Nightmare Game - Cover

Nightmare Game

Copyright© 2025 by CaffeinatedTales

Chapter 3

Silence smothered the banquet hall, a chill creeping up everyone’s spines, their hearts sinking into a pit of dread.

“No need to worry yourselves sick,” Mrs. Bennett said, her smile soft as a summer breeze, cutting through the tension. “These are just unwritten rules. Follow them, and you’ll be fine.”

She gestured to the table. “You’ve traveled far to reach us. You must be starving. Our chefs are exceptional, and I’m certain you’ll enjoy a fine meal.”

As she promised, the table was a feast for the eyes: delicate appetizers, hearty mains, decadent desserts, all arranged with meticulous care. In another setting, this could’ve been a lavish buffet, pure indulgence. But in this eerie place, with danger lurking in every shadow, most had no appetite.

More importantly, no one could be sure the food was safe.

Ethan paused, then mimicked Rosie, tying his napkin with deliberate care. He picked up his knife and fork, slicing into the steak before him. The meat, rare and tender, bled red juices with the lightest cut.

Ignoring the startled glances from the others, Ethan speared a piece and popped it into his mouth without hesitation, all while watching the host family’s every move.

Rosie and Mrs. Bennett dined with impeccable etiquette, silent as they savored their food, their movements graceful. Yet their eyes roamed over the guests, sharp with scrutiny, a cold glint buried deep within.

Bella, seated beside Ethan, kept her head down, nibbling at a slice of cream cake. Since her chilling greeting, she hadn’t spoken, as if the guests held no interest for her.

Lucas, catching Ethan’s lead, raised an eyebrow, his usual disdain replaced by a flicker of surprise. With a scoff, he grabbed a plate and began eating, relishing the flavors.

“Ethan, aren’t you worried the food’s ... tainted?” Serena’s hand gripped his arm, her palm icy against his skin.

He hesitated, glancing at the others before leaning close, his voice a low whisper. “Remember the task? Survive seven days in the Castle.”

Serena nodded, puzzled. “Yeah, so?”

“A week’s not long, but it’s not short either. A person can survive without food for about that long, but by then, you’d be too weak to run.” He kept his voice steady, his words measured. “There’s a monster outside, so we can’t leave. That means our only food comes from this Castle. You’ve seen how strange this place is, how danger’s everywhere. The food might be risky.”

He paused, letting the weight settle. “But think about it. Even if you avoid their food, can you trust anything else you find here? Being paranoid will only drain you. Eating keeps us strong, calms the nerves, and gives us a chance to escape if things go south.”

Serena loosened her grip, her tense expression softening. “You’ve got a point.” A faint smile tugged at her lips. “Didn’t peg you for the reliable type in a crisis.”

Ethan chuckled, sidestepping the comment. In the real world, he was bedridden, barely able to turn his head, hardly someone others leaned on. Reliable? They both knew better.

“So, I should eat?” Serena asked.

“Go for it,” Ethan said, nodding. “Or, if you’re nervous, wait and watch.”

She shook her head, offering a small smile. “No, I trust your judgment.”

 
There is more of this chapter...
The source of this story is Storiesonline

To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account (Why register?)

Get No-Registration Temporary Access*

* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In