Emma's Choice - Cover

Emma's Choice

Copyright© 2025 by Megumi Kashuahara

Chapter 1

Valentine, Nebraska, 1939

The afternoon light fell through the study window in dusty golden bars, illuminating worn ledgers and faded maps. Emma Perkins stood perfectly still, hands clasped so tightly that her knuckles had gone white as fresh snow.

She could hear every sound with preternatural clarity—the ticking of the mantel clock, the distant lowing of cattle, her own thundering heartbeat. But her father’s words seemed to come from somewhere far away, muffled and strange, as though she’d plunged underwater.

“The arrangement is made,” Thomas Perkins said—not unkindly, but with the flat finality of a man stating an immutable fact. “You’ll leave Thursday morning.”

Emma’s lips parted, but no sound emerged. She tried again.

“Father, I don’t understand. You promised I could teach. Miss Brennan said the schoolhouse in Denver—”

“Denver.” Her father laughed—a short, bitter sound. “With what money, girl? You think dreams fill empty stomachs?”

He crossed to the window, his broad shoulders blocking the light. Thomas Perkins had once been a prosperous man. The Perkins Ranch had stretched across two thousand acres of prime Nebraska grazing land, supporting three hundred head of cattle and a dozen hands. But the Great Depression had been merciless, and the drought that followed had broken something fundamental in the land and in her father.

They’d lost half the herd. The Federal Land Bank had come calling, and Thomas Perkins, proud man that he was, had found himself with only one asset left to bargain with: his daughter.

“Caleb Kincaid is a good man,” her father said, still staring out the window. “Solid. His ranch is thriving—water rights secure, cattle healthy. He needs a wife, a mother for his children.”

“He needs a servant,” Emma whispered. “An unpaid nursemaid.”

Now Thomas turned, and she saw something flash in his eyes—shame, perhaps, or anger at her for speaking the truth aloud.

“You’ll have security. A home. Children of your own in time. That’s more than most women can say.”

“Most women get to choose.”

The words hung between them like a slap. Emma felt tears prickling behind her eyes, but she refused to let them fall. She’d learned early that tears were currency wasted on her father. Thomas Perkins was a practical man, a rancher’s man who measured worth in tangible things—acres, cattle, water, grain. Sentiment was for those who could afford it.

“I don’t even know him,” Emma said quietly.

“You will.” Her father’s tone softened slightly. “He’s coming for supper tomorrow night. You’ll meet then.”

“How generous. A whole evening to become acquainted with my future husband.”

“Emma.” Warning in his voice now. “This isn’t some romantic novel. This is survival. His and ours. The marriage contract includes enough to save this ranch, to pay off the bank, to keep your mother and brothers fed through next winter. Do you understand what I’m saying?”

She understood perfectly. She was being sold. Oh, they’d wrap it in prettier words—arrangement, agreement, beneficial union. But the truth was as stark as winter bones. Her body, her future, her very self in exchange for her family’s survival.

“Does Mother know?” Emma asked.

Something flickered across her father’s weathered face.

“She knows what needs to be done.”

Which meant yes, and meant Mildred Perkins had cried herself sick over it, and meant Emma’s two younger brothers—eleven-year-old Tommy and nine-year-old Elias—would grow up on land purchased with their sister’s freedom. They’d probably never even understand the true cost.

“What about what I want?”

The words came out smaller than Emma intended—the voice of the child she’d been before the world taught her that wanting was a luxury. Her father crossed to her then, and for a moment she thought he might embrace her, might offer some comfort in this impossible situation. Instead, he placed one rough hand on her shoulder, squeezed once, and said, “Want is for the wealthy, daughter. We do what we must.”

He left her there in the study, surrounded by maps of land that would remain in the Perkins name only because she was willing to sacrifice hers.

The rest of that day passed in a strange fog. Emma moved through the familiar rooms of the ranch house—the only home she’d ever known—as though seeing them for the first time and the last time simultaneously. The kitchen where she’d learned to bake bread at her mother’s side. The parlor where she’d practiced her letters, dreaming of the day she might teach other children to read. The porch where she’d sat on summer evenings watching lightning dance across distant mountains and imagining a future that had looked nothing like this.

Her mother found her there as twilight fell, painting the sky in shades of bruised purple and burning orange.

Mildred Perkins was a small woman, fine-boned and delicate, though years of ranch life had weathered her hands and lined her face. She’d been beautiful once—Emma had seen the daguerreotype from her parents’ wedding day—but hardship had a way of eroding beauty like water wore down stone.

“I wanted better for you,” Mildred said quietly, settling onto the porch step beside her daughter. “I wanted you to choose. To marry for love the way young women in those novels you read always do.”

Emma said nothing. What was there to say?

“Caleb Kincaid lost his wife three years ago,” her mother continued. “Fever took her, sudden and cruel. Left him with three babies, the youngest not yet walking. People say he hasn’t been the same since. Works himself near to death trying to fill the silence.”

“How convenient for him.”

“Emma.”

“I’m sorry, Mother. I know this isn’t your doing.” Emma drew her knees up, wrapping her arms around them like a child seeking comfort. “I just thought I’d have more time. More choice. More...” She trailed off. “More.”

Mildred reached over and took her daughter’s hand. Her grip was strong despite her small size—a lifetime of ranch work left its mark.

“Listen to me. I know this isn’t the future you imagined. But Caleb Kincaid is not a cruel man. I’ve made inquiries. He’s fair, hardworking, respected in Valentine. His ranch prospers. His children are said to be sweet-natured.”

“You’re describing a horse I might purchase, Mother, not a man I’m to marry.”

A sad smile crossed Mildred’s face. “When I married your father, I barely knew him. Three weeks of courtship and most of that chaperoned. I was terrified on my wedding day, certain I’d made a terrible mistake.” She paused, staring out at the darkening land. “But we built something together. It wasn’t the romance of novels, but it was real, solid. We made a life, Emma. We made you.”

“And now you’re sending me away to make another man’s life easier.”

“I’m doing what I must to keep this family alive.” Mildred’s voice turned fierce. “You think I don’t hate this? You think I don’t lie awake nights sick with guilt? But your father is drowning, child. This ranch is his entire identity. If we lose it, it will kill him. Not quickly, but slowly—drinking himself into an early grave while his sons watch. Is that what you want?”

“Of course not. But why must it be me who pays the price?”

“Because you’re the eldest. Because you’re strong enough to bear it. Because...” Her mother’s voice cracked. “Because you’re my daughter, and I raised you to do what was right, even when it costs everything.”

They sat together in the gathering darkness, two women bound by love and duty and the cruel mathematics of survival. Finally, Mildred rose, brushing dust from her skirt.

“He’ll be here tomorrow evening. Wear the blue dress—it brings out your eyes. And Emma...” She paused in the doorway. “Give him a chance. You might be surprised.”

Emma doubted that very much.

Caleb Kincaid arrived precisely at six o’clock, driving a well-maintained wagon pulled by two sturdy horses. Emma watched from her bedroom window as he climbed down—a tall man, broad-shouldered and lean, moving with the economical grace of someone who never wasted motion.

He wore clean work clothes, his dark hair slightly too long, and even from a distance she could see the careful way he’d prepared for this visit. His boots were freshly polished, his shirt pressed. A man going courting, she thought bitterly. Except there would be no courting. Just inspection and transaction.

“Emma,” her mother called up the stairs. “Our guest is here.”

She took one last look at herself in the small mirror above her washstand. The blue dress fit well—cinched at the waist and falling in soft folds to her ankles. She’d braided her honey-colored hair and pinned it in a coronet, her mother’s style, elegant and adult. At nineteen, Emma Perkins stood at the threshold between girlhood and womanhood. After Thursday, that threshold would be permanently crossed.

With leaden feet she descended the stairs. The family was gathered in the parlor—her parents, her brothers scrubbed and uncomfortable in their Sunday clothes, and Caleb Kincaid, who stood as she entered, his hat in his hands.

He was younger than she’d expected. Twenty-six, her father had said, but hard work had carved him into something that seemed older. His face was all strong planes and angles, weathered by sun and wind. His eyes were gray—the color of storm clouds—and they studied her with an intensity that made her want to look away. But she forced herself to meet his gaze steadily.

“Miss Perkins,” he said, and his voice was lower than she’d anticipated, rough-edged but not unpleasant.

“It’s a pleasure to meet you, Mr. Kincaid.” She managed a small curtsy, hating how her hands trembled.

“Please, sit.” Her father gestured to the settee, playing host, though everyone in the room knew this was no ordinary social call.

“Emma, Mr. Kincaid has come all the way from Valentine. Perhaps you’d pour the coffee?”

It was busy work, something to occupy her shaking hands. She moved to the side table where her mother had laid out their best china—the set saved for special occasions, with tiny painted roses on each cup. Emma had always loved these cups. After Thursday, she’d never see them again.

“One lump or two, Mr. Kincaid?” she asked, her voice steadier than she felt.

“One, thank you. And please, call me Caleb. We’re to be...” He hesitated, seeming to search for the right word. “We’re to be family.”

Family. What a strange word to use for two strangers bound by financial necessity. She handed him the cup, careful not to let their fingers touch, then poured for the rest of the family. The coffee ritual bought her a few minutes before she had to sit, before the real conversation had to begin.

But eventually, inevitably, she found herself perched on the edge of the settee, her own untouched cup in her lap, while the adults negotiated her future.

“The ranch is forty minutes northwest of Valentine proper,” Caleb was explaining to her father. “Eight hundred acres, mostly grazing land with good water access. I run about two hundred head of cattle plus horses. The house is modest but sound—four bedrooms, a good kitchen, a root cellar. The land’s been in my family for fifteen years.”

“And your children?” Mildred asked gently. “Emma should know about the children.”

Something shifted in Caleb’s expression—a softening, a vulnerability that transformed his stern features.

“Jimmy is seven. Bright boy, loves horses. Mary is five—quiet, watchful. Takes after her mother that way. And June...” His voice roughened. “June is two. She was only six months old when we lost Sarah.”

An uncomfortable silence fell. Emma’s younger brothers shifted in their seats, uncertain how to respond to adult grief. Her father cleared his throat.

“It’s good the children will have a woman’s care again,” Thomas said.

“That’s what I’m hoping.” Caleb’s gray eyes found Emma’s. “I’ll be honest with you, Miss Perkins. I’m not looking for romance. My late wife, Sarah, was my childhood sweetheart. What we had—that doesn’t come twice in a lifetime. But my children need a mother. They need gentleness and care and the kind of love a man can’t provide, no matter how hard he tries.”

“And what do I need?” The words escaped before Emma could stop them. “Or doesn’t that matter?”

“Emma!” Her mother gasped, but Caleb held up a hand.

 
There is more of this chapter...
The source of this story is Storiesonline

To read the complete story you need to be logged in:
Log In or
Register for a Free account (Why register?)

Get No-Registration Temporary Access*

* Allows you 3 stories to read in 24 hours.

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In