Please read. Significant change on the site that will affect compatibility [ Dismiss ]
Home ยป Forum ยป Author Hangout

Forum: Author Hangout

need advice on wording.

Remus2 ๐Ÿšซ

I've been part time training some folks to weld. Schools in the area have just now opened. I've got one young black kid in my class that has a chip on his shoulder the size of Mount Rushmore. Every time he screws up, it's automatically not him screwing up, it's because he's black. The kid has potential if he could make it past that chip.
Somehow, I need to get that message to him. I could just stand back and let the system deal with him. However, that would turn him into another statistic that is certain "the man" is just holding down another black kid.
So with a site full of wordsmiths, can anyone advise as to how to word that message?

Switch Blayde ๐Ÿšซ

@Remus2

I'm afraid, in the U.S. today, if you're black you're the victim and the white person is a racist. Anything you say that doesn't agree with that will get you in trouble.

It's not accurate. It's not fair. But it is what it is.

Replies:   Remus2  Vincent Berg
Remus2 ๐Ÿšซ

@Switch Blayde

I don't think that applies in my case. I'm mixed native Cherokee/white.
Not too worried about getting into any kind of trouble either. I'm retired and can walk away from this at any time.

Vincent Berg ๐Ÿšซ

@Switch Blayde

I'm afraid, in the U.S. today, if you're black you're the victim and the white person is a racist. Anything you say that doesn't agree with that will get you in trouble.

Systemic racism is rarely so black and white, otherwise it wouldn't be so systemic.

What's needed here is a certain amount of trust. Generally, when facing this sort of attitude, it's best to simply let them vent, get it out of their system, acknowledge that it is a serious issue, and then ask how they plan to confront it. That will usually set them back momentarily, giving you time to make your pitch.

The issue is not to fight racist person to person, but to focus on establishing yourself, making inroads, and avoiding unnecessary conflict. In most cases, open conflict by blacks is a guaranteed death sentence, and they've got to learn that if they hope to succeed, so few employers will put up with it, simply because it terrifies their majority white professional staff.

There's a reason why most employers focus on either British or Jamaican blacks, rather than American blacks. Americans continually hear the incessant racism claims, which is just another form of racism (i.e. setting them up to fail). However, the older Jamaicans (the newer ones were directly influenced by the corporate Americans which has essentially doomed their country. It's also the reason why black women tend to do better professionally than black men. Black men's first response is to send their honor, while women are generally peacemakers, hoping to fit into an existing system without challenging it.

The difference is largely educational. Educated blacks know how to fit into the larger white culture their employees are from. They know the language, how to communicate, and more importantly, how to avoid the larger conflicts which will quickly sabotage their careers.

It's more difficult with someone without that prior training, but under the mentoring with someone with experience in these issues, you can recoup the loss. They key is communication, not who wrote which 17th century poem. Besides, it's hard to make your case to a mostly white audience if you can't present your case. That means learning how to temper your message, simply so you can present your case in the first point, and then, you've got to appeal to their values, rather than your own perceived slights.

Having married a Jamaican and raised two daughters, I had these discussions with young children more often as I did the 'how to prevent getting killed by the police' talks. And once you start, everyone wants you to speak to their kids too. The benefit of which is that you can visibly observe how those messages play out over time, and observe which kids build successful lives, and which crash and burn.

Replies:   Switch Blayde
Switch Blayde ๐Ÿšซ

@Vincent Berg

Systemic racism is rarely so black and white, otherwise it wouldn't be so systemic.

Systemic racism is a real thing. But my point was the current environment in the U.S. has gone crazy.

The Chicago major had exclusive interviews with reporters. She only set them up with reporters of color. That's not racist? Imagine if she were white and set the interview up only with white reporters.

Replies:   Vincent Berg
Vincent Berg ๐Ÿšซ

@Switch Blayde

The Chicago major had exclusive interviews with reporters. She only set them up with reporters of color. That's not racist? Imagine if she were white and set the interview up only with white reporters.

Sorry, but your making a mountain our of a anthill. Mayors routinely provide targeted interviews, not just to different select groups (ex: Lions and Elks clubs), but also high-school reporters for their high-school newspapers. So, claiming that giving an interview to professional black reporters is an example of reverse racism is patently absurd. If you follow that logic, then it should be illegal to impose ANY limit on public interviews, no matter the topics being discussed, who it impacts, or whose support the legislature needs to get it approved.

What's next, lynchings are racist because whites are 'allowed' to be strung up like blacks? Your question is a textbook example of structural racism. You could get away with similar complaints against any white organization, only against those without the financial wherewithal to defend themselves against utterly frivolous claims. That's akin to kicking someone when they're already bleeding in the street (which isn't actually that uncommon).

Dominions Son ๐Ÿšซ

@Vincent Berg

Sorry, but your making a mountain our of a anthill. Mayors routinely provide targeted interviews, not just to different select groups (ex: Lions and Elks clubs), but also high-school reporters for their high-school newspapers.

This is not targeted interviews like what you describe.

The current Chicago Mayor is outright refusing to provide any interviews except to reporters of color.

Switch Blayde ๐Ÿšซ

@Vincent Berg

Sorry, but your making a mountain our of a anthill.

Some black reporters with high character canceled their interview with the mayor because of the nature of her intent. Gimme a break. Doing something based on race is racism.

Keet ๐Ÿšซ

@Remus2

If he screws up again walk with him through every step until where he screws up again. Then show him how to avoid the screw up and let him try again. That way he can't ignore that he himself did the screw up and he will appreciate that you showed him how to do it right.
He won't confess that he did the screw up but he will know that YOU know ;) After a few of of these he hopefully accepts that he can make mistakes and that you will help him to do it right.
Often it's a case of not saying "There's where you do it wrong" but saying "Hold it this way and turn that way, it's easier and makes a better weld".

Replies:   Remus2
Remus2 ๐Ÿšซ

@Keet

Often it's a case of not saying "There's where you do it wrong" but saying "Hold it this way and turn that way, it's easier and makes a better weld".

That, I've already done as well as could be done for welding. Tactile feedback while welding is not something that can be explained in that manner. It is something than can be observed if you know what you're looking for. I see him adjusting without instruction, which is why I believe he has strong potential.

Replies:   Vincent Berg
Vincent Berg ๐Ÿšซ

@Remus2

That, I've already done as well as could be done for welding. Tactile feedback while welding is not something that can be explained in that manner. It is something than can be observed if you know what you're looking for. I see him adjusting without instruction, which is why I believe he has strong potential.

That's why trust is so essential. It's vital that he sees you as an ally, one who understands what he's facing, rather than a potential opponent. Trust me, it's worth the time establishing that initial trust, as it will pay off in spades in the long run (no pun intended).

But ultimately, the attitude needs to be addressed first, if not, you'll NEVER convince him to trust you!

Pixy ๐Ÿšซ

@Remus2

Some are beyond telling. However, you could point out to him that metal and welding rods don't care if you are black, white, orange, straight, gay, bi, fat, thin, disabled or whatever. All and any mistakes are purely that of the welder and it's up to him to make good. If he can't, then maybe welding is not the profession for him. Welding is not a task that you can blame someone else for your poor weld and that could be what you need to get over to him.

Replies:   Remus2
Remus2 ๐Ÿšซ

@Pixy

Some are beyond telling.

Agreed. However this kid is not stupid. Somewhere in his mind he recognizes what he's doing. Problem is, he refuses to comply with the WPS (weld process specification). The WPS details out current, travel speed, materials, etc. Code welding is where he will make the most money. If he can't comply, he will never make it in the real world.

Replies:   JoeBobMack
JoeBobMack ๐Ÿšซ
Updated:

@Remus2

Problem is, he refuses to comply with the WPS (weld process specification). The WPS details out current, travel speed, materials, etc. Code welding is where he will make the most money.

Ah! This adds a layer. I see two possible issues. One, he knows why he is resisting compliance. Two, he doesn't. I'm guessing it has something to do with issues of control, of not wanting to comply with... what? I'm not sure. "The man"? "White standards"? Don't know. Either way, you might consider helping him explore the WPS Code. (Is that the right way to put it? I know nothing about Welding.) And by explore, I'm thinking let him learn for himself. Why do the standards exist? What's their purpose? "Meeting standards" may not motivate him. "Keeping people safe" might. Would be great if he could talk to some people knowledgeable in the industry. Maybe a codes inspector who could talk about real times when a failure to comply created some problem. Also with "code welders" who could talk about what it's like to have mastered that skill. How it feels to be one of the few who can consistently perform, and what it means to their team and employer when they get it right, first time, every time. I'm imagining a guy standing there saying, "You know how they say, 'Good, fast, cheap - pick any two'? Well, I'm good and I'm fast, so they don't get me cheap."

If he ever gets to the point he wants to comply but just can't, then that's likely an issue with some deeper belief or value that's driving in the direction of non-compliance. If you hit that, send me mail and I'll give you some suggestions.

Anyway, good luck. It's been great seeing folks really try to be helpful in this thread.

Replies:   Remus2
Remus2 ๐Ÿšซ

@JoeBobMack

Either way, you might consider helping him explore the WPS Code

A weld procedure specification is not a code but does come from one. It comes from the American Society of Mechanical Engineering (ASME) Boiler and Pressure vessel code Section IX which covers the requirements for filler materials, weld processes, and qualifications of welders to be used in other sections of ASME code. If a person is to weld in a code shop, or on a project governed by ASME code, the person will be required to be tested to a WPS. Which means more $$$ for the job verses a non-code welder. Rod and wire burners are a dime a dozen, welders who can code weld are not that many.
In his particular case, he knows how to read the WPS, but will not comply with it of his own volition when it doesn't make sense to him. If he does that and gets caught doing it on a code job, he will be fired for cause.
His race will be ignored as it doesn't matter when weighed against a pipe or boiler blowing out if the weld fails. People tend to die or worse when the former happens. Think a nuclear plant for the worse than dieing comment (ASME section III and XI nuclear codes). The same thought process applies to other codes as well. Especially those that apply to aerospace and structural codes. Failure of welds in those environments, can mean aircraft falling out of sky, or bridges and buildings collapsing. Next to that, his race means nothing. Today's lesson is covering that. Maybe he will get it after that. I hope so.

Replies:   JoeBobMack
JoeBobMack ๐Ÿšซ

@Remus2

Good luck! And best wishes to your student. I'm gathering that welding in a way that meets code is harder and, having had some success with other ways, he would like to avoid going through the learning curve to where he is as comfortable doing it to code as he is with the other ways. Hopefully the combination of the critical nature of such welds and the prestige and money of achieving proficiency will be enough to motivate him!

Replies:   Remus2
Remus2 ๐Ÿšซ

@JoeBobMack

m gathering that welding in a way that meets code is harder

It's not necessarily harder, it's just more structured and detailed.

Replies:   JoeBobMack
JoeBobMack ๐Ÿšซ

@Remus2

Given my personality, that makes it harder !

JoeBobMack ๐Ÿšซ
Updated:

@Remus2

First, Remus2, thank you for what you are doing.

Second, you've really hit some of my hot buttons. This is an area I can go on about from a theory and science standpoint, but I'll try for some restraint.

So, ideas. You've likely thought of and done many of these, but maybe some will spark something new:

- Does he know you care about him? Not his performance, but him? Concern for his performance can be written off as not wanting his failure to reflect on you. Anything you can do to let him know he matters as a person will help. Could be something as simple as a piece of hard candy, or going to lunch, or just staying and talking after class. The old saying is, "They don't care how much you know until they know how much you care."

- Be specific with him when you talk about why you think he has potential. "You can do this," "You've got what it takes," etc. aren't helpful because he doesn't know what "it" is. But, if you can connect "I see him adjusting without instruction" to his specific actions in an attempted weld, then go on to say how rare it is to see that and how it's going to let him master welding with attention, effort, trying new approaches, and practice - that might get through.

- Tell stories, to him, yes, but probably to the whole class, of individuals you have known who struggled with the skill, then went on to become masters. Maybe somebody who was an amazing welder who told you how they almost quit when they first tried to learn. That kind of thing. It makes the process of growing into the skill normal and the difficulties just a sign that they are on the road.

- Focus feedback on observable behaviors, not the result. For example, "I noticed that you made an adjustment partway through that weld. Walk me through what you were thinking and how you thing that worked." Then, "What could you try differently next time?"

- Get him to do something different that only he would know (without telling you) on his next weld attempt. Even if it is standing with his toes pointed slightly differently. There's evidence this helps very skilled people improve performance, so it might help him pay a little more attention to what was happening, rather that to his own judgments about his performance.

- Ask him about his best qualities and how they might help. Determination is an obvious one, or competitiveness. But, if he's got a sense of humor and some playfulness, maybe pretending he's making a weld that's going to save the space station would help.

- Maybe have him watch another student who is also still working toward mastery and ask him what he thought might help that student the most and how he would communicate that. Sometimes, we can master the basics ourselves when we try to teach others.

Hope some of these help. Good luck and, again, thank you!

Replies:   Remus2
Remus2 ๐Ÿšซ

@JoeBobMack

Haven't tried the stories/history. Most of them are not suitable for the environment. Somewhere in there may be the answer though. I can relate to the racial angle more than he realizes. Think I'll try that one though it will be unrelated to welding directly. I seriously doubt any of these kids have ever had a cross burned in their yard, or been run down by the pickup of an irate father who just learned his daughter was dating a half-breed.
Maybe that will get past the chip.

Replies:   Vincent Berg
Vincent Berg ๐Ÿšซ

@Remus2

Haven't tried the stories/history. Most of them are not suitable for the environment. Somewhere in there may be the answer though. I can relate to the racial angle more than he realizes. Think I'll try that one though it will be unrelated to welding directly.

That's the best approach, and it doesn't necessarily require much time, but you need to develop the trust, or you'll always be seen as being 'complicate' in the abuse he sees.

While not everyone has physically been confronted with a cross burning, nearly every black individual has seen countless racial confrontations since they were young children, not yet able to comprehend what was going on. That's a given, so acknowledge it, but then redirect the conversion to what he needs to survive in a white environment. He doesn't need to sell his soul, or 'work with the devil', instead he needs to lean to deflect. He can protest on his own, but he can't allow that to end his future. He'll need to learn a career is he hopes to survive.

Replies:   Remus2
Remus2 ๐Ÿšซ

@Vincent Berg

what he needs to survive in a white environment

That assumes a "white environment." From my perspective, it's a human environment. He probably catches as much shit from the black environment as he does from a white environment. I know I did from the natives on the rez. If you were not full blood, you were trash to them. If you excelled at anything, they'd try to bring you down. The same applied to the whites when I transferred off the rez and into a normal county school. It was after that, that my mother and father began homeschooling me and my siblings. I ended up in college where most of them ended up working a factory assembly position. There is nothing wrong with the latter, it's at least honest work.

Replies:   Vincent Berg
Vincent Berg ๐Ÿšซ

@Remus2

That assumes a "white environment." From my perspective, it's a human environment. He probably catches as much shit from the black environment as he does from a white environment.

I'm not arguing with you, as human nature is to dig in your heels whenever you face opposition. But as they say, you catch more flies with honey than shit, and if all it takes to resolve this is to spend a few minutes developing trust--something I suspect this poor kid is sorely laking, it seems a fairly safe investment getting him to open up about what he's facing that's producing such strident antagonism. It seems better than simply letting him fail on his own, which seems to be his current trajectory (no offense Remus, I'm just making a general observation about young men who are lost and don't know where to turn).

Remus2 ๐Ÿšซ

@Remus2

Thanks to all who've tried to help.

Remus2 ๐Ÿšซ

@Remus2

Maybe we can dampen the rhetoric and politics here. None of that will help this young man.

Replies:   Switch Blayde
Switch Blayde ๐Ÿšซ

@Remus2

Maybe we can dampen the rhetoric and politics here. None of that will help this young man.

Except in the first post โ€” "Every time he screws up, it's automatically not him screwing up, it's because he's black."

That's the message being burned into his brain. That's what he's being taught which will not help him. It simply puts that chip on his shoulder and allows him not to take responsibility. That needs to be countered.

Replies:   Remus2
Remus2 ๐Ÿšซ

@Switch Blayde

That needs to be countered.

Which is something I'm trying to do.

Replies:   Switch Blayde
Switch Blayde ๐Ÿšซ

@Remus2

Which is something I'm trying to do.

And I applaud you for it. But it has to be recognized before it can be addressed. It's not political (on my part).

Back to Top

Close
 

WARNING! ADULT CONTENT...

Storiesonline is for adult entertainment only. By accessing this site you declare that you are of legal age and that you agree with our Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.


Log In