Chapter 6

As he approaches his house, he sees Kara sitting on the porch, her arms crossed, her expression thunderous. Shit. She knows.

“Hey, sis,” he says, walking up the path.

“Don’t ‘hey, sis’ me, Jay,” she snaps, standing up.

“Where the hell have you been? I’ve been calling and texting you all night!”

Jay winces, knowing he’s in for a lecture. “I’m sorry, sis. I fell asleep at Gabriella’s house.”

Kara’s eyes narrow, and she crosses her arms. “Fell asleep? Or were you two up all night screwing like rabbits?”

Jay feels his cheeks heat up, and he looks down at the ground. “We didn’t screw, Kara. We just fell asleep, I swear,” Jay replies, still avoiding her gaze.

Kara snorts, shaking her head. “Yeah, right. You expect me to believe that you just happened to fall asleep at Gabriella’s house? After everything you promised me?”

Jay winces, knowing he’s in deep shit now. “I know I messed up. But it just happened, okay? It wasn’t planned.”

Kara rolls her eyes, throwing her hands up in frustration.

“Jay, I don’t know what to believe anymore. One minute you’re telling me you have my back, and the next you’re screwing my best friend.”

Jay looks at Kara, his eyes pleading with her. “Kara, it was a mistake, I swear. I love you, and I never meant to hurt you.”

Kara looks away, trying to contain her emotions. “Well, now you have. I trusted you, and you betrayed that trust.”

Jay takes a step closer to Kara, reaching out to grasp her hand. She tenses involuntarily, but it’s too late, as Jay pulls her into a ferocious kiss. Her mouth is hesitant at first, but she eventually lets her guard down, wrapping her arms around Jay’s waist and giving in to the passion that’s been building between them.

Their bodies are pressed together, as Jay’s hardened cock is grinding against Kara’s thigh. She moans into his mouth, clutching at his shirt and tugging him closer. She breaks the kiss and pushes him back.

“Your ‘girlfriend’ is inside,” Kara tells him as she tries to maintain her look of anger.

“She’s been waiting for you.”

Jay smirks, licking his lips. “Oh, I bet she has. She’s probably been waiting for me to fuck her brains out.”

Kara scoffs, rolling her eyes. “You’re disgusting, Jay.”

He chuckles, taking a step closer to her. “Maybe. But you still want me, don’t you?”

She swallows hard, her eyes flicking down to his lips. “No.”

He leans in, his voice low and husky. “Liar. I can see it in your eyes, Kara”.

He playfully swats her bum and heads into the house. He finds Gabriella in the living room sat on the couch.

“I never told her,” Gabriella says, standing up to meet him “I told her you slept on the couch and she didn’t believe it”.

She steps closer to him, her voice dropping to a low, sultry whisper. “But I don’t care. All I care about is you, Jay. About us.”

He grabs her hips, pulling her flush against him. “Fuck, Gabby. I thought I was going to have to fight Kara to get back here.”

She laughs, her hands sliding up his chest. “You’re such an idiot. But I’m glad you’re here.”

He captures her lips in a searing kiss, his tongue pushing into her mouth. She moans, her body melting into his.

“What the FUCK do you two think you’re doing?” Kara asks.

They break the kiss and turn to see her standing in the living room doorway, hands on her hips and an angry look on her face.

Jay and Gabriella exchange a guilty look, but before they can say anything, Kara storms into the room.

“What the actual fuck, Jay? You’re not supposed to be fucking my best friend!” she yells, her voice shaking with anger.

Jay holds up his hands in surrender. “Kara, calm down. It’s not what it looks like.”

Gabriella rolls her eyes. “Oh, please. Don’t bother lying to her, Jay. She’s not stupid.”

Kara glares at Gabriella. “Stay out of this, Gabby.

This is between me and my brother,” Kara snaps, her eyes never leaving Jay’s.

Jay sighs, running a hand through his hair. “Look, Kara, I’m sorry. Okay? I never meant for this to happen.”

Kara scoffs, crossing her arms. “You expect me to believe that? You’ve been sneaking around with her behind my back for God knows how long!”

Gabriella steps forward, her voice firm. “Kara, listen to me. This isn’t Jay’s fault. It’s mine; all mine. I came onto him and seduced him”.

She turned to Jay, her eyes filled with tears. “I’m sorry, Kara. I never meant to hurt you.”

Kara looked between the two of them, her expression softening. She took a deep breath, her shoulders slumping. “I don’t know what to say, guys. I’m ... I’m hurt. Betrayed. But I also understand. I know how persuasive Gabriella can be.”

Jay stepped forward, taking Kara’s hand. “Kara, I’m so sorry. I never meant to hurt you. And I promise, it won’t happen again,” Jay pleaded, his thumb brushing over Kara’s knuckles.

Kara looked at him, her eyes searching his face. She then turned to Gabriella, who stood there with tears streaming down her cheeks. “And you ... you’re my best friend. How could you do this to me?”

Gabriella sniffled, wiping her nose with the back of her hand. “I never meant for this to happen. But ... I can’t help how I feel about Jay.” Gabriella’s voice trembled, her eyes begging for forgiveness. Kara looked between the two of them, her expression conflicted. Then, she did something unexpected. She laughed. A harsh, bitter laugh that cut through the tension in the room.

“You know what? Fine. Go ahead, fuck each other’s brains out. Just don’t expect me to be okay with it anytime soon.” With that, she stormed out of the room, leaving Jay and Gabriella staring at each other in shock.

Gabriella turned to Jay, her eyes filled with a mix of fear and excitement.

“Do you think she means it? Will she really be okay with this?” Gabriella asked

Jay shrugged, his mind already elsewhere. “Who knows? But right now, I don’t give a fuck. I am with you, Gabby. My sister does not dictate who I can date”.

Jay says, turning to Gabriella. “She’ll come around, eventually. But for now, I don’t want to waste any more time arguing about this. I want you, Gabby. Right here, right now.”

Gabriella’s eyes widen, but she doesn’t hesitate. She lunges at him, their mouths crashing together in a fierce, passionate kiss. Jay grabs her ass, lifting her up and wrapping her legs around his waist. She grinds against him, moaning into his mouth as she feels his hardness pressing against her.

“Fuck, Jay,” she gasps, breaking the kiss “I want this so fucking much; but my mom knows I’m here”.

Jay nods, remembering that she only came over to explain to Kara that Jay did not sleep with her.

“I’d better go,” Gabriella says, kissing Jay gently “If you survive World War Kara, let me know”.

He walks her to the door, his eyes constantly staring at her bum through her jeans.

“Bye,” she says with a wave as she opens the door.

“Bye,” Joseph replies with a smile.

When she’s gone and closed the door; Jay turns to find Kara standing in the hallway, arms crossed, and a stern look on her face.

“World War Kara, huh?” she says, raising an eyebrow.

Jay shrugs, trying to play it cool. “She’s exaggerating. You know how dramatic she gets.”

Kara snorts, uncrossing her arms. “I know you’re fucking her, Jay. And I know you’re going to keep doing it, despite what I said earlier.”

“Kara, I’m sorry. I really am. But I can’t just stop seeing her”.

Jay says, his voice barely above a whisper.

Kara’s eyes flash with anger, but she keeps her voice steady. “You can, and you will. Or else, Jay. Or else, I swear to god...”

Jay steps closer to her, his voice low and dangerous. “Or else what, Kara? What are you going to do? Tell Mom? Ground me? I’m not a kid any more, Kara. I can make my own decisions.”

Kara’s breath hitches as Jay crowds her space, her heart pounding in her chest.

She knows she should stand her ground, put her foot down, but the way he’s looking at her, with that hungry, predatory gleam in his eyes, has her insides clenching with desire.

“Or else what, Kara?” Jay repeats, his voice a low growl. His hands grip her hips, pulling her flush against him. She can feel his erection pressing into her stomach, and she can’t help but whimper.

“Jay...” she warns, her voice a stern even tone “You can’t fuck my best friend WHILE YOU’RE ALSO FUCKING ME”.

Her eyes narrow, her gaze intense. “That’s not how this works, Jay.”

Jay smirks, his hands sliding up her sides, tracing the curve of her breasts through her shirt. “Oh yeah? And how does this work then, Kara?” His thumbs brush against her nipples, making them harden instantly.

Kara swallows hard, trying to maintain her composure. “It works like this,” she says, grabbing his wrists and pushing his hands away. “You stop fucking Gabriella. You choose. Me or her.”

Jay chuckles, a low, dirty sound that is a challenge to Kara’s demand.

“And if I don’t choose, Kara? What then?” he asks.

Kara’s response is swift and unexpected. She grabs Jay by the collar, pulling him down to her level, and crushes her lips against his in a fierce, passionate kiss. Jay stumbles back, caught off guard, but quickly recovers, his hands gripping her ass and pulling her flush against him.

Their tongues clash and tangle, teeth clicking together in their urgency. Kara can taste the faint remnants of coffee on his tongue, and it spurs her on, making her kiss him harder, deeper.

“And if I don’t choose, Kara? What then?” he asks, breaking the kiss and repeating his question “What will you do then?”.

She steps back, her tone a simple yet defiant one as she says “That’s simple; I’ll let Uncle Joseph put his hands on my body...”.

She removed her t-shirt, revealing her naked breasts. She removes her tracksuit bottoms revealing that she is not wearing any underwear.

“So you choose dear brother,” Kara says, putting her hands on her hips “What is it to be dear brother?; Will you give up fucking my best friend or continue and let Uncle Joseph have his way with me”.

Her voice is calm, collected, but Jay can see the fire burning in her eyes.

Jay looks at her, taking in her naked form, her breasts heaving with every breath she takes. He can feel his cock throbbing in his pants, aching to be inside her. He knows he should choose, should put an end to this madness, but he can’t. He won’t.

He steps closer to her, his voice a low growl. “You’d really go there just to stop me from sleeping with your best friend?”.

“Yes,” Kara replies in a tone that is firm “Now choose; me or Gabby; and remember what will happen if you don’t choose me”.

Her eyes blaze with determination and something else, something darker, more primal.

Jay feels a surge of lust at the sight of her, standing there, naked and confident, her body flushed with arousal. He knows he should choose, should put an end to this twisted game they’re playing, but he can’t. Not now. Not with her looking at him like that.

He takes a step closer, his voice a low rumble. “And what if I want both?”

Kara’s eyes widen slightly, surprise flickering across her face before she schools her expression. “Both?

Jay, what the hell are you talking about?” Kara’s voice is a mix of shock and excitement, her breath coming in short gasps.

Jay grins, a wicked, predatory smile that sends shivers down Kara’s spine. “I mean exactly what I said, sis. I want both. I want you, and I want Gabriella.”

Kara’s eyes narrow, but Jay can see the spark of interest in them. “And how do you propose we make that happen, hmm?”

“Simple,” Jay replies while his gaze roams over his sister’s naked form “You drop any objections to me and Gabriella fucking and in return, I’ll sleep with you every night I’m not at hers”.

He smirks “Think of it as a win-win situation”.

Kara’s eyes flash with anger, but Jay can see the hunger in them too. She wants this, wants him, and she knows it.

“Fine,” she hisses “But you better make it worth my while, brother”.

Jay grins, his cock throbbing at the challenge in her voice. “Oh, I will, sis. I promise you that”.

He reaches out, cupping her breast in his hand, squeezing it gently. Kara gasps, her nipple hardening under his touch. He leans down and starts kissing and licking her tits gently.