Home Β» Forum Β» Author Hangout

Forum: Author Hangout

New Amazon restriction - 3 stories a day

Dinsdale 🚫
Updated:

Quoting from a geek site (slashdot.org) which has the story from the Guardian,

Amazon has created a new rule limiting the number of books that authors can self-publish on its site to three a day

You would imagine this to be directed against plagiarism, but no - it was triggered by suspected AI-generated content.

The number three may change, and:

Authors and publishers will also have the option to seek an exception to the rule.

I wonder how easy it will be to get an exception.

Edit: Added a link to the article.

Dicrostonyx 🚫

@Dinsdale

Without knowing any details, my guess would be that any exception would be a one-time or short duration thing to allow existing authors not on the platform to upload their back catalogue rather than being an ongoing thing.

Justin Case 🚫

@Dinsdale

Because "AI" is being used to flood the book market with pseudo-writing that is a bastardization of the art.
AI books are NOT 'literature', and those who crate them are NOT 'authors'.

Merely thinly veiled plagiarism from charlatans who dupe the uneducated.

Real writers and works from the HUMAN mind are the only true literature.
Everything else is an abomination.

FYI -
Yeah… I said it.
And I believe it.
And I'm not sorry. And I won't take it back.

Replies:   Dinsdale
Dinsdale 🚫

@Justin Case

That was why I made the posting in the first place, Amazon have inadvertently made mass-plagiarism on their site more difficult.

Pixy 🚫

@Dinsdale

To be honest, I don't see the 3 books a day limit being an obstruction. When you look at popular writers, very few have more than twenty books.

There is an old, and very apt saying; "Quantity, is not an indication of quality."

If someone has, say, fifty books to their name, there is a good chance those books are going to be either, very short, or poor in quality. Most likely both.

And for those who have the amazing ability to write well and prodigiously (not sure that's the right word), I'm sure being restricted to a couple a day is not going to be a problem, because if you have waited this long to get your novels on Amazon, then a few more days is not going to make the slightest bit of difference.

Dinsdale 🚫

@Pixy

The point is that the plagiarists copy large numbers of stories and only being able to post three a day does complicate their business somewhat.
Is three a day not also the limit here on SOL?

helmut_meukel 🚫

@Pixy

When you look at popular writers, very few have more than twenty books.

The British writer Niall Teasdale has far more, Amazon UK lists 68 titles, Amazon US lists 81 titles.
I haven't tried to find out what causes the difference.

Few single novels, some of them really stand alone, the others intended as first book of a new series.
Many series (2 to 14 books), some listed below:
Thaumatology 14 books (12 novels + 2 story collections),
Fox Meridian 10 novels
Aneka Jansen 7 novels,
Death's Handmaiden 6 novels,
Princeps Venator 3 novels,
Misfits 2 novels,
Tatsu Yamada 2 novels (a third is awaiting edits and then proofing, according to the author)

BTW, I've read – except Fox Meridian – these series and a few stand alone novels.
I've looked into (not even read all of the free sample) the Unobtainium, Fallen and Ultrahuman series and was not interested.
With Fox Meridian and Sondra Blake I'm uncertain after reading the free sample, maybe I'll buy the first book of both series.

HM.

Replies:   Dicrostonyx
Dicrostonyx 🚫

@helmut_meukel

There are a number of popular authors who have more than 20, yes, especially later in their careers, but note that Pixy said "average".

Having a large backlist is key to making money as a published (dead tree) author, but there aren't a lot of authors who write more than one book per year. Certainly there are some, plus there are some authors who have a backlog of completed books when they first get published, but generally speaking one per year is about the norm.

Self-published authors are often more prolific for the simple reason that they don't need to go through as many steps between completing the first draft and publishing. I haven't read Niall Teasdale so I can't comment on how raw their text may be. Regardless, just because you can name one author with more than 20 books doesn't mean Pixy is wrong about the average. I have no idea if 20 is correct, but it feels about right as an average, depending on how you define "successful," of course.

Keep in mind that the single richest author in the world, J K Rowling, has written a total of 9 novels* and 1 play.

* Note that typically in Britain children's books are not considered to be novels by the publishing industry, or at least they weren't when Rowling started writing. I'm using the word in a general sense here of a fiction book, not in a literary or publishing sense.

Replies:   helmut_meukel
helmut_meukel 🚫

@Dicrostonyx

I haven't read Niall Teasdale so I can't comment on how raw their text may be.

That's easy to fix. Just go to Amazon select the first book of one of his series and click on "Send Free Sample".
The free samples are usually long enough to judge the authors writing.
You need to create an account and download the free Kindle app to your PC. No need for a Kindle device. I've none and read the books on my laptop.
BTW, I started with the "Death's Handmaiden" series.

One warning, the MCs of all books I've read are female, and if there is a 'significant other' it's a female.

HM.

Not_a_ID 🚫

@Pixy

To be honest, I don't see the 3 books a day limit being an obstruction. When you look at popular writers, very few have more than twenty books.

While being dead certainly puts a crimp on the ability to write further. Isaac Asimov has quite the catalogue of books/textbooks that has written and/or edited with his name attached to it.

IIRC, I recall some of the biographies placed the count somewhere in excess of 500 books. Not (short) stories, books.

Replies:   Pixy
Pixy 🚫

@Not_a_ID

As was correctly stated by someone else earlier, that comment is NOT (just to make it clear) encapsulating all writers but the average writer. THE AVERAGE

richardshagrin 🚫

@Dinsdale

AVER

aΒ·ver
/Ι™ΛˆvΙ™r/
verbFORMAL
state or assert to be the case.
"he averred that he was innocent of the allegations"
Similar:
declare
maintain
claim
assert
state
attest
affirm
avow
swear
vow
profess
insist
protest
avouch
asseverate
LAW
allege as a fact in support of a plea.
"the defendant does not aver any performance by himself"

aver age for authors is likely to be over 21 years old, since you can not drink alcoholic beverages if younger.

Replies:   awnlee jawking
awnlee jawking 🚫

@richardshagrin

Aver age means self-identified age verification

AJ

Ron Jon 🚫

@Dinsdale

Why would someone need or have the time to write 3 good stories a day?

Back to Top

 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In