Bending Eli
Copyright© 2025 by Broken Boundaries Gay Erotica
Chapter 17: Questions Answered
Erotica Sex Story: Chapter 17: Questions Answered - I'm Eli, an 18 year old university freshman. I join the school's gymnastics team in search of something new but find myself caught in a world of lust, dominance and kink that I never expected when I become entangled with my sexy Assistant Coach, Casper, all while hiding things from my equally sexy, straight, roommate, Mason.
Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Ma Ma Consensual Gay School Sports DomSub MaleDom Humiliation Rough Spanking Anal Sex Analingus Exhibitionism First Masturbation Oral Sex
Lecture dragged today. Every minute felt like ten, my professor’s words blending into a meaningless drone. All I could think about was the dream I’d had. The roughness. Casper’s hands gripping my hair, tugging me back, the force of him shoving inside me with a rawness that sent chills down my spine just recalling it. It wasn’t like Casper at all, at least not the Casper I’d experienced in real life. He was always so controlled, methodical, careful. But the Casper in my dream had been wild, primal, a complete contrast to the composed gymnast I’d come to know.
And God, I’d loved it.
Admitting that made something surge in my stomach and my face flush right there in the middle of class. I glanced around quickly, paranoid someone had noticed, but the other students looked as bored and uninterested as usual. I shifted in my seat, my jeans suddenly feeling tighter, a pressure building between my legs as I replayed the scenes from the dream. Casper pressing my face into the mattress, whispering commands, taking me in ways I’d never imagined but apparently craved.
My mind wandered unbidden to Mason. That single drunken night we’d shared still lingered in my thoughts, surfacing unexpectedly. He’d been rough too, different from Casper but similar in ways I was now becoming increasingly aware of. Mason had pushed my boundaries, grabbing and holding and using my mouth with a kind of confidence that was intoxicating. Raw and unrefined. Nothing graceful. Nothing soft. Just pure, hungry force. It had left me shaken and desperate for more, even though I hadn’t admitted it to myself until now.
Is that what I really wanted? Roughness? Control stripped away, someone else’s desires overpowering mine, pushing me past hesitation and fear? The thought felt dangerous, reckless, but undeniably thrilling.
I wished, not for the first time, that I had a gay friend I could talk to about this stuff. Irina was supportive and kind, but there was no way I could bring this up to her. The few gay guys I knew on campus were acquaintances at best, and none of them felt approachable enough to unload my messy, complicated questions onto. I was alone in this, spinning through desires and confusions with no one to ground me.
Almost no one.
Mason’s face popped back into my thoughts. He wasn’t gay, at least, he’d never indicated anything beyond girls, but he knew sex. He understood desire. And weirdly, Mason was approachable in his own abrasive, teasing way. Maybe I could ask him without revealing too much. Frame it as curiosity, something vague, something I’d heard. Mason might make fun of me, but he’d also answer honestly. Probably too honestly.
I chewed the idea over, my knee bouncing nervously beneath the desk as the professor droned on. Could I really trust Mason to keep it casual? Would he suspect something more? My stomach knotted anxiously. He was all I had. He wasn’t perfect, not even close, but right now Mason was my best shot at understanding these desires churning inside me.
Class ended, and I stood, gathering my stuff. I’d talk to Mason tonight. I had no other choice.
When I got back to the dorm that evening, Mason was exactly where I’d expected him to be, sprawled lazily across his bed, earbuds half-in and the muted glow of his laptop illuminating his face. He glanced up briefly as I entered, offering his usual casual greeting.
“Yo, Eli. Done being a responsible human for the day?”
“Yeah,” I mumbled, dropping my bag onto the floor. My heartbeat quickened as the silence thickened between us. I stood awkwardly by my bed, trying to muster the courage to ask what I’d spent all day agonizing over. The questions felt heavy on my tongue, too clumsy and personal to say out loud. But I had to try.
“Hey, Mason...” I started.
He lifted an eyebrow, pulling out an earbud and fixing me with a curious stare. “Uh-oh. What’s up?”
I hesitated, heat rising to my face. “Can I ask you something?”
Mason swung his legs around, sitting up and giving me his full attention. He seemed amused by my hesitation. “Sure, man. Fire away.”
I drew a breath and dove straight in. “What do you know about rough sex?”
Mason’s eyes widened slightly, surprise quickly shifting into a cocky smirk. “Rough sex, huh? That’s an interesting choice of topic, especially for you.”
I shrugged, fighting to keep my voice steady and casual. “I’m just curious. Like ... what exactly does rough sex entail?”
He chuckled softly, clearly enjoying this more than he should have. “Depends. There’s a lot of ways to do rough. Like, you mean spanking, choking, hair-pulling, that kinda stuff?”
“Yeah,” I managed, cheeks burning. “Stuff like that. Or even ... rougher?”
He laughed lightly again, shifting forward on his mattress. “Damn, Eli. Didn’t expect this kind of curiosity out of you. But alright.” He tilted his head thoughtfully. “Well, rough oral is one thing. Girls can get into it if you hold their heads down a bit. Y’know, really control the rhythm. Spit gets everywhere, it’s messy, and usually, it’s pretty damn hot. If they’re into it, obviously.”
“Messy?” I echoed dumbly.
“Yeah, messy,” he confirmed, amused. “Spit, drool, sometimes tears if you’re really going at it. The whole thing is about control. Taking it. Not asking.”
The words sent fire surging through me, memories and dreams mingling in my mind. I forced myself to stay composed, to keep pressing. “And when it’s ... actual sex? How rough is normal?”
“Normal?” Mason laughed outright now, leaning back comfortably. “Normal’s whatever gets her off. But yeah, hair pulling, holding wrists down, slapping her ass or thighs ... all pretty standard. The trick is knowing how much she wants and when to back off.”
I nodded slowly, absorbing his words. “But how do you know how much they want?”
“Body language. How they sound. If she pushes back into you, begs you to keep going, that’s a pretty clear sign. Some girls want you to go hard. Like, leave a mark kind of hard. But they have to trust you first.”
I swallowed hard. “Trust?”
He raised an eyebrow at my nervous tone. “Yeah, man, trust. Rough sex isn’t about hurting someone, it’s about pushing boundaries safely. She’s trusting you to know where to stop. That’s part of what makes it hot. The risk, the intensity. But you have to have trust, or it’s just fucked up.”
I took a shaky breath, my mind spinning with possibilities, images from the dream flooding back. “What about ... talking? Do you usually talk during it?”
Mason’s smirk widened. “Talking’s half the fun. Doesn’t have to be complicated. Stuff like, ‘take it,’ or ‘you like that?’ or telling her how good she feels. Some girls like hearing dirtier stuff, being called names. But again, only if you know she wants it.”
My chest tightened, excitement mixed with anxiety. “Do you ... hit? Or bite?”
He laughed quietly, shaking his head. “You’re really diving deep, aren’t you? Yeah, biting can be good. Usually softer spots, neck or shoulders. Slaps are fine, too, as long as they’re not too hard. Again, it’s all about reading her. If you slap and she moans, you know you’re on the right track.”
I must’ve been staring intently, because Mason leaned forward suddenly, eyes narrowed in playful suspicion. “Dude, you seem way too invested in this. You got something you wanna tell me?”
I jolted, quickly shaking my head. “No! I mean—no, I’m just curious. I don’t have anyone else to ask about this stuff.”
He grinned, amused by my discomfort. “Sure, sure. Well, I’m flattered you’re coming to me for advice.”
I rolled my eyes, but couldn’t stop my blush deepening. “Just figured you had more ... experience.”
Mason settled back, hands behind his head now, relaxing again. “You’re not wrong. And for the record, rough sex is fucking awesome. If you’ve never tried it, you’re missing out.”
I swallowed again, fighting to keep the tremor from my voice. “So, it’s better than ... regular sex?”
“Not necessarily better. Just different. More intense, more primal. But regular sex can be hot as hell too.” Mason’s mouth curled into a lazy grin as he leaned forward a little. “But when it’s rough, everything feels sharper. Harder thrusts, harder breathing. You don’t stop every two seconds to adjust a pillow or whisper something sweet. You just ... take. And you don’t give them time to think about what’s coming next.”
I swallowed hard. “So you just ... keep going?”
“Oh yeah,” he said, eyes bright with the memory of whatever he was thinking about. “You keep a grip on them and you don’t let up. Maybe you pull her hair to keep her face down. Maybe you hold her hips so she can’t move. If she wants it rough, she’ll get loud, she’ll claw at the sheets, she’ll beg for more. And you don’t slow down until you feel her go limp from it.”
The way he said it made my skin tingle. “And if she ... gags or cries a bit?”
“That’s part of it too,” he replied easily. “Spit everywhere, tears in her eyes, her throat working hard to take it. If she’s into it, it’s the hottest thing in the world. You see her drooling on you and you don’t even care. You keep holding her head, you keep her there, you make sure she knows you’re in charge.”
He leaned back again, smirk deepening, his eyes on me now in a way that made my throat tighten. “It’s not the kind of thing you really understand until you’ve been there.”
The silence lingered between us for a few seconds, charged and heavy. Mason watched me closely, eyes narrowed just slightly, the corner of his mouth twitching upward in a teasing smile.
“You’re quiet all of a sudden,” he said finally. “You were practically interrogating me a minute ago. Run out of questions?”
I shrugged awkwardly, my throat dry. “I guess ... I don’t know. Maybe.”
He chuckled lightly, still watching me. “Come on. You’ve been asking all these questions like you’re studying for a test or something. But you know, with stuff like this, you won’t really get it until you feel it for yourself.”
My pulse sped up, blood rushing hot under my skin. Mason’s voice had lowered slightly, becoming softer, quieter, and yet somehow more intense. His eyes locked onto mine, never wavering, as if he was daring me to look away. I didn’t.
“I mean,” he continued, his grin slowly spreading, “all this talking is just theory. It doesn’t compare to actually feeling it firsthand.”
I swallowed hard, tension pooling low in my stomach. “Yeah, I guess not,” I murmured, my voice barely above a whisper.
Mason sat up straighter, leaning forward toward the edge of the bed. “So, do you wanna know what it feels like?” His voice was playful but carried a quiet intensity. “I can show you better than I can explain it. All this talk has actually made me pretty horny.”
My breath hitched, heartbeat hammering in my chest. Was he serious, or was this just another one of Mason’s jokes, his endless teasing to see if he could embarrass me?
“What do you mean?” I managed, trying to keep my voice steady.
Mason laughed quietly, his eyes still fixed intently on mine. “Exactly what it sounds like. You’ve asked enough questions, Eli. Might as well stop talking and just show you.”
I stared at him, heart pounding, mouth dry. I didn’t respond—not because I didn’t want to, but because the words wouldn’t come. Mason seemed to understand my silence perfectly, because his smile deepened, turning into something more knowing, more confident.
Slowly, deliberately, he stood and stepped toward me, closing the small gap between us. My body felt frozen, every muscle rigid as Mason reached forward and cupped my crotch firmly through my jeans. My breath caught sharply.
“You seem curious enough,” he murmured softly, eyes dancing with a mixture of amusement and something darker. “Let’s see how curious you really are.”
Before I could answer, Mason hooked his thumbs into the waistband of his sweatpants, tugging them down casually. I inhaled sharply as I saw him exposed, cock already thickening, so big and inviting in front of me. My hesitation faded, desire overriding uncertainty. Without thinking, my hand reached out, my fingers curling around his length. Mason chuckled softly, a low, knowing sound that told me he understood exactly what I wanted.
Mason’s laugh still hung in the air as he kicked off his sweats completely, leaving them in a heap by the bed. He peeled his T-shirt over his head and tossed it aside, standing there for a moment in front of me, bare and confident, like it was the most natural thing in the world. My hand was still wrapped around his cock, and I could feel it swelling under my fingers, hardening by the second as he looked down at me with that half-smirk, half-dare.
He tilted his head slightly, eyes flicking to the rest of my clothes. He didn’t say a word, but the message was clear enough. My pulse kicked up hard as I reached for the hem of my T-shirt, tugged it off in one motion, and dropped it on the floor. Mason’s gaze followed me, steady and unflinching, as I fumbled with the button on my jeans.
I hesitated for a breath before pushing them down and stepping out of them. When I slid off my underwear, a faint grin tugged at his mouth, like he was amused at how quickly I was stripping for him.
For a moment, the room went quiet. I couldn’t hear anything, just the sound of our breathing and the low hum of the radiator. Mason stepped forward and closed the small space between us. He reached out, one hand brushing my cheek, the other sliding into my hair, his fingers curling until he had a solid hold. With one firm tug, he tilted my head back so my eyes locked with his.
“You ready to see what rough feels like?” he asked. His voice was low and smooth, but there was weight in the words.
I nodded, barely breathing.
Mason grinned, the expression sharp but not cruel. He shifted his grip slightly, guiding my head lower as he brought his cock to my lips. The head of it brushed over my mouth, smearing a bead of pre-cum across my lower lip.
“Open,” he said simply.
I obeyed, parting my lips as wide as I could. Mason pushed forward slowly at first, just enough for me to taste him. Warm skin and the faint tang of sweat filled my mouth. He fed me more, an inch at a time, until the weight of him pressed against the back of my tongue.
My chest tightened as his grip on my hair firmed, pulling me forward in small, deliberate tugs. The tip of his cock pressed deeper, sliding past the back of my tongue. My throat tightened reflexively, my eyes starting to water as he pushed a little further.
Mason groaned, low and approving. “That’s it. Take it.”
The words made my stomach clench. His hips gave the first sharp snap forward, and spit spilled from the corner of my mouth, trailing down my chin as I gasped around him.
Mason’s grip on my hair tightened, his fingers digging in at my scalp as he set the pace. His hips pushed forward again, harder this time, the head of his cock sliding across the back of my tongue and pressing into my throat before easing back just far enough for me to catch a ragged breath. Then he drove in again, faster now, testing how much I could handle.
The mess started almost immediately. My lips couldn’t keep up with the weight of him moving in and out. Spit slipped over my chin, thick strings stretching toward my chest as I tried to swallow around him. Mason’s voice dropped lower, rougher, the words carrying that effortless confidence that always made me feel smaller beneath him.
“Good. That’s it. Keep your mouth open for me.”
I couldn’t do anything but obey. My jaw was already aching, the muscles straining as he fed me more of himself. Each thrust forced him deeper, the blunt pressure at my throat making my eyes sting until tears blurred my vision. He didn’t stop.
He used the hold on my hair like a handle, pulling my head down into him when he wanted more, letting me ease back just enough to suck in a shaky breath, then drawing me forward again. His hips found a rhythm, sharper now, confident, wet sounds filling the space between his low groans and my muffled breaths.