Ever since the WS thread and Lazeez listing the top 15 excluded story codes, I've been wrestling with the idea of the impact of excluding story codes. In that thread I already mentioned that excluding one of the top 15, "torture," would not show readers a great novel like The Count of Monte Cristo. That novel is not about torture, but torture is used to show the character's suffering and need for revenge.
As I said, it's been troubling me that readers could miss out on good stories for excluding story codes that may only be a small part of the story. Another novel came to mind โ Prince of Tides.
The story is about the psychological torment the MC is going through and how it affects his relationships. The story is told through flashbacks and the plot's climax is the flashback of the rape of him and his mother and sister.
The "rape" story code is not one of the top 15 excluded, but it's a big no-no for many. But "M/m" is in the top 15 and probably high up on it since "gay" is also in the top 15.
The rape and M/m is one scene in the entire story. It's a critical and powerful scene, but I wouldn't call the story a gay story or a rape story. So if the author includes those story codes, the story won't be seen by those with those codes in their exclusion list. If he doesn't put them in, he could be subjected to the ire of small-minded people who are offended by that scene.
I didn't put this in the Authors forum because it's directed to readers. There's a saying: "Be careful what you wish for." That might be true for exclusions as well.