Kinsey's in Charge
Copyright© 2026 by TailWeaver
Chapter 2: Who Knew?
Erotica Sex Story: Chapter 2: Who Knew? - It had never occurred to Kinsey that she could play her games anywhere else but at home, but she soon discovered that with the right situation and the right sort of preparation, even more fun could be had.
Caution: This Erotica Sex Story contains strong sexual content, including mt/ft Mult Teenagers Exhibitionism Massage Masturbation Oral Sex Voyeurism Babysitter
“I need to clean up a little,” she said, adjusting her top a little and pulling her bottoms back into place. Mostly. She did not bother to fully adjust them or cover herself as she had when she started, but she did cover the important bits. She ran her fingers across the sperm that had cooled on her skin, and she wondered how it could seem so hot and exciting one minute, and rather gross and disgusting the next. She pushed herself up and off the lounge chair, the boys milling about like a nervous group of ducklings. She walked over to the pool and stepped in via the built-in steps, feeling the cool water wash over her still-aching body. Ducking down, letting the water wash her torso, she felt her nipples throb as the water hit them, still sensitive after her rather amazing orgasm. Who knew? Who fucking knew it could feel like that? She was no prude; she’d played with herself lots of times. But she had never...
She saw the boys still milling about, and she called over to them. “It’s ok, guys, really, I just ... you can swim or whatever...” She moved into the deeper water and treaded water slowly, watching them walk back over. Suddenly struck by an idea that seemed to resonate within her as a way to get her feeling a bit back to normal, she stopped them from jumping in. “Wait!” She watched as they stopped, looking at her more than a little confused.
“I, mmm, why don’t you line up on the side for a minute, let me have another look before you get in.” She wanted to get back to something a bit more normal, at least in her mind. Looking at the boys and their pricks was something she was much more comfortable doing. As they lined up, she could see that both William’s and Colter’s pricks had not yet fully recovered - though neither of them appeared to be completely deflated -- rather, they simply were not as upright as before. Breck also seemed to have lost some oomph, and she smiled to herself as she reminded herself of one of her rules.
“Oh, dear, some of you are not quite, mmm, standing proud. Why don’t you all take things in hand and make sure they all look like they should?!”
Kinsey watched them slowly begin to stroke themselves. She marveled at the change in view. From her spot below them, she could see their hanging testicles much more clearly. It was not that she found them very captivating; rather, it was just that she had not really noticed them before. Or saw that much of.
She watched for a minute until they all seemed quite recovered, then told them to come jump in. The earlier nervousness and awkwardness after her embarrassing orgasm seemed to have dissipated, and she found herself quite enjoying the boy’s antics as they returned to their games. Frequent touches of their cocks and bare bottoms did much to revive her spirits, and she realized she was getting quite comfortable with them, even though things had gotten rather carried away.
After a while, close to an hour, Kinsey got out and sat on the side of the pool for a minute before getting their attention. “Time to order pizza and move inside?” she asked, not surprised that they all clamored for pizza, the pack of them swiftly getting out and grabbing their towels. She waited while they got dry, and then walked amongst them, grabbing onto one or two of them and reminding them, “Don’t forget to keep yourselves nice and proud. I like it when my boys are good, and you know what happens to good boys!” She smiled, enjoying their slightly nervous laughter mixed with young male bravado. It was a rather heady feeling, having them all so eager to do what she said, to make her happy. She watched as a trio of bare bottoms preceded her into the house, and she wondered just how much more fun she was going to have before the Jacksons came home tomorrow. She felt an answering tingle deep inside of her, and she knew she wanted more of what she had this afternoon, even if it was a bit embarrassing.
“I’ll go change and then order the pizza. Why don’t you guys get things ready by the TV? Make sure there are spots for everyone - including me, and someplace to put the pizzas when they get here!”
Kinsey headed off to the spare room and closed the door carefully behind her. She stripped her wet suit off and tossed it on top of the dresser, and ran her hands over herself, idly teasing herself briefly while she stood naked next to the bed. There was a bit of thrill from being naked in some place that wasn’t her own bedroom - or bathroom, and as she got dressed, being sure to put on the peach set of undergarments, she stood in front of the mirror and stared at herself, wondering just what she was doing. She knew what she was thinking, and part of her was as shocked at herself as the rest of her was excited. Putting her top and shorts back on, she headed back down to the kitchen, looking for and finding the note the Jacksons had left along with the money for the pizza. Quickly dispatching their food order, she followed the sound of voices to the entertainment room, marveling a little at just how nice their house was. Her own house was nice, as well, but sometimes other people’s furniture and decorations just seem nicer.
She saw some sort of action movie playing, and shook her head slightly. While there was nothing wrong with a superhero movie, she had imagined something a bit more ... fun ... that would keep them in a ready state. She’d have to wait a bit, though, let things happen a bit more organically.
“We saved you a seat,” she heard Andrew call out, patting the middle of the couch between himself and Tom. Breck was sitting in one of the recliners, and the other three were kicked back on the other overstuffed couch. She was a little surprised to see towels placed over where everyone was sitting, but she figured it might make a little sense. Bare bottoms and all that.
“Hey, we got some towels, you know, just in case...” Andrew said, grabbing himself briefly.
“Oh, yeah, makes sense,” Kinsey said, blushing slightly, not from embarrassment, but because she hadn’t thought of putting towels down. “Make sure you don’t move so I can’t see, now, keep yourselves out in the open!”
“Of course!” “Sure” “Ok”
It was a little heady, how obediently they listened and did what she asked. She knew that boys loved sex and their erections. It was just surprising how far they’d go to keep her happy and playing with them.
“Hey, I thought you said you were going to wear that peach set?” Colter asked when the movie cut to a long scenic shot.
“I am!”
“Oh, but I thought ... I mean”
Kinsey smiled, amused, knowing exactly what he and the others, no doubt, had thought.
“I do have to answer the door, you know, unless you were going to?” she teased, laughing lightly.
“No, no, of course, I didn’t ... I mean, yeah...”
It wasn’t long before the doorbell rang and Kinsey got up to answer, not before teasing the boys again about getting the pizza for her. Returning a minute later with three pizza boxes, she set the delicious-smelling pies down on the table and watched as they attacked the food. She watched them eat for a minute, and then two, before idly stretching and yawning, as if bored.
“What’s wrong?” one of them asked, and it took her a moment to figure out it was Noah.
“Oh, nothing, just ... you know, waiting,” she said, teasing, wondering if they were going to figure it out.
“Waiting? Waiting for what?” Tom asked, before Colter chimed in, “Oh, your outfit. Is now a good time?”
Kinsey felt a little guilty, pushing things like she was, but she couldn’t stop thinking about what had happened earlier, and she wasn’t sure, exactly, how she was going to get a repeat performance - but she knew she wanted one. And the first step was to tease and show off some more.
“Oh? Hmm, yes, I guess. As long as you guys are good.”
“Of course! Yeah! Yep!” Their voices overlapped as they all paused their pizza to look at her. Smiling, her anticipation building once again, she stood up and unsnapped her shorts, pulling apart the flaps to show off a bit of the peach undergarment.
“You don’t mind if I take these off here? I can go to my room if you think that’s better,” she said, teasing, turning in a circle as they all protested that she should stay.
She stopped turning and slowly shimmied her shorts down, bending down to slide them off her feet, Noah and Colter getting a perfect view of her stretched panties covering her bottom. The fabric was slightly sheer - she knew that a hint of her skin would show through as she moved, but it was not crass or vulgar. Just a little sexy. She turned to the other side and began to pull off her shirt, being careful not to let her bra ride up - at least not yet. Feeling a surge of power, knowing they were all watching her, she took her time, slowly pulling her top off, brushing her hair back after handing her shirt to Tom, who had also grabbed her shorts when she’d dropped them. She sat back down between Andrew and Tom, and looked around at her audience, her face flushed with excitement. She glanced down at her bra, pretty sure that in the bright light of the room, her salient features would be visible. Confirming her suspicions, she looked around to see them all watching her, their food forgotten for a moment. She reached out with both hands and lightly grabbed onto Andrew and Tom, feeling them twitch beneath her hands.
“I seem to have my hands full, would someone feed me a bite or two of pizza?” she asked, smiling broadly as she made a big production of her hand movements for a second. Kinsey enjoyed the energy racing through her as she sat next to the two naked boys. Breck was the first to jump up and bring a fresh piece of pizza over, but Colter was right behind him. Deciding to alternate between the two and reward them both for their efforts, Kinsey leaned forward a little and took a small bit of Breck’s pizza before chewing quickly and turning to the other side, where Colter was waiting. Grinning while she chewed the bite of pizza, Kinsey sat back and looked around at her obedient boys and felt another delicious twinge run through her as she surveyed their forms.
The boys soon switched places, Andrew saying something about making sure everyone got a turn to sit next to her. She could feel their eyes tracing over her body, examining her barely clad form, seeking out the peeks of her nipples through the fabric of her bra. Hands now occupied with Noah and William’s firm staffs, Kinsey smiled at Andrew as he retrieved one of her two partially eaten slices of pizza and offered her a bite, holding it rather close to his prick before raising it to her mouth. She had a fleeting image of her taking a bite alongside his prick, and she blushed as her mind kept going along in that vein. The rather naughty pizza dinner continued for a few more minutes, with the guys switching places every few minutes. When Andrew and Tom were beside her again for the second time, Kinsey decided it was time to push things along. Again. Leaning forward to take a bite, she purposely only partially bit down, pulling the pizza from Colter’s grasp and gasping as the pizza landed directly on her stomach and bare lap.
“Oh shit!” she swore, not really upset, pulling her hands free and picking up the pizza. It had made a satisfying bit of mess on her skin, and she smiled to herself. Now she had her excuse to take a shower.
“I’m gonna have to take a shower now. I was hoping, though, you guys might want to help me?”
“What? Yeah! Of Course!”
Kinsey giggled, their enthusiasm infectious. “Well, there are six of you, so, um, maybe 1 to help me get started, 1 to help me dry off, 2 to put lotion on my back, and 2 on the other side.”
“Yeah, but some of use didn’t get to, you know, before.”
“Oh, I know. Um, after say, 2 minutes, we can do it as we did outside, all of you, you know, make sure you rotate as you did just now on the couches? I will be sure you all get a turn ... or two...” she teased, feeling more than a little naughty. Her mind was already consumed with thoughts of repeating that orgasm, and even if she had to sort of make up an excuse to make it happen, she didn’t care.
“I thought about you guys having a race or something to decide who goes first, but I think I’d rather you all stay ... excited and stuff. So, get a couple of dice or some cards and figure out who gets to pick first and last. I’m going to the little girls’ room and will give you a couple of minutes. Whomever wins can have Andrew show him where the towels are that I will need and meet me there.”
Kinsey felt her anticipation rising faster and faster as she got up and went to attend to her personal business. She could hear the boys shouting and hollering as they yelled at Andrew to get some dice. Leaving them to figure things out, she quickly did what she needed and then stood looking at herself for a long minute in the well-lit mirror. She could see her hard nipples trying to poke through her bra, and she rubbed her fingers across one to try to release a little pent-up tension. Taking a couple of deep breaths, she calmed herself, while still staring into her eyes and knowing what she was going to let them do. Again. She just needed to make sure they kept quiet. She trusted them a bit more than the older boys, but she still wanted to be sure somehow.
Figuring she’d given them enough time, Kinsey took one last look in the mirror and opened the door. She Breck was standing there, a small stack of towels in his hand. His sizable prick had lost some of its luster, and she made a note that she needed to encourage them to stay hard more frequently. Smiling, she nodded at him, “So, you won, hmm?”
Breck looked back at her, blinking a couple of times before shrugging. “Well, um, yeah. I guess. I won this spot, but only because they picked everything else ahead of me.”
“What? No one wanted to help me get ready for a shower?” she said, half-teasingly, and a little surprised.
“I dunno, um, they thought drying you off would be better. And, you know, the lotion. This was just, you know, bringing you towels and stuff.”
“Oh, well, thats what you guys get for thinking you know everything. Why don’t you bring those in here and set them on the counter? Kinsey waited while Breck stepped past her before closing the door and turning to look at his surprised face.
“Well, I can’t take a shower without water, too, not just towels. Why don’t you get it started for me?” Kinsey asked nicely, standing and smiling while the nervous boy hurried to do as she asked. “Make sure it’s not too hot or cold, k?” she added, watching as he bent over a bit, his rather chunky frame not completely hiding his impressive prick. Just being near her in the smaller confines of the bathroom seemed to be having an effect on him; his cock was once again standing proud. She put her hair up, not wanting to get it wet.
“I think it’s ready,” he said after a few seconds of testing the water and turning the knob. He looked uncertain, as if he was supposed to push past her and leave, and Kinsey felt more than pleased with herself when she calmed him a little by putting her hand on his forearm.
“Relax. It’s all good. You do need to help me a bit more, though,” she said, being purposely vague as she slowly turned around, reaching up to pull her hair away from her bra strap. She glanced at him standing behind her in the long bathroom mirror, and saw him look at her as if unsure. She nodded, smiling, and watched as he lifted his hands and began to fiddle with the clasp of her bra. She felt the strap loosen, and she watched as he stood uncertainly behind her. Turning around, she felt her bra hanging rather loose, but she kept her arms positioned just right to keep it from falling off. She watched his face and the nervous way he kept glancing from her loosened bra to her face and back again. She waited a couple of seconds, then told him, “Go ahead.”
Give the boy credit, she thought. Once she gave him the go-ahead, he didn’t hesitate. A few seconds later, she was standing in front of him dressed only in her peach panties, her bra clutched nervously in his hands. His eyes bored into her breasts as if he had not just seen them this afternoon. Though to be fair, this was a bit more up close and personal, like. She let him enjoy the spectacle for a few seconds before prodding him, “You going to do the rest?” The look on his face was priceless, and she felt another surge of anticipatory arousal rush through her as he put her bra on the counter and reached for the waistband of her underwear. He must have decided he wanted a better view, she thought, since after he pushed her waistband down an inch or so, he stopped and knelt down before again reaching for her panties. He drew them down over her hips slowly, exposing the small patch of hair she had left above her slit. As he lowered her panties farther, she knew that her whole sex was exposed, and she wondered if he had any idea how aroused she was. She could feel the wetness threatening to drip out of her as she lifted one leg and then the other as he removed her final piece of clothing. She waited while he took a long look at her aroused body before he stood back up, his large prick throbbing and bobbing as he moved. She reached out to grasp him in her hand, marveling at how big he was, and thanked him. “Thanks, I think I’m good now. You’ve been such a good boy, huh?” Her voice was light and teasing, and she continued to stroke him for a few seconds until she noticed he appeared to be on edge. She debated about having him pop off as a final reward, but she had visions of something else happening. Pulling her hand free, she placed it on his chest and smiled, “Save that ... for later ... ok?” He nodded, groaning a little, and watched her as she stepped into the shower.