Chapter 5: Stuart Joins The Party

Angie had been getting very clingy lately, wanting to sleep with me. I mean sleep, spend the night in my bed, not just fuck, wanting to be with me more. I hope she didn’t think this thing was going down the boyfriend route, no way. She was a sex buddy and nothing more. My cute and sexy sex toy, that’s all. I had something in mind that would stop her from thinking like that. Something that would shock her and throw her off balance. That was something else that turned me on, keeping Angie off-balance, never knowing what I wanted her to do. It was something that was going to happen sooner or later anyway, and I was getting turned on with the idea of what it would bring. The fun I could have and all the extra perversions I would get Angie to agree to.

I was just snuggling up to Tim after we’d had sex, a good hard session this time. I’d more than willingly done everything Tim had demanded. I’d stripped for him, giving him a real slow, sexy striptease, revealing my young and nubile but rapidly developing body for him. I’d been very compliant and fucked him hard. I’d let him cum in my mouth and swallowed it all for him, allowing him to watch me. Now all I wanted was to relax next to him, have him cuddle me. Is that too much to ask of him? After all, I had enjoyed it fucking my sexy big brother. What more could a girl want, I thought dreamily.

Then he shocked me. I couldn’t believe what he had just asked me to do. No told me to do.

“Angie, Stuart is home for the weekend from tomorrow night. I want you to go to him. I want you to go with him.”

“WHAT? what do you mean, go with him?” I screamed at Tim, a good idea of what he wanted already forming in my mind.

“Angie, you know what I mean. I want you to fuck Stuart tomorrow night.”

“No way, Tim. I’m not a whore. I’m not fucking anyone you want me to. I thought we had an understanding. I did what you wanted.” Mistake!!!

“Yes, Angie, that’s it; do-what-I-want, and I want you to fuck Stuart. Look, it will give you a new experience, and Stuart is not just anybody, he’s your brother, just like me.”

“And that is supposed to make it better, make it easier for me. So now I’m the little tramp who’s fucking both my brothers. Isn’t it bad enough that I’m already your sex toy, now you want me to become the same for Stuart? It’s still fucking incest, Tim.”

All the time I was speaking, I was wondering what it would be like to fuck Stuart. But I wasn’t going to make it easy for Tim. I was growing up fast, and I was more in control now.

“Angie, remember your position in this family. Now, tomorrow night you are going to Stuart, and after you do, I want you to come back here and prove that you’ve fucked him.”

“You really are a bastard Tim, you know that. If that’s what you want, then fine, I’ll fuck him. Will that turn you on? The thought of me with my other brother, letting him fuck this young, little body of mine. Sucking him off as well. Is that what you want? Is that what you think of me. Just a little fuck toy for you both.”

Tim just smiled at me. A leering smile. The answer to all my questions was there in that smile. Yes, Tim saw me as just a little fuck toy.

I knew I really had no choice in the matter, so I was pretty quiet all day, becoming even more so when Stuart arrived home. Later on, in the evening, Stuart had gone to his room when Tim gave me a nod, obviously indicating what he wanted me to do. Bastard!

Well, time to go and fuck my youngest brother, but how to do it? I wasn’t really looking forward to the night. I’m OK with Tim. In fact, I would have done anything he asked of me years ago, he doesn’t need to blackmail me, but I’m letting him think that he does. But I’m not that keen on Stuart.

I decided to just do it. So I crept into Stuie’s bedroom, wearing only a pink nightdress with a “My Little Pony” motif. I still have a load of stuff like that even though I grew out of that scene ages ago. As I don’t really need a bra, I didn’t bother with one and decided to do without panties as well. Stuart would have no problem getting at the goodies when we got started.

I was feeling nervous and a bit afraid as I opened the door and slipped inside his bedroom. Stuart looked up in surprise and shock before shouting out, “Angie, what are you doing in here?” I’d caught him out looking at a porn mag. Well, at least that made my task easier.

“Stuie, I’m a big girl now. I’ve grown up while you’ve been away. I’m feeling randy. I want you to fuck me, now.” Smiling shyly, eyes downcast, I continued. “You won’t need that mag this weekend. You can look at me if you want to look at a naked female.”

As I said this, I lifted my nightdress above my head, slowly letting it drift up my long slim legs. As the hem rose above my hips, I heard a gasp from my brother as he saw my nice little pussy. Wasting no time now, I pulled the nightie off as quickly as I could and stood in front of Stuart, letting him get a good look at my small, young but sexy body. Turning around so that he got a look at my cute, pert bum as well.

Stuie didn’t say a word, just looked shocked as I first posed for him, then walked slowly, and I hoped sexily towards him. As I got next to his bed, I pushed him down on his back and sat astride him, rubbing my pussy on his body. Letting him know that I was wet. I was ready, even though I wasn’t really wanting to fuck him that much.

Stuie reached out and pawed at my tiny boobs, groping them, pulling on my nipples. Oh, I like that. Despite myself, I couldn’t help but moan in pleasure, and my pussy started to moisten even more.

I was determined that this was going to be a quickie, in and out. So, as Stuie was already hard, I moved slightly, got hold of his cock and pushed it straight into my pussy, clenching on it as it slid in. I squirmed at the feeling. I’m beginning to like the feel of a cock in me now. No, I love the feeling of Tim’s cock buried deep in me.

Stuie’s eyes opened wide in amazement and shock at what I had done. Not thirty seconds ago, I had walked uninvited into his bedroom, and now his cock was deep in my pussy. No preliminaries, no questions, cock deep in his younger sister. I shivered in forbidden delight at the look of shock on Stuart’s face.

I could sense he was more than turned on. Incest and a young girl! All of his perverted dreams are coming true at once.

As Stuie still seemed in a state of shock and unable to move, I started to fuck him. I was slamming up and down on him for all I was worth, riding him hard and fast, not letting him have any input on what we were doing.

Stuie bent up and tried to kiss me, but I slapped his face. I didn’t want that sort of intimacy. With Tim, yes, but not Stuie. It wasn’t my choice to do this, so no kissing, not yet. He would have to earn that intimate privilege. As young as I was, I felt that kissing was so much more intimate than actually fucking my brothers.

I was slamming down hard on Stuie when I realised something was different. I was being stretched nice and wide, much wider than Tim stretched me, but no depth. Stuie wasn’t getting in very deep. Not as deep as I thought when I first started. It feels like he’s not very long.

Shit, if I had to screw my other brother, I at least wanted a decent sized cock to be screwing me.

At last, Stuie started to take some interest in what we were doing, with the shock of his little sister fucking him wearing off, and he began to push back into me. That’s better now. His cock was twitching and throbbing in my hot, wet pussy, thrusting into me a lot harder now.

I could tell the situation was getting to Stuie and that he wouldn’t last long, so I bent over him and allowed him to suck on my boobs. Latching his lips on my nipples, he sucked hard on them. As this is a thing I love, I balanced on him and held his face in place on them, making sure he couldn’t stop, rolling my sensitive nipple in his mouth. That’s when I started to cum.

Not a hard cum as I do with Tim, but a long slow climax. A nice change. As usual, I started to get vocal and was soon moaning and groaning as love juice escaped me and ran down onto Stuie’s balls. I clenched as hard as I could on him and felt him shudder as the first strand of his cum shot into me, quickly followed by loads more.

As Stuie softened and slipped out of my pussy I got off the bed, grabbed my nightdress, gave him a quick kiss on the top of his head and left, saying, “Thanks for that bro, hope you enjoyed it.”

Stuie was so shocked he couldn’t move or say anything.

As I walked back to Tim’s room, I knew I hadn’t liked what I had done, not very much. OK, the situation was weird in I’d had no choice in fucking Stuie, and that was the same with Tim the first few times. Also, Stuart had had no chance to say or do anything either. It wasn’t that. Although I’d cum I felt frustrated. I’d wanted more from it. I’d hoped I would feel excited and could look forward to some nights of fun with both my brothers, getting lots of big cock inside me. Then it hit me. That was it. Stuart wasn’t that big!!! Wide and thick, but not very long at all.