Chapter 29

Greg couldn’t believe what he had just watched. Jana and Jeff had fucked like animals, but now they were saying it was the best thing ever and that their relationship was the strongest it had ever been. He stared longingly at his lovely daughter but couldn’t dare hope that the same would apply to them. It didn’t help that the smell of sex was even heavier in the air after Jeff had launched a boatload of cum into his daughter’s pussy. The only sounds he was hearing were the quiet rubbing noises of Jeff and Jana’s bodies where they were touching each other after sex. Then Jana spoke to him. “I could make you have sex with Erica. You know you couldn’t resist me. However, I’m going to give you the choice of what to do. I will say that I think you will find having sex with Erica the most thrilling and fulfilling experience you’ve ever had.”

“What do you say, Daddy?” Erica asked him. “Look at Jana and Jeff; don’t they look so happy right now? Our relationship is so much like the one they have. If it didn’t hurt them, I don’t think us having sex will hurt ours.”

“That sounds too good to be true, Erica. What if I start making love to you and you say it’s making you uncomfortable? You’re so beautiful, I’m not sure I’d be able to stop.”

“Oh Daddy, I might have been worried if you said you wanted to fuck me. But when you said you wanted to make love to me, that tells me we’ll be as happy as Jeff and Jana once we have daddy-daughter sex. Let me show you that I can make love to you just like Jana made love to Jeff, and you can prove to yourself that you can make love to me and not fuck me.”

“I don’t know, baby. Even though it worked out for them, I’m terrified of it not working out for us.”

“Here, Daddy. I’ll show you how much I trust you. I won’t mount you like Jana did her father. I’m going to lie on the couch and spread my legs so that you can decide what to do. I hope you decide to make love to me, though.”

“I’m giving you control, Greg; I’m lifting my order for you not to fuck your daughter,” Greg heard Jana say. He walked over and decided to delay his decision by putting his dick in his daughter’s mouth. His little girl slurped eagerly on his boner while she looked at him with puppy dog eyes.

“Oh man, you are really pleading with me to put my cock in your pussy with your mouth and your eyes. You’re always so beautiful, but even more so than usual with a cock in your mouth. I don’t know if I can resist. I don’t want to be in control; tell me what to do, Titty Mistress.”

“Nope, this is your decision. I won’t make it for you.”

Greg decided to delay again by probing Erica’s pussy with his fingers. His little girl jumped and gasped with every little touch. It was warm and wet; Greg thought it would taste delicious. “I should have known your pussy would be sensitive; you were probably close to cumming on Jeff’s cock, weren’t you?” Erica nodded in agreement as she continued to urge him to even greater incest with the way she sucked on the tip of his dick and teased it with her tongue.

“You’re really trying to get me to use more than my fingers on your pussy, aren’t you, Erica?”

His daughter nodded again, then made him groan when she stopped using her mouth on his cock. “You warmed it up for Jeff so well, Daddy. It really loves having a cock inside it. I want you to be able to enjoy that too. I love you, Daddy; let me show you how much with my pussy.”

Greg’s mind was reeling. Was his daughter really begging him to put his cock inside her? There didn’t seem to be any other way to interpret what Erica was telling him. She was so beautiful, and he was so horny. It seemed like he had to accept her offer. His heart was pounding as he told his daughter, “I don’t think I can resist any longer, Erica, but you have to tell me immediately if this makes you uncomfortable in any way.” Greg climbed between his daughter’s legs, and his hard cock pointed at her pussy looked so obscene, but her toned thighs felt so inviting as he probed his daughter’s body one last time with his hands before penetrating her. He could taste both fear and anticipation in his dry mouth as he worked up the nerve to do what his cock so badly wanted him to do. He gasped as his throbbing cock-head touched Erica’s plump pussy lips.