Chapter 32

“Okay, you have fun then. I’ll be back after dinner, but call if you need anything.” I had thought the worst when I had to leave Susan’s side to answer my mother’s call. But it actually turned out better than I could have planned. I’d have the rest of the afternoon, and I had invited myself for dinner at the Davis’. So, I didn’t have to worry about coming back until after they did the shopping.

I thought I was pretty smart until I considered the possible problems. I stood on my walkway, wondering how I should return to the den of perversion. Should I just walk right in? Should I knock on the front door? What if I walk in on something I’m not prepared for? What if her parents come home, and I have to go back home too early? Maybe I’m not as bright as I thought?

My desire to make sure Jeremy wasn’t doing anything to Susan overpowered my initial concerns, and I pushed the back gate open. I wonder if that’s because I love her, or I just want to be the only one? My thoughts would probably have to be addressed for years in therapy. However, they were instantly erased by the sight of Jeremy, Jasmine, and Susan, all drying off by the pool. All without a stitch of clothing. As I approached, I quickly scanned for Jesselyn. She wasn’t anywhere to be seen.

“Hey Stud, lock that gate. Can you imagine the look on your mother’s face if she popped in here and saw me sucking your throbbing cock?” My first thought was, how could they have left it open? Then, I realized Jasmine using a pet name for me, and suggesting she might suck my dick might make Susan uncomfortable or suspicious. It was one thing if Jasmine acted that way at school, but we made a deal to never hurt Susan.

I spun around just in time to see Jeremy’s dick watering down the lawn. Susan seemed oblivious to Jasmine’s nasty talk because she was watching Jeremy’s fire hose.

“Does anyone in your family use the toilet?” I whispered in Susan’s ear when I reached her.

Susan jerked like she had been snapped out of a daydream. “I’m glad you came back!” She kissed me and launched into one of her nervous info dumps, “I normally do. I’m sorry everything was so weird before. I thought maybe you wouldn’t come back. My parents won’t be home for a long time. They found something to do after that thing, and they told us not to wait up. We’re having pizza or something. Can you stay?” Susan took a much-needed breath while I tried to process everything she said.

When I didn’t say anything fast enough, Susan’s face drew a concerned look. “I hate it that they did that. They used to do that when we were little. That normally meant they were going to one of their sex parties. But they aren’t doing stuff like that anymore. So, maybe they just needed adult time.” I couldn’t help wondering if Susan’s concern wasn’t related to her own probable future?

“Of course I came back. We made a promise, ya know. You think a little weird is going to run me off? I love you.” I felt very sure of my words but wondered if I would have felt different had I opened that gate to Jeremy’s cock sliding inside my girlfriend?

“I know, but there are so many things I haven’t told you and that whole prison thing.” Susan’s open book look seemed to invite any questions I might dare to ask.

As much as her granddad being in prison was of interest, I was more interested in knowing why Jesselyn was calling out for her daddy while her brother shoved his cock in her. Too bad she was out here, being as open as Jeremy had been earlier. I wanted to know all about her and Jasmine. I wanted to know how she didn’t ever give in to her brother’s advances. Was she too busy doing her daddy? Where was her daddy anyway?

“Joe, are you with me?” Susan’s voice interrupted me from all my million-dollar questions.

“Yes, I’m sorry. I was just wondering how you fit that in your mouth.” I pointed in the direction of Jeremy’s cock, which was in Jasmine’s hand. She was gripping it from behind him and shaking it like a fishing pole, making some comment.

Susan’s eyes seemed to light up, and suddenly it all seemed too planned. Like I was the setup guy to put a plan in motion. Jasmine was waving Jeremy’s tool in Susan’s direction.

I felt my heart race, and heat flash across my face. A powerful fear gripped me at the same time as wicked excitement. It reminded me of how I felt the first time I saw porn. No, it was more like the day in my attic when I saw Mr. Davis’s cock in Susan and her mother’s face.

I was terrified of what I might experience when the reality of Jeremy’s dick in Susan’s mouth hit me. But, the powerful desire to see her doing it swelled in me, like Jeremy’s prick in Jasmine’s hand.

“Go ahead, big mouth, prove it.” Jasmine’s lustful eyes were on her sister. I knew Jasmine could care less about anything except seeing her sister doing something nasty. She definitely liked to watch.

Susan dropped her towel and knelt on it in front of Jeremy. Her hands were trembling as she reached for her cousin. She nervously looked at me, almost pleading for someone to make her stop. Terror and lust roared inside me as Susan’s hand gently touched Jeremy’s leg. Neither she nor I wanted it to stop more than continue. Her hesitant fingers moved up the back of his thigh. Jeremy turned his hips toward her. His throbbing mass of flesh was now bobbing in front of Susan’s face.