Mail Order Annie
Copyright© 2025 by DFL Runner
Chapter 3
Annie was concluding her day’s lesson with Esther, whose hand brushed with pride over the primer on the table. It was the same primer Martina and the other eight-year-olds in her former classroom were learning to read from. Using her familiarity with the schoolhouse to her advantage, she entered the building one Sunday morning while most of the town was at church. She found the primer, noted the publisher’s information, and reached out to them to order a copy. She had thought about taking it outright as her pound of flesh, but her successor was a rather severe woman with an affinity for the paddle; she didn’t want one of the students to pay the price if it were discovered missing.
Esther ... who the clientele knew as “Helen” ... had just read two entire pages aloud with nearly no mistakes and no hesitation. It almost made Annie feel like a teacher again. She wrapped her arm around the young woman and lightly embraced her. “I’m so proud of you!”
“As am I!” came Lydia’s approving voice from the entryway into the dining room. She approached the table, beaming as she touched Helen’s arm. She then turned to Annie. “I’ve just come from the depot, Annie. The postmaster had this for you.” She handed Annie an envelope, and when Annie saw the name of the sender, she was briefly taken aback.
“Hmm,” Annie vocalized briefly. “Well, let’s see if this one is any more...” She looked at Lydia. “Normal, perhaps?”
Lydia chuckled. “Well, thank heaven for small mercies that the first one had so little shame.” Annie had responded to another notice found in the discarded magazine pages in which she had found Mr. Crane’s notice.
She had felt she should be forthcoming about her current circumstances, but the man had responded with suggestions that she had never even imagined were physically possible. He further intimated that any woman currently sustaining herself as Annie was should willfully, even happily submit to such depravity. Annie not only burned the letter, she vigorously scrubbed her hands afterward to ensure all traces of it were eliminated.
Still chuckling softly, Annie opened the letter and began reading.
Lydia was standing in the kitchen minutes later when Annie, silently, with a dazed expression on her face, walked past her to sit on the back stoop.
Concerned, Lydia walked back into the dining room, where the letter sat face-down on the table. Lydia picked it up and read it, then made her way out the back door to sit beside Annie.
Quietly, Annie asked, “Did you read it?”
Lydia nodded. “Yes.”
Annie’s voice trembled. “I am so afraid right now. I am afraid that his words are deceptive. Strangely, I am even more afraid that they are not.”
Lydia covered Annie’s hand with her own, and Lydia briefly noted how cold it was, a coldness that could not, and did not, result solely from the late-winter chill coming off the foothills of the Pocono Mountains. “That’s ... natural. These past several months, you have been surrounded by men who are not who they say they are. Men who claim to be servants of the Lord and yet are worse than the serpent in the Garden. Men who promised to be faithful to their wives and yet come here multiple nights a week. Even the first gentleman who reached out, saying he was looking for a companion, when what he really wanted was to subject some poor woman to acts that were beyond even what I could imagine, and I have been a courtesan since I was barely a woman.”
Lydia paused. “I have my opinion on the matter, but my opinion is not what is important right now. I am not the one who must make this decision, and I am not the one who would have to accept whatever that decision might bring.”
She stood, placing a hand on Annie’s shoulder. “With your permission, I’ll tell the men you are not available tonight. I think you should rest. Sleep tonight, and re-read it in the morning. See what your heart tells you then.”
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.