Shayna to the Max
Copyright© 2025 by Naughty Shayna
Chapter 1: Meeting Max
Erotica Sex Story: Chapter 1: Meeting Max - Heather Walker and I became friends when we were juniors in high school. It wasn't until I started spending time at her place after school that I realized her brother was The Max Walker, probably the most famous, and certainly the most desirable guy at Harrison High. When he actually started noticing me and seemed to like me, I thought life couldn't get any better. I was wrong, it was about to get a lot better.
Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Teenagers Coercion Consensual Heterosexual Exhibitionism First Petting
Heather Walker and I had known each other since the eighth grade, but we finally became best friends in our junior year of high school. We had four classes together, leading to one of those quick-blossoming friendships that sometimes make high school less annoying. When I found out that she lived just a few blocks from me, we started hanging out together after school. Since both her parents worked, I usually went to her house to watch TV, have some snacks, and just, in general, get to know each other better.
Heather had an older brother who was a senior. I knew who he was when she told me his name, Max Walker. Even though they had the same last name, I had never made the connection between Heather and her brother. Max was kind of a god at our school. He was the starting quarterback on our state championship football team, and an ace pitcher on the baseball team. The sea of students crowding the halls at school between periods would part for him, as if he were Moses crossing the Red Sea. He always had a half-smile on his face, like he ruled the world, and at Highland High, that was true.
It wasn’t enough that he was a gifted athlete; he was gorgeous, too. There were reports that talent scouts had approached him about a modeling career. Like probably every girl at Highland, I wanted Max to notice me, but we existed on different planes. He dated a lot of girls, and there were rumors that he was, as I heard one girl say, hung like a horse. I was so inexperienced when it came to male genitalia that I didn’t fully understand what that meant, but from how other girls reacted when discussing his manhood, I assumed it was a good thing.
Even though I was hanging out at the Walker home a lot after Heather and I bonded, I only caught a few glimpses of Max. He was a busy young man. On those few instances when I did see him, he almost always had his shirt off. And boy, was that a view. Pecs, biceps, and other muscles I didn’t know the names of, all displayed on Max like a chiseled Greek statue. Even though I tried to keep my cool, I got a bit of a thrill every time I saw him walking through the house naked from the waist up. After a few weeks, he learned my name and even smiled at me occasionally. Even a quick smile and “Hi, Shayna” made my heart skip a beat. I knew that was all I could expect, but it was good enough.
I once asked Heather what it was like to have Max as a brother. I expected a simple three- or four-word answer; instead, I got a speech, in Heather’s typical scatter-brained way. “He’s all right, I guess,” she told me. “Kinda full of himself, but if I need his help, he comes through, at least he used to. Lately, he’s had a lot of college coaches trying to recruit him, so in a way, he’s already checked out as far as our family is concerned. I’m just hoping to get his room when he goes away. It’ll probably smell like a gym, but I can handle it. Sometimes he brings girls here, and they spend the night. My parents pretend they don’t know, probably because they worship him like everybody at school.”
After spending some time around the Walker house, I noticed that Max helped out occasionally, usually by doing yard work. Heather told me that he considered working up a good sweat while mowing the lawn or trimming the hedge as part of his fitness routine. A wet Max was an even better Max. He looked like a model out of one of those men’s perfume ads.
After one of his yardwork days, I saw what was, up to that point, the most exciting thing I had ever seen. I had spent Friday night with Heather. After breakfast on Saturday, we put on our swimsuits, grabbed some towels, and went to lie down in her backyard, next to the nonexistent pool behind the Walker house. There was no pool, but we could pretend while we tried to work on our tans. We hadn’t been out there long when Max came around the corner, pushing the lawn mower. He hadn’t started it, so we could hear him when he said, “Sorry, ladies, got to get this done before it gets too hot.”
He looked at me with a long, meaningful look and smiled. It was the best day of my life, but the moment didn’t last long. Heather and I went back inside and retreated to her room, where we sat on her bed and talked. Heather was a world-class talker, and I’m a good listener, so those gabfests could go on for a while.
We heard Max come in and go to the bathroom down the hall. I heard water running and knew he was taking a shower. The image of a naked Max was projected across my mind, and I almost wished Heather would leave me alone so I could entertain myself with that fantasy.
Half an hour later, Heather went to the kitchen to fix us a snack. I stayed in her room, trying to catch up on the required reading for American Lit that I was way behind on. When she came back, she was carrying a tray with sandwiches and chips, and giggling. “What’s so funny?” I asked.
“Come with me,” she said, and we headed down the hall toward the rec room where Max liked to take naps after he finished his chores. As we neared it, she put her finger to her lips and whispered, “Quiet.”
When we entered the den, I saw Max passed out on an old sofa. I knew he was asleep because he was snoring. Even his snoring was enticing. He was shirtless and wearing what looked like an old pair of soccer shorts, the kind with big leg holes. It took me a second or two to see why Heather had brought me there, then - there it was. Max had a massive erection. The bulge in his shorts was impressive enough, but the most unforgettable sight was the end of his dick sticking out of one of the leg holes. I had only seen two erect penises before, and Max’s looked like it was twice as big as either of them. I almost said something out loud when Heather grabbed my arm and dragged me away.
When we returned to her room, I couldn’t hold myself back any longer. “Damn, he’s deformed,” I said.
“I know, right?”
“I guess those stories I’ve heard around school are true. Have you seen it before?”
“Yeah,” Heather said,” a few times. Sometimes, when he’s in a hurry, he’ll run from his room to the bathroom naked, and I’ve run into him a couple of times. Once, when I went to his room to get him for dinner, he was lying on his bed, naked, and playing with himself.”
“Did he say anything?”
“No, he just smiled at me like he had done it on purpose.”
“What did you do?”
“I ran out of there like a scared rabbit. I might be the only girl at school who doesn’t dream about having sex with Max, but since he’s my brother...”
“Yeah, I get it.”
“How about you?” Heather asked. “Is he in your dreams?”
Of course, he was, but I hesitated to tell Heather that. “I’d be lying if I said he wasn’t,” I admitted, “but my fantasies might be nightmares after what I just saw.”
“Is he that much bigger than Jerry?” she asked.
Jerry was my former boyfriend, the one who had deflowered me a few months earlier. “Yeah, Jerry is kinda pony-sized, and Max is...”
“I know, hung like a horse. I’ve heard that a lot. And I guess a pony is good for a new rider,” she giggled. “Is Jerry’s the only other dick you’ve ever seen?”
“I saw my cousin once when he was sleeping, but he was only thirteen, so I guess that really doesn’t count. I’ve seen a few in the dirty magazines Polly has been showing around school.”
“I haven’t seen them. Polly and I aren’t friends. I think she’s kind of a slut. Did I tell you she’s one of the girls who spent the night with Max? When she left the next morning, she just said hi to my parents like it was a normal thing, so ... yeah ... slut.”
It almost sounded like Heather was jealous, making me wonder how much she hid her real feelings toward Max. Living with a possible future All-American athlete with a body like a Greek god can be challenging. Still, what she said next shocked me. “Sometimes I think about Max taking my virginity, kind of like a going-away present before he leaves for college.”
“Don’t you think starting with a pony would be better?” I said. I meant it as a joke, but Heather took me seriously.
“Well, the good thing about Max doing it is that, because he’s my brother, he wouldn’t go bragging about it around school, like Jerry did when he got your cherry.”
And that’s why Jerry was my former boyfriend. He told all his friends what had happened in the back of his mom’s minivan, as if I were a conquest to be bragged about. Like a lot of girls my age, I was stupid. It took me a while to realize that’s all I was to him. He screwed me for a second time a week or so later, after, as he put it, I’d had time to heal, then he ghosted me. The next thing I knew, he was dating Debbie Marshall.
“It sounds like you’re seriously thinking about it,” I told her. “Have you talked to Max?”
“God, no. I think he would freak out.”
“I don’t know. From what you told me about how he acts around you, I’m pretty sure he’s sending you a message.”
“Would you ask him for me?” Heather asked.
“Girl, he barely knows who I am.”
“That’s not right. He asks me about you a lot, and I saw how he looked at you earlier. He wants to know if you’re still dating Jerry.”
“Oh great,” I sighed, “even the seniors know about me. I might as well switch schools.”
“Don’t be stupid, you’re not the first girl that’s happened to, and in a way, it kinda makes you cooler.”
Yeah, high school can be weird.
A few weeks after that conversation, I went to the Walkers’ home one Saturday morning. Heather and I had planned to work on a History project together that afternoon. When I knocked on the door, I was surprised when Max answered. “Uh, hi, Max. I’m here to see...”
He smiled and said, “Yeah, I know, Shay. Heather isn’t here right now. She and my parents went to look at used cars. They’re getting Heather one for her birthday. They might be gone for a while. Come on in, you can wait for her.”
I followed him into the house. I was kind of pissed that Heather hadn’t let me know she was going out, but I soon forgot all about that. I was alone with Max Walker, and even though I knew nothing was going to happen between us, it was still a thrill. I started to head toward Heather’s room when Max stopped me and said, “You can hang with me if you want. I’ve been wanting to get to know you better anyway.”
“Okay,” I said, letting him lead me to his room. It wasn’t the mess I had expected, not nearly as bad as Heather had described it. Mostly, it was neat and organized, especially for a teenage boy. Strike that, Max may have still been in high school, but he was definitely a man. There were two shelves attached to one wall, full of athletic trophies. The other walls displayed a collection of posters, some featuring famous athletes and others Playboy centerfolds. It didn’t smell like a locker room either. I thought I could detect a slight odor of cologne, which seemed odd for a Saturday afternoon.
He sat down in a beanbag chair. The only other place to sit was a straight-back chair facing his desk. He gestured to his bed, and feeling excited and a bit naughty, I sat down there. The idea that little ole me, shy and quiet Shay, was sitting on Max Walker’s bed made my head spin.
“How’s school?” he asked.
Geez, I was having small talk with the most popular guy in our school. Come on, Shayna, come up with something interesting, but all I could say was, “Can’t wait for this year to be over. I’m looking forward to being a senior. Senior year rocks, right?”
He grinned at me, which made me shiver a little. “Yeah, you sound like Heather. You guys are pretty tight. Seems like you spend more time here than I do.”
“Do you mind that?”
“Nah, I like having you around. You’re very pretty, Shay. Maybe a little too shy, though. You should loosen up.”
As he said that, he got up from the bean bag. Most people look awkward doing that, but Max made it look easy, like a puma emerging from the bush to go after prey, and I felt like the prey. That was even truer when he sat down on the bed next to me. “You still seeing that creep Jerry Summers?” he asked, his voice quiet and soothing. I wondered if that was his seduction voice.
“No, that’s over.”
“That’s good,” Max purred, moving even closer to me. I should have seen it coming, but it was still a surprise when he kissed me. If I were a lonely cat lady romance writer, I would go on to describe that kiss in flowery, elegant language, but all I can remember about that moment was how just the light touch of Max’s lips on mine both scared and thrilled me.