A Family Chosen
Copyright© 2026 by Megumi Kashuahara
Chapter 3: The First Night
For a little while nobody moved. The children stood bunched in the doorway with the cold at their backs, and Gideon stood by the dead hearth with his hat in his hand, and the room waited between them.
He was the one who broke it. He looked up at the loft, then down at the bed, then at the seven children, and Evelyn watched him do a sum in his head and dislike the answer.
“Loft sleeps four,” he said. “Maybe five, if they’re not big. The rest down here by the fire. I’ll—” He stopped. It was plain he hadn’t thought this part through, and plainer still that he knew it. “I’ll sort out where everybody goes.”
“The children can all go up,” Evelyn said. “The older ones on the outsides so the little ones can’t roll off the edge. They’ve slept like that before. Clara stays down here with me.”
He looked at her a moment, and she saw a flicker in his face that might have been relief at being handed an answer.
“Fine,” he said. “Bed’s yours, then.”
“And where will you sleep?”
“Outbuilding. There’s a cot.”
“Is it heated?”
“No.” He crouched by the hearth and reached for the tinderbox on the shelf beside it. “I’ve slept in worse.”
“Mr. Wolf, this is your home. You can’t put yourself out in a stable on our account. We can make do on the floor, all of us, we’ve done it—”
“Mrs. Hart.” He looked back at her over his shoulder. His voice wasn’t hard, but it didn’t leave much room. “It’s not a conversation. I said I’d sort it.”
He turned back to the fire.
She shut her mouth. Behind her, she heard Ruth draw breath to say something, and heard Rachel elbow her before she could.
“Hook for coats is there by the door,” he went on, laying kindling as he spoke. “Well’s twenty feet behind the outbuilding. Cover on it’s loose. Don’t let the little ones near it alone, not once, not for a minute.”
“I won’t.”
“Privy’s past the woodpile. Path’s trodden.” The tinder caught, and he leaned close and blew on it, and a small yellow light came up between his hands. “I’ll cook tonight, since you don’t know where anything is. Tomorrow I’ll show you where things are kept.”
“I can cook.”
“I know you can. Tomorrow.”
They unloaded the wagon in the last of the light. Tobias and Samuel carried in the heavy things without being told, staggering a little under the blanket rolls, and the twins brought the sacks, and James carried in his own sack and then went back and carried in Nora’s, very proudly, because Nora had sat down on the porch step and refused to stand up again. Evelyn took the medicine box herself and found a place for it on the end of the table where she could reach it in the dark.
The rifle she carried in last. She stood inside the door with it in her hands and looked around the room for somewhere to put it, and found two empty pegs above the door frame that seemed made for nothing else. She took the box of cartridges out of Tobias’s sack, loaded five into the tube, and hung the rifle on the pegs.
When she turned around, Gideon was watching her from the hearth. He didn’t say anything. He looked at the rifle, and then at her, and gave a short nod, as if she’d done a sensible thing and he wanted her to know he’d seen it. Then he went back to the fire.
Outside, Marshall stamped and blew. Gideon went out to see to him, and James was at the door before it had shut.
“Can I help with the horse?”
Gideon stopped on the porch step. “You can carry the water bucket. Not the hay. Hay’s heavy.”
“I’m strong.”
“The water’s heavy too. Carry that.”
James went, beaming, and came back ten minutes later with both knees soaked through where he’d fallen in the snow and the news that Marshall had a stall with his name carved over it, and that the stable smelled good, and that there was a cot in the little room beside it with a bearskin on it, a real bearskin with the claws still on.
“Did he shoot the bear?” Ruth demanded.
“I didn’t ask.”
“Why not?”
“Because he was busy,” James said, with enormous dignity. “With the horse.”
Before supper Evelyn took Ruth and Nora out along the trodden path past the woodpile to the privy, with the lantern swinging, and on the way back she found Gideon at the well behind the outbuilding, filling two buckets by the light of his own lantern. He’d lifted the heavy plank cover aside and leaned it against the stone curb. She could see at once what he’d meant about it. One edge was split and the iron strap that should have held it was hanging by a single nail.
She sent the girls on ahead to the porch and waited until they’d gone inside.
“May I ask you something?”
He hauled up the bucket hand over hand and set it on the curb. “Go on.”
“How far is the nearest neighbor?”
“Eleven miles by trail. Over the north ridge. Prospector named Haskell.” He unhooked the bucket and lowered the rope again. “He’s half crazy and he doesn’t like visitors. I wouldn’t count him.”
“And if one of the children gets badly hurt? Or sick past what I can manage?”
He looked at her across the well. The lantern light came up from below and made his face harder to read.
“Then we go down. It’s a long day to Doc Ehlers in good weather. Longer in bad.” He brought the second bucket up and set it beside the first. “I carried a man down once with a broken leg, on a travois behind Marshall. It can be done.”
“That isn’t very comforting.”
“I’m not trying to comfort you. You asked me a straight question.” He lifted the cover back onto the curb and set it carefully so the split edge wouldn’t slide. “I’ll fix this tomorrow. It’s been on my list.”
She looked at the cover, and then at him. “Thank you for telling me the truth.”
“You’ll always get that from me,” he said, and picked up both buckets and walked past her toward the cabin.
Supper was bean soup with dried venison in it, plain and filling, and bread from a round loaf that Gideon said he’d baked two days before. It had gone hard enough to need sawing, and nobody said a word about it. He set out bowls—tin ones, mismatched, more of them than one man could need, which Evelyn noted and didn’t ask about—and ladled the soup himself, and passed the bowls down the table one at a time.
There was only the one bench, so the children sat where they could: the older ones along the bench, Nora on Samuel’s knee, James cross-legged on the hearth with his bowl in his lap. Evelyn took the chair Gideon pushed toward her without arguing about it. Gideon stood at the end of the table with his own bowl and ate standing, as though he did it often.
The children were very quiet. Evelyn kept glancing from face to face, looking for a flush or a glassiness around the eyes, before she understood that none of them were sick. They were only overwhelmed. They had left home before dawn and ridden all day up a mountain into a stranger’s house, and now they were sitting at his table eating his food, and they did not know yet what the rules were.
Even James ate in silence, which in seven years Evelyn had never once seen him do. He watched Gideon over the rim of his bowl the whole time, as if the man were a bear himself, or a bear’s cousin, a creature that might at any moment do a thing worth seeing.
Ruth was the one who finally couldn’t stand it.
“Did you build this house yourself?”
“Yes.”
“All of it?”
“All of it.”
“How long did it take?”
“Most of a summer and into the fall.”
“By yourself?”
“Ruth,” Evelyn said.
“I’m only asking.”
“She can ask,” Gideon said. He tore a piece of bread off the loaf. “Yes. By myself.”
Ruth looked around at the walls, the thick squared logs, the great stone chimney, and Evelyn could see her trying to work out how one man could lift a log that size, and failing, and deciding to save the question for later.
Rachel had been studying the window—a single pane of real glass set high in the west wall, which was more glass than their old cabin had owned. “The sky was red in the west while we were climbing. Does that mean good weather tomorrow?”
Gideon looked at her a little longer than he’d looked at Ruth. “Sometimes. Not up here. Up here you watch the high clouds. If they’re moving from the northwest and thickening, weather’s coming no matter what color the sunset is.”
“Were they moving today?”
“Some.”
Rachel nodded slowly and went back to her soup, and Evelyn could see her filing it away in whatever orderly drawer she kept such things in.
James had been working himself up to it all through the meal, and now he couldn’t hold it in any longer.
“Did you shoot the bear?”
Gideon looked at him. “What bear?”
“The one on your cot. In the stable. It still has its claws.”
“Ah.” Gideon ate a spoonful of soup before he answered. “No. I didn’t shoot that one. I traded for the hide with a Crow man down on the Wind River, the second winter I was up here. He’d shot it.”
James’s face fell a little. “Oh.”
“I gave him two good knives and a trap for it. He thought he got the better end.”
“Did he?”
“Probably. It’s a good hide. Warm.”
James considered this and decided that a bearskin got by clever trading was nearly as good as one got by shooting, and brightened again.
Samuel had been quiet all through supper, but now he set his spoon down and looked at Gideon down the length of the table. “What should we do tomorrow? To help, I mean. Mama said we’d all work.”
“There’s always wood to split and stack. Water to haul. Snow to clear off the path to the stable and the privy.” Gideon paused. “I’ll show you in the morning. Not tonight. Tonight you eat and sleep.”
“Yes, sir.”
Then Tobias spoke for the first time since they’d come through the door.
“What happened to your face?”
The table went still. Ruth’s spoon stopped halfway to her mouth. Evelyn felt the heat climb up her neck.
“Tobias. That is no way to—”
“He can ask.” Gideon didn’t look away from the boy. His voice hadn’t changed at all. “A man with a skinning knife, in a saloon in Deadwood. I was twenty-two and drunk, and I said something I shouldn’t have to somebody bigger than me.”
Tobias stared at him. Whatever he’d expected, it hadn’t been that. “Did you win?”
“No. I lost. That’s why the scar’s on me and not on him.” Gideon reached for the bread. “I quit drinking that year. It’s the only good thing that came of it.”
There was a long pause. Tobias looked down at his bowl, and the color came up in his own face, and he didn’t ask anything else.
Evelyn looked at Gideon. He met her eyes briefly over the boy’s head, and she understood that he wasn’t offended, and that he’d answered as he had because a plain question deserved a plain answer, even from a thirteen-year-old who’d meant it as a challenge.
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.