Nightmare Game - Cover

Nightmare Game

Copyright© 2025 by CaffeinatedTales

Chapter 6

Ethan gave a nod.

“Traps come in all shapes and sizes, some physical, others more like mind games, but either way, we need to stay on guard.”

“Rosie gets one shot a day to give us orders, and we can turn them down, but probably no more than three times total.”

“Cleaning the rooms doesn’t sound too risky, and I doubt anyone here would blow a valuable refusal on something that minor. The real trick is figuring out whether we’re truly accepting or rejecting it.”

Serena’s eyes lit up as the pieces clicked for her.

“You mean someone might inspect our rooms?”

“More than likely,” Ethan went on. “There has to be some standard for what counts as fulfilling the order. If they check and spot any mess left behind, it could count as us ignoring the command, wasting a refusal for nothing.”

“Plus, the guest rooms might hold clues or even traps tucked away somewhere. Bottom line, I think we all need to take this cleanup seriously.”

Ethan had stayed cool as a cucumber from the start, even while everyone else was still reeling from the death threat Butler had dangled over them. He kept his own steady pace, quietly sizing up the surroundings and piecing things together.

It was a relief, really, having someone step up like that in a pinch. It boosted their sense of security and eased the tension hanging in the air.

“You’re one sharp cookie, Ethan, gutsy and thoughtful all in one,” Albert said, flashing him a thumbs-up. But a second later, his brow furrowed again. “Still, I’ve got this nagging worry. The task says we survive seven days here, but with only two refusals, that means we have to obey five times at least.”

“What if he hits us with three straight orders to off ourselves right away? Wouldn’t that trap us from the jump?”

His words landed like a gut punch, and everyone’s faces darkened.

This creepy castle was home to a sheep-headed monster in Butler who could crush their skulls with a single swing.

Even that sweet-looking little girl had unleashed some horrifying strength just moments ago.

Deep down, they all knew the score: there probably wasn’t a single normal human in this place, not even the girl, let alone her parents.

Against a crew of monsters like that, could they really last seven days?

“It’s not that cut-and-dried,” Ethan said, shaking his head as if reading their minds. “If they wanted us dead for real, they could’ve wrapped it up in under a day.”

“But...” Grace raised her hand timidly. “What if they’re just a bunch of sadists who get off on dragging out the torture, picking us off slow?”

“I’ve run that scenario too,” Ethan replied, easing her fears quick as a flash. “But I don’t buy it, not after seeing the wine they laid out for us.”

“I’m sure you all caught that the red wine has some kind of hypnotic pull to it. Downing it could lead to serious trouble.”

“That gives us two possibilities. First, if it’s outright lethal, we drop dead on the spot, which doesn’t fit the whole ‘thrill of the kill’ vibe you mentioned. Second, if it triggers some change in our bodies, would a group of murder-happy freaks really use the exact same trick on all of us?”

A faint smile crossed Ethan’s face.

“Put yourself in their shoes for a sec. If I were one of those thrill-seeking monsters with powers way beyond human, offing you lot would be child’s play. Relying on a single gimmick like the wine to seal your fates? That’d get boring fast.”

A chill ran through the room right then. Ethan’s smile was warm on the surface, but it came off eerie, almost sinister.

 
There is more of this chapter...
The source of this story is Storiesonline

To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account (Why register?)

Get No-Registration Temporary Access*

* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In