Not My Brother's Keeper
Copyright© 2026 by Daemon D. Hart
Chapter 2
Erotica Sex Story: Chapter 2 - At nineteen, I never expected to get a new brother, but that’s exactly what happens when my father remarries. His new wife brings a son along, and chaos enters my life. I’m a choir boy; he’s a troublemaker. We dislike each other from the start, and things only get worse when we’re forced to share a college dorm room. I’m convinced he’s my doom. My sensual, sexual, the darkest of dark doom. So, no one - my father, his mother, or him - should expect me to be his salvation.
Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Ma Reluctant Gay Fiction Anal Sex Analingus First Oral Sex
Adrian and Madeline settled into our lives like they had always been a fixture. I still have no idea how that happened because one day I was minding my own business, having my own life, with its usual ups and downs, and then I got myself a brother.
A stepbrother. The difference is important. It’s actually the one thing I kept telling myself as I fell to my doom. Since we’re not related by blood ... anything goes, right?
Save for the part where sodomy is a mortal sin, and as a good choir boy, I should stay away from anything remotely looking like I’d like that: to be sodomized – what a word – by my stepbrother.
But I’m running ahead, and I bet no one cares about my interior demons and what they do to me on a daily basis.
For a couple of days after moving in, I saw little of Adrian. He was always somewhere; it was like he couldn’t bear the simple thought of being inside. True enough, it was a glorious summer at the time. Only bookish nerds like me would choose to stay inside rather than do the things young people do when it’s hot outside and everything seems possible.
If things had stayed the same – me inside, him outside – it would’ve been freaking swell. But my dad had a different opinion about how his new family was supposed to function. That included me taking care of that good-for-nothing bad boy. You see, from the start, I got it into my head that it’d be damn good to label him because he pissed me off so much.
Or maybe other things were pissing me off. Such as how I recalled, so clearly, the way his skin smelled or the feel of his rough hand on my skin when he’d wrestled me on the bed in his room, treating everything – me included – as a joke.
“Jordan, go find your brother. His mom needs him here for dinner,” my dad said through my bedroom door, shouting loud enough to make me consider getting a new pair of headphones. Not that I afforded it; my dad didn’t care about things that weren’t a ‘need’. And I didn’t ‘need’ new headphones.
“I’m sure he’ll show up,” I shouted back.
But my dad was already gone, which meant that I had to suck it and find my stupid brother. Damn, it was one thing that Dad considered him my brother, but did he think that asshole was his son? After two days he and his mom spent under our roof?
There was no one I could yell at, not that my dad tolerated any yelling. I knew he had a heavy hand as a fact. So, groaning for show though there was no one to witness my reluctance, I began dressing to go outside.
Where could that idiot be? Seeing how he looked, he was probably hanging out by the old quarry where all the cool kids went to sneak beers and cigarettes. That was my first choice.
And I was right, of course. Adrian was there, one arm hung over the shoulders of a chick who had come back from college after only two unproductive years and now shared her time between hanging out here and working a dead-end job at the local mart.
She wore too much makeup and was a couple of years older than him. Not that I gave a damn about any of that. What I had to do was drag my brother away from her and take him back to his loving family.
“Hey,” I called out, making most guys and gals there look at me.
Not Adrian. He was busy whispering in that chick’s ear, and she was busy laughing at whatever stupid jokes he told her.
I wasn’t one of them. They knew me as the weirdo who went to church too much with other weirdos. So their looks would soon turn hostile; I knew it.
“Hey,” I said louder.
The fucker ignored me, but his new girlfriend didn’t. She locked eyes with me and chewed on her bubble gum more aggressively. I didn’t want to get any closer because I’d have some of that hostility present starting to surround me.
“Hey,” I yelled for real this time.
Adrian snapped his head in my direction. “The fuck you want, choir boy?”
His audience – of course, they were his audience because it was his type of crowd – started laughing and hooting. I dug my nails into my palms so hard I could scream in pain.
“Home, now. Dinner’s ready,” I said and turned on my heel.
Dad told me to find him, and I had. If he chose to be a moron and stay behind, he might just learn that his new dad was hard on people who made the mistake of disobeying him.
“Stay, Adrian,” the chick begged, which surprised me. “Come on, don’t go yet.”
I didn’t turn to see if he was following me. Maybe he’d caught whiff of my father being a hardass and didn’t want to push his luck.
Good for him. I’d done my part.
His hurrying steps followed me until we were close to home. I didn’t say a word, and he understood it was better to keep silent.
How wrong was I? I was about to find out.
An old oak grows at the edge of what counts as our lawn. It’s protected or something else. It still stands today. And it was against its rough bark that Adrian pushed me, his breath hovering close to my face.
“My name isn’t ‘hey’,” he said. “Learn to address me properly, or I’ll fucking make you.”
So, he was a bully. Big whoop. I struggled to push him away, but he seemed made of steel and granite. My back rubbed against the tree, and it hurt. My t-shirt might tear if he kept on pushing me against it.
“Okay, Adrian,” I said, knowing when to lose a battle so I still had chances to win the war.
He relaxed his hold on me. I let out a breath I had no idea I was holding in.
“Good. Looks like you have half a brain,” he said, brushing his knuckles against my jaw to show me who’s boss. “But you tricked me out of a good lay, so I’ll come to collect later.”
“A good lay? Who? That girl?” I snorted and showed a bit of teeth. I preferred to glide over his not-so-veiled threat.
“Yeah. She promised to suck me off later. But now is later, and I’m here.”
“Good for you. She’s a skank, though.”
“Damn, do you kiss Jesus with that mouth?” He still hovered close so that I couldn’t move.
“We don’t kiss Jesus. You have no idea what you’re talking about.”
He chuckled, a sound that sent a shiver down my spine.
“Okay, whatever, choir boy. You’ll kiss my dick later, though.”
He finally moved away.
“I have a name,” I called after him.
He turned, opening his arms wide, and shrugged. “I don’t care. I might give you one, though.”
Like hell. Still digging my short nails into my palms, I started walking, brushing by him to let him know bullies didn’t impress me.
“So, come fall, you boys will be in college,” Madeline said, finally pulling her undivided attention away from my dad, who, no point in lying, enjoyed being the center of his new woman’s universe.
Don’t get me wrong; I had nothing against her. She was nice. She still is. And from the start, she liked my dad. It wasn’t like she could be in it for the money. Dad had to be the descendant of a long line of misers who counted their pennies as their favorite way to entertain themselves. Our house was modest, and we only had enough for ourselves.
So, that begged the question: how the hell did he expect to keep a wife and another son? Madeline worked from home, and I learned soon that she was a teacher who tutored kids online. My internet time was closely supervised, meaning I was allowed online only two hours a day, time I had to spend completing my studies, rather than indulging in mindless entertainment like other people my age.
As you can imagine, there was some pent-up aggression in me. I usually got rid of it by running through the forest that stretched close to our town. And I had a couple of weights in my room, so I wasn’t totally useless when it came to physical strength. There was prayer, too, of course. But I had a feeling I wasn’t genuine enough to pray for real, because I wanted to get even, not be given absolution.
Madeline’s words caught up with me with a bit of a delay because I wasn’t paying close attention. Adrian let his hand drop on my shoulder, squeezing it hard.
“I suppose they’ll let us bunk together, right?”
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.