We have our winners! Thank you for reading and voting [ Dismiss ]
Home Β» Forum Β» Author Hangout

Forum: Author Hangout

How much do minor details matter?

PotomacBob 🚫

I'm reading a story (not on SOL), in which the author has a character driving along "the I-80" in Pennsylvania. Same story, another character visits the Piggly-Wiggly grocery store in California.
Taken together, I suspect the author is from neither of those places. The map online of the states in which Piggly-Wiggly has stores shows it's a southeastern chain and does not include California. And I doubt Pennsylvanians would include "the" in referring to an interstate highway.
On the other hand, neither of those things interfered with my enjoyment o the story, though they did give me pause.

Quasirandom 🚫

@PotomacBob

Any friction that bumps the reader is another opportunity for them to stop reading and go on to something else.

Some details matter more than others. I'm a firm believer that those details that support verisimilitude matter a lot.

Dominions Son 🚫
Updated:

@PotomacBob

For me, the nature of the story would matter a lot.

If the story is supposed to take place in the real world, or something close to it, those kinds of details matter and effort should be made to get them right.

On the other hand if the story clearly takes place in an alternate reality with significant changes from the real world, those kinds of minor changes are not something I would consider intrusive.

Of course even the alternate reality story needs to be self consistent. If the story itself makes a point that chain store X is a southeastern thing than sticks a store from chain X in California, that would be inconsistent and be a problem.

Replies:   Joe Long
Joe Long 🚫

@Dominions Son

I'm in Pennsylvania and have lived in the Virginia suburbs of DC.

I would formally be called "I-80" or "I-66" or informally "80" or "66". I cringed when watching an episode of NCIS, where there office is set in DC, and Tim tell Gibbs the perp was on "The I-66" Another time Tim pronounced McLean as "MICK-clean" instead of "muh-CLAIN"

tendertouch 🚫

@PotomacBob

What timeframe? Piggly Wiggly was all over the northwest twenty years ago, and was in Wisconsin less than ten years ago.

Using 'the I-80' sounds very much like California, I've never heard it anywhere else, though I suspect they'd say, 'the 80'.

As for the original question – as Quasirandom and Dominions Son mention, it depends. If it's not meant to be an alternate reality then small mistakes can throw me, so if you're going to add them it's best to do some research (and get some editors from different areas then listen to them.)

awnlee jawking 🚫

@tendertouch

Using 'the I-80' sounds very much like California, I've never heard it anywhere else, though I suspect they'd say, 'the 80'.

Didn't the latest Variation on a Theme chapter say pretty much the same thing?

AJ

Replies:   tendertouch  Grey Wolf
tendertouch 🚫

@awnlee jawking

No idea. I stopped reading that series early on.

Replies:   awnlee jawking
awnlee jawking 🚫

@tendertouch

No idea. I stopped reading that series early on.

I haven't been able to find it again so I must have confused it with another story :-(

AJ

Grey Wolf 🚫

@awnlee jawking

I could write 'the X' for a freeway, but probably wouldn't, as it's not a Texas thing. On the other hand, 'the Interstate' is a Texas thing (and even more an Austin thing). Or calling it 'IH-35' instead of 'I-35'; that's another Austin thing.

In Houston, most of the freeways are commonly referred to geographically: 'Katy Freeway', 'North Freeway', 'Southwest Freeway', 'Gulf Freeway', etc. Using the number is less common but certainly happens.

I wouldn't rule it out, but it'd likely be an error, unless I was quoting a character who'd lived a fair bit in California.

Replies:   Dominions Son  ystokes
Dominions Son 🚫

@Grey Wolf

In Wisconsin we either just use the number or I-X.

Replies:   tendertouch
tendertouch 🚫

@Dominions Son

Ditto in Washington. You'll hear '90' or 'I-90', though less often '5' instead of 'I-5'.

Replies:   DBActive
DBActive 🚫

@tendertouch

I never hear anyone say "I-80". Here (NJ) most commonly it's just the number for any highway or "Route X".

Replies:   tendertouch
tendertouch 🚫

@DBActive

What I mostly hear is "I-" for an interstate (we don't have that many) and just the number for a state route/highway - 99, 101, 104, 520, etc… The exception is 405, which is really I-405.

Replies:   DBActive
DBActive 🚫

@tendertouch

Where are you?

Replies:   Dominions Son
Dominions Son 🚫
Updated:

@DBActive

A three digit interstate is either a bypass, or a spur. Bypass if the first digit is even, spur if it is odd.

A search on Google maps for I-405 indicates that he is in the Seattle, Washington area, because that's where I-405 is.

ystokes 🚫

@Grey Wolf

In Houston, most of the freeways are commonly referred to geographically: 'Katy Freeway', 'North Freeway', 'Southwest Freeway', 'Gulf Freeway', etc. Using the number is less common but certainly happens.

Here in SoCal we also have names for freeways.
The 1, also known as the Pasific Coast Highway which goes along the coast.
The 101, also known as the Ventura highway which goes to Ventura.
The 110, also known as the Harbour freeway which ends at the harbor.
And then we have the 405, also known as the San Diego freeway which ends lone before it reaches San Diego.

Dominions Son 🚫

@ystokes

And then we have the 405, also known as the San Diego freeway which ends lone before it reaches San Diego.

Interesting. I did a search on Google Maps for I405 and got Seattle, Washington.

Replies:   helmut_meukel
helmut_meukel 🚫

@Dominions Son

And then we have the 405, also known as the San Diego freeway which ends lone before it reaches San Diego.

Interesting. I did a search on Google Maps for I405 and got Seattle, Washington.

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia
Interstate 405 may refer to:

Interstate 405 (California), a bypass of Los Angeles, California
Interstate 405 (Oregon), a bypass of Portland, Oregon
Interstate 405 (Washington), a bypass of Seattle, Washington

Seems someone thought to reuse the same number in different states won't cause irritation.

HM.

Dominions Son 🚫

@helmut_meukel

Seems someone thought to reuse the same number

Apparently. I didn't even need to refer to Wikipedia to figure that out.

Odd though that Seattle was the only hit I got on a Google Maps search.

Must be a lot of bypasses on I-5 that they used the same bypass number three times.

mauidreamer 🚫

@Dominions Son

Must be a lot of bypasses on I-5 that they used the same bypass number three times.

Yup. On primary N/S I-5 from MX to CAN borders in WA/OR/CA states has at least a dozen "auxiliary" connectors.
I-105 has segments in LA and in Eugene, OR.
I-205 - Central CA and around Portland, OR metro area.
I-305 - not officially used, but a section of US 50 near Sacramento CA get federal funds under that tag.
I-405, as was noted, 3 segments.
I-505, once in central CA.
I-605, once in LA urban area.
I-705, in Tacoma WA, also possibly the Hollywood Fwy ...
I-805, once in San Diego CA (alt access to/fm MX border)
I-905 not designated yet, but proposed for Otay Mesa Fwy.

helmut_meukel 🚫

@Dominions Son

I didn't even need to refer to Wikipedia to figure that out.

I needed Wikipedia to find out they used the same number not only twice (Washington and California) but three times (Oregon, too).

BTW, seeing only one result with Google Maps, could we assume Google Maps is even less reliable than Wikipedia? ;-)

HM.

Replies:   Dominions Son
Dominions Son 🚫

@helmut_meukel

BTW, seeing only one result with Google Maps, could we assume Google Maps is even less reliable than Wikipedia? ;-)

Not generally, no.

awnlee jawking 🚫

@helmut_meukel

But doesn't 'interstate' mean between states? An interstate's designation should therefore be nationally unique.

AJ

Replies:   StarFleet Carl  julka
StarFleet Carl 🚫

@awnlee jawking

But doesn't 'interstate' mean between states?

Actually, no. Otherwise, Hawaii wouldn't have three. Everything is part of 'The Dwight D. Eisenhower System of Interstate and National Defense Highways', because it was his way of making roads for national defense similar to the German Autobahn. American roads at that time sucked, and he'd seen how easily train tracks could be destroyed. And yes, Hawaii has H-1, H-2, H-3, and H-201.

That's not to say our roads don't STILL suck, but that's another topic. It's a good thing we have a completely competent engineer that's highly well aware of the issues as our National Transportation Director. (That last was sarcasm, in case you didn't know.)

julka 🚫

@awnlee jawking

The naming convention for interstates and auxiliaries is actually pretty reasonable and communicates information. Even-number interstates run east-west, increasing in number as you go north (so I-90 is the northern-most east-west interstate and I-10 is the southernmost) and odd-number interstates run north-south, increasing in number from west to east (so I-5 is the western-most north-south interstate and I-95 is the easternmost). If the number is two digits, you know it's a true interstate.

Auxiliary interstates have three digits, taking the two from their host and the third (generally, there are exceptions) telling you how it connects to the host. Even numbers connect in two spots, odd numbers connect in one. So 405 is an auxiliary to I-5 that connects at two different points. We also know that I-5 runs north-south and is on the west coast, so it spans washington, oregon, and california. Auxiliaries don't repeat intrastate but do repeat interstate, just like exit numbers - there is an I-5 exit 1 in washington, oregon, and california.

You could argue that auxiliaries could have four digits and be unique across the country as opposed to just the state, but it's not clear what benefit that would give you - it's not like there's an expectation that interstate names (or city names, or street names) are unique nationally. If I told you that I lived on Center Street in Rochester and it sure was snowy, you'd still need to ask if I lived in New York or Minnesota.

Switch Blayde 🚫

@ystokes

Here in SoCal we also have names for freeways.

In AZ, our freeways have names as well as numbers. But most people refer to them by their numbers.

(State Road) SR-51 when built was called Squaw Peak Freeway because it was near Squaw Peak. I usually call it "51" but sometimes I slip and call it "Squaw Peak" (usually without the freeway). Why is it a slip?

The word "squaw" is unacceptable so the peak was renamed after a Native American woman killed in the first Iraq war. So it's now Piestewa Peak and the freeway is Peistewa Freeway. I can never remember that name.

Dominions Son 🚫

@tendertouch

Piggly Wiggly was all over the northwest twenty years ago, and was in Wisconsin less than ten years ago.

I'm in southeastern Wisconsin. There is a Piggly Wiggly with in a couple of miles of my house. I'm in my 50s. Piggly Wiggly has been in Wisconsin since I was a child.

StarFleet Carl 🚫

@PotomacBob

If this story is written from the perspective of someone FROM a certain part of California and it's set forty plus years ago, then the character would probably call all interstates 'the' and Piggly Wiggly did exist there, starting in the 1960's. If it's set modern day, then no.

That's the whole point of keeping in your mind as the reader the time frame of the story. As the author of a small story (!) set in the mid-1980's, I'm continually doing research so that I get the 'minor details' of something as correct as possible, rather than simply making stuff up. If I use the actual store name, such as 'Red Lobster,' instead of just saying a restaurant, then in 1985, there really WAS a 'Red Lobster' at that location.

Replies:   Michael Loucks
Michael Loucks 🚫

@StarFleet Carl

That's the whole point of keeping in your mind as the reader the time frame of the story. As the author of a small story (!) set in the mid-1980's, I'm continually doing research so that I get the 'minor details' of something as correct as possible, rather than simply making stuff up. If I use the actual store name, such as 'Red Lobster,' instead of just saying a restaurant, then in 1985, there really WAS a 'Red Lobster' at that location.

I do exactly the same thing in my 'small' universe of stories. With the exception of two fictional towns in 'Good Medicine' (done to give me freedom I normally do not have in my series), if I use a place name, an address, a road, etc, etc, you can be sure it was there in the timeframe of that chapter of that story.

I have taken one or two liberties with language, where I used terms before they were in general use, but I simply say that my characters used them before they were mainstream. :-)

tenyari 🚫
Updated:

@PotomacBob

Incorrect details like that can be jarring if as a reader you're aware of them.

An author I actually like set their stories in a part of California I happened to have partly grown up in. I kept noticing things and eventually just forced myself to ignore them.

I've just published stories in a City I've been to but not lived in. Where I put in major place names I did some research for them. Where I set a small business and a character's home I kept where in the city it was unstated, and made the business owned by its operator and not a chain.

Slang is one that can really get you. Reading stories where characters from one country are talking in the slang of another country is jarring. Or they use vernacular that is way too specific in time and place - I have one unfinished story that greatly suffers from this problem.

Read a story recently where a Californian character was getting a reaction for saying "bloody" which... has no meaning out here other than something having blood on it - the knife was bloody. She blew her nose and it was bloody, so she took some cold medicine and allergy pills.

-shrug-

Now... being from where I am, I have my own sets of slang, and I would be tempted to put them into any story I wrote. So I get it. And I'm very likely to make some mistakes. Almost certainly have in my newest stories. It's something to remember though.

Never say 'pub' for a story on the west coast. Probably in most of the USA. All I know about Pubs it's its where parents take their kids to get them drunk and pimp them out or something... like, is it a bar or is it disney land or both? Everytime I see the word 'pub' in a story I get tossed right out the window. Do they have windows? I think it's illegal for a bar or strip club to have windows you can see into or out of out here in Cali. Or that could just be city codes in the places I've lived.

I remember watching CW's new "Walker" show and they kept taking the kids to a bar and it kept bothering me. At least they set that one in Texas and not California.

That's the danger of the "almost familiar" - a place that seems to share a lot in common with own's culture - the small details that do differ can throw readers out the window of your scene.

Also... get the local ethnicity right.

Nothing bothers me more than seeing packs of Caucasian characters in California. Yeah we've got them - but its mixed here to a degree that ignoring that mix is about as jarring as having an all Botswanan cast in a story set in 1987 Moscow would be. In California - every other person you meet is likely to be a different race than the last one you met. Even among the Caucasians they will be from all over Europe and you're actually more likely to meet a Pierre Jose Stanislavsky than a John Franks. You're also likely to meet a Black guy named Carlos Fujimura.

If I set a story in 'over there istan' - I'm going to look up some names of people there, demographics, some common stores, common phrases, and then a basic article or two about the place.

You can get away with more if it's super remote, but even then...

ps: It's also important to be intelligent enough to spot the difference between, and purpose of; a specific silly example and the larger point it's trying to illustrate.

Bondi Beach 🚫
Updated:

@tenyari

Do they have windows? I think it's illegal for a bar or strip club to have windows you can see into or out of out here in Cali.

I've never heard a native or long-term resident of California call it "Cali," although my younger daughter says she has.

(Para on single-race guys deleted.)

mix is about as jarring as having an all Botswanan cast in a story set in 1987 Moscow

Except that foreign students in Moscow, especially those from Africa, tended to hang together since they were disliked by ethnic Russians.

~ JBB

Replies:   richardshagrin
richardshagrin 🚫

@Bondi Beach

California

Californicate

LupusDei 🚫
Updated:

@tenyari

I'm kinda sorta trying to write a couple stories that are kinda sorta set in alternative universe of my native environment, and showcasing some quirks of that environment is partly a point, or other times I just use it as base for what may sound like almost high fantasy to foreigners, but be still very familiar to me personally, just intensified, taken a bit over the top.

And the specifics of the native language can make or break plot points unwittingly at times, but I don't want to go on long lectures why, or feature that language much at all, only providing general awareness that all dialogue is to be perceived as narrator's translation.

I'm also very aware that if I used local names I'm fond of, they could appear unpronounceable for anglophone people, because we adopted latin alphabet through German gothic, and then added our own quirks on top. Or should I attempt to spell Jānis as Yaaanis, or Līga as Leeghah, or mention Gundega is meant to be pronounced as gun+deg(ree)+ah and means roughly "fire that burns" (etymology: ugun-s -> 'gun-s = "fire" + deg-t = "to burn" + feminine ending, yes, it's a girl name, and also a name of small, nasty wild weed flower). I would likely fail at that because I don't spell or speak English at all and use that same Latvian phonetic alphabet for rendering of all texts in my internal usage.

Instead, I translate Jānis to John, because it is the same name (also Ivan and I think even Zak is derived from it, whatever the guy who baptized Jesus is called in the local translation) and try to mostly confine myself to girl names that has international spread and presence here as well.

Well, and in one project ostensibly set in 1995 (but never exactly specified) I deliberately use currency that went out of circulation in 1994, but visit a night club that I believe didn't open before 1996, at least not in that place/design, but I kinda sorta wanted the atmosphere. But I double checked any music I mentioned there was out before 1995.

Paladin_HGWT 🚫

@tenyari

I have to disagree about Pub.

In Washington state there are a number of establishments referred to as Pubs.

Partially this is from proprietors from the UK operating a "traditional" (ish) Pub; as opposed to a Tavern.

Microbreweries, in particular "Brew Pubs" have added Pub to the local lexicon, at least for some folks.

When I was stationed at Fort Bragg in the 80's there was a pub, named: The Pub, it had typical Budweiser, and such, but also Guinness, Smithix, several British Ales, as well as Fosters and KB (both Australian). It had a much quieter atmosphere, darts, and some other quirky touches.

I am not a fan of blaring music, and such in a nightclub or bar/tavern. So, I sought out Pubs across the USA.

Since my time in college, I frequent several pubs in the Seattle area. The George & Dragon, The Ballard Arms, The Old Peculiar, FX McRory's, The Six Arms, are among my favorites.

redthumb 🚫

@tenyari

Reading stories where characters from one country are talking in the slang of another country is jarring.

I don't mind if a person from a different country uses their 'native' jargon or slang. What does bother me is when a 'native' used the 'non-native' terms. Esample if somebody from Australia visiting the US uses petrol, no problem. But when a person native in say the US uses petrol (except when the author makes it clear that he has roots where that term is used) is jaring.

helmut_meukel 🚫

@PotomacBob

Piggly Wiggly is especially time dependent:

A total of 499 independently owned Piggly Wiggly stores currently operate across 18 states, primarily in smaller cities and towns.
At its peak in 1932, the company operated 2,660 stores.

HM.

ystokes 🚫

@PotomacBob

The title should have been more like "How accurate should details be?"

When I saw the title I thought it was about one of my pet peeves, going into to much detail. Things like every step on how to cook a meal, not just every street but every turn to get across town.

Dominions Son 🚫

@ystokes

When I saw the title I thought it was about one of my pet peeves, going into to much detail.

I have the somewhat the opposite reaction. While yes, there are stories with too much detail, there are just as many with not enough detail. Little or no sense of scenery, of when or where the story takes place. Nothing to differentiate it from the next story.

It's the details as much as any action or drama that takes place that makes a story stand out from the crowd and makes it interesting and worth reading.

Freyrs_stories 🚫

@ystokes

You should try reading "wheel of time" by Robert "too darn much detail" Jordan. I swear I've tried to read that first book at least half a dozen times and never get more than a chapter or two in from sheer exhaustion reading details that make you think the reader had never seen anything past a one block tenement in a concrete jungle where nothing bigger than a grain of rice was ever out of place. The detail is excessive to say the least.

However I feel that there are two schools of thought. time/location specificity and authenticity or generalisation. Going with the former may alienate people who have no first hand knowledge of the area if there is to be too many private/in jokes or on the other hand over generalisation may dilute the water so to speak to the extent that nothing has much meaning.

I've lived in a lot of countries and locations but I don't think I'd ever write a specific place for many reasons. Some of which have been attested to here. Just because you knew a place to be 'just so' doesn't mean many people either side of you by more than a couple of years would too.

I'll ask at another point in time when I'm further into a draft, but is it at all possible to be down the middle? no specific names but just enough detail that a good portion of people can relate and ascribe it to X town in Y year. There's a concept that people over estimate the changes 2 years will bring, whilst underestimate the same over 10.

Yes I realise the majority of members here are Americans but I think that majority may not be as large as suggested. The internet is international and so is English, mostly. Overly America centric content does not alway come off either as right or wrong, just more cultural imperialism. So much as to say, how dare you not know the difference between this or that state, or this or that decade there.

What I'm trying to say, and I hope this is the right way of putting it. Generalisation, generally wins out over specifics if only because it means more people can relate more intimately with something if it doesn't require in depth and local knowledge of everything within 100 Km of a point of interest in the story. But you can also say the opposite that 'small' inconsistencies do not matter as much as a lot of people think they do to the larger reader body as a whole.

Balance is the key, tempered yes by a little research. Just enough details that a 'local' can say I'm 'there' but not too many so as to confuse someone from 100 or 10,000 Km away. No, I've never been to the USA but I have hauled my arse around a good 1/3rd of the globe distance wise and maybe 1/8th location wise. I've seen countries that are trying to be the 51st state and other's that are running away as fast as they possibly can. neither is a statement for or against the actual US just that there are many points of view and there is a grand spectrum between 100% US Authentic and somewhere that doesn't even know how many 'states' there are.

I do plan on setting all of what I write outside of America but have of yet not come across a method of describing somewhere that is not somewhere specific other than not USA. If anyone has an idea for that particular tightrope I'd love to know as I'm walking without a pole and wearing a blindfold and it's a long way down.

Finally I think you will find that many of the readers would be struggling to know the difference between IHOP and Waffle house once you got past the menu headliners. My 'pet peeves' go both ways too much or too little. there's a reason most stories are either set in an instantly recognisable location or one generic enough to belong to a $2 store (inflation adjusted).

Replies:   ystokes  Switch Blayde
ystokes 🚫

@Freyrs_stories

an instantly recognisable location or one generic enough to belong to a $2 store (inflation adjusted).

Here in the US we have a store named "99c Only" store where everything was only 99 cents or less. Due to inflation they had to raise their prices but all their signs on the buildings and their trucks had the old name and being how cheap they were known for they just pasted a blank sticker over just the cent symbol and now just goes by "99 Only" store.

Switch Blayde 🚫

@Freyrs_stories

not come across a method of describing somewhere that is not somewhere specific other than not USA.

My novel "High School Massacre" takes place in southeastern Arizona and Mexico. I have fictitious towns on both sides of the border. I have a fictitious border crossing. But I sprinkle in real cities (like the plane landing in Tucson), real highways in that part of the state taking the main character from Tucson east to my fictitious town, and a real border crossing and real towns on both sides. I also have a real Army base called Fort Huachuca.

Another of my novels, "Sexual Awakening," in my mind takes place in Long Island and Manhattan, but I don't call them that. I call them "the City" for Manhattan (because that's how we referred to it from Brooklyn when I grew up) and the suburbs (not Long Island although I mention the Atlantic ocean).

So one approach is to mix real stuff with your fictional stuff.

richardshagrin 🚫

@PotomacBob

A tale is more interesting than D tail.

awnlee jawking 🚫

@PotomacBob

Minor details should be omitted to comply with Canadian law - only adult details should be described ;-)

AJ

Pete Fox 🚫
Updated:

@PotomacBob

Details matter even the small ones. We are writers are trying to get the reader to buy into our vision or story. Every detail maters as they are the buidling blocks that you build the vision on. Of course we must create at times but knowable information. No old west cowboy in 1875 would have semi-automtic colt .45 for example that is common knowlege. But a street address in 1875 Tombstone harder to know and not so relavatnt. My point is every mistake takes away from the story, the escape.

Today with the internet you can find almost anything. I just wrote a story that had a chapter that took place in a fancy hotel in Tallinn Estonia. The hotel has a web page with pictures. I know what the dinning room looked like so could add details to my story. Same with weather. Its all out there. An no, no one calls I-80 'the 80' in California. But in LA there is 'the 405 or 405'.

My point is if I read a story and the author was to lazy to get the details correct, Ill walk away as I'll doubt the rest his or her story. Especially when it comes to erotica.

Replies:   Switch Blayde
Switch Blayde 🚫

@Pete Fox

and the author was to lazy to get the details correct

That's why I use fictitious places and sprinkle in real stuff to make it sound more real. It's not a question of being lazy. Not everything you find on the internet is 100% correct. And some of the information is dated.

Replies:   Ron Jon
Ron Jon 🚫
Updated:

@Switch Blayde

and the author was to lazy to get the details correct

That's why I use fictitious places and sprinkle in real stuff to make it sound more rea

Do you ever make a note to readers telling
them said city does not exist? Or is obvious because of its fictional subject eg Superman?

Switch Blayde 🚫

@Ron Jon

Do you ever make a note to readers telling
them said city does not exist?

No.

In my novels, I have the following on the page with the copyright:

This is a work of fiction. Names, characters, organizations, places, events, and incidents are either products of the author's imagination or are used fictitiously.

StarFleet Carl 🚫

@Ron Jon

Do you ever make a note to readers telling
them said city does not exist? Or is obvious because of its fictional subject eg Superman?

NOTE: Any names and/or other similarities between people, living, dead, or fictional are purely coincidental (maybe).

richardshagrin 🚫

@PotomacBob

Minors are under 21 years old. So minor details are younger than adult details.

Replies:   Dominions Son
Dominions Son 🚫

@richardshagrin

Minors are under 21 years old.

In the US at least, minors are under 18 years old. If you are going to be pedantic, do it right.

Replies:   richardshagrin
richardshagrin 🚫

@Dominions Son

minors are under 18 years old

"Is a minor a person who is at least 18 years old?
In the United States as of 1971, minor is generally legally defined as a person under the age of 18. However, in the context of alcohol or gambling laws, people under the age of 21 may also sometimes be referred to as minors. However, not all minors are considered juveniles in terms of criminal responsibility."

If you are 18 you are definitely under 21.

Paladin_HGWT 🚫

@PotomacBob

Piggly Wiggles used to operate on the West Cost. I remember them in the Seattle-Tacoma area, and in Spokane too.

I thought I remember going to one when we traveled through California in the late 70's.

DBActive 🚫

@PotomacBob

I was just reading a story on Lit. The British author had the couple embarking on a cruise from Orlando. Couldn't he have spent 10 seconds looking at a map?

Replies:   ystokes  palamedes
ystokes 🚫

@DBActive

The British author had the couple embarking on a cruise from Orlando. Couldn't he have spent 10 seconds looking at a map?

Was the story set in the future where the rising seas turned Orlando into a coastal town? Just asking.

Replies:   DBActive
DBActive 🚫

@ystokes

No. But it was interesting that they were in a hotel at the port in Orlando.
From my experience with Brits, the only places they know about in the US are NYC, San Francisco, LA and Disney, so I was surprised that the author did this.

Replies:   palamedes
palamedes 🚫

@DBActive

No. But it was interesting that they were in a hotel at the port in Orlando.
From my experience with Brits, the only places they know about in the US are NYC, San Francisco, LA and Disney, so I was surprised that the author did this.

One thing about going on a cruise is how are you getting to the boat. The author being Brit would need to fly in and Orlando International Airport would be one of the entry points to the USA for them to connect up with getting to the boat.

Replies:   DBActive
DBActive 🚫

@palamedes

Yes, but he repeatedly says he's in Orlando. He takes a "two mile walk" from their hotel at the port to the nearest shopping center.

Dominions Son 🚫

@DBActive

Yes, but he repeatedly says he's in Orlando. He takes a "two mile walk" from their hotel at the port to the nearest shopping center.

He could be referring to the international airport in Orlando.

US Customs and Boarder Patrol considers our international airports to be ports of entry.

Here's an official list of the ports of entry for Florida. All three Orlando airports are listed.
https://www.cbp.gov/contact/ports/fl

Replies:   DBActive  DBActive
DBActive 🚫

@Dominions Son

You're not getting on a ship there - he did.

Replies:   Dominions Son
Dominions Son 🚫

@DBActive

You're not getting on a ship there - he did.

The nearest ocean port to Orlando would be Port Canaveral(~50 miles from Orlando) on Cape Canaveral.

DBActive 🚫

@Dominions Son

Another thing - nobody in the US (the characters are American) would walk two miles to a shopping center.

Replies:   StarFleet Carl
StarFleet Carl 🚫

@DBActive

nobody in the US (the characters are American) would walk two miles to a shopping center.

In an urban environment, where people don't actually have cars and the bus doesn't go that way, maybe. I do see people here in the OKC metro walk a mile or more, depending upon where they're going. Otherwise? Car, bike, or other mode of wheeled transportation. In Orlando? You'd take a taxi or ride the bus - it sucks to walk there. Hell, in summer, you'd die from the heat and humidity, let alone if you crossed into a gang territory on foot.

Replies:   Grey Wolf
Grey Wolf 🚫

@StarFleet Carl

I have walked two miles (each way!) to and from shopping in Orlando. In July. It was distinctly not pleasant.

StarFleet Carl 🚫

@DBActive

He takes a "two mile walk" from their hotel at the port to the nearest shopping center.

The only way this would be feasible is if they were considering the bus parking lot that takes them from Orlando to Canaveral the 'port,' like it was part of an FTZ. Otherwise, he maybe should've looked at a map.

Funny thing - Port of Lafayette is in the middle of a corn field. The Subaru plant in Lafayette, Indiana is a Foreign Trade Zone, and thus the entry point for cars assembled there. (Except for the Northeast - those cars assembled in the US get shipped via rail from Port of Lafayette to Port of Boston or Port of Davisville)

palamedes 🚫

@DBActive

Yes, but he repeatedly says he's in Orlando. He takes a "two mile walk" from their hotel at the port to the nearest shopping center.

Going from Orlando to Port Canaveral where all the cruise ships pretty much anchor in that area is less than 60 miles (96.5 Km) around an hour drive time. As for the shopping center that would depend on which one they went to but 2 miles isn't bad.

palamedes 🚫

@DBActive

I was just reading a story on Lit. The British author had the couple embarking on a cruise from Orlando. Couldn't he have spent 10 seconds looking at a map?

Yes Orlando is inland but you can take and have cruises out of Orlando and it is a very large industry. Just do a search of " cruise from Orlando" .

Three cruise lines offer cruises that leave out of Orlando in 2023 - Carnival (total of 150 sailings, among them 83 on Carnival Liberty, 42 on Mardi Gras and 9 on Carnival Freedom), Royal Caribbean (total of 106 sailings, among them 64 on Independence of the Seas and 20 on Mariner of the Seas) and Norwegian (NCL) (total of 11 sailings, all of them on Norwegian Escape).

Replies:   Dominions Son
Dominions Son 🚫
Updated:

@palamedes

Yes Orlando is inland but you can take and have cruises out of Orlando and it is a very large industry. Just do a search of " cruise from Orlando" .

I did the suggested search on Google. Then I checked some of the listings. They don't actually leave from Orlando. The cruises listed actually depart from Port Canaveral, Fl, 50 miles east of Orlando.

awnlee jawking 🚫

@PotomacBob

In a serial I've been following, a university student studies until 6pm each day, then goes to a hospital to do voluntary work starting at 5:30 pm. There's no opportunity for time zone jiggery pokery or using Hermione's Time Turner ;-)

AJ

redthumb 🚫

@PotomacBob

It is not just authors that do that. I was living in Las Vegas several years ago when I-15 and various spurs & bypass were built. Some car dealerships were built along one of the bypasses. Las Vegas has US 95 going from the CA border in the south to the OR border in the north. Several of the ads on the radio said that a dealership was on I-95. I was tempted to call the dealership and ask why I should go to the east coast to buy a car.

ystokes 🚫

@PotomacBob

One of the things that get me to skim is overly-descriptive travelogue.

Replies:   solitude
solitude 🚫

@ystokes

overly-descriptive travelogue

Overly-descriptive anything, really! (But what qualifies as o-d will depend on the reader.) Travelogue is certainly one area where many writers are o-d in my opinion; who but a native to the area is concerned about the exact route taken - and going into such details risks errors/anachronisms, as well as actually hiding info: is this a direct route? Often better to simplify - "we went to X avoiding the interstate(s) to avoid stress/speed cameras/whatever, even though it might have added an hour or so to or journey ". (Of course this does not apply if the journey is the story!)

ystokes 🚫

@PotomacBob

I once did a Google Earth search for the Trailer park in Duelwriter's Vacation using the streets described and damn if I didn't find it.

Replies:   CB  Joe Long
CB 🚫

@ystokes

I recieved a message from a reader saying that my global x,y coordinates from my second novel in "Make the Cut" did not show a temple in Sri-Lanka. I replied, "Look on the other side of the road." :-)

Replies:   ystokes
ystokes 🚫

@CB

I recieved a message from a reader saying that my global x,y coordinates from my second novel in "Make the Cut" did not show a temple in Sri-Lanka. I replied, "Look on the other side of the road." :-)

Ok this is a great example of giving too much detail.

Replies:   Paladin_HGWT
Paladin_HGWT 🚫

@ystokes

I recieved a message from a reader saying that my global x,y coordinates from my second novel in "Make the Cut" did not show a temple in Sri-Lanka. I replied, "Look on the other side of the road." :-)

Ok this is a great example of giving too much detail.

That is a very Subjective Opinion.

Providing information on the location in a story, in particular if it is a real world location, is common and often appreciated.

Since I was a teen I have travelled to locations depicted in books I have read.

It is a Multi-Million Dollar Industry look up "Band of Brothers Tours" which is one of several dozens (more like hundreds) of guided tour groups catering to people who want to tour battlefields, or other locations depicted in books.

Not just historical military battlefields. There are tours of the locations depicted in the "Sharpe's Rifles" books (and TV shows); or where movies were filmed, often different from actual battlefields. Tour locations depicted in Louis L'Amour novels is a thing. People enjoy going to a booth in a restaurant in Las Vegas frequented by the Rat Pack, etc. etc.

I understand that it might not be "your thing" ystokes; however, it appeals to a significant number of people.

Writing in detail every step from a fictional character's room, through the lobby, and all the way to the temple would be waaaay too much detail.

On a side note. In one of my stories I have characters observing a battle via RQ-9 "Reaper" RPA, they use two sets of two letters and eight numbers, using the US Army Grid Location System. I was just going to use random letters and numbers, some readers who have served in the US or NATO armed forces would probably think, oh, I remember coordinates like those we used in Afghanistan, Iraq, Germany, or Korea, etc.

I decided to check the internet and found a site that let me determine the Actual grid coordinates. If a single reader uses that information they would find it is the real world location of the fictional battle in the story.

Joe Long 🚫

@ystokes

Hell, I found the clearing behind Steve Adams's house from AWLL (where he'd sneak away to be with his sister)

Mike-Kaye 🚫
Updated:

@PotomacBob

I live in the San Jose CA metro area. "The 5" or "The I-5" is not something I hear. I'm under the impression that "The [routeName]" is a Southern California thing."

In Generous Offers I was comfortable about naming a grocery store and Costco and the San Jose General Aviation lounge my characters used in their trip to Sydney Australia. Their pre-cruise layover in Sydney mentions a concert in the opera house, a zoo visit, and a tall tower visit and no real details. In my story, Australian customs were rather more trusting than I suspect real officials would be. I used a real cruise itinerary and its first stop making sure that its airport could support an aircraft capable of reaching San Diego, California.

I was unable to find the cost of a custom flight from San Jose to Sidney. My guess is $400k for must-be-asap to $250k for a somewhat open plan with 14+ day notice. I also found no real information about 18-month life insurance for my MC's slutty ladies.

Replies:   Marius-6
Marius-6 🚫

@Mike-Kaye

I also found no real information about 18-month life insurance for my MC's slutty ladies.

Life Insurance? That is a "simple" actuarial calculation. However, presuming they are younger than 55 years of age, she should be able to get each of them a Half-Million (USD) Life Insurance for $15 to $20 a month; perhaps less. Unless you are insuring them for something extraordinary.

If they were to be murdered, or die by "misadventure" in those 18 months, expect an investigation by the authorities and PIs hired by the insurance company! Life Insurance policies for only 18 months is Odd. Suicide is not covered in many policies; if added, it can significantly increase the cost.

I have shopped for Life Insurance policies for "Contractors" in Afghanistan, the Middle East, and other war zones... Life Insurance policies that cover acts of war, terrorism, etc., are significantly more than ordinary life insurance policies for most people under 70; but still quite reasonable. (Well, for Western Contractors. "Cannon Fodder" hired by Wagner Group is probably prohibitively expensive, if available at all.)

Now "health insurance" that would be considerably more expensive. Its all (or mostly) in the Actuarial Tables.

Back to Top

Close
 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In