Michelle Tanner Going West
Copyright© 2025 by Ron Lewis
Chapter 2: The Deserters
The three horses travelled along at a fast walk moving at about 10 miles per hour. Leaving Kansas City, Meeker and Michelle headed toward Denver City. Eventually passing the workers laying track westward, they were more than a year from reaching Denver City. The tracks might make it as far as Penny Kansas by snowfall. Then again if they were really lucky they might get as far west as Fort Dodge by winter.
The first two days of the trek west were monotonous, the trip accomplished without much in the way of verbal communication. Meeker rode his horse; offering little conversation to Michelle other than a few simple directions or requests. He fought not only with the guilt that gnawed at him over killing the gunman, but why the man had tried to kill him in the first place. Joseph Nathan Meeker never got used to killing anyone. It tugged at him hard that he had no idea why the man would hate him enough to try to kill him.
Michelle, being good at reading people, left Meeker to his thoughts. Offering a few comments on occasion but not pushing conversation on the man. She contented herself with leading the packhorse, an eight year old gelding called Smokey that seemed to have a few misplaced, romantic notions regarding Mary Todd. There was also the added weight and chafing of the brace of heavy pistols now strapped across her hips. At that particular moment, they seemed more of a nuisance than a novelty, or even necessary. At noon of the third day, Meeker’s mood changed. He looked over at Michelle and thanked her for her quiet understanding.
“Most women,” he said, smiling at her as he pulled his horse to a standstill, “want a man to talk this sort of issue out. They would be pestering a fellow to tell them his feelings.” His eyes grew sad for a moment, “My wife was the world’s worst for wanting to talk about stuff that upset me. She would poke and prod at me in English, Crow and sign language until I would just explode at her.” He almost stopped there but continued as he nudged Star into a slow walk. “Then I would finally talk about whatever was bothering me until she was satisfied and I could go back to enjoying the peace and quiet.”
“I know very well why you have been so withdrawn lately and I do sympathize. However, you do know that old Indian is following us don’t you? The one that watched me ride Mary Todd the other day?” Meeker again pulled his horse to a stop. Staring at the young woman intently; a broad smiled crossed his weathered face.
“My goodness Shell, I’ve been meaning to mention that to you for more than two days now. You knew it all along! Woman you’re a wonderment do you know that?” Again, he lightly tapped his horse with the heels of his boots and they continued their westward journey. “He doesn’t want to spook us so he is catching up to us slowly.”
The gap between our duo and the lone rider slowly closed as the days wore on. At about Mid-afternoon on the 6th day Meeker pulled his horse to a stop. Dismounting he tethered him to the solitary tree in the area. Michelle followed his lead. “We will give old Buffalo Head a chance to catch up with us.” Meeker pointed toward a herd of buffalo; “go get us some fuel for a fire,” He was looking around the grassy plain; “there is not going to be any wood here; too far from the river. Get some dry buffalo chips, they burn good and hot.”
“So do we trust the old man?” Michelle persisted; not entirely sure what they were doing was the right thing.
“That old man is an educated Cherokee Indian. Some fancy university in New England taught him Vet Medicine. He’s no cutthroat.” Michelle shrugged as she grabbed an empty flour sack from the packhorse and headed out to gather the fuel. Approaching the big woolies, she noticed they paid her no attention at all. These dumb beasts would be easy pickings for any hunter she mused. Soon her sack was full and she headed back toward camp. Seeing Meeker and the Indian talking, she walked into camp wondering what this feller’s story was.
Turning away from the Indian, Meeker continued to talk to Buffalo Head and motioned for Michelle to come on in and join them. Michelle couldn’t help but notice they were an odd-looking couple, Meeker tall and thin but muscular. He was dressed in buckskins and a rather flamboyant wide brimmed hat with a large feather sticking up from the band. The Indian short rather round dressed in a blue pinstripe suite and bowler hat, looking ready for Sunday go to Meeting. Both men had one thing in common, long white hair, though Meeker was perhaps 20 years younger than the Indian was. Whatever they were talking about, they continued until Michelle was close enough that Meeker did not need to yell at her.
“Buffalo Head here has a proposition for us.” Michelle walked closer as Meeker continued to talk to her. “He would like to throw in with us, thinks there’s safety in numbers. I think that will be just fine, don’t you?” Shell nodded her head as she closed the last few feet between them. “Michelle this is Buffalo Head, Buffalo Head this is Michelle Tanner...” Buffalo Head cut in on him
“Hair of Flame, good to see you again;” he extended his hand to her. She grasped his and firmly gripped it as they shook hands. He gave her a slow grin.
“Good to meet you Mr. Buffalo Head...”
“He’s Doctor Buffalo Head, Michelle.”
“No, just call me Buffalo Head. I have dinner for us,” turning he went to his horse and held three cottontail rabbits by their legs. Holding the rabbits high in the air for the pair to see, “don’t worry they taste like chicken.”
Michelle busied herself building a fire while Buffalo Head went to cleaning the rabbits and preparing them to cook. Meeker rode off south with the empty canteens to find the river and fill them with water. He tried to fill them every day; knowing there would be times when they would not be able to find water.
Michelle and the Indian talked as he began to cook the food over the fire. Telling her, he was an old man now having graduated from Harvard more than 38 years before. His face grew sadder looking as he continued to talk, “After I graduated I got married and my wife had a child. Then there was the Trail of Tears. Happiness died for many moons.” Changing the subject, he talked on until his mood lightened. “What about you Miss Tanner?”
Michelle told him of her father; her Journey west and joining up with Meeker. She even told the old Indian about Meeker’s determination to kill the man who murdered his wife and child.
“Hate is never a good thing. It feasts on your soul; eating you up. Vengeance never satisfies, never heals the wrong done to you. Justice is a different thing but justice is difficult to find. Best to forgive, I will tell him so without telling him so.” Michelle looked confused by the old man’s words. “I have a story.”
Soon Meeker returned with full canteens. A big broad grin on his face as he dismounted as if he knew a joke no one else knew. Tethering Star; he unsaddled him and eventually he sat next to Buffalo Head; poking the older man in the ribs.
“Penny ain’t ten miles from here. If it wasn’t for Michelle we could go down and see the badger for a bit.”
“See the badger?” Shell looked at him confused; sipping on her coffee.
“He means; visit us some whores. Probably good thing you are with us, “Hair of Flame”, lest “Sleeps with Bears” and I go into Penny with our pockets full and just get into much trouble.” The old Indian laughed loud and hearty. “Besides that, I don’t think Penny allows Indians in the saloon.”
“Money is money; why would your money be different than my money?” Meeker asked him with honest curiosity.
“If only all white men were like you, “Sleeps with Bears’!” Meeker knew damn well that most whites would not allow Buffalo Head in to eat, drink or sleep in their business. He did not understand it but he knew such bigotry existed. Still Meeker had not gone to see the badger for a long time. Since before, he was married. It had just been a poor attempt at a joke.
“If you ‘Gentlemen’ want to go and ‘See the badger’; then let’s all go down to Penny. It don’t bother me one whit if you want to do that. I can play me some poker there.” Michelle said pouring a bit more coffee.
“I was only funnin’ Shell,” Meeker took the pot from her and retrieved his cup filling it with the dark fluid. Replacing the pot, he settled back next to Buffalo Head. “Maybe Doc here wants to go make some sport but I can’t do that to her memory,” meaning his wife.
“Not me, still have the want to but the equipment don’t agree no more.” The Indian smiled nodding his head; he continued to grin; pleased with his witticism.
“Well this conversation is sure getting embarrassing,” Michelle said. “How long till them vittles is done?”
“About 5 minutes I guess. Why you embarrassed, “Hair of Flame”? I’m the one with the defective parts,” still poking fun at her; hoping she did not take offense.
“Alright, you keep prodding and poking your fun at me. I don’t have any interest in your kind of equipment anyway.”
“Figures,” the two men spoke almost in unison.
Captain Edward Powers, First Sergeant James Thomason and Private Simpson were hardened men. Generally, called “Halfwit”, Simpson was a violent, odd individual. Neither of the two men knew what Halfwit’s real first name was. They had always known him only as Halfwit Simpson. Having a union ball in his brain might have caused much of the oddness. Simpson was a normal soldier before the head injury. Jovial and friendly he was a well-liked individual. He was always a bit slow in his thought process, which earned him the nickname, Halfwit. He never took offense at anyone using the handle to call him. He actually did not know what the word meant.
Then in a skirmish, standing next to an officer at the rear of the lines a sharpshooter shot him. It is unknown whether the sharpshooter aimed to hit Simpson or intended the bullet for the officer standing next to him. Still the bullet hit him on the left side of his forehead traversing halfway through his brain. The bullet lodged deep enough the doctors were unwilling to remove it. Afterwards he was anything but normal.
Quick to get into fights; he became almost uncontrollable around women. Formerly shy around women he became aggressive to the point that he was dangerous for the women. His jovial nature turned to dark desires which if any opportunity presented itself, he would act on. He now had a greatly increased sexual appetite and any girl would do, pretty, not so pretty, young, not so young, downright old, willing or otherwise. Prostitute, free white woman or Negro slave he would take them and have his way with no regrets. Afterward the women if they were still alive; feared him so that they just kept their mouths shut.
For Powers, Simpson was easy to control. Whatever the reason was, if Captain Powers asked him to do something, anything; he acted on it immediately. This made the man useful. Powers would give an order and Simpson would follow it. Powers was the only person who had such an influence on Simpson.
By the time they reached Kansas, Thomason had about had it with these men. Unlike the other two, he had a conscience, a conscience that gnawed at him. Their actions bothered him badly; eating at his soul. He was never quite sure why he ran with these two men. He remembered Powers saying, “Let’s just take off and leave this damn war to those that want to fight it.”
After the first hold up, he should have left. After watching the two men rape and murder the first of many women, he should have killed them. He did not; for a lack of courage. Power’s was quiet a formidable man and Thomason feared him. Never participating in the rapes he held back knowing he could not do that. Neither could he leave the group no matter how much he wanted to. He was awash in emotions of hatred for these men and shame for himself. He had always been something of a coward.
They were a long way from Louisiana having deserted from General Kirby Smith’s command during the heat of battle in March. The Red River Valley was long behind them and the Battle of Mansfield where they simply rode away. Deserting their post back there; the men stole, killed and raped their way from Louisiana through Texas, up through the Nations and now into Kansas. Kansas Sheriff’s offices and Marshal’s office had paper on the men - Wanted Dead or Alive. Notice that dead precedes alive, suggesting that was the preferred manner to bring the men to justice.
Three bounty hunters had failed in attempts to take the men. The trio didn’t even bother to bury the men. Leaving the dead men’s bodies a feast for the vultures and coyotes, their picked clean bones bleached whiter in the sun. Thomason heard the men pleading for their lives in his dreams. Knowing the last thing the men saw was Powers sadistic smile.
The grass stretched out on the flat Kansas prairie; a seeming endless expanse of grassy sameness. A solitary tree here, a small hill there and for miles and miles; a dull featureless landscape. Some thought it to have its own beauty, while others hated it. The three men sat astride their horses carefully watching the single wagon. It struggled in a vain attempt to catch up to the wagon train miles ahead. They followed the deep ruts in the sod, vainly trying to close the distance between them and the safety of the train.
Near sundown, the wagon stopped and the occupants descended from the wagon. The man unhitched the horses tethering them a short distance away from the wagon. A young female brought the animals’ grain in buckets. An older female made her way to a big buffalo wallow to bring back some water from the muddy pond. She was probably the mother; not that it mattered to them.
The three men held back, following and waiting for the right time to strike. The leader of the group ran his hands over his sunburned face. Feeling the rough stubble of his days’ old growth, he wondered how long it had been since he last shaved his face. Pushing his hat up high on his head, he studied the situation. Working his tobacco in his jaw, he built up a good wad and spat it down on the ground. The thick gooey juice pooled up then soaked into the dry eager soil.
“I got me a hankering I need to satisfy boys. Those women over there could fill the bill!” The officer’s uniform showed the horizontal gold bars on his collar of the rank of captain.
“The young one can’t be more than 14.” The old sergeant said with just a touch of anger present in his face and voice.
“First sergeant ... you going to give me trouble over sparking?”
“Those chicken guts on your sleeve don’t mean squat to me.” Putting his hands on the saddle horn, he adjusted himself in his saddle and then turned, facing the younger man. “You’re a runner same as me and we got no rank anymore.” Power’s eyes locked onto Thomason’s, his brow furrowed and his naturally dominant personality gave him the advantage over the ‘nicer’ man. He had a short fuse having shot men down for violating the most minor of orders.
“You’re going to toe the mark do you understand? I don’t need you if you don’t ... if you get my meaning.” The man had his hand resting on his gun. The First Sergeant knew very well what the meaning was.
“I just think she is too young,” the man said backing off from his original position. His stomach knotted up as his mouth dried out. Edward Powers would have thought nothing of killing him and he knew it. Sergeant Thomason pushed his feet forward in the stirrups and pushed back stretching. His butt ached; they had been in the saddle most of the time for over three months. All he really wanted anymore was a nice soft bed and to get up in one place in the morning and go to bed in the same place that night. His natural meanness burnt from him in the fire of their months of wanton slaughter. When he slept, he heard the screams of the women the other two had raped and saw the faces of the men they killed. He wanted to be free of these men. He wanted to atone for his sins.
“Think what you like but keep your pie trap closed.” Powers snarled back; the third man laughed in a strange cackle that sounded something like strangling a chicken. This was his way of showing his excitement of what was to come.
“Ain’t had any in over a week. I’m going to get me some tonight though.” Talking and cackling like a hen at the same time a thick stream of juice ran out of his mouth and over his chin. Spittle flew from his lips as he spoke; the dark fluid laced with bits of the tobacco in his jaw. “Yes sir, going to split her wide tonight.” Reaching up, he wiped his face with his sleeve; the gray material of which was stained nearly black. Gingerly he touched his forehead. The wound had long since healed but he was marked now with a horrid scar; Cain’s own mark; marred Simpson’s forehead; for all to see. “Damn this just won’t stop hurtin’. How long has it been since I got this anyway?”
“A year last month,” the Captain told him.
“I done got me a bitch of a headache, ringing in my ears; every damn hour of every damn day!” Halfwit complained as he stared fixedly at the unsuspecting little family in the campsite.
Luck had been a thin, meager gruel for Joshua Culbertson and his family. Marina his wife and Sarah his daughter were plain worn out from the constant misfortune that plagued them. Marina was especially haggard; her worn out body ached all over. She was too young to feel so old. She felt like an old woman at 37 years of age. She thought of a boy she had known in her youth. He had courted her but she favored Joshua, till death do us part. She shrugged off her thoughts and returned to the task at hand. What rest the females managed to get did not refresh them. A simple month long journey to Denver was not even half over; already they trailed the wagon train more than a day behind. First, it was a busted wheel; Joshua taking ill and then a busted axle; the calamities of the trail kept them falling further and further behind. The axle, repaired with leather was a constant worry. Now they could not even see the other wagons. Following only the deep ruts left by them but they knew they would get to their destination ... eventually.
They lacked the safety of numbers. That was what a wagon train was all about, safety of numbers. The train was not heading to Oregon or California; it was going to Denver City. Joshua was going to give prospecting a whirl in the Golden Valley. The promised land that lay just west of Denver City in the Rockies. He mustered out a month before they left for Denver City. Tired of the fighting; he wanted to move on and do something new. His profession no longer interested him. Cobbling was just not a profession that helped a man make a mark.
Always at the back of Joshua Culbertson mind was a nagging thought “You just don’t provide well for your family.” It gnawed at him. Making him have a powerful need to do something better than anyone else. A persistent whisper from his own mind plagued him. Often at night, he would be unable to sleep as he listed his shortcomings. He feared he would always be mediocre. He was not bad at the things he did. He was fair at everything he put his hand to, but he was not great at anything. He suffered from being adequate, just sufficiently good enough to do the task but just barely. To some people being ordinary is failure. Certainly, he was not extraordinary at one single thing, even in failure he was only average.
Building a roaring fire with some wood he was carrying in the wagon; the blaze aided by chips thrown in for good measure. A large herd of buffalo meandered around the prairie near them. The great beasts looking at the interlopers with a mild curiosity wondering why there was only one of the strange animals with wheels instead of a long line of them. Cautiously they kept their distance, as sometimes the smaller animals with only two legs would magically kill one of them. Their upper bodies had stumps like legs that they did not walk on. These would spit lightning and one of the big woolies would drop dead. They were never comfortable when the two-legged creatures were near.
The fire blazed and Marina cooked their meal. Salted pork stewed with potatoes and carrots. She chose salted pork because the salted beef just tasted so nasty. She had soaked the pork all day to get most of the salt out. Stewing it was the best method to soften and rehydrate the meat. The last of the red was fading in the western sky. Stars were visible as she began to dish up the food. They sat around on the ground enjoying each other’s company and relaxing after the hard days travel. They had been unaware of the eyes watching them from a distance all day.
“Hello in the camp. May we ride in?” The voice sounded pleasant and kind.
“When I was a young man,” the old man began to relate a story to his companions. Henry Buffalo Head graduated from Harvard School of Veterinary Medicine in 1826; a twenty-four-year-old man. Setting up practice in Georgia, he worked hard for both whites and Indians. Dr. Buffalo Head built up a good reputation taking care of cattle, horses, sheep, dogs and even house cats.
Henry married his childhood sweetheart in 1827. She gave him a daughter in 1829, the same year that they found gold in Georgia. They were a very happy family up until then. No man ever loved his wife and child more than he did. Buffalo Head worked hard to be the best vet in the state of Georgia. His only desire in life was to provide for his family. A Christian by faith, he walked a tightrope of wanting to honor his ancestors and Christ. His faith which was sorely tested in the coming years proved to be all that allowed him to stay sane. His faith was also the only thing that allowed him to forgive those who wronged him.
In 1830, Congress passed the Indian Removal Act. George Washington had proposed the absorption of Indians into white society. There was little, if any difference visible in how the Buffalo Head family lived their life from any other citizens of Georgia. However, the Buffalo Head’s were not citizens of Georgia, or the United States either. They were members of the Native American tribe known as Tsalagi or Cherokee.
Eventually the federal government forced them to move and confiscated their lands for “reassignment.” Thus, the trio began the arduous journey in 1838. The trip was hard and they had to walk as even their horses were impounded by the government, to belong to others by lottery.
“It began in 1829 when gold was found in Georgia.” The old man talked in an absent voice, like a teacher lecturing his students. “Then Congress passed a law setting a disaster in motion. The Tsalagi held on until ‘38 we were the last tribe they moved. We don’t call ourselves Cherokee, it is a name given us by others. Other tribes call us the Mountain People, the Dog People, People of the Caves, People of another Tongue or Cherokee. We call ourselves Tsalagi the Real People,” The fire danced in his eyes; occasionally he would stop and tear meat from the rabbit with his fingers then place it in his mouth, chewing as best he could. Once he swallowed the food, he would continue.
“President Jackson was not our friend; he sided with Georgia. When the Supreme Court ruled that Georgia could not impose law on the Tsalagi Nation; John Marshall wrote the opinion. Only the Federal government had authority over the Nations. Jackson said, “Marshall has made his decision ... let him enforce it. Build a fire under them; when it gets hot enough they will leave.” Build a fire they did and congress passed a law. It got hot and in the end we left.” Again, he ate and drank then continued to talk. His voice held no hint of malice but sounded quite melancholy.
“The damned treaty passed by a single vote, Jackson signed it but left office before we were moved. Chief John Ross lost his life for signing the damn thing along with other leaders. I think only one of the Tsalagi that signed the treaty lived. I can’t remember his name, doesn’t matter though. With or without the treaty we were done in Georgia. The damn gold ensured that. Jesus must have been speaking of Gold when he said money is the root of all manner of evil.
“Militia, volunteers and regular army, escorted us. That sounds so pleasant doesn’t it? Escorted us, you know, as if we were all going together for an enjoyable picnic. They had seven thousand men with guns; a lot of manpower to do the job. Regular army, volunteers and state militiamen gathered us up at gunpoint. Then herded us like so many cattle. General Winfield Scott led the men. Holding us in, what is the word for it,” He searched his mind for the right word; “concentration, yes, that is the word...” The old man seemed pleased he had found the word. “They held us in Concentration Camps in Tennessee.
“Our lands were given away to whites in lotteries, while the soldiers burned our homes and possessions to the ground. Then the journey of ... I don’t know; maybe fifteen hundred miles give or take a life or two ... began. The soldiers were all around; their guns and bayonets at the ready to keep us in line. Marching us forward to our new adventure, yes adventure that is what the soldier boys called it. Adventure, sure; dysentery, cholera, and small pox as well, that is quite the adventure.
“In the dead of winter with no shoes or moccasins, we walked through a frozen waste. Men and women froze to death. Coldest winter in Illinois ever, I’m thinking. One month in the winter, we moved 68 miles. That’s right 68 measly miles in an entire month. We spent three of the weeks with the leaders just trying to figure out how to get across the Mississippi. Just sitting there watching big blocks of ice flow down the river. So big, they would have knocked out a barge. Hell, they did knock out a barge.
“A big barge was loaded with wagons filled with goods for sale somewhere on the other side of the river. No one was on the damn thing the operators were running their little steam engine pulling it from one side to the other. Great ropes stretched across the river, on the other side a steam engine pulled the rope on to a spool. It spun off a spool on our side. The barge got about 50 yards out in the water and a big block of ice came crashing into it. Busted it to pieces. The ice left behind mostly kindling floating down stream so the leaders abandoned the idea of going across right then. Not for our safety you understand but for theirs.
“I have heard that freezing is a pleasant way to go. I don’t know that I agree with them. I didn’t sleep much; I was too afraid to sleep. I didn’t let my wife or daughter sleep. People died when they slept. People lay down to sleep and never woke up. My daughter got pneumonia there; she died a week later. A month later and 300 miles away from there, my wife died from the pox.
“Captain Charles Lexington led my group. A meaner man never lived. He forced a young girl named Tadpole Crowe to be his woman. Once relocation was completed, he left her. Six months later, she bore a child and she called him, Charlie Three Feathers, she didn’t want him to have the bastard’s last name. He must have taken after his daddy anyway because I hear he is a mean son-of-bitch.” He stopped talking and his eyes grew sad as he blankly stared into the fire.
“Four thousand Tsalagi died on the trail. My wife and daughter along with all the others,” pausing he continued. “You call it the Trail of Tears we call it Nu Na da ul tsun yi--, the place where they cried.” Buffalo Head stopped talking. He sat there in silence and neither Meeker nor Tanner knew what to say. After a long silence, the trio threw the nearly bare bones of their dinner into the fire.
“I seen me a blue jay fight a bear once,” Meeker spoke then thought better of it. “Oh, nobody wants to hear that story.”
“I do,” Buffalo Head, told him turning his eyes toward the man. Meeker’s bright blue eyes seemed almost red in the light of the campfire. The firelight dancing in his eyes was an eerie sight to Michelle.
“Well sir, this bear wandered over near where a blue jay had a nest. That momma blue jay must have been the bravest little bird ever...” Meeker told his story then ended it as usual. “Like I said Damndest thing I ever did see; that big old bear; running away with that little bird; diving down at its head.” Meeker laughed aloud. “Now that is how I remember it, accuracy is not ensured.”
“I think you should take up writing Dime Novels. You would get rich!” Buffalo Head then nestled against his saddle. “Well I think I will try and sleep now.”
“How can you not want to murder us in our sleep; after what you just told us?” Michelle asked.
“I ask God one time if I could kill all the whites I could find. He said, “No.” I asked Him if I could hurt them then. He said, “No.” I ask Him if I could hate them, just let me hate them I told Him and I will follow all the other rules. He said, “No I say you can break all the other rules as long as you forgive them.” So, I did. I didn’t want to but I did. Still I don’t break many rules.” Meeker heard the words but he did not like the meaning. Meeker wore his hate like his buckskin, right next to his skin.
An hour after they settled in for the night they heard gunfire. There were five or six gunshots over the period of several minutes.
To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account
(Why register?)
* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.