p.m.
Keynes Is My Copilot @KeynesCopilot: HELLO TWITTER. LANA HAS BEEN A LEXI BENNETT FANGIRL FOR TWO YEARS. THIS IS THE GREATEST NIGHT OF MY LIFE
Replies
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @KeynesCopilot No. Absolutely not. Go back to Tumblr.
Dr Alexandra Bennett @DrLexiBennett: @CelloLana Two years?
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @DrLexiBennett I would like everyone to appreciate how preventable this was.
Keynes Is My Copilot @KeynesCopilot: @CelloLana I REGRET NOTHING
Dr Alexandra Bennett @DrLexiBennett: @CelloLana That does explain some remarkably thorough lecture notes.
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @DrLexiBennett I take thorough notes generally.
Economics Girl @EconNerdGirl: @CelloLana TWELVE PAGES IN FIFTY MINUTES
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @EconNerdGirl WHY DOES EVERYONE KNOW THAT
Amy @amyplaysviola: @CelloLana INTERNET
Dr Alexandra Bennett @DrLexiBennett: @CelloLana Twelve pages is excessive.
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @DrLexiBennett I have been informed. Repeatedly.
Dr Alexandra Bennett @DrLexiBennett: @CelloLana Did you understand all twelve?
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @DrLexiBennett Eventually.
Dr Alexandra Bennett @DrLexiBennett: @CelloLana Then they served their purpose.
Economics Girl @EconNerdGirl: @CelloLana I AM WATCHING MY OTP BUT IT’S ACADEMIC MENTORSHIP
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @EconNerdGirl Please never write that sentence again.
11.05 p.m.
Dr Alexandra Bennett @DrLexiBennett: @CelloLana One thing I particularly liked tonight: You didn’t pretend the evidence was cleaner than it is. Keep that habit.
Replies
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @DrLexiBennett I will. Thank you.
Actual Economist @actualeconomistmaybe: @DrLexiBennett Okay that is genuinely excellent advice.
Market Liberal Girl @marketliberalgirl: @DrLexiBennett Agreed. Annoying when people you disagree with are intellectually responsible.
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @marketliberalgirl You continue to make compliments sound painful.
Market Liberal Girl @marketliberalgirl: @CelloLana they are
11.06 p.m.
Debate Nerd UK @DebateNerdUK: @CelloLana Which part of your original Tumblr argument did you CHANGE before tonight?
Replies
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @DebateNerdUK Quite a lot. Mainly: (1) a narrower definition of structure; (2) less repetition of concessions; (3) more class; (4) three arguments, not six; (5) a stronger link between the gap and the mechanisms producing it.
Debate Nerd UK @DebateNerdUK: @CelloLana What were the three?
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @DebateNerdUK Very roughly: (1) evidence ≠ proof; (2) “choice” can be real while constraints remain gendered; (3) controls can describe mechanisms rather than make structure disappear.
Actual Economist @actualeconomistmaybe: @CelloLana GOOD
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @actualeconomistmaybe Your methodological nagging also helped.
Actual Economist @actualeconomistmaybe: @CelloLana “NAGGING”
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @actualeconomistmaybe Constructive nagging.
Free Market Dan @FreeMarketDan: @CelloLana Still think “controls can be mechanisms” is where you’re cheating slightly.
Lana Carrington @CelloLana: @FreeMarketDan Why?
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.