Impossible Love; the Pensioner, the Starlet, and the DJ - Cover

Impossible Love; the Pensioner, the Starlet, and the DJ

Copyright© 2025 by storyace

Chapter 2

Erotica Sex Story: Chapter 2 - Sheena is a very beautiful out of work 17 year old actress, living with Bradley, an older man. She meets 64 year old Joe while walking their dogs, and they become friends. Sheena loves to talk, Joe loves to listen, Bradley loves cream pie. Sheena could have any man she chooses; will she choose Joe?

Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/ft   Mult   Consensual   BiSexual   Heterosexual   Sharing   Polygamy/Polyamory   Interracial   Black Male   White Male   White Female   Cream Pie   Pregnancy  

I phoned Sheena the next day, the call dropped and I got a text a short time later; “I’m going to see my aunt in Pennsylvania, can you please walk Henry sometimes? X, Sheena”

That meant I had to face Brad; and I was the offending party. Anyway, I did it, because Henry is a good dog and Greg liked him too.

The worst of it was how Brad talked to me; completely normal. As if I hadn’t fucked his beautiful girl. As if I wouldn’t kill him to have her back, and he wouldn’t kill me to keep her. Yeah, we were civil, modern, liberal men.

Sheena called me a couple of weeks later as I was walking the dogs, and my heart made that ridiculous funny little jump.

“I just needed some space you know, from both of you guys.” She said, and I knew her babble was going to last a while, and I was glad. Her voice was like a drug that soothed and calmed me. “I told Bradley how I was attracted to you, and he even encouraged me, and wow, it was just so good you know, better than, well, just the best ever. And I was feeling weird afterwards, because if I love Bradley how could I love you that way? And while you were out with the dogs he came home and I told him, and he went a little crazy, and, oh shit. Well, you know once I start talking I can’t stop, right? Ok, so Bradley threw me on the bed and he went down on me! And right when I couldn’t take it anymore, you rung the bell and I heard you and him talk for a minute as you dropped off Henry, and then Bradley came back into the bedroom and took his cock out and he put it in me and, well, he didn’t last long but it was intense for sure. Afterwards though, he was weird and I felt weird too, I mean, oh my god, two men in two hours three times! Well four really since you did it double, anyway after that I just needed some space you know, so I came out to Philadelphia to visit my aunt Penni for a while...”

She went on to tell me about her aunt, her aunt’s ex, his new wife, their baby (who Sheena was helping with), their dog, and a lot of other things of no importance.

“Shit Joe, I’m sorry.” She said after almost an hour, “I’ve been talking your ear off again.”

“Don’t be sorry.” I told her, “You know I love to listen to you. You can call me every day and tell me everything on your mind.”

“Oh Joe.” She sighed, “No one ever said anything so sweet to me. Is it really true, you don’t mind my endless talking?”

“Sheena darling, your voice is my drug.” I told her. “Whatever else we do or don’t do, I hope you’ll keep talking to me.”

“I will!” she laughed, “Everyone else either tells me to shut up or just avoids me.”

Luckily, I had an unlimited data plan, because we were on the phone for an hour or two every day. We didn’t have any sex talk; Sheena’s aunt had warned her that we should be really careful about any of that until she was 18. Even plain talking could be interpreted as ‘grooming’. I guess it was; I had fucked the girl, and I hoped to fuck her again. Maybe it was wrong, maybe I don’t care. I was happy with whatever I got from her; I longed to see her face, her smile, look into her eyes, hold her hand.

Of course I wanted to fuck her; If her voice was all I could have, then that was good enough.

“Joe, I had a call from my agent, it looks like the series has been greenlit! It’s a sort of sequel, so I’m tipped to be recast as Julieann, as a 16 year old, but this time it would be a high school dramady, and centered on me! If it happens. Probably won’t, I know it’s a long shot. anyway, the producers want to meet, I need a new portfolio, can you meet me at the airport? Will you bring Henry? Oh God, I miss him SO much!”

“Of course.” I said, “I’ll get your car keys from Brad.”

I waited nervously at the pickup spot in front of the terminal building until I saw her. Man, I felt like a teenager myself. We only hugged briefly; she might be recognized. She got into the back seat and cuddled ecstatically with her dog, laughing and muttering endearments as I drove us back towards our neighborhood.

“I’m starving.” She said, “Let’s go over to Bradley’s restaurant.”

The food was great, and Sheena went home with him. I knew he’d put his dick in her. What could I say? If Sheena wanted to go with him, that was her choice to make.

I suppose I could have made an ultimatum, him or me. The fact was, neither of us were good enough for her. Not rich enough, not young enough, not good enough lovers. I had already accepted the reality. I was not her lover, he was.

I had to drive her car back, I held onto the key though. The next day I took her to get her hair done, then to the photographer who took a lot of pictures, many of them quite explicit. Not nude of course, just crazy sexy promotion pictures. Poses, flirting with the camera, you know. Well, flirting with me, because I was standing behind the photographer and she was eating my heart out as he took the pics. That face, I could live and die to just look at her, and when she smiled at me like that, my old cock would stir.

We were back; friends again. We walked, she prattled, I listened and laughed at her jokes, I looked into her eyes, we smiled at each other, and it gave me an erection. I picked her up at Brad’s place and took her to her meetings, went walking with our dogs, and dropped her off at the end of each day. I was rewarded with a kiss; and I didn’t want more. Well, let’s be honest; of course I wanted more. I was willing to accept that kiss, that sweet intense little cuddle, and then I’d go home to my empty apartment with my dog Greg, content. Mostly.

I was an old man with nothing better to do. I loved her without sex, yet it was not a platonic love. I lusted for her, adored her even though I wasn’t and would never be her lover. Or, so I thought.

Sheena met the producers and a couple of network executives. I just stood around like a goon. No one seemed to even notice me, I was like a ghost, a shadow. The bodyguard. Nobody. I liked it.

She did a screen test, said her lines, reacted to a director. She seemed great to me. They were just waiting for her to turn 18 before they did the love scene testing. Underage actors couldn’t perform nude or sexual scenes, not even for tests now days. Even kissing is tricky. The series was heavy on sex, so her ability to make those scenes work was essential.

We were back to our usual routine, driving somewhere remote to avoid her stalker or anyone else who might recognize her, and walking the dogs as Sheena babbled incessantly and I listened blissfully. Even if we didn’t have sex, I was happy to be her goon companion goffer bodyguard driver. To have the privilege of looking at her face all day long.

That was the reward for listening. A man is not allowed to stare at the face of a beautiful girl for more than a few seconds; unless she’s talking to him. Man, that face; I could look at her face for 100 years and never get tired of it. I know I’m a bit repetitive about that, it’s important though. Yes, Sheena has a playboy girl body, and people tend to focus on that. Her face is her true beauty though, it’s her face that makes her a star, it’s her smile that everyone imagines is focused on them.

On her 18th birthday, I went with her to the final screen test. I watched her do a nude scene with a young actor named Tim, and then another guy, and then a girl. kissing and cuddling for almost two hours in front of a camera. I swear, every man there had a hardon, and probably the women too.

“Was it ok?” I asked as we walked back to her car.

“That Timothy had a hardon the whole time.” She said.

“What about the other boy, Ben?”

“Gay I guess.” She said with a shrug. “I’m a bit wound up, can we go to your place?”

“We sure can.” I agreed, just before Brad called to tell us he’d prepared a special birthday dinner.

“Can it wait a couple of hours?” Sheena asked him, “I really want to spend a little time with Joe. You know? Just, like, me and Joe.”

She made a funny face at me; “Bradley took the night off to make a s0pecial dinner for us.” She told me, the phone still at her ear.

I drove her home; I wanted to be with her so much, be alone, naked, in bed, touching, kissing her sweet perfection and looking into her jewel eyes. She seemed to want me too, sexually I mean. It wasn’t illegal anymore, yet it was still wrong.

It was ok that I was in love with her, and now I had the idea that she was falling in love with me too. I saw it in her eyes when we kissed, when my hands were on her face. It was more than fun and lust, more than a game she was playing with Brad. He was 20 years older than her, and that would become a problem if they were lucky enough to stay together; I was 46 years older than Sheena. She was vulnerable and young, too inexperienced to know that love is a trap.

I was healthy. I still had 90% of my young strength, but the clock was ticking. If I was lucky, I’d have 10 years where I was still able to walk and fuck. On the other hand, I might fall ill tomorrow.

If that happened, or rather WHEN that happened, and we were bound together by emotion and shared body fluids, she’d be unfairly burdened.

“Hey, aren’t you coming up?” she asked after I parked and started to walk towards my place.

“I thought he made a dinner for two.” I said.

“No, he clearly told me he cooked for us all.” She said. “Come on!”

Come on, come in, come everywhere...

Anyway, Brad’s food was amazing as usual. Small perfect lean steaks, asparagus, and baked potato, spiced and sauced with some creation of his. He loved Sheena too. I really felt it was time to pull out of this, before the damage was too great.

“That was SO good Bradly.” Sheena cooed as I took the plates to the sink, and she sat sideways on his lap and held his handsome blond head as she kissed him.

It tore at my heart to see the reality I knew so well. It was finally legal for me (and Brad) to have sex with Sheena, yet it was still wrong. I was about to slip around to the door and escape, when Sheena stood up and put her skinny arms around my neck, tilted her mind bending face up, and kissed me too. That mouth, that wonderful mouth...

No one spoke; her desire was clear. It was her birthday, we were her lovers, we had to do it.

I’d had threesomes; this was different, because it was emotional. I loved her, he loved her, she possibly loved us both.

I stood still in his kitchen as she undressed me. Her tiny pale fingers stripped off my shirt and she squatted down to unlace my shoes and open my belt. She turned to grin at Brad as she pulled my underwear down, and she took my stiff black cock in her hand and rubbed it around her face and through her hair, breaking into a little laugh.

She stood and faced him as I lowered the zipper of her tight colorful dress and eased it down her torso. I opened her bra and removed it, and Brad just sat there watching us, smiling slightly.

It was wonderfully erotic.

I reached around and fondled her young white breasts with my old black hands as he stared in fascination, horror, and lust. She was still wearing her panties and heels, so her ear was at the level of my mouth, and I took the lobe between my lips and felt her small body shudder.

The reality was that we’d been a thruple for a while. Even though I’d only had sex with her one time, Sheena had been jumping between our hearts and our minds, for months.

Brad reached forward and pulled her undies down her smooth legs, and she stepped out of them with her shoes still on as he stood and kissed her mouth.

We stood there like that for a minute or two; me behind her and Brad in front of her, just touching gently, and I didn’t notice that she’d opened his pants until she stooped slightly to push them down over his ass.

She broke out from between us, and with a small laugh and hard old cock in each small hand, the 18 year old starlet pulled us into the bedroom she shared with Brad.

That was when I saw his cock was huge; 10 inches or more. The fucker was porn-star size. Sheena sat on the bed between us, as we fondled her, kissed her, and bathed in her glorious young beauty, her crazy sexuality, her inexplicable desire for older men.

Well, Brad was damn good looking and had that big cock. Her desire for me was still inexplicable though.

And another thing; like Sheena, Brad had no pubic hair. I thought only women did that.

She pushed me onto my back and lay on me face to face, my cock throbbing between our bellies as we kissed softly, sensuously. Brad took position behind, put his hands on Sheena’s perfect tight ass, and set his big white cock to enter her.

I didn’t like that, it was too soon, it was crude to start fucking already. It wasn’t for me to say though, I was the guest here, I was the intruder.

She lifted her head, her hands still on my face, and her pretty eyes widened as he carefully, slowly, penetrated her. Her mouth fell open, and she grunted slightly.

She lifted herself up on her hands and knees, so only her big breasts still touched me as he slowly fucked her doggy position above me, while she looked into my eyes with an odd blankness. Not like the joy she displayed when I’d been inside her.

“Enough.” She told him, reaching one hand back to push him out. “I want Joe now.”

And the hand reached down for my cock, and she slid her hairless tight wet pink pussy down my hard cock for the first time in almost 2 months. The sensation at the groin was intense, yet it was her face I was really concentrated on. Because she looked different now; pleasure, joy when mine was the cock inside her. She rotated and bucked forward and back, her flat belly rippling and her big breasts bouncing, pink nipples tearing into me, her blond hair whipping me mercilessly as her jewel eyes cut deep.

She started to come, and I knew I wouldn’t be able to hold out against that unstoppable assault of sensuality. I held her hands and stared into her face, blinded by my helpless love, and my inability to prevent my own orgasm.

Her youth, raw beauty, and tight pussy would have already been too much for me; Her orgasm though, the orgasm of a 17 year old angelic beauty staring into my head caused that unstoppable autonomic reaction that everyone craves so much. I knew I couldn’t stop it, and I didn’t try. I just stared into her eyes as we both came.

Brad stood above me, his big white cock poking Sheena’s breasts, he took her face in his hands as her orgasm subsided. Her hands held his penis and she just looked up at him ecstatically.

I was defeated; she was sitting on me and sucking on him as my cock deflated inside her. I was nothing, powerless now, a depleted old fool lying in the bed of a young couple who were going to fuck into the night.

Sheena lifted herself off of me, and as I sat up she smiled at me brightly, as if I hadn’t just come prematurely like a kid. She took my face in her hands and kissed me sensuously, in that way she did that always blew my mind. Our mouths and eyes remained in contact as her body shifted, lifted, and descended. I saw she’d set her come filled pussy down on Brad’s face, he was now lying on his back eating my semen from her. He seemed to like it, his big white cock was throbbing on his stomach all by itself.

After a minute, Sheena lifted her groin from his face and turned to suck my sorry cock. Brad’s big hands went under her hips and lifted and shifted her so she and I were 69, and I was looking up at that beautiful open pink pussy I’d just fouled as his cock arrived and proceeded to push into it again, right in my face this time. I think it went easier, lubricated by the semen that was still in there.

My sexual arousal towards Sheena’s pink pussy and my revulsion of Brad’s big cock fought each other in my mind. It was beautiful really, wonderful harmless conflict, gay and straight, totally erotic.

I saw Sheena’s pretty vagina open to his big hard white rod. She was still sucking my cock, I was trying to get hard again while looking up at a pair of swinging pale testicles as he carefully penetrated the girl I hopelessly loved.

 
There is more of this chapter...
The source of this story is Storiesonline

To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account (Why register?)

Get No-Registration Temporary Access*

* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In