Chapter 5

The rest of the school day was a blur. My afternoon classes felt endless. The worst part? I still had to sit next to Mayumi. She didn’t say a word, not a single glance. My mind couldn’t shake the images from the bathhouse. She’d just had sex with eight boys. A faint scent of cum clung to her, a constant reminder of what had occurred.

I couldn’t take it anymore. So, I whispered, my voice shaking slightly. “Mayumi, are you ... alright?”

Her smile was dazzling, genuine. “Oh, Joe-kun, I’ve never felt better. But physically, I’m a bit ... sore.” She leaned into me, her voice dropping to a whisper. “But it’s a good sore, you know? The kind that reminds me of the first night I had sex.”

“I’m sorry, Mayumi. I just fucked up, okay?” I couldn’t help but said sorry. “You don’t have to do all of this, really.”

“This isn’t about you. This is about me,” Mayumi whispered back, her eyes glinting with a strange excitement. “With all the sex I am provided at home, I’ve just never had a chance to try so many different cocks before. I always wanted to try this, you just pointed it out to me.”

Her words were like a slap in the face, but I knew she was right. I had pushed her to this point.

Baseball practice after school was no escape. I moved through the drills on autopilot, my mind miles away, still stuck on the massage table and the long line of faceless guys. What if she found a new thrill in this? The terrifying thought that she might actually enjoy being gangbanged, might get hooked on it, was a nightmare I couldn’t wake up from. Let alone hundreds of cocks, seeing her take just two at home was already unbearable.

As I got home, I pushed open the front door, expecting an empty house, but the quiet of the entrance hall was quickly broken by familiar voices. Hana and Yuki were in the living room, looking up as I entered, their faces a mix of concern and something I couldn’t quite place. My eyes also found Mayumi and Sena, they were there too.

Then, I heard my dad’s voice from inside the house. “Joe,” he called out, his tone serious. “We need to talk.”

I walked into the living room, feeling the weight of everyone’s gaze. My dad sat on a kitchen chair, his expression unreadable.

“Sit down.” He gestured to the spot in front of him.

I did as told. The silence stretched, thick and uncomfortable.

“Sena told me what happened at the bathhouse today,” my dad said. He glanced at Mayumi, then back to me. “What’s going on between you two?”

I took a deep breath, trying to organize my thoughts. “I made a mistake, Dad. I said some things to Mayumi that I shouldn’t have. It escalated into...”

“No, he didn’t do anything wrong,” Mayumi spoke up, her voice smooth. “How many people I have sex with is none of Joe-kun’s business. It can never be his fault.”

“But ... but it’s like you two have been playing a kind of game? It’s like you’re always trying to push each other, to hurt each other, and we’re always caught in the middle.” Yuki spoke up, her voice trembling slightly. Hana nodded. “Please, just stop it. It’s making everyone feel bad.”

“Game?” My dad’s brow furrowed. “What game?”

Mayumi’s eyes shimmered with mischief. “Oh, you know, Jin-ojisan. The one where Joe-kun tries to be the moral police and I try to get him to loosen up.”

“It’s not about the morality. It is because you were teasing me. You were teasing me like you did to Kenji. And I just want you to approach me the other way around.” I replied, my voice tight with frustration.

“Is that why you went on that date with the twins?” Mayumi asked, a hint of accusation in her voice. “Tried to make me frustrate? To make some kind of point?”

Yuki stepped closer. “Joe-kun,” she began, “Did you really go out with us just to get back at Mayumi?”

I felt the heat rising in my cheeks. “No, of course not. I went because ... because I really like you and want to spend time with you. I really want to make you feel good.”

“Really?” Mayumi scoffed, pushing off the sofa to stand. “How many times have you two gone out with him? But Joe-kun is still too chicken to actually fuck you. Why? Because he’s just using you to make me jealous!”

“That’s a lie!” Yuki cried, her voice rising, stepping forward to stand shoulder-to-shoulder with her sister. “He already said that he cares about us! Mayumi, you’re just mad because he had a better time with us while he was suffering being around you!”

Mayumi’s eyes narrowed to slits. “Suffering? Please. He’s suffering because he’s a coward!”

With a sudden, swift movement, Yuki lunged, her hand shooting out to slap Mayumi across the face.

A sharp crack echoed in the room. Mayumi staggered back, clutching her cheek, her eyes blazing with shock and then pure rage. She let out a furious cry and launched herself at Yuki, tackling her. The two tumbled onto the floor, a flurry of limbs and angry shouts. Hair was pulled, clothes rustled, and the sounds of muffled thuds filled the air.

“Get off her, you little bitch!” Hana’s voice pierced as she join they fray, throwing herself onto the piles. Now it was a tangled mess of three screaming girls, rolling and clawing on the living room floor.

“Enough!” My dad’s roar ripped through the room. He dived into the tangle of limbs. With powerful grips, he separated them, pulling Mayumi and Yuki apart with one arm each. The living room was silent again, save for the ragged breathing of the girls.

“What the hell is going on here?” my dad demanded, his eyes flashing. “This is my house, I demand some respect!”

“Joe,” my dad’s voice boomed. The room went quiet as I looked into his furious gaze. “You’re the one causing all this trouble,” he said, his voice a thunderclap in the suddenly silent room.

“What do you mean, Dad?” I managed to ask.

“I’m going to ask you some questions, and I expect you to answer them truthfully. Can you do?” My dad’s tone was firm, leaving no room for argument.

I nodded, swallowing the lump in my throat. “Yes, Dad.”

“Good,” he said, his eyes still blazing. “Now tell me, Joe. Do you want to have sex with Mayumi?”

The question hung in the air, heavy and charged. I felt everyone’s eyes on me, but I focused solely on my dad’s. “Yes,” I said.

“Do you want to go out with her?” my dad pressed on.

“Well, I don’t have to ‘want to’ because we already live together like a family. I go to school with her, see her, talk, and have dinner with her every day,” I said, trying to keep my voice steady. “I have to say that she did tease me a lot, but honestly, I’ve never felt like I was suffering around her.”

Mayumi’s expression shifted from anger to surprise, then to something else entirely. It was as if a weight had been lifted from her shoulders. She gave me a warm smile, the first genuine one I had seen from her in what felt like forever.

“That’s good, Joe.” My dad’s voice remained firm, but there was a hint of understanding in his eyes. “Now, the next question. Since you’re already going out with Yuki and Hana, so the question are: do you want to, and will you, have sex with them?”

“Yes,” I replied, turning to the twins. “Yuki, Hana, I have to admit that when I first heard about your body count, it shocked me. But that was solely because I grew up with the outside world’s moral standards. After I ruled that out, it means nothing to me. I don’t care if I’ll be your twenty-fifth or twenty-sixth or a thousandth. I still want to have sex with you. I still want to date Yuki, and share you with Hana’s boyfriends. I want to explore my feelings and learn how they can align with this village’s culture.”

Dad nodded, his face appreciative. “And how about Sena? She’s a good girl. She’s been waiting for a chance with you. Would you consider having sex with her?”

I took a deep breath, turning to Sena. “Sena, you’re a very cute girl and you’ve turned out to be a really good friend to me, and to Dad too. I’ve wanted to have sex with you since the first time we met. After you hooked up with Dad, I was afraid that my virgin skills could never match his. I hope you’re still willing to give me a chance.”

Sena looked at me, nodding slowly, her cheeks flushing.

My dad then turned his gaze to Mayumi.

“Mayumi,” he began, his voice softening slightly, “What about you? How do you feel about Joe and what he just said?”

Mayumi met his gaze, then mine. Her cheeks were still flushed, but her eyes held a vulnerability I hadn’t seen before.

“Honestly, Jin-ojisan,” she said, her voice quiet, “I’m ... surprised. And a little relieved, I think.” She took a deep breath, her breasts rising and falling with the motion. “Since Joe arrived, I couldn’t help but think about him. My pussy is the worst; it ran wet every time I was around him. So, I’ve been trying hard to get him to give in, but with the wrong approach. I regret that now.” She then stared at me, her eyes searching. “Joe-kun, I’m sorry for being such a bitch. I promise to treat you better from now on. Please, be kind to me.”