Bending Eli - Cover

Bending Eli

Copyright© 2025 by Broken Boundaries Gay Erotica

Chapter 12: Silent Witness

Erotica Sex Story: Chapter 12: Silent Witness - I'm Eli, an 18 year old university freshman. I join the school's gymnastics team in search of something new but find myself caught in a world of lust, dominance and kink that I never expected when I become entangled with my sexy Assistant Coach, Casper, all while hiding things from my equally sexy, straight, roommate, Mason.

Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including Ma/Ma   Ma   Consensual   Gay   School   Sports   DomSub   MaleDom   Humiliation   Rough   Anal Sex   Analingus   Exhibitionism   First   Masturbation   Oral Sex  

Wednesday morning sunlight stung my eyes as I pushed open the dorm door, stepping inside feeling like I was glowing from the inside out. My whole body was humming, skin flushed, heart still fluttering wildly. Mason glanced up from his desk, earbuds dangling loosely from his ears, textbook forgotten the instant he saw me.

“Dude,” he said with an exaggerated smirk, dropping his pen dramatically. “Seriously, again? What the fuck did Casper do to you?”

“Nothing,” I protested weakly, face already burning.

“Nothing, my ass,” Mason snorted, shaking his head, eyes glittering mischievously. “You look like someone ran you over with a good time. You definitely got laid. Who was it, Eli? Hot gymnast chick? Dance major? Wait, wait, don’t tell me—yoga instructor?”

“It wasn’t like that,” I managed lamely, slinging my bag onto the floor by my bed.

“Sure,” Mason drawled, leaning back with a cocky grin, folding his arms behind his head. “Keep your secrets, Romeo. But don’t think I’m buying your bullshit ‘just training’ line.”

He winked, utterly pleased with himself, and I turned away, forcing out a shaky breath as heat coiled tightly in my chest. I tried desperately to suppress the thoughts flickering behind my eyes: Casper’s strong hands on my shoulders, the sharp, low commands, his cock sliding between my lips...

Thursday and Friday blurred together into a dizzying pattern of early mornings. Each session started the same way: kneeling obediently, Casper’s firm grip guiding my movements, his quiet murmurs as he pushed himself deeper into my mouth, and then relentless, punishing drills that left me trembling, exhilarated, my performances improving noticeably each time. It was working, exactly as Casper said it would.

But there was a problem, a big one. Every training session left me aching, throbbing, impossibly turned on, with no relief in sight. Classes, gym, Mason always fucking around, always there, cock-blocking by sheer proximity. By Friday evening I was climbing the walls, desperate to find some space to release the frustration simmering under my skin.

Then Casper surprised me, texting Friday night that we’d have an extra session Saturday morning, later at 8 a.m., a small mercy. When I crept out of the dorm early Saturday, I was startled to see Mason already awake, lounging casually on his bed, watching me intently.

“Off for another round, Eli?” Mason asked lazily, a teasing edge to his voice.

“Just training,” I muttered, slipping out quickly before he could interrogate me further.

The halls were eerily quiet, the whole building still sleeping off Friday night. As I hurried through the deserted corridors, I felt an uneasy prickle down my spine. The feeling persisted even after I glanced back, seeing nothing. Just my imagination, probably.

Casper was waiting for me, calm and composed as always, ice-blue eyes glittering faintly with that now-familiar predatory gleam. Kneeling became second nature, a relief almost, as my lips parted willingly, welcoming his hardness deep into my throat, tasting him, savoring the control he wielded effortlessly. Each stroke he pushed me further, trained me deeper, until I was gasping, shaking, beautifully wrecked.

As I rose afterward, breath still ragged, I swore I heard the faint creak of a door somewhere in the gym. I glanced around quickly, heart jumping, but saw nothing. Casper didn’t seem to notice.

“Good work, Eli,” he said softly, handing me a towel. “You’re improving fast.”

The rest of Saturday stretched endlessly, Mason lingering in the room, friends dragging me out, leaving me nowhere, no time to relieve myself. By evening, I was almost delirious, body wired, cock aching desperately for release.

Finally, mercifully, Mason left for the bars, and when I got home a few hours after he’d left, I was alone. My clothes were off in seconds, my back hitting the mattress, fingers closing eagerly around my painfully hard cock. My breath caught sharply, chest rising and falling rapidly as images flooded my mind.

Casper. Always Casper.

The vivid memory of him standing tall and calm above me, eyes glittering with authority as he guided my lips onto his cock, filled my consciousness entirely. My own hand mimicked that rhythm, fingers tightening around my shaft, sliding slowly upward, thumb brushing slick precum across my sensitive tip, pulling a shuddering gasp from my throat.

My tongue instinctively darted out, wetting my lips as if Casper were standing right there, silently commanding me to prepare myself for him. I imagined his scent, rich and heady, invading my senses, making my pulse quicken even more. My cock throbbed insistently in my grasp as I vividly remembered the saline, masculine taste of him, pressing insistently on my tongue, how he’d held the back of my head gently, firmly, controlling every inch that passed between my lips.

I stroked myself harder, hips jerking upward involuntarily. The vision of Casper’s lean, muscular body flexing as he thrust slowly into my mouth sent hot spikes of arousal surging through me. My throat tightened reflexively at the phantom sensation of his cock slipping deeper, forcing me to relax, forcing me to surrender completely to his pace, his pleasure. My own fingers mirrored that powerful, deliberate rhythm, squeezing tighter, sliding faster, matching each remembered stroke.

Casper’s whispered praise echoed clearly in my ears, the way he’d quietly murmured encouragement while guiding my movements. “Good boy, Eli,” he’d breathed softly, sending shivers down my spine. “Take me deeper. Show me you can handle it.” I whimpered softly into the empty room, hips lifting from the mattress again, thrusting urgently into my hand as I lost myself fully in the fantasy.

My breathing grew rapid, uneven, my cock slick and pulsing hot in my grip. My eyes fluttered closed, chest heaving as I pictured Casper’s fingers threading through my hair, tightening slightly to hold me still, hips rolling smoothly, his cock gliding deep into my throat. The ache of longing in my chest was sharp, intense, matched only by the throbbing desperation pulsing through every inch of my aching cock.

As the fantasy deepened, I let myself imagine more, pushing into new, uncharted desires that I’d barely allowed myself to consider until now. Casper’s low voice, murmuring darkly seductive commands, flooded my thoughts. “We’re going to push you further today, Eli,” he whispered, that wicked edge to his voice making my whole body tremble. “It’s time to prepare you properly.”

 
There is more of this chapter...
The source of this story is Storiesonline

To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account (Why register?)

Get No-Registration Temporary Access*

* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In