1: Aftermath by Al Steiner The first story I read here, over a decade ago. Got me hooked with a great premise and amazing characters I cared about.
2: A Fresh Start by rlfj Another long story that kept me hooked until the end. Also really enjoying the grim reaper.
3: Welcome to Summer Camp by Nick Scipio Everything in this universe is amazing. Part of the reason I am hooked on this site is I want to know who Paul's wife is.
