A Family Chosen
Copyright© 2026 by Megumi Kashuahara
Chapter 11: A Terrible Patient
He was a terrible patient.
Evelyn had expected that. She’d nursed Thomas through a broken leg one spring and learned then that the strongest men make the worst invalids, because they’ve never had any practice at being weak. But Gideon was worse than Thomas had ever been. He didn’t complain. He was constitutionally incapable of complaining about his own condition; she suspected he’d have bled to death in silence rather than mention he was cut. The trouble was that he could not be still. He lay in the bed by the fire and watched the cabin go on around him, and every task he saw left undone, or done in a way he wouldn’t have done it, worked on him like a burr under a saddle.
On the first day he asked her four times whether Marshall had been fed. On the second he asked Samuel to bring him the harness he’d been mending before the hunt, and sat up against the logs working at it one-handed with an awl until she took it away from him.
“The stitching’s half done,” he protested.
“Then it can stay half done another week.”
“It’ll take me ten minutes.”
“It’ll take you ten minutes and pull every one of those stitches in your shoulder.” She hung the harness on a peg well out of his reach. “I didn’t sit up four nights with you so you could undo it all over a strap of leather.”
He looked at the harness on its peg. Then at her.
“You’re a hard woman, Evelyn.”
“I’ve been told.”
That was the second time he’d said her name. She noticed he didn’t stumble over it.
On the third day she caught him at the woodpile.
She’d gone out to the privy with Nora, and when she came back around the corner of the cabin he was there in his shirt sleeves in the cold, with his coat thrown over his shoulders like a cape, and the axe in his right hand. He’d set a round on the block and was squaring up to it.
“Gideon.”
He stopped mid-swing, which was just as well, because she’d have walked straight into the chips.
She came across the yard and put her hand out, palm up, and waited.
They stood there in the snow looking at each other. They both knew perfectly well he could simply keep the axe if he chose. He was bigger than she was by a foot and a hundred pounds, wounded or not. And they both knew equally well that he wasn’t going to.
“The arm’s better,” he said.
“The arm is not healed.”
“I can manage with the right.”
“I see.” She didn’t lower her hand. She turned her head instead. “Tobias!”
Tobias appeared in the cabin doorway with his book in his hand.
“Come and take the axe from Mr. Wolf, please.”
Tobias came down the porch steps without hurrying. He crossed the yard and stopped beside them, and looked at his mother’s outstretched hand, and at Gideon, and at the axe, with the careful, neutral face of somebody walking into a conversation he has firmly decided to stay out of. Then he held out his own hand.
Gideon looked at him for a long moment.
Something passed between the two of them that Evelyn wasn’t part of—man to man, or the nearest a thirteen-year-old and a grown man using his own injury as a bargaining chip could come to it.
“I’ll get the wood,” Tobias said. He didn’t say it like a boy obeying. He said it like a man who can do the job telling another man, who can’t do it just now, that it’s taken care of. “You sit down.”
Gideon handed him the axe.
“Fine,” he said. He looked at Evelyn. Then he turned and went back inside.
Evelyn and her son looked at each other across the chopping block. Neither of them said a word. Neither of them needed to. Then Tobias set a round on the block, and swung, and split it clean in one stroke, and stacked both halves bark side down.
She learned, in those days, what he looked like when he wasn’t pretending to be well.
He was quieter than usual, and for Gideon that meant very quiet. He slept a good deal, in long heavy stretches in the afternoons. He ate what she put in front of him without protest, which was its own kind of sign. In the evenings he sat propped up in the bed by the fire and watched the children, and he watched them differently than he had in the early weeks. In November, he’d watched them as a man watches weather—at a distance, taking note. Now there was less distance in it.
James made good on his promise within about three minutes of Gideon being reliably awake.
He came and stood at the side of the bed on the first evening, with his hands behind his back and his chin up, as though he were about to recite a piece at the schoolhouse.
“I want you to know,” he announced, “that you’re my hero.”
Gideon looked at him.
He looked at James for a long time, with an expression of plain, acute discomfort that Evelyn, at the hearth, had to turn her back on so she wouldn’t laugh. Then the discomfort shifted into a more careful look, as if he were turning the words over and finding them heavier than he’d expected. And then it settled into a kind of gruff, wary acceptance.
“I just went and got the meat,” he said.
“You fought a lion.”
“A mountain lion.”
“That’s still a lion.”
“James, it isn’t really—” Gideon stopped. He looked at the boy’s face, which was shining with total, uncomplicated conviction. “Yes,” he said. “All right. It’s still a lion.”
James beamed at him. It was a wholehearted, generous beam that asked for nothing back and expected nothing. Gideon looked at it as a man looks at a lamp after a long time in the dark.
Ruth had been listening from the table. Ruth was constitutionally incapable of letting a thing alone.
“Why didn’t you just let it have the elk?”
“Ruth,” Evelyn said.
“It’s a fair question,” Rachel said, from beside her sister, with the expression of a person taking careful notes.
Gideon looked over at them both. He took his time with it. He always took his time with Ruth’s questions, Evelyn had noticed, as if they deserved more care than other people’s.
“I thought about it,” he said. “For about half a second. The cat had me down, and it was on the hindquarters, and I thought, let it have it. Get your rifle, get clear, and go home.” He paused. “And then I thought about nine people and twelve pounds of salt pork.”
“So you fought it.”
“So I fought it. You needed that meat more than the cat did.”
Ruth considered this for a while, with her chin on her fist.
“That’s a good reason,” she decided.
“It was the only reason.”
Rachel had been drawing on the palm of her left hand with one finger, as she did whenever she was setting a thing down in her memory to keep. She looked up now.
“Did it hurt worse than when Mama sewed you up?”
There was a pause.
“No,” Gideon said. “Your mother’s worse.”
Ruth shrieked. James fell over sideways on the hearthstones laughing. Rachel looked at her mother with frank and enormous interest. And Evelyn, at the fire, found that she was laughing too—out loud, helplessly, for the first time since September—and that Gideon was watching her do it from the bed, with that look around his eyes that was not quite a smile.
Thomas would have loved these girls, she thought, when she could think again.
The thought came to her more often now than it once had. It didn’t come with the stab of the early days. It came with very nearly the opposite: a warmth, tangled and bittersweet, that grew out of knowing him well enough to be certain of it.
On the fourth day James asked him how to fight a mountain lion.
He asked it at breakfast, with his mouth full, in the tone of a boy who has been thinking about a thing all night and can’t hold it in a minute longer.
“You don’t,” Gideon said.
“But you did.”
“I did because I had to. There was no other way out.” Gideon set down his spoon. “If you ever see one, you don’t fight it. And you don’t run. That’s the most important thing. You never run. A cat chases anything that runs, same as a barn cat chases a mouse.”
James’s eyes went round. “Then what do you do?”
“You make yourself big.” Gideon lifted his good arm over his head, slowly, and spread his hand wide. “Arms up. Coat open, if you’ve got one on, and hold it out wide like wings. You stand tall, and you look it straight in the eye, and you shout at it. Loud as you can. Deep, like a man. Not a squeal.”
“Shout what?”
“Doesn’t matter what. Shout your own name if you like. And you back away slow. Never turn your back on it. Back up a step at a time till you’re clear.”
James slid off the bench and stood up in the middle of the floor and put both arms up over his head and spread his fingers wide.
“JAMES HART!” he roared.
Clara burst into tears. Nora dropped her spoon. Out in the stable, Marshall let out an indignant whinny. Ruth and Rachel collapsed against each other on the bench, helpless with laughter.
Gideon didn’t laugh. He looked at the boy standing there in the middle of the floor with his arms in the air, red-faced and fierce.
“That’s right,” he said. “Exactly like that. Now back up.”
James backed up, one careful step at a time, glaring at an imaginary cat, until he bumped into the hearth and sat down hard on the stones. And Evelyn, comforting Clara, thought that if her son ever did meet a lion up here, that poor animal was going to get the fright of its life.
On the fifth day she told him he could sleep on the pallet by the door, and let her have her bed back.
“I can go to the stable,” he said.
“You can go to the pallet.”
“The stable’s warmer than you think. With the bearskin—”
“The stable has no stove, and you’ve had a fever that nearly killed you, and I won’t have you out there alone in the cold for anyone to find frozen in the morning.” She folded her arms. “The pallet, Gideon. Or I’ll put you back in the bed myself, and you can explain to the children why their mother had to carry you.”
He looked at her a moment longer. Then he took the pallet.
On the sixth day he asked again whether he could go back to the stable, and she said no. He didn’t argue. She noticed that.
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.