Chapter 2: Kay Shares Me With Susan

My sister’s friend, Kay, has been my girlfriend for several months now. It all started when my sister Jen, Kay, and their group of teenaged girlfriends tricked me into going out with Kay. They gave me no prior warning and not much choice. That first night with Kay, even though it had been unplanned, had been exceptionally pleasant and rewarding.

Before she even got in my truck, Kay had placed her ample boobs on my driver’s side window sill. She was obviously giving me an invitation to pet her tits. She then informed me she was ready to give up her virginity, and she wanted me to be her first lover. Her cherry was mine for the taking. At Kay’s request, I took her out into the desert outside Phoenix. There, under a moon and stars of the inky black desert sky, Kay did just what she had promised. She gave me her virginity with no strings attached. Of course, we were soon very much attached.

Over the last few months, Kay and I have tried almost every sexual activity and position we could think of. Kay had told me she wanted to learn all she could about sex. She eagerly engaged in any position of vaginal sex and quickly took to giving me blowjobs. She swallowed my cum every time. She had difficulty doing deep-throat, but she kept trying. Her plump tits were great for fondling and titty-fucking. The only thing she really had trouble doing was taking my cock up her butt. It took several attempts and lots of lube, but she was finally able to take it in her ass.

One night she came over to my place grinning from ear to ear. When I asked what had made her so happy, Kay lifted her skirt and showed me her freshly shaved pussy. Not a hair could be seen. I ate her pussy with enthusiasm that night until she had had multiple orgasms.

Then, one night after sex, we were cuddling and petting each other on my sofa. Kay smiled up at me. She said, “Pete, one of my friends, Susan, just turned eighteen.”

“Oh, that’s nice.” I replied

“No, you don’t understand. Remember, I asked about sharing you with a couple of my friends? Well, Susan asked to borrow you for one night.”

I thought about it for a few minutes then replied. “Kay honey, I thought you were kidding about that. You’re my girlfriend now, and I don’t want to be with anyone other than you.”

Kay cooed and smothered me with kisses before continuing her request. “Pete, you won’t be with someone else. You’ll just be doing Susan a favor. Please say you’ll do for Susan what you did for me. Please say you’ll take her cherry and be as gentle with her as you were the first time with me.”

“I don’t know Kay. I don’t want you to be jealous. I don’t want to loose you.”

“You won’t loose me. Please Pete, Susan and I really want you to take her cherry. Just take her cherry, you don’t have to fall in love with her.”

“Are you sure, Kay?”

“Yes! I’m very sure. Susan and I are both sure, We want you to shove your wonderful cock up her pussy and pop her cherry.”

After thinking about it a short time, I said to Kay, “Okay, I’ll do Susan. When and where do you two want me to do her?”

“She loved it when I told her about how you took me out into the desert and popped my cherry under the stars. Will you take her out into the desert too? Tomorrow night would be good if you will.”

“Okay Baby,” I replied. “If that’s what you guys want. Where does she want me to pick her up?”

“She said she’d come over here about nine o’clock and be ready to go. By the way, she’s says she’s been on the pill for about three months so she’ll be safe for you to fill her with your cum. She also said she would shave her pussy for you. I told her how much you liked it when I shaved my pussy bald.”

“Okay Baby. If she’s here at nine o’clock tomorrow night, it’ll be cherry popping time.”

Susan knocked on my door a few minutes before nine. I was very pleasantly surprised at the sight that greeted me when I opened my door. Susan was a slender young thing with bright blue eyes and long blonde hair. She stood a little over five foot two inches tall. She was wearing a light blue party dress, and I enjoyed the view. The hem of her skirt was a few inches above her knees. The top of the dress was cut low in both the front and back. Though she had small boobs, Susan and her dress were doing all they could to let her cleavage show.

Susan nervously looked up and with a big smile and sparkling eyes said, “Hi Pete. I am so happy you agreed to do this. Kay has told us all how sweet you were with her. I look forward to our time together tonight.”

To break the ice, I took her into my arms and kissed her lips tenderly.

Susan seemed to press herself into my body. She cooed and returned the kiss.

“Susan, are you sure you want to do this? Do you still want to do it in the desert?”

Susan threw her arms up around my neck, pulled herself up, and kissed me with passion. As I grabbed her ass to help hold her up, she wrapped her legs around mine and thrust her pelvis tightly against my growing cock. “Does that answer your question? I am so ready. Please take me out to where you first took Kay.”

Easing her down until she stood on her own feet, I told her, “Okay Baby. Let’s go cherry picking.”

Susan giggled and took my arm as we walked to my truck. Since she was so petite, I had to help her step up into the passenger seat. Before I could get around to the drivers side, she had scooted over to sit very close as we drove out of town. Whether she wanted to admit it or not, Susan was nervous. She talked a mile a minute on the ride out to the spot I had taken Kay. As soon as I stopped the truck, she seemed to freeze up. I had to pull on her arm before she slid out to me.

Without saying a word, she slid her butt across the seat, until her legs were hanging off the side of the seat. Her dress had ridden up over her hips revealing her naked ass and bald pussy.

“You have shaved your pussy and are not wearing panties. It looks like you are indeed ready to give up your virginity.”

Susan grinned and replied, “Pete, Kay told us you like shaved pussy. I thought going without panties would help me get in the mood.”

I pulled her out of my truck and hugged her tightly. When I passionately kissed her, Susan seemed to loose her nervousness. She pressed her slender body tightly to mine and said, “I am ready, Pete.”