Chapter 2: The Game heats up

Consensus was reached that one of the boys should go next, with most pointing to Chuck.

“I’ll go,” Chuck says. “So. Um, Ben, Truth or Dare?”

“Truth!”

“Mmm, ok.” He looked like he hadn’t expected Ben to pick ‘Truth’, so he had to think for a moment.

“Ok. Are you hard right now?”

Chuck obviously figured that since Cyndi did the guys a favor (by getting the girls to show some skin), he would try to return the favor, getting the girls a peek at one of the boys.

Ben looked at him oddly. “No. I’m not!” And with the way he was sitting, no one could really tell.

“Bull shit!” said Jeremy. “Not that I want to see your junk, but I call bullshit, so prove it!”

Looking around the room, Ben noticed that they were all calling him on his answer, so, standing up, he complied.

Ben undid his shorts and flashed everyone confidently. He wasn’t hard, but there was a telltale thickening, though, by no means would anyone say he had a hard-on. Yet.

“How the hell do you have such self-control?” Jeremy asked.

“Years of having to suppress it during class, never know when you’ll be called to the front of the room!” Ben boasted.

Niki murmured a bit, shocked and a bit upset, her nakedness, as embarrassing as it was, was not enough for Ben to ‘get hard’. She consoled herself by glancing at the other two boys, whose hardness was quite evident, even if not as exposed as she was. Nervously, she shifted a bit on the floor, not finding a way to get comfortable, finally succumbing to the inevitable, and letting her thighs slide open into a slightly cross-legged seat.

Ben looked around the group, considering (and perhaps still a bit irritated that he had to flash his prick to everyone)... “Ok, all you mofos have to either 1) Remove your single item of clothing left and get completely naked ... OR ... masturbate in front of us all for a full minute - at which time you can put one item back on if you want.”

Cheyenne gasped a little, “Ohmygawd!” she said, no doubt thinking about masturbating in front of the other five people in the room. Getting naked seemed a much less scary option, though that was only by comparison. “God, if anyone had told me that I would be naked in a room full of people before midnight, I would have laughed my ass off!” Reaching around her waist, Cheyenne unhooked her skirt and let it fall, revealing for the second time her nicely shaven bare sex. She stood there nervously for a second before sitting down, trying to get comfortable in a side kneeling position.

Chuck, with a smirk, merely stood, dropping his boxers, proudly showing off his rampant, throbbing prick, easily 8 or maybe 9 inches in length. Standing there, watching the girls look at it for a moment, he seemed to enjoy the looks of what he probably assumed was desire evident on each girl’s face --- as if the mere showing of such a prick was enough to get their motors running. Niki mentally shrugged; the extent of the boys’ self-satisfied impression with their own genitalia amused her a little bit.

As Chuck sat down cross-legged, not hiding his hard cock at all, Cyndi was trying hard to decide her choice. The more she saw everyone getting naked, the more she sat and thought about that choice. However, unlike the others, she was still dressed. “Since I don’t have any to put back on and I’m not wearing just one item ... how bout I strip down to my jeans, you all know there’s nothing under them?” she asked Ben, looking around the room for confirmation.

Niki piped up, “Yeah, it’s not fair to make her go all the way; she did not lose the earlier dare...”

Ben considered “Hmm, ok, but as long as it’s just the one item, like you made all of us choose, not two. You can choose, unless you want to be like Niki — I’d let you wear two items if it was two socks!” he grinned, looking over at the stocking clad, but otherwise nude girl.

Accepting the dare, Cyndi stood up to remove her t-shirt, slipping it up and over her full chest, her bra sliding up a bit as she moved her arms over her head, giving a peek at the soft flesh contained within. Tossing her shirt down beside her, she paused, flushed, reaching back to unhook her bra, letting the cups fall forward, exposing her hard pink nipples, her soft full breasts standing high on her chest. With a bit of a relieved sigh, Cyndi added the bra to her shirt on the floor, and sat back down, looking a bit pumped up a bit from doing the dare, and maybe amazed at herself, although, compared to the other naked girls, she was quite covered.

Jeremy said, “I’m not going to run around naked, you fuckers can just watch me if you are such perverts. Niki had peeled off her socks as she sat in the circle, tossing them onto her other clothes. “I was not hiding anything anyhow!!” she said, blushing as she looked from Chuck’s hard cock, to Jeremy, standing there and lowering his briefs down below his hard cock, hooking it under his balls, which had the side effect of lifting and showing off his testicles as he reached for his cock...

As he started to stroke himself, his cock rock hard from all of the stimulating sights, the other two boys made a point of ostensibly looking away ... though it was hard to completely ignore what was going on. “Someone better be timing,” Jeremy said, as he continued to slowly pump his cock, working a bit of a mental exercise so as not to get overly excited, as the whole scene, standing in front of naked or ½ dressed girls and playing with his prick, was straight out of one of a guy’s fantasies.

Niki watched, entranced, never having seen so much of a boy as this, much less one playing with their prick. Her previous encounters, enjoyable as they might have been, were rather hurried and in the dark. It looked rather ... awkward ... and neat at the same time, she thought as she watched his hand stroke the long shaft, up and down, over and over.

Ben was watching his watch, obliquely watching Jeremy do his dare, running his gaze over the total naked skin on display from both Niki and Cheyenne, and he surreptitiously adjusted himself inside his shorts. It seemed as if his discomfort was getting to be a bit intense.

“Time,” Ben called eventually.

Jeremy took another couple of squeezing strokes before stopping, pulling his underwear back up over his cock, leaving a very noticeable bulge.

“Psshhh ... Not sure why you want to hide it anymore!” Cheyenne teased, doubtless having enjoyed the way he had held himself, displaying his charms to the group.

Looking around the room, Ben nodded, apparently satisfied. Chuck, Niki, and Cheyenne were now naked, and giving everyone a show as they sat around the circle, while Jeremy, trying to hide his bulge, and Cyndi, with her full breasts rising proudly on her chest, completed the group. Sitting down, still just wearing his shorts, and still maintaining more self-control than either of the other boys, he turned to Cyndi ‘Truth or Dare? Well, wait, you picked Truth before, so Dare?”