First of all, thanks to all of you who took the time to give me your feedback. It turned out not to be as close as I expected, but using my weighted tabulation method, here are the results:
1) Bug - 15
2) Are We There Yet - 16
3) Pool Party - 23
4) The Volleyball Girls - 35
So, it looks like I'll be working with the volleyball team. Good thing I like tall, athletic women. Since I've already done some soccer stories, this shouldn't be difficult.
Personally, my fav is Pool Party, because it has the potential to turn into a really nasty one, which I haven't done for a while.