Chapter 7: The Contests

It was rather interesting that so far the only one of us that had undressed at all was Beth and she was just bottomless. So much for your stereotypes about Truth or Dare games! For a few moments we all just sat around as if unsure of how to go on to whatever we were going to next. Beth had apparently expected the game to go in a different direction but now that it had ended on such a strange note, it was like everything she had planned needed to be reinvented. Well, leave it to Beth to be the first to make a move.

“Tell you what Kelly, I bet I can make your boyfriend cum faster than you can make mine,” she challenged me.

I looked at her with a rather bewildered look while the two guys grinned from ear-to-ear. Now THAT was a new one for me. Sure I’d gotten pretty good by now, learning how to either speed up or slow down a guy when sucking him, depending on my mood at the moment, but I’d never done it as any form of contest before.

“What’s the matter, afraid I’ll beat you?” she teased me.

Well, I wasn’t going to sit back and let her bash my cock-sucking skills. She may have fucked more guys than me but I was willing to bet I’d sucked more dicks than she had. In fact, I was rather proud of my ever-growing reputation at school.

“Watch ... and learn,” I responded rather egotistically.

Turning to Bill, I huffed and pointed at his pants, saying, “Well, what are you waiting for? Do you want me to suck your cock or not?”

Both Bill and John stripped off their jeans as fast as they can. I noticed they both wore the same underwear - Hanes jockey shorts. I ALSO noticed that both pairs of underwear were having a hard time restraining their wonderful erections! It would be interesting to see how their cocks compared and in a few more seconds I got my first look. Actually, they both looked quite similar. Neither of them had a future in the porn industry as their cocks were average at best, but what they lacked in size was certainly compensated for in terms of stiffness.

What was amusing, at least to me, was the way they both stripped off their pants without ever once looking at the other guy. Sheesh, once again I had to wonder what was it with guys that they were so self-conscious of another guy’s dick? It’s not like they didn’t all have one after all. Neither had anything to boast about but then, neither did they have to be embarrassed. I had certainly sucked more than a lot of cocks that were a lot smaller than theirs.

Both guys stood up and faced their assigned contestant. I’d never sucked a cock in front of another guy before, especially not one I was dating at the time. Well, technically that wasn’t 100% true as my dad would sometimes peak in my bedroom when I was blowing a guy without him knowing it; but I knew he was just checking up on me so that really didn’t count.

“Ready?” I asked Beth as I kneeled in front of her boyfriend.

Beth had taken a position in front of John. She hadn’t bothered putting her jeans back on or taking anything else off. I had to admit she looked really cute kneeling in front of my boyfriend with her bare ass sticking out behind her.

“I’m ALWAYS ready to suck a cock,” she teased in return.

That was good enough for me. I reached out and took Bill’s dick in my hand and then took it in my mouth as quickly as possible. Usually when I give a blowjob I like to play with his cock a little, run my hands around it and let my fingertips glide up and down the hard shaft, my fingernails just barely touching him. Then I would use my tongue and tease the tip of his dick and lick his shaft and balls, taking in the musky odor of his crotch like the scent of the forest after a rain.

Not so today! Not generally a “hand” girl, I prefer to rely on my mouth and tongue to make a guy come. It’s a little slower but then usually I’m not in such a hurry either. Today I was giving the hand job AND the mouth job at the same time, stroking his shaft with my hand while my mouth worked the upper portions of his dick, especially the head. I loved to run my tongue under the lip, feeling the soft smoothness of his cock head in my mouth against my lips.

“Damn Kelly, you’re good!” Bill gasped as I worked his cock.

I glanced over at where Beth was sucking my boyfriend, just in time to see her glare at Bill for making such a comment about a girl other than her.

“Hey, your girlfriend’s not so bad herself,” I heard John say back to Bill. Bastard, what was he doing complimenting another girl’s BJ right in front of me? He knew how protective I was about my reputation so he must’ve been saying it just to tease me. Oh well, I guess I could live with him fibbing a little to make Beth happy.

I was actually starting to feel a little dizzy as it was hard to breath while I was bobbing up and down on Bill’s dick so fast. I felt his hands on the back of my head, pulling me into him more and I knew just what he wanted. Pausing a second to catch a breath, I let go of his dick and started to take him into my mouth completely. He wasn’t THAT huge so I was sure that I would be able to get him all in and sure enough, my lips bottomed out against the hairy base of his dick and my face was buried in the thick pubic hair that formed around his crotch.

“Oh shit, that’s it, take it all,” he groaned as I twisted my head around his hard shaft. God he smelled and tasted so good! If someone could only figure out how to bottle the musky scent of a guy’s crotch during sex, I’d be first in line to buy a case of it!

Bill grabbed my head and held it still while he started fucking my mouth. His hips swung back and forth as he rammed his cock all the way into my mouth and then pulled back until just the head was between my lips. A couple of time he really pushed it in hard and I thought I might gag but he was doing it so fast that before anything bad could happen he was already out of my throat on a backstroke.

“Shit, I’ve always wanted to do this,” he said, almost like a growl escaping him.

I had no idea of Beth was watching or had heard what he said as it took all my concentration to take his thrusts. It was like he was banging my pussy the way he was fucking my mouth. Deep, fast stroked that slammed his crotch into my face. This was less a blowjob than it was a face fuck but hey, if it got the desired results, I was all for it!

As horny as Bill was, combined with the excitement of deep-throat fucking me, it was amazing he held out as long as he did. There are days when I like to lay on the couch next to a guy with my head on his lap and just suck his cock slowly for hours while we watch a movie or TV. Today wasn’t one of those days!

“Oh god, I’m cumming!” he gasped.

I’d fully expected him to ram his dick in my mouth as far as he could and I was actually worried for a moment that I might choke or gag when he came given how far his dick was in my mouth. It turned out to be a needless worry. I don’t know if he did it for himself or just to tease Beth, but regardless of the reason, he pulled out of my mouth and started spraying his cum all over me, like a firehouse that had been let loose and was spraying all over the place. The first shot almost missed me it was so forceful but I could feel it land on the top of my head and could only imagine the mess it was already making in my hair. From there he splattered my blouse right over my boobs, my face, and one random shot finally made it to my outstretched tongue. To my chagrin, almost all of it ended up somewhere on me BESIDES my mouth.

“Crap Billy, couldn’t you have held out a LITTLE while at least?” Beth whined.

I looked over and she was stroking John almost absentmindedly, a look of disgust on her face as her eyes bored holes into her boyfriend who had just cum all over her best friend. It wasn’t the fact he came on me that she was pissed off about, it was the fact he came so fast and she lost her bet with me. Like me, Beth hated to lose which is probably one reason we seldom competed directly head to head (no pun intended).

“Sorry babe,” Bill said sheepishly as he shrugged his shoulders and lifted his hands up. “You know, your friend gives one HELL of a BJ!”

“Hey, you gonna finish mine or what?” John complained. Who could blame him as everyone seemed to be more worried about Bill than him.

“Well, now that you’ve done him, how about getting over here and help me get your guy off,” Beth suggested.

What I really wanted was to get to the bathroom and wash off Bill’s cum before it started to dry and got all itchy and congealed in my hair. I’d never sucked a boy’s cock next to another girl before, though, so the temptation was too much to turn down.