Chapter 6

It was the night of Halloween, and Gordon was home passing out candy to the local trick or treaters. This was something he always enjoyed doing, encouraging the next generation to have as much fun as he did at their age. With everything going on, he didn’t have the time to decorate the front of his house. He just put a pumpkin on his step and had his front porch light on, the local signal that he had candy.

He hadn’t been able to talk to Kelsey about what had happened a couple of weeks earlier. When they went to school that next Monday, Kelsey acted as she normally did the prior weeks. He wasn’t sure if she regretted what happened or just wanted to keep up the act of staying apart. In either case, he was confused but had to wait for her to make the next move. He was also curious about what she told her parents when she got home. Did she tell them where she was and with whom? If it was anyone but Kelsey, he’d have expected the cops to break down his door later that same day, but of course, that didn’t happen.

As the evening progressed, the darkness descended along with the amount of candy he had left. There was only enough for a few more kids, but the frequency of the doorbell ringing had decreased significantly. He was about to retire for the evening and turn off his light when he heard the ding of the bell. He picked up the bowl and opened the door. He found a ghost, Iron Man, and a witch wearing a mask.

“Trick or treat!” they all shouted.

“Don’t you all look great. I’m about to stop for the night, so here’s some for the spooky ghost,” Gordon said, divvying up a third of the remainder to the ghost, before he ran off to meet his parents.

“ ... and here’s some for Iron Man, thank you for protecting us tonight.” And gave him a third of the candy before he took off down the pathway.

“ ... and here’s the rest for the scary witch,” he said, putting the rest of the bowl into a small bag. He leaned down and blew out his pumpkin, but when he stood up, he saw that the witch was still standing there.

“Is something wrong,” he asked. She looked a bit old to be trick or treating but had assumed she was a guardian of one of the other kids. “I don’t have any more candy.”

“Trick or treat!” the female voice reiterated, with a gravelly tone.

“I’m sorry, I don’t have anything else. You seem a bit old to be doing this, don’t you think?” he asked, slightly concerned.

“I want a different type of treat, Gordon.” The voice said before catching him off guard and shoving him into his house, shutting the door.

“What do you think you’re DOING!” Gordon said, shocked and nervous.

“Getting my treats,” the witch said, running her hands over his body. Gordon, in an attempt to break free of the stranger’s advances, lifted his hands up and knocked her pointy hat off, revealing a head of bright red hair.

“KELSEY!” he yelled, annoyed and relieved at the same time.

She took off her mask and then fell to the floor in hysterics, “You should have seen your face! You looked so freaked out,” she said between bouts of laughter.

“Well, yeah! I thought I was about to get stabbed or robbed.”

Slow to get up off the floor, Kelsey wiped away her tears from laughing. “I told you I’d be back. I just wasn’t sure when. Halloween gave me the perfect excuse to go out, so I made my way here. Do you like my costume?”

“You look very scary,” Gordon replied, his heart rate finally returning to normal.

“Scary? I was going for a sexy witch. Maybe I should take off this poncho thing. Are your blinds closed?” Kelsey asked with a mischievous tone.

“No, hold on,” Gordon said before turning off his front porch light and shutting his blinds. “Ok, it’s safe now.” He said, as his mouth went dry.

Kelsey turned away from Gordon. Her hands reached the bottom of her witch outfit and slowly teasingly raised it up. He watched her show off her legs, then thighs, and finally, a small pair of black lace panties appeared, encasing her tight little ass. The garment kept going, over her lower back, until a black bra was revealed, and the costume was pulled over her red hair and tossed onto the ground. Kelsey turned around, her hands on her hips as Gordon took in the sight of her sexy young body.

“I see that you still like what you see. Can we take this somewhere else, though?” Kelsey took his hand and led him towards his bedroom. When they entered, Kelsey put her arms around him and kissed him lustfully on the lips, “I had such a hard time waiting for this. I knew if I talked to you too much at school, I’d lose it,” she said, as she pulled at his shirt.

“I didn’t know what you wanted. I thought you may have decided this was a bad idea. I’m glad I was wrong,” Gordon replied, taking the girl’s ass in his hands.

“We only have a couple of hours before my parents expect me back, so let’s get those pants off.”

In a couple of quick motions, she undid his fly and yanked down his pants and boxers. He stepped out of them, leaving Kelsey wearing the only piece of clothing for the moment. Gordon reached behind her back and easily unsnapped the light bra she wore. Her small breasts with pink puffy nipples were released, Gordon bent down and nibbled them.

Kelsey carefully lay down on the bed, bringing a suckling Gordon with her. He lay on top of her small body, trying not to put down too much weight for fear of crushing her. Kelsey actually enjoyed the feeling of her teacher on top of her. It was something she’d dreamed about for years, and now it was coming true.

“I love what you’re doing, Gordon,” she moaned, “but I want more.”

Getting the hint, he reluctantly let go of her cute nipples and moved down her body. His target was the last stitch of clothing remaining on either of them, her black lacy panties. His mouth made contact with the top of the frilly material. He took it in his teeth and pulled it down with his mouth. Kelsey’s butt lifted up, and it easily slid down her legs and off her feet, where it fell to the floor.

Her legs were slightly spread open, her pussy covered with a dusting of fine ginger fur. He could see a bit of her soft pink interior and it called to him. Last time he hesitated to touch her. This time he decided to dive right in. His face slipped between her legs, spreading them open further as he went. He could smell the sweet, dripping excitement coming from her. It was a pheromonal attraction, his biological brain said, but inches from her wet sex, all he wanted to do was taste her.

He stuck out his tongue and gathered a drop of her dew and drew it into his mouth. She tasted divine, like ambrosia, the nectar of the Greek Gods. His mouth dove in, drinking as much as it could from her aroused body. His tongue snaked along her slit, dipping into her tight hole to pull out more to devour.

At the first touch of his tongue, Kelsey’s body was on fire. Her legs spread wide apart, opening herself up for his mouth to lick as much as it could. Her head snapped back as waves of pleasure radiated through her body. She’d never felt anything like this before! It was miles better than when she touched herself at night or in the shower. She looked down and saw his nose pressed up against her thin ginger bush, his eyes locked onto hers, as he ate her pussy.

“Oh my God, Gordon. That feels so good!” she cried out, one of her hands rubbed her tits while the other tangled itself in his hair, holding onto him for dear life.

Gordon attached his mouth to her small pink clitoris and started lightly chewing and flicking it with his tongue. The moans and groans it produced, told him he was on the right track. Her thighs would open and close on his head, and her pussy seemed to be overflowing with wetness. He’d let his tongue occasionally roam back down to dip into her bubbling honeypot before returning to her sensitive pink bundle of nerve endings.

Kelsey was having a hard time breathing, her pulse rate was skyrocketing, and her eyes couldn’t focus anymore. All she could feel was the unbelievable pleasure coursing through her body. Suddenly, her whole body arched and lifted off the bed. She screamed but no sound was heard, as explosions and fireworks burst from her body. She had a releasing sensation like she had never felt before. After several glorious seconds, her body collapsed on the bed, as she tried to catch her breath.

Gordon watched the whole display as his mouth and face were squirted with a warm fluid from deep in the girl’s body. He now knew that she was a squirter and was amazed at her display. He drank up as much as he could, before he climbed up the resting girl and kissed her.

Kelsey knew she was tasting her own pussy juice but didn’t care. He had given her the strongest orgasm of her young life. She pulled him down onto her to continue their embrace, feeling his hard cock against her leg. She was now certain that she knew what she wanted tonight and hoped he would be willing to give it to her.

“That was incredible, Gordon. I’ve never felt anything like that before. Now I know why you’re called Mr. O.,” she said with a giggle.

“I’m glad you enjoyed it. I wanted to return the favor after what you did the last time you were here.”

“My legs are still shaking,” she said, looking down at them. “Everything feels wet. Was that me?”

“Yup, you soaked the bed. Looks like you’re a squirter, Kelsey. It’s the first time I’ve ever made someone do that!”

“Sorry, I didn’t know. I didn’t mean to make a mess. When we’re done, I’ll help you clean up.”

“That’s ok, don’t worry about it. It was really sexy anyway,” he said, kissing her softly as she recovered.

“Gordon, there’s something else I want you to do tonight,” she said, looking in his eyes.

“Anything. Whatever you want, just name it.”

“I want you to be my first, tonight,” Kelsey said, before kissing him.

“Are you sure? That’s a big deal.”

“I am. I was 95% sure on the way here and after all this, I want to give myself to you.”

“Well, if you are certain,” he said. He reached for the nightstand, “Let me just get a condom.”

“I don’t want you to use one. I want to feel you inside me naturally, for my first time.”

“Kelsey, that’s a bad idea. I don’t want to risk you getting pregnant.”

“I won’t. My mom put me on the pill when I started seeing Austin. It led to another fight with my father, but I’m protected,” she said, with a lustful glow in her eyes.

“But it isn’t 100% effective and then there are diseases...” he tried to say when she stopped him.

“I know all the risks, Gord. Please, at least just tonight, do this for me.”

As much as he tried, he couldn’t say no to her. He simply nodded in agreement. As he climbed between her legs, his cock was as hard as steel. She parted her legs as far as she could, allowing him full access to penetrate her and take her virginity. He looked down between them, past her fine red hair, and saw her still dripping pussy with his cock just above it. He reached down and rubbed his cock against the interior of her slit, coating it in her slippery lubrication, before lining it up at her untouched entrance.

“Are you sure about this, Kels?” he asked, looking into her green eyes.

“I am, Gord. I want you to know, I love you,” she said, kissing him.

“I think ... I love you too,” he replied, nervously stumbling over his words.

Unsure how much it would hurt, Kelsey bit her lower lip as she waited for him to enter her for her first time. Gordon, seeing this, ran his hand over her head, pushing her hair behind her ear before smiling at her, trying to get her to relax. He knew it might be worse if she was too tense. She gave a little smile before nodding her head for him to start.

Gordon was now the one who was nervous. Not only was he about to take Kelsey’s virginity, a girl he’d had fantasies about for years, but also he was about to do it without a condom. This would be a first for Gord himself, as no one he’d ever been with would let him put even the head in without protection. With his cock poised at her entrance, he was worried he’d finish too fast and ruin her first time.

He couldn’t tell if she had anything left of her hymen. He didn’t notice it when he was going down on her, but he thought he should go in slowly, just in case. He leaned down and kissed her once more before slowly pushing his cock into her virgin vagina. The first inch went in easily. She was tight, but didn’t indicate any discomfort. She just looked up at him, with a little smile, while still biting her lower lip.

Even as shallow as he was, Gordon could feel how soaking wet the girl was. It was a night and day difference from using a condom. He could feel her wetness and all the little ridges inside her. He moved a bit deeper, pushing another inch into her. Her pussy started gripping him now as he moved a third inch into her. He looked at her face, she was no longer biting her lip, her mouth was open slightly and her eyes were closed.

“Are you ok? Do you want me to stop?” Gordon asked, concerned he was hurting her.

“No, I’m ok. It just feels ... full, in there,” she said in almost a whisper. “Keep going, please.”

Gordon thought about just ripping the band aid off and pushing it all into her in one stroke but decided against it. He never wanted to hurt her and didn’t want to risk ruining this moment for her. He pushed another inch inside her, giving her over half of his 7 and a half inches. She was starting to get really tight the deeper he went, and he had to push a little harder to get inside her, despite how wet she was. He was amazed at the heat from her pussy that encased his rod. It felt like he had his cock in a toaster oven.